Skip to content
modelmiserPublic

About

The Seam Is Load-Bearing — a structured impossibility argument for seamless safe systems languages, plus a build-and-break field guide of 37 real Rust seam primitives. The SEAM face of the Radiant verification trinity: Sol (proof) · Spicule (seam) · Corona (type).

Resources

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Repository files navigation

Spicule

The seam face of the Radiant type-theory work — the Seam Trilemma, explored build-and-break.

Where Corona reduces an invariant to a compile-time error and Sol proves the reduction sound, Spicule stress-tests the seams: it constructs a seam, tries to break it, and records what survives. The 37-seam build-and-break pass is closed; the writeup lives in PAPER.md (Tier 1+2). The monoculture control has run under TWO foreign families (2026-08-12, GPT-5.6 Sol 6/8 and Gemini 3.1 Pro 5/8 outcome-class agreement, each as every cold role): all four BREAKS reproduced by both with horn-exact labels (all four share the modal horn; COSTS agreement cells are horn-inexact). On the full-sample runs the HOLDS demotions were three horn-3 cost cells plus one horn-1 spec-wording cell; an earlier single-seam run ruled the flagship HOLD a BREAKS outright and was later vindicated: the v1 spec never pinned variance — a covariance laundering path found by two families (one attested by the disclosed session record) — nor dropck ownership (found in-family at v4), so the recorded HOLD is contradicted as stated; the v2–v6 amendment lineage (design_seam/FOREIGN_REPLICATION.md) ran v5 to three independent panels (COSTS [horn2] · COSTS [horn1] · BREAKS [horn1]; fourth surface component: input provenance) and the v6 respec (input eliminated) to three pre-registered panels (BREAKS · COSTS · BREAKS; fifth component, latent since v1: §3's unbounded Consumer<T>: Send vs §4's bounded stopper — the RUSTSEC-2020-0150 class). Five distinct discoveries in six specs; twelve post-v1 panels (9 in-family + 3 foreign) never rated the flagship clean; the clean HOLD is not recovered, the realizability table has no all-holds row, and the lineage is closed under its pre-registered stop rule (owner-reopenable). What the instrument left standing: the negative results (eleven broken seams, replicated horn-exactly by two foreign families where sampled), the trilemma and its nine-axis cost basis, the three-domain grading, and the three-streak holds outside the flagship (spin_lock, drain, total_div-at-COSTS). The Gemini refined escalation was re-examined line-by-line and sustained at the recorded COSTS [horn2] (the claimed UB path targets an unvended configuration; the out-of-family corroboration is a disclosed single draw) — design_seam/REFINED_ESCALATION_ADJUDICATION.md. Standing caveats: 33 of 37 seam verdicts are single-gauntlet (only SPSC-v1, spin_lock, drain, total_div ran the three-streak bar), transport deltas on the foreign runs, and the v5/v6 tier distributions themselves.

Layout

  • seam/, design*/, proof/ — the seam constructions and their analysis.
  • runs*/ — build-and-break run records.
  • PAPER.md, WRITEUP.md, TUTORIAL.md, THE-SAME-WALL.md — the writeups.
  • orchestrator/ — run tooling.

Public research repo (made public 2026-08-13, after the publish-gate cold round recorded in DEVLOG-adjacent project records). The paper is a repo-native artifact; nothing here is submitted to any venue.

License

MIT. Copyright (c) ModelMiser. The full text is in LICENSE.

About

The Seam Is Load-Bearing — a structured impossibility argument for seamless safe systems languages, plus a build-and-break field guide of 37 real Rust seam primitives. The SEAM face of the Radiant verification trinity: Sol (proof) · Spicule (seam) · Corona (type).

Resources

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Releases

Packages

Used by

Contributors

Languages