Skip to content

Waldorf Quantum/Iridium: write the attributes in the wording of the device - #337

Open
douglas-carmichael wants to merge 1 commit into
git-moss:mainfrom
douglas-carmichael:qpat-attribute-tags
Open

Waldorf Quantum/Iridium: write the attributes in the wording of the device#337
douglas-carmichael wants to merge 1 commit into
git-moss:mainfrom
douglas-carmichael:qpat-attribute-tags

Conversation

@douglas-carmichael

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

The Quantum/Iridium lists four attributes next to each patch name and lets you filter the whole library by them, so for anyone converting a sizable library they are the difference between a browsable collection and a wall of names. They are written from the category, and for a part of the categories that wording does not match what the instrument's own sound sets use.

I scanned the attributes of 1855 factory and commercial patches on my Iridium to see which words are actually in use:

Synth 764, Pad 451, Atmo 400, Keys 329, FX 281, Percussive 235, Epic 228, PPG 214,
Lead 178, Bass 173, Arp 90, Noise 89, Granular 83, Strings 83, Sequenced 72,
Vocal 58, FM 53, Cinematic 47, Organ 35, Loop 31, Bells 29, Experimental 22,
Mono 16, Piano 15, Drum 15, Sample 12, World 11, Monophon 10, Pipe 8, Winds 6,
Chromatic Percussion 5, Drone 5, Pluck 5, Brass 4

Most of our categories are spelled exactly the same and are written unchanged. Thirteen are not, and those now get the device's word:

Category written as
Keyboard Keys
Bell Bells
Percussion, Hi-Hat, Kick, Snare, Clap Percussive
Loops Loop
Acoustic Drum Drum
Monosynth Monophon
Orchestral Cinematic
Ensemble Strings
Destruction Experimental

Before this, converting a library wrote Keyboard next to the Keys of every other patch on the device: two entries in the filter list, each finding half of the keyboard sounds.

'Unknown' is no longer written. An undetected category filled the first attribute with the literal word - my instrument has 876 patches tagged 'Unknown' from converted libraries against 3 in the entire factory content, because Waldorf leaves it empty. It is left empty now. A keyword which merely repeats the category is also no longer written into a second slot.

Reading a category back is fixed as well. Two of our own category names did not survive being written into a preset and read from it again:

  • Winds was detected as FX, because the Wind sound effect is a shorter keyword and the contains-search prefers it.
  • World was not detected at all - its keyword list holds only Asian, not the word itself.

The name of a category is now a keyword of its own for all of them. I verified the whole list: before the change 2 of 32 names failed the write-then-read round trip, afterwards 0 of 32. I also checked that adding the names collides with no existing keyword. This affects every format which stores the category as text, not only QPAT.

Verified by converting a 55-preset library to QPAT and reading the written headers back: every attribute is a word which the factory sound sets use, no Unknown is written, and the 11 presets whose category is genuinely unknown have an empty attribute. Each of the 13 translated words also reads back to a sensible category, so a QPAT-to-QPAT conversion keeps the category.

…evice

The device lists the four attributes of a patch next to its name and
filters the patches by them. They were written straight from the
category, which uses a different wording than the factory sound sets for
a part of the categories: 'Keyboard' instead of 'Keys', 'Bell' instead
of 'Bells', 'Percussion' instead of 'Percussive', 'Loops' instead of
'Loop'. Both words then end up in the filter list of the device and each
of them finds only a part of the sounds. The category is translated now;
every other category is spelled identically in the factory sound sets
and is written unchanged.

A category which could not be detected wrote the word 'Unknown' into the
first attribute. That fills the filter list with an entry which says
nothing about the sound - the factory sound sets leave the attribute
empty instead, which is what is written now. A keyword which repeats the
category is no longer written a second time.

Also fixes reading a category back: 'Winds' was detected as FX, because
the 'Wind' sound effect is a shorter keyword and wins the search, and
'World' was not detected at all since its keyword list did not contain
the word itself. The name of a category is now a keyword of its own for
all of them, which is verified for the whole list.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant