Skip to content

feat: add Neovate Code terminal harness - #8209

Draft
milesatao-svg wants to merge 28 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6494-neovate
Draft

milesatao-svg wants to merge 28 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6494-neovate

Conversation

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Code changes: +904 -29
Tests: +1138 -5
Others: +16 -3

Account migration from @nikhilachale to @milesatao-svg. This draft continues original PR #6494 at original head 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2. Original commits and commit authorship are preserved. Descriptions and evidence below include historical results with their original sources.

What

feat: add Neovate Code terminal harness

Original PR description, preserved

Binary assets in current PR diff: 9.

Adds the pinned native Neovate terminal integration with additive AO plugin instructions and preserved native/user/project controls. Chat, reviewers and cross-interface handoff are unsupported.

Actual AO audit is mixed: primary fresh private/project/user actions passed; a separate fresh private action failed. Exact restored NEW-token consumption failed despite read-only native composed-system configuration containing NEW only. Executing Escape failed to settle. Independent AO Kill and specific missing-transcript rejection passed. Earlier invalid overlapping controls and blank frames are retained separately.

Harness-owned report and receipts. Runtime and UI source were 6be36883; evidence commits do not relabel the executable. Stock @neovate/code0.28.5 matched all12 released package files. Authenticated third-party wire role NOT_CAPTURED.

PR remains draft. Native ACP load/resume are unimplemented in released 0.28.5 and current upstream. Current batch status and exact-head CI. GitHub CI only. Historical evidence below remains unchanged.

Latest reconciliation pass and current-head CI. ACP readiness remains unqualified.

Latest ACP source progress, native blocker and final-head CI. Chat remains unregistered; draft retained.

Current-main recheck (2026-10-21): merged 7c83bd68c1 and explicitly disabled unattended terminal version refresh until exact-conversation restore is qualified. CLI/daemon checks on 8d1c3ac3c7 installed Neovate 0.28.5 successfully, opened the native provider chooser (an additional Enter was needed in the terminal check), listed a configured project model, and created a standalone TUI task through the New task API. The fresh task exited because no native model was configured. The existing configured-provider credential returned HTTP 401. A successful authenticated task response is not verified. The follow-up commit only adds the disabled refresh capability and its matrix expectation; draft retained.

Why

The contributor is moving this harness submission to @milesatao-svg. The linked source preserves the implementation and review history.

Before / After

Before After
Submission in PR #6494 from @nikhilachale at 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2 Submission from @milesatao-svg at the same commit 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2

Original product behavior and existing UI evidence are included in the preserved description and copied evidence comments.

How

Copy the source head into milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6494-neovate and target upstream main.

Testing

Historical test results and screenshots are reproduced in the evidence comments with their original sources. Fresh validation is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.

Checklist

  • Original head SHA and commit authorship preserved.
  • Original description and evidence provenance included.
  • Fresh CI validation on this submission.
  • Resolve current main merge conflicts.

Account migration verification

  • Exact source head copied: 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2.
  • New fork branch: milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6494-neovate. Base: main.
  • Evidence comments retain their original author, timestamp, source URL and result wording.
  • Fresh validation status is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.
  • Source mergeability at migration: conflicts with current main; reconciliation pending.

nikhilachale and others added 22 commits October 10, 2026 05:02
Move the unmerged harness migration to unused 209 and recover requested_output for historical Neovate databases that burned main migration 195. Preserve all harness-owned evidence.
Build the real daemon in PR CI for isolated VPS runtime verification without local validation suites or dependency installations. Record source revision, Go build info, and executable hash.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… /login

- Model catalog lists every built-in Neovate v0.28.5 provider model,
  defaulting to configured or keyed providers (env vars or native /login).
- Seed AO's model through the plugin config hook instead of --model, which
  disabled native /model for the whole session.
- Configure opens Neovate and sends /login once the TUI is ready.
- Add the official Neovate mark and show a saved credential as Connected.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 1/3

Historical material from original PR #6494, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T07:49:54Z

Original comment

Evidence correction from the skill packaging review: the historical system_prompt_restore token was included in the initial standing instructions before the first turn. Its later appearance proves that token remained available after restore; it does not prove fresh instruction delivery or reinjection. The original 17/17 lifecycle result is a recorded runner result, not verified evidence for all 17 intended behaviors. Refreshed instructions remain unproven for this historical run. The reusable runner is being corrected to introduce a fresh token only after confirmed kill and before restore; fixture validation of that change is separate from real-provider validation, which has not been rerun. Original counts and artifacts below are retained for traceability.


Neovate Code 0.28.5 — VPS audit report, 2026-10-10

Functional lifecycle: 17/17 PASS. CI on the audited commit: 24/24 PASS. Overall audit: BLOCKED. This is diagnostic lifecycle coverage; a full strict audit PASS is not claimed.

Audited commit: e82a48fa09c07e7d70cdd19a26aea0ae1bed7e1f. Environment: Ubuntu 24.04 x86_64, the released native CLI, an isolated AO daemon/workspace/profile, and real Z.ai coding-plan calls using glm-5.3-flash. No tests, builds, lint, typechecks or provider execution ran on the user's Mac.

Gate totals: 25 PASS, 2 NOT_RUN, 1 BLOCKED. These are gate counts, separate from the 24 CI checks.

Local CLI

Gate Result Reason
local_binary PASS local executable resolved
local_version PASS local version command succeeded
local_integration PASS local integration probe succeeded
local_session_spawn PASS direct local CLI session produced the requested proof
local_models_list NOT_RUN local model-list command is not defined

AO / AOS11

Gate Result Reason
registered PASS agent is registered
installed PASS AO resolved the installed executable
fresh_probe PASS installation and authentication observations are fresh
authentication BLOCKED Neovate Code has credentials configured, but AO could not verify them.
ao_models_api PASS AO model API listed 1 model(s)
tui_spawn PASS AO created the requested TUI session
proof_file_creation PASS AO_AUDIT_PROOF.json contains valid JSON
correct_working_directory PASS provider reported AO's session workspace
initial_prompt_exactly_once PASS unique initial token was handled once
hidden_ao_instructions PASS provider consumed hidden AO standing instructions
project_agents_md PASS provider consumed project AGENTS.md
activity_status PASS AO exposed ready status and an active→idle transition
second_message PASS second API message produced the requested provider-authored mutation
native_session_id PASS AO persisted a provider-native session identity
cancellation PASS AO terminal mux sent configured input to the observed active session and the same terminal settled
termination PASS kill was acknowledged and termination was confirmed
native_restore PASS AO restored in native mode with the exact provider-native ID
same_ao_session_workspace PASS restore retained the AO session ID and workspace
post_restore_terminal_ready PASS the restored native terminal displayed the configured ready cue on the same terminal generation
post_restore_message PASS post-restore message produced a provider-authored mutation
history_file_continuity PASS native history recall and original proof-file continuity were both observed
system_prompt_restore PASS restore-only hidden standing instruction was observed after restore

Cross-check

Gate Result Reason
model_catalog_consistency NOT_RUN both local and AO model catalogs are required for comparison

AO reports credentials as configured, not provider-verified. Real Z.ai calls succeeded, so this metadata gap is not evidence of an expired login. The inspected native CLI exposes no supported model-list command; native listing/exact catalog comparison remain NOT_RUN.

No Neovate production change was required during the VPS audit. Earlier continuation was sent before the restored native UI mounted. A controlled same-session retry and final attempt 3 waited for the real native composer and verified the original history, proof-file fields and refreshed standing instructions. Cancellation used Neovate's Escape key through AO's actual terminal WebSocket mux.

The original strict skill remains unchanged. The separate diagnostic runner continues lifecycle testing only after successful direct native proof and AO installation/freshness checks; it retains the original non-passing auth/model gates. The runner revision used here passed 80/80 fixture tests; subsequent generic improvements passed 91/91.

Audited-head backend/aggregate CI · Pinned released-native conformance

Cleanup confirmed: the created session was terminated and the isolated daemon/native PTY processes stopped. A final audit-wide process scan found no remaining owned test processes. Credentials and raw native IDs are omitted here. Previous failed attempts and controlled comparisons remain preserved in the audit bundle. Real terminal text was captured; screenshots, Electron UI and native non-Linux harness coverage are not claimed.

Evidence identity
  • Final attempt: neovate-diagnostic-attempt3
  • Source report: neovate-diagnostic-attempt3/report.json
  • Original JSON report SHA-256: f38efeda3f3fa5ad1c82bf1e3644fbaac553ac71f2adc3bf67205779415d3c7e
  • Audited AO binary SHA-256: e32b841daefa160e2ac4c4129035af2fdded197ddf6e42abb782aba97561c3f2
  • Diagnostic runner SHA-256: 09070c3086b73d8a5d54b28ab07697dda06b67b23bc3c1ddea4555f7144ec741
  • The retained export includes sanitized report copies, prior attempts, fixture logs, review findings and exact-head CI evidence; export copies hash native/opaque identities and retain original-file hashes.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T09:01:33Z

Original comment

Evidence correction from the skill packaging review: the historical system_prompt_restore token was included in the initial standing instructions before the first turn. Its later appearance proves that token remained available after restore; it does not prove fresh instruction delivery or reinjection. The original 17/17 lifecycle result is a recorded runner result, not verified evidence for all 17 intended behaviors. Refreshed instructions remain unproven for this historical run. The reusable runner is being corrected to introduce a fresh token only after confirmed kill and before restore; fixture validation of that change is separate from real-provider validation, which has not been rerun. Original counts and artifacts below are retained for traceability.


Neovate 0.28.5 — failed-attempt report, 2026-10-10

The original failures remain preserved even though the final diagnostic run passed all 17 lifecycle gates. The full strict audit remains BLOCKED: AO reports configured credentials, and native model discovery/comparison are NOT_RUN. See the final gate-by-gate report.

All times below are UTC on 2026-10-10. Testing ran on the Ubuntu VPS, with real Z.ai calls; no local Mac checks were run.

Attempt / start Observed failure Cause and resolution Preserved evidence
Strict 1 / 05:47:08 Authentication BLOCKED; dependent lifecycle gates NOT_RUN. AO's configured-only observation does not prove provider-verified auth. Direct native proof allowed a separately labeled diagnostic run; the strict result was not promoted to PASS. neovate-strict-attempt1/report.json
Diagnostic 1 / 05:53:51 Cancellation FAIL: runner tried a nonexistent TUI interrupt HTTP endpoint and received 404. Post-restore execution/history/instructions also remained unproven. Runner defect: AO has no such interrupt endpoint. Corrected the runner to send Escape over the actual /mux WebSocket to the current terminal. Restored input also required readiness handling. neovate-diagnostic-attempt1/report.json
Diagnostic 2 / 06:13:49 Real mux Escape canceled the turn, but the restored API message stayed as unsubmitted pasted text. post_restore_message, history_file_continuity, system_prompt_restore failed. Runner readiness defect: continuation was sent before the native UI/composer mounted. HTTP 200 from send did not prove submission or task execution. neovate-diagnostic-attempt2/report.json; original terminal-capture/
Restore control 1 / 06:26:24 Control stopped before sending; no successful control result claimed. Control setup defect: it searched for the PTY registry beside the old data root. The registry is beside the current AO_RUN_FILE. Corrected the lookup and cleaned up the attempt. neovate-postrestore-control/report.json
Restore control 2 / 06:27:55–06:28:31 Controlled continuation passed. Waited for the actual native composer, then sent the identical normal API message. Exact native ID, original history/file and refreshed hidden instructions were all verified. No Neovate production change was needed for these failures. neovate-postrestore-control-attempt2/report.json
Diagnostic 3 / 06:38:48–06:40:13 No functional lifecycle failures. All 17 lifecycle gates passed with the corrected readiness-aware runner. Gate totals: 25 PASS, 1 BLOCKED, 2 NOT_RUN. All 24 CI checks passed on e82a48fa09c07e7d70cdd19a26aea0ae1bed7e1f. neovate-diagnostic-attempt3/report.json; final-ci.json

Original failed gate reasons included:

cancellation: AO exposes no TUI session interrupt endpoint
post_restore_message: post-restore message did not complete
history_file_continuity: history recall or original proof-file continuity was not proven
system_prompt_restore: hidden AO standing instructions were not proven after restore

Those downstream failures mean continuity was not proven in those attempts; they do not demonstrate that native history was deleted. The successful same-session control and final attempt provide separate positive continuity evidence.

Remaining gaps: configured credentials are authorized for this audit but still not classified as provider-verified by AO; this is not an expired-login finding. Local model listing and exact catalog comparison remain NOT_RUN because no valid native model-list contract was supplied.

Screenshot coverage: the historical attempts have real terminal text/ANSI captures, but no PNG screenshots. No rendered log or recreated error image is claimed as an original screenshot.

Evidence paths above are relative to the preserved VPS report directory /home/azureuser/.ao/audits/harness-20261010/reports/. A sanitized report export is retained locally under ao-agent-harness/reports/vps-2026-10-10/, including attempt-history.json; raw terminal captures remain on the VPS. These paths are provenance references, not public downloadable GitHub attachments. Original failed/partial artifacts were not replaced by final passing results.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T09:56:18Z

Original comment

The reusable integration/testing skill and consolidated session report are now in #6509.

The report includes two redacted, actual screenshots from the new Open Interpreter early-send reproduction; they are published repository evidence, not historical screenshots of Tau or Neovate. Original captures remain unchanged.

The historical instruction-refresh correction remains explicit: the old system_prompt_restore token was available before the first turn, so the recorded 17/17 result does not prove reinjected/refreshed instructions. The packaged runner now creates and installs a fresh token only after confirmed kill. Its exact commit passed 98/98 fixture tests on the Ubuntu VPS; the strengthened instruction gate has not been rerun against real providers. Auth/model gaps and the observed early-send failure remain unresolved in the historical integration results.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T18:41:17Z

Original comment

Fresh current-runner VPS follow-up: Neovate Code 0.28.5 / Z.ai aozai/glm-5.3-flash / TUI finished 2026-10-10T18:37:20.725Z with 25 PASS, 0 FAIL, 1 BLOCKED, 2 NOT_RUN. Functional lifecycle passes; strict BLOCKED / diagnostic-only because auth is configured, not verified, and native model-list/comparison remain NOT_RUN. No login or contract relaxation.

Fresh restore-only instructions were introduced after confirmed kill, written/read back through the project API, then consumed after the same native-ID/workspace restore. An end-anchored cue established the initialized empty composer with configured model and exact audit workspace before continuation. Mutation/history/fresh instructions passed. Cancellation proves the observed active-turn Escape→settled transition; it does not prove already-running subprocess reaping.

Functional source e82a48fa09c07e7d70cdd19a26aea0ae1bed7e1f; AO executable SHA-256 7c0340a91489e8dc9e2e306a821eee79e4aad313d343b85201470f53792fb31f; UI same exact source; runner 8887aa2e7101b9e6d3950bfca08ffddf2e1e6c1c3f1d030c8dec2676443aecea. AO session audit-neovate-c3090324-1; native SHA-256 b9fb3eadd73e423e648ee1959b17b836afcae16183298fd7119ec281e8316a35. Evidence-only head 49e850d3f4a676e14046755487c751d99bc94ad7. Original source 24/24 exact-head CI successful; final evidence-head jobs tracked separately. No huge backend race or frontend tsc/OOM rerun for assets only.

Neovate restored mutation/history/fresh instruction proof inside actual AO Electron

Actual AO Electron/preload bridge and exact session selected, source-matched UI; actual scrot/Xvfb at 2026-10-10T18:39:19.976133Z, PNG SHA-256 b082322cfc46f9faace73554c01a54c5ef817a69ee4e41e972d8ef754ee68cfc. Visually inspected for secrets/relevance. Harmless audit-only instruction tokens visible prove consumption, not secrecy. Native digest/restored generation reconfirmed. Supervisor reopened same isolated data with identical verified executable after finalized runner stopped; this is retained-session evidence, not a fabricated original gate screenshot or terminal mirror.

Curated gates, exact provenance/native fingerprint and cleanup. Historical failures remain unchanged. Historical 17/17 label did not prove fresh instructions; older native mirrors did not qualify as AO UI. Original preflight auth screenshot unavailable because no session existed.

Cleanup complete: audited session API-killed/termination confirmed; exact main Electron and current run-file daemon gone; exact GUI scratch auth PTY host terminated after it survived daemon shutdown. The first incomplete cleanup and GPU-PID rejection are retained. Unrelated AO/native processes and regular data untouched.

Final evidence-head CI verified at 2026-10-10T18:57:29.043379+00:00: 24/24 checks successful on 49e850d3f4a676e14046755487c751d99bc94ad7. Exact-head check example. Original source CI and final evidence CI are separate records; these are remote workflow results.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T16:52:27Z

Original comment

Harness-specific reports, JSON receipts, screenshots and provenance now live on this integration PR branch, rather than the skill PR #6509.

Evidence index with embedded screenshots and JSON links.

Historical successes, failures and scope limitations remain as recorded. Moving these files does not rerun native/AO testing or upgrade any verdict.

This is evidence relocation only. Existing tested source/native hashes and failures are preserved; the documentation commit is not a fresh runtime pass. Applicable checks run in PR CI.

Recorded harness evidence — see scope above


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:13:51Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 0ac9fbe42d9f, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:18:19Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 6f7d3cb3cb7b, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T20:57:37Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 6be36883b738, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T22:55:31Z

Original comment

Neovate actual AO evidence is owned by this integration PR at 49881bbffae5: report, immutable asset hashes. Fresh primary controls passed, restored NEW-token consumption and executing Escape failed; separate independent AO Kill and missing-transcript rejection passed. Invalid overlapping attempts remain separately labeled. Runtime/UI source 6be36883, released native0.28.5; authenticated wire role NOT_CAPTURED. Draft retained and new-head CI pending.

Actual registered fresh controls

Unrelated session still usable after independent Kill


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:40:25Z

Original comment

Continuing this existing draft on the VPS. Live head is a93d7afd282e9dce98d5284280ba1220c79ca986; current canonical main is 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f. The supervisor left their normal merge pending with one migration-ledger conflict; preserve both sets of entries and all historical work.

Plan: (1) finish that ancestry-preserving merge, (2) inspect current official Neovate release/source for real ACP initialize/load/resume and additive plugin support, (3) only if mandatory exact restore is supported, add a thin nativeacp/persistenthost binding and meaningful regression tests, then qualify real native and AO Chat behavior, (4) otherwise keep Chat gated and publish the precise upstream blocker. Routine suites run in PR CI only. No new evidence files, no PR6509 activity, no merge/release/deploy. Current free disk is 229 MiB; avoid allocations until native viability is known. Historical TUI receipts do not establish Chat conformance or executing-child interruption.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:42:57Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — native ACP exact restore is unavailable; draft retained. VPS-only bounded investigation on 2026-10-18T17:42:57.252651+00:00. This is not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Live PR head 4075d44fc6111883d8efb8e309aeec80f9982acb includes canonical main 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f through a normal merge. Both actual remote branches were fetched again before push and before this report; neither advanced. The sole migration-ledger conflict was resolved by retaining main’s 198/199/200/206 entries and Neovate’s 209 entry. Historical source, evidence and user work are preserved. No new report/evidence files, Chat implementation, duplicate AO PR, upstream fork, or PR6509 changes/comments were made.

Supported scope remains the existing terminal harness. There is no registered Neovate Chat binding. Shared nativeacp/persistenthost was inspected and left unchanged. A fresh native conversation must never masquerade as load/resume.

Gate Result Current evidence/scope
Official release/source PASS Latest official release 0.28.5; current master 0a24b363ecbe24eb87a0190a88fcb78c80593b4b still has the stubs in agent.ts. No supported newer release found.
Released native ACP initialize PASS Real stdio JSON-RPC: protocolVersion=1, agentCapabilities={}. Isolated empty profile/workspace, not a fake provider.
Native session/load FAIL Actual response below: method not implemented, before any history lookup. This does not qualify missing-history rejection.
Native session/resume FAIL Actual response below: method not implemented. No fallback attempted.
ACP authenticate method FAIL Same -32603 implementation error. No claim about provider credential validity; presence is not authorization.
New session/provider turn/model/options NOT_RUN Not needed to establish the unconditional restore-method blocker; no provider authorization or model support inferred.
Private additive plugin, fresh AND exact restore BLOCKED Existing TUI plugin does not qualify ACP independently. Fresh ACP consumption NOT_RUN; same-history refreshed private instruction cannot pass without native load/resume. Provider wire role unknown.
Text/reasoning/tools/plans and allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN No registered AO Chat session or provider turn in this attempt.
Executing child interrupt / separate AO Kill / continuation NOT_RUN No child execution or live AO Chat controls in this attempt; historical TUI failures remain unchanged.
Exact identity, missing-history/workspace, process restart, detached reconnect/replay BLOCKED No native ACP load/resume implementation; do not promote historical TUI restore to Chat proof.
Actual AO Chat UI / durable attachment BLOCKED No Chat binding/session to capture. No screenshot created or uploaded; attachment flow not tested. Historical TUI screenshots remain historical.
Current-head CI BLOCKED 25 current-head checks observed, none treated as historical green; statuses listed below. Routine local suites NOT_RUN by human instruction.
Independent review NOT_RUN No qualified Chat implementation to hand off.

Sanitized first-failure receipt, from the installed released executable, not source inference:

{"method":"initialize","result":{"protocolVersion":1,"agentCapabilities":{}}}
{"method":"session/load","error":{"code":-32603,"message":"Internal error","data":{"details":"Method not implemented."}}}
{"method":"session/resume","error":{"code":-32603,"message":"Internal error","data":{"details":"Method not implemented."}}}
{"method":"authenticate","error":{"code":-32603,"message":"Internal error","data":{"details":"Method not implemented."}}}

Native executable /home/azureuser/.ao/audits/harness-20261010/tools/neovate/node_modules/@neovate/code/dist/cli.mjs, version output 0.28.5, SHA-256 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323; runtime Node v24.21.0. No AO binary or UI build was allocated, so AO binary/UI/session/generation fingerprints are NOT_RUN. Native profile and workspace were under the supplied private runtime root. No source credential profile was written or copied. The exact owned ACP PID 1302006 was terminated and waited to exit (exit 0); no AO daemon, Electron app or foreground child was started. Production and unrelated controls were untouched. Disk preflight had 229 MiB free, so dependency installs/builds were avoided; the blocker above is native functionality, not an inferred resource failure.

Current-head CI observation:

Required external change: a supported first-party native ACP release implementing deterministic persistent session load/resume, workspace/history validation and replay. Current master has no such implementation; a future source patch/fork must stay explicitly gated until qualified. After that, rerun all real native/AO Chat gates including independent additive plugin consumption and direct screenshot attachment. This report retains the original implementation failures and does not upgrade any historical TUI result.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:44:42Z

Original comment

BLOCKED; not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. Final current head 12a06b5d5a348ce21269f126cc42c2f9a353717c; canonical main 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f. Both actual branches fetched again before the last push and this final update; no new remote commits to reconcile. Worktree clean. Draft retained.

The full gate table, exact released-native fingerprint, sanitized first failures, UI/attachment gaps and cleanup remain applicable: stock Neovate 0.28.5 ACP initializes with empty capabilities, then both session/load and session/resume unconditionally return -32603 / Method not implemented. Current official master 0a24b363ecbe24eb87a0190a88fcb78c80593b4b has the same stubs; no supported newer release exists. No ACP Chat binding was added. Independent fresh/restored additive plugin consumption is BLOCKED/unqualified, authenticated wire role unknown; AO Chat UI and direct attachment BLOCKED, remaining functional gates NOT_RUN/BLOCKED, independent review NOT_RUN. No AO binary/UI/session/generation was created in this attempt; exact native cli.mjs SHA-256 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323. All ready gates stay false.

A subsequent genuine CI failure was investigated and repaired in 12a06b5d: first failed live-feeds run requested https://registry.npmjs.org/-/package/@neovate%2Fcode@0.28.5/dist-tags, returning HTTP400. Registry metadata lookup now strips the version/tag suffix while retaining the scoped name, and a fake-HTTP regression checks the real requested package path. Install pin and native behavior are unchanged. Meaningful regression added; gofmt and diff whitespace check completed. Routine local tests/lint/typecheck were NOT_RUN per human constraints. The code fix is submitted to fresh CI, not claimed verified by old-head results.

Gate Result
Preserve current PR/main ancestry and user work PASS
Released-native initialize PASS
Released-native exact load/resume FAIL; upstream native blocker
Registry fix current-head CI BLOCKED pending completion
Real native/AO Chat qualification and UI BLOCKED
Independent review NOT_RUN

Exact current-head workflow observations:

Cleanup remains complete for the exact owned ACP process; no AO daemon/Electron/foreground child was launched, and no production or unrelated processes/data were changed. Historical evidence and first failures remain intact. No new report/evidence assets in Git, no PR6509 modifications/comments, no merge/release/deploy. External action: qualify a first-party ACP load/resume implementation/release (or separately gated upstream fix), then run the full native/Chat instruction, permission, executing-interrupt/Kill, exact restore/reconnect, UI attachment and independent review gates. CI completion remains separately pending.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:55:56Z

Original comment

Reconciliation pass only. Refreshed live head 12a06b5d5a348ce21269f126cc42c2f9a353717c and canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Preserve the existing in-progress merge and historical evidence; combine Neovate and main’s Memcode registrations/enums/tests, retain both migration ledgers, regenerate API artifacts if needed, then refresh both branches again and normally push to the live owner/ref. Routine suites remain CI-only; no ACP implementation or native/UI build in this pass. Parent cleanup is complete; no further deletion is needed (about 2 GiB free).


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:58:36Z

Original comment

RECONCILED — reconciliation pass complete; ACP readiness is not claimed.

Pushed normal merge e7f718f814a4d059840075cfb68d081e432d140c to nikhilachale/agent-orchestrator:feat/neovate-harness, integrating actual canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 and preserving PR head 12a06b5d5a348ce21269f126cc42c2f9a353717c. Both live branches were fetched at start, immediately before push, and again before this report; no newer commits remained. Worktree is clean.

Conflict decisions: retain both Neovate and main’s Memcode registration/activity/catalog enums and independent selection tests; combine DTO/generated API harness enums; retain ledger 209 alongside main’s 210–212 and preserve every burned entry. Main does not own migration 209; no merged migration was modified. Keep main’s account/lifecycle changes and Neovate’s native cancellation/environment propagation. API generation exposed a duplicate auto-merged LaunchConfig.Env and missing environment arguments in newer interactive restore/account-switch paths; these were reconciled to use the selected launch/account environment. No whole-file ours/theirs replacement.

Check Result
PR/main ancestry, no unresolved conflicts, clean worktree PASS
Go formatting, diff whitespace check PASS
OpenAPI and TypeScript generation (existing pinned 7.4.4 tool) PASS
Routine suites/lint/typecheck on VPS NOT_RUN — CI-only human instruction
Current-head CI PENDING — exact checks below; no historical green substituted
Native/provider/AO Chat/UI/independent review NOT_RUN in reconciliation pass; prior failures and blocked gates remain unchanged

Current-head checks:

Cleanup: parent removed only verified unused ignored historical node_modules, disposable npm cache and two superseded unused Codex vendor versions; affected checkout status and lockfile hashes were unchanged. No additional cleanup performed here. Historical code/evidence/history/screenshots and first failures preserved. No new report/evidence files, dependency installation, native/AO/UI runtime, production mutation, or PR6509 activity. API generation used existing tools; about 1.9 GiB disk remains. No owned live runtime processes were started to clean up. Draft retained. ACP implementation and full current-head CI qualification belong to the following ACP pass; this is not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:57:52Z

Original comment

Continuing ACP on the VPS at e7f718f814a4d059840075cfb68d081e432d140c, with live PR and canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 freshly fetched and already integrated. Worktree clean; about 1.1 GiB disk free; no additional deletion.

Plan: (1) repair current-head CI reconciliation defects: install inventory coverage and a Memcode negative fixture that unintentionally lacks Neovate; (2) inspect latest official release/current upstream ACP plus supported SDK/plugin restore paths, retaining exact native identity and replay requirements; (3) qualify additive plugin delivery independently where native permits, and keep Chat unregistered unless real gates pass; (4) submit reviewable source/tests to CI, refresh both branches before push/final publication, and report exact remaining native/UI gates inline. No routine suites on VPS, no evidence files committed, no PR6509 activity, no production mutations.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T23:04:55Z

Original comment

Fresh ACP investigation on VPS, source 9e040de3b725dceb3af68ddddacf4249a1a8573a; installed official @neovate/code@0.28.5, Node 24.21.0. CLI SHA256 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323; SDK/index SHA256 882416c63ffd9134ef6064972be126451125a174789024b0d9837e6eadc22077. Latest npm release remains 0.28.5; current upstream ACP still lacks load/resume/auth/mode implementation. Upstream search found ACP PRs #692/#717/#732, no current loadSession fix. SDK resume exists, but the session helper registers toolApproval with unconditional approved:true and exposes no approval callback; it is not an acceptable substitute for native permission control.

Real provider aozai/glm-5.3-flash, isolated profile/workspace, stock native ACP plus unchanged AO additive plugin. Visible ordinary task: “Summarize this workspace in SUMMARY.txt.” No private/project witness or instruction hints in the task. New random private additive instructions required a separate private file; independent AGENTS.md required a distinct project file. Both files matched their exact independent random values and the summary existed. Native permissions were answered allow_once; this alone does not prove rejection/cancel. Actual remote provider wire role remains UNKNOWN.

Controlled attempt 3 native conversation SHA256 0b3a99a4c507a61004e151540035d6fc18aaf190fc3f756aecaa70e075cc5fc1 (32-character native ID, not fabricated TUI identity). initialize returned protocolVersion:1 and empty agentCapabilities. session/prompt returned end_turn. Updates observed: agent_message_chunk, agent_thought_chunk, available_commands_update, tool_call, tool_call_update. Both exact session/load and session/resume, and authenticate, returned JSON-RPC -32603 / “Method not implemented.” No fresh fallback used. A further native protocol failure was preserved: plain assistant prose appeared on stdout outside JSON-RPC at completion. Diagnostic capture tolerated this only to collect downstream errors; AO transport is not changed to tolerate it and no protocol PASS is claimed.

First failures retained: attempt 1 probe refused an unimplemented fs/read_text_file client callback and cleaned up; attempt 2 added workspace-bounded filesystem callbacks and produced the three files, but its strict JSON reader failed on native plain stdout. Attempt 3 separately captured that line and collected final native errors. Owned PID/birth witnesses: attempt1 1331487/141021890, attempt2 1331640/141026185, attempt3 1331849/141033459; all exact owned native processes stopped, no daemon/Electron/production process started or changed. Private runtime history/first failures retained; no evidence assets committed.

Source progress: fixed both current-head CI reconciliation regressions, explicit Neovate Chat rejection regression, and remote-only pinned-release additive plugin fixture. Independent read-only source review found no actionable defects; no local suites ran. Following the newly observed native stdout defect, the fixture is being scoped explicitly to provider request construction (additive private/default/project prompt composition), not completed ACP protocol conformance. Chat stays unregistered and PR draft; exact restore, NEW instructions after Kill, reject/cancel, executing interrupt/Kill, reconnect/replay and actual AO Chat/UI remain unqualified. No real AO UI screenshot exists for unsupported Chat; screenshot unavailable. All current-head CI remains separately pending and will be read at the final head.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 2/3

Historical material from original PR #6494, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T23:08:38Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — source progress pushed; not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. Draft retained; Neovate Chat stays unregistered. Current released native ACP lacks exact load/resume and contaminates protocol stdout. Fresh private additive instructions now independently proven in native ACP; restore instruction refresh remains unproven.

Current head fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f on nikhilachale/agent-orchestrator:feat/neovate-harness; integrated actual canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Both actual live branches refreshed at start, before each push and immediately before this status; already integrated, no new commits or conflicts. Worktree clean; no user work overwritten. Normal commits 9e040de3 and fe0363e9, no history rewrite.

Implemented reviewable progress:

  • Replace stale install-plan count with exact canonical harness-set coverage, retaining duplicate/incomplete-plan checks. Original CI failure: 38 plans versus hardcoded 37.
  • Isolate the Memcode unmatched-constraint negative fixture on the current migrated schema; remove only Memcode and intentionally break the repair anchor. Original CI failure incorrectly encountered missing Neovate before Memcode. No migration or production repair logic altered.
  • Explicitly assert typed unsupported Chat rejection for Neovate.
  • Add pinned-release CI-only ACP additive plugin fixture: ordinary task and private addition exactly once, project rules preserved, private addition in system configuration alongside native defaults. This checks provider request construction with a local fixture, not completed protocol/real-provider/restore conformance. It deliberately stops at that boundary after live investigation exposed native plain stdout. No existing test disabled or skipped to make green.

Sanitized live receipts, first failures and native/source analysis remain inline. Real-provider proof used stock @neovate/code@0.28.5, Node 24.21.0, aozai/glm-5.3-flash, isolated native profile/workspace. All 12 installed package files independently matched a freshly streamed official npm release archive; no install modified. CLI SHA256 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323; SDK SHA256 882416c63ffd9134ef6064972be126451125a174789024b0d9837e6eadc22077. AO plugin source SHA256 3f7c70f0420983bc1ee5b863c7cc6449cf3f66d3baccae4be78f147c43fbe288 (same plugin at both pushed commits). No AO binary/UI build executed this pass; no AO build fingerprint or UI screenshot is claimed.

Current upstream source 0a24b363ecbe24eb87a0190a88fcb78c80593b4b; latest official npm release still 0.28.5. ACP source has unimplemented load/resume/auth/mode operations. SDK route investigated: native exact resume exists, but exported session helpers unconditionally approve tools and expose no approval callback; plugin nodeBridgeHandler handles the server side, not that reverse client callback. _query exposes messages/systemPrompt, not a native-session load/replay/permission contract. No unsupported bridge, synthesized identity/history, patched vendor install, overlapping AO PR, or unqualified upstream fork was substituted. A first-party native lifecycle/protocol fix or separately qualified SDK/plugin bridge is still required.

Acceptance / validation gate Status and precise scope
Branch/main ancestry, source formatting/diff check PASS
Native released identity and executable/package verification PASS
Initialize PASS: protocolVersion 1, empty agentCapabilities
Auth Configured profile and real provider call succeeded; ACP authenticate FAIL: -32603 Method not implemented. No configured→authorized metadata promotion
Fresh native session identity PASS: 32-char native ACP identity; controlled ID SHA256 0b3a99a4c507a61004e151540035d6fc18aaf190fc3f756aecaa70e075cc5fc1
Ordinary fresh private additive + independent project instructions PASS in native ACP: exact separate random private/project file values and requested summary; visible task named neither private/project witness nor standing instructions
Provider wire role/default prompt UNKNOWN for real remote provider; fixture asserts additive system configuration and preserved native defaults only
Text/reasoning/tools Native updates observed; completed prompt end_turn. Full clean ACP protocol FAIL: extra plain assistant prose on stdout
Plans, model/options qualification NOT_RUN; one configured real model exercised, no broad catalog/options claim
Native permissions allow_once observed; reject/cancel NOT_RUN, full approvals gate unqualified
Foreground executing child interrupt and separate AO Kill/control NOT_RUN in ACP; prior TUI failures remain preserved
Exact load/resume and stable identity after process restart FAIL: both exact load/resume -32603 Method not implemented; no fresh fallback
Missing-history/workspace native load rejection BLOCKED: no implemented native load contract; a generic unimplemented-method error is insufficient
NEW hidden instructions after confirmed Kill on same history BLOCKED by native load; fresh success is not restore proof
Detached host/daemon restart, reconnect/replay without duplication BLOCKED by native load/protocol; not fabricated from TUI
Actual AO Chat UI, source/build/session/generation screenshot BLOCKED: Chat unregistered; screenshot unavailable, no Chat UI started or attachment fabricated
Independent review PASS for changed source/tests, read-only reviewer twice found no actionable defects; full real integration review NOT_RUN
Routine suites on VPS NOT_RUN by human instruction; GitHub CI only
Final-head CI PENDING below; no previous-head green substituted

First failures remain preserved: probe 1 refused unsupported client fs callback; probe 2's strict JSON reader exposed native plain stdout after creating requested files; controlled probe 3 retained the offending line and collected exact load/resume errors. These diagnostic probes are not AO Chat qualification. Historical reports/assets and their earlier failure corrections are untouched.

Exact-head workflows (queried for fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f):

Published job snapshot (Go workflow pending may not yet expose job check-runs):

Current-head job Result
mac-update-helper QUEUED
released-tui QUEUED
native (ubuntu-latest) IN_PROGRESS
linux-proof-artifact IN_PROGRESS
live-feeds SUCCESS
scan SUCCESS
native (macos-latest) IN_PROGRESS
native (windows-latest) IN_PROGRESS
container QUEUED
test QUEUED
renderer-smoke QUEUED

No failure conclusion exists yet on this final head at publication. The earlier e7f718f8 failing Go run was inspected, both concrete failures addressed, and regression coverage submitted to current-head CI. Pending checks must still finish and any failures be repaired; source completion/green CI is not claimed here.

Cleanup: all exact owned native PIDs/births verified absent (1331487/141021890, 1331640/141026185, 1331849/141033459); no AO daemon/Electron/foreground child or unrelated control was launched. Private owned scratch profiles/history and first failures retained; source credential profile read only, isolated copies 0600, no credentials published. Parent cleanup removed only previously verified unused ignored node_modules/cache/superseded vendor versions, preserving source/status/lockfiles/history/evidence. No additional deletion, installs, code/evidence/history cleanup or production mutation; about 1.1 GiB free, above 512 MiB reserve. No new report/evidence assets committed, no PR6509 modifications/comments, no merge/release/deploy.

Remaining external/native blocker: supported exact ACP load/replay with permission-preserving session ownership and clean JSON-RPC output. After that, qualify fresh NEW instructions after Kill, reject/cancel, executing interrupt and AO Kill/control, exact missing history/workspace, reconnect/replay, supported options, actual AO Chat screenshots/direct attachment and independent full review, plus all final-head CI. Checkpoint verdict blocked; supervisor may advance without interpreting this queue exit as readiness.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:49:14Z

Original comment

Fresh testing-only retest starting for neovate at current PR head fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f using harness skill bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db. One bounded serial attempt (25-minute maximum; eight-minute output-stall watchdog); isolated source/runtime. Previous evidence is historical and will not count as fresh proof. Full 12-area matrix and screenshot checkpoints will follow in a new comment. No implementation, pushes, production restart, or excluded PR changes.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:01:07Z

Original comment

Bounded fresh harness retest — Neovate / PR #6494 — 2026-10-21T06:00:54.560773+00:00

Verdict: FAIL. Strict TUI audit: FAIL. AO UI capture and attachment evidence: BLOCKED. Full integration PASS is unavailable.

Tested source: fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f. Staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all 15 staged files byte-match that commit. Current GitHub head readback: fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f (unchanged). Detached worktree clean; no main merge or source/branch modifications. Linux x64, Node v24.21.0, Go 1.27.1. UI source intended: same tested SHA; no actual Electron window ran.

Native @neovate/code 0.28.5 SHA256: 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323. Fresh serial AO build (GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB go build -o "$RUNTIME/bin/ao" ./cmd/ao) exited 0; actual basename ao, version dev, SHA256 5757620cd83aa820fb593da43ef9b258669127dbc1949d67b9ffcd8ad791073d; Go build info records tested revision and vcs.modified=false. Binary file mtime 2026-10-21T05:53:34.007308+00:00 (build start timestamp was not separately captured).

Model/provider: aozai/glm-5.3-flash / aozai. Only minimum matching existing native provider configuration was copied into an isolated 0700 profile with 0600 config. No original profile/account writes. Fresh configured state is not verified authorization. No credential values or private profile paths are published.

Attempts and first failures (UTC):

Attempt Time Command / result
native-version 2026-10-21T05:51:23.809548+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:24.758829+00:00 <installed-neovate> --version; exit 0; PASS. exit and output hash only; no auth claim
native-help 2026-10-21T05:51:24.759287+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:25.701872+00:00 <installed-neovate> --help; exit 0; PASS. exit and output hash only; no auth claim
native-model 2026-10-21T05:51:25.702422+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:26.636092+00:00 <installed-neovate> config get model; exit 0; PASS. Valid project-scoped query exited 0; returned undefined, so no global selected-model claim. Corrected -g attempt is separate.
native-provider 2026-10-21T05:51:26.636654+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:52:41.722791+00:00 <installed-neovate> --quiet --approval-mode yolo --model aozai/glm-5.3-flash -- <unique disposable token/cwd file-witness task>; exit -15; FAIL. No matching provider-authenticated file witness; bounded 75s timeout, empty stdout/stderr, reaped; not an explicit native auth rejection
native-model 2026-10-21T05:56:51.318815+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:52.271983+00:00 <installed-neovate> config get -g model; exit 0; PASS. Fresh global setting aozai/glm-5.3-flash; output SHA256 e05e19e65930d21c36c3cb9adb93a62c2c53cc696d2927e342409f458236f875
chat 2026-10-21T05:56:51.318802+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:53.315661+00:00 <installed-neovate> acp --cwd <runtime-workspace> --model aozai/glm-5.3-flash; exit 0; PASS. Local native initialize/session-new and currentModelId only; no provider turn or registered AO Chat qualification. Stdout SHA256 eba3aa7aa492faaf5e8514d20ff46c99560eded676d3b8707a41bee1aec85c91
strict-audit 2026-10-21T05:53:52.751Z → 2026-10-21T05:54:34.047Z node <pinned-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent neovate --repo <tested-source> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao --local-contract <runtime>/native-contract-001.json --report <runtime>/attempts/strict-001/report --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 60; exit 1; FAIL. Finished strict report; direct native proof FAIL, AO auth BLOCKED configured; dependent TUI lifecycle NOT_RUN; daemon exit 0
chat 2026-10-21T05:56:21.384445+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:24.497379+00:00 python3 <runtime>/api-probe.py; exit 0; PASS. Safe registered daemon inventory/model/refresh/preference persistence and excluded Chat/reviewer rejection only; no AO Chat lifecycle; owned daemon exit 0
ui 2026-10-21T05:54:41.270383+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:55:03.761767+00:00 npm ci --no-audit --no-fund; exit -9; BLOCKED. Disk guard stopped setup before 700 MiB floor; free MiB before/minimum/after [1349, 826, 808]; only incomplete owned dependency/cache trees removed afterward

Independent native witness: 75-second timeout, no output and no matching file; stdout/stderr SHA256 each e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855. PID 1462710, kernel-start 160763945, stopped/reaped. This is a failed bounded proof attempt, not proof of expired/missing credentials. Strict local session then independently timed out at its 35-second bound. Both attempts remain separate. Strict native proof timestamps: 05:53:58.457Z → 05:54:33.976Z, duration 35,519 ms, timedOut=true, command exitCode=null after timeout handling, proofObserved=false.

Native ACP returned an empty agentCapabilities object and one available/current model aozai/glm-5.3-flash; native ID digest e143da32a5efc950239c64227751374dc78f2338df07a90e59ec1662756eff9e. This is local initialization only: no streamed/authenticated ACP turn, session/load, approvals, executing-tool cancellation or recovery was qualified. AO has no Neovate Chat driver, so its shared composer journeys remain NOT_RUN/NOT_IMPLEMENTED. Reviewer suitability is independently unqualified; no AO reviewer was run or published.

Strict result (strict-001):

Gate Verification Observed result
local_binary PASS local executable resolved
local_version PASS local version command succeeded
local_integration PASS local integration probe succeeded
local_session_spawn FAIL direct local CLI session did not produce valid token and workspace evidence
local_models_list NOT_RUN local model-list command is not defined
registered PASS agent is registered
installed PASS AO resolved the installed executable
fresh_probe PASS installation and authentication observations are fresh
authentication BLOCKED Neovate Code has credentials configured, but AO could not verify them.
ao_models_api NOT_RUN AO readiness prerequisite did not pass
tui_spawn NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
correct_working_directory NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
initial_prompt_exactly_once NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
hidden_ao_instructions NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
project_agents_md NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
proof_file_creation NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
second_message NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
activity_status NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
cancellation NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
native_session_id NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
termination NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
native_restore NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
same_ao_session_workspace NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
post_restore_terminal_ready NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
post_restore_message NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
history_file_continuity NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
system_prompt_restore NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
model_catalog_consistency NOT_RUN both local and AO model catalogs are required for comparison

No diagnostic runner attempt: native direct file proof failed, so diagnostic prerequisites were not met. Missing native model-list CLI stays NOT_RUN; no command was invented. restoredReady was deliberately omitted because no fresh settled/restored composer samples established a safe pattern. Native ACP model discovery is separate later evidence and does not rewrite strict gates.

Safe independent daemon API receipt (05:56 UTC): /readyz PID 1464353/executable/hash matched the owned launch; fresh probe/ensure returned installed/configured and effectiveReadiness=unknown. Models GET and refresh each HTTP 200 with one explicit provider-labelled entry, source=config, selectionMode=catalog, customModelEntry=configured, allowCustom=false. Native ACP and AO configured model IDs match. PATCH disabledModels off/read/on/read persisted in this runtime only; actual picker changes and last-enabled/bulk UI behavior were not exercised. Explicit Chat creation returned HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED (request vps-linux/34TIVK9YwM-000011) and session lists stayed unchanged. Reviewer configuration returned HTTP 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS (request vps-linux/34TIVK9YwM-000013); this is rejection proof, not an actual reviewer session.

AO read-only offers: installer uses @neovate/code@0.28.5; auth plan offers native terminal setup. Install/update/reinstall, login, account changes, logout/reset were NOT_RUN by authorization. No provider/account operation or production restart was performed. Read-only installer metadata also advertises an update target ending @neovate/code@0.28.5@latest; execution and package-spec validity remain NOT_RUN, not a tested successful update.

Completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI TUI worker/orchestrator; shared settings/task surfaces BLOCKED Fresh daemon inventory/probe confirms registered and installed. Actual selected-head Electron setup stopped by disk guard; no UI capture.
Models Native configured models; AO source=config/catalog; no native model-list CLI BLOCKED AO GET/refresh HTTP 200 and fresh native ACP session/new agree on aozai/glm-5.3-flash. Isolated preference disable/read/enable/read passed. Both UI surfaces, actual picker changes, bulk/last-enabled behavior and authenticated effective launch NOT_RUN. One configured model; no invented switches/catalog.
Providers Existing aozai native provider configuration BLOCKED Matching saved credential copied minimally into protected isolated profile; native provider witness timed out. Configured is not verified auth/account/effective routing. Model entry carries provider=aozai. AO add/change/remove/account flows and configured-account grouping NOT_RUN.
Setup AO npm installer offer and native terminal setup plan NOT_RUN Read-only APIs offer pinned @neovate/code@0.28.5 install and terminal setup. Install/update/reinstall/login/logout/account changes prohibited by testing authorization; no fresh onboarding claim.
Readiness Fresh Linux binary/config/auth observations BLOCKED Installation fresh/installed, authentication fresh/configured, reasonCode=auth_configured_unverified, effectiveReadiness=unknown. Independent native file proof failed by timeout, not an explicit credential rejection. Native macOS/Windows runtime not exercised.
Identity and logo Neovate Code label and intentional initials fallback BLOCKED API label and product-ui identity present; current avatar map has no Neovate asset. Repo documents fallback. Installed upstream README links logos, but separate asset licensing and actual AO avatar were not verified.
TUI and Chat AO TUI registered; native ACP local initialization; AO Chat absent FAIL Strict TUI audit FAIL at direct local file proof; dependent AO TUI turns NOT_RUN. Native initialize/session-new PASS only. Explicit Chat HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED with no session created. Supported native ACP is not qualified AO Chat; missing production driver remains unfinished scope, not N/A.
Reviewer No AO Neovate reviewer registration NOT_RUN Safe selection rejected HTTP 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS. Prompt-driven native review suitability remains unqualified. No actual AO review target/head/run/result/cancel/rerun; external reviewer publication forbidden.
Permissions and instructions Adapter maps default→default, accept-edits/auto→autoEdit, bypass→yolo NOT_RUN Mappings/source inspected only. No accepted provider witness or admitted AO lifecycle session, so approval/rejection, instruction consumption and long/multiline guarded input were not qualified. No readiness bypass.
Lifecycle TUI follow-up/cancel/Kill/archive/exact restore/reconnect NOT_RUN Strict preflight blocked dependent turns. No executing command PID/kernel-start witness, native ready composer, native identity continuity or delayed-side-effect proof. Missing freshly derived restoredReady contract retained honestly; clean daemon teardown is separate.
Evidence Fresh source/binary/contract receipts and complete checkpoint index BLOCKED One strict attempt preserved; standalone native/API/ACP/UI setup attempts separate. Zero actual AO UI PNGs; all required attachment evidence BLOCKED. No approved uploader. Historical committed evidence was not reused or changed; no new evidence committed.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub CI, conflict state and owned cleanup BLOCKED 26 check runs completed success on tested head; no pending/failing check runs. Legacy status endpoint says pending with zero contexts. PR mergeable=false/dirty; source clean. Local routine suites CI ONLY/NOT_RUN. PR-description evidence link remains pending for parent; runtime/UI/auth gaps unresolved.

Screenshot checkpoint index (all required rows, plus explicit Chat/reviewer subjourneys):

U1 = actual current-head Electron setup BLOCKED by capacity. Fresh npm ci --no-audit --no-fund started with 1349 MiB free, disk guard at 850 MiB stopped it (sampled minimum 826 MiB; 808 MiB after stop, above 700 MiB floor), exit -9 after bounded TERM/KILL grace, process reaped. Xvfb/scrot were available, but dependencies/runtime setup did not complete and Electron never launched. Only new incomplete dependency/cache trees were removed; space recovered to 1348 MiB. No safe actual AO screenshots exist for this attempt.

A1 = no approved working GitHub attachment uploader. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. Private attachment queue exists with zero PNG entries; no fake image URLs or substitute images. No checkpoint counts as published screenshot proof. No capture timestamp/session/generation is asserted for a nonexistent image.

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed state Functional status Screenshot / attachment
harness-listed Open Harness listing → no Electron window; API registration/label/installed confirmed. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
install-offer Inspect Install offer → API offer read, before/action/result UI unavailable. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
install-run Start Install → not attempted; provider installation/upgrades unauthorized. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-before Inspect existing credential state → fresh configured/unverified; no visible AO row. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-action Start login/setup → not attempted; login/account provisioning prohibited. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-ready Fresh verification → AO configured/unverified; native file proof timed out; no ready UI. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-maintenance Account change/logout/retry → account mutations prohibited; existing route preserved. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
harness-models List/refresh models → API list/refresh and native ACP model match passed; real Harness loading/result absent. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
model-visibility Off/on/bulk/reload/picker effects → API disable/enable readback passed; actual UI/pickers/bulk/last-enabled NOT_RUN. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
provider-management Inspect/add/change/remove provider → configured provider metadata only; no verified routing/account/UI actions. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-agent New Task Agent selection → no Electron dialog; registered ID available through API only. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-model New Task Model selection → no dialog; one configured native/AO model observed separately. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-running Submit → no admitted AO TUI task; strict preflight blocked; native provider file witness failed. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-followup Composer follow-up → no fresh AO provider session/initial completion. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-cancel Stop active tool → no executing PID/kernel-start witness; no cancellation claim. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
kill-action Archive control/confirmation → no provider AO session; daemon shutdown is not this journey. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
archived View exact archived session → no created AO provider session. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
restore-action Restore exact session/ready composer → no saved native AO identity or fresh ready contract. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
kanban-return Restore/continue/same Kanban card → prerequisites absent. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat Select Chat/stream/history/approval/reject/Stop/reconnect → AO driver NOT_IMPLEMENTED; truthful API rejection only. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-select Select actual AO Neovate reviewer/target/head → no registration; truthful capability rejection only. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-running Start/cancel/error/retry reviewer → no registered reviewer; publication-capable execution prohibited. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-result Result/verdict/rerun/new head → no AO review run; external publication unauthorized. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reconnect-cleanup UI reconnect/recovery/final screen → no UI/provider session; exact owned process teardown passed independently. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/new-task Persisted Chat session/new and initial file proof → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/followup-stream Shared composer, partial stream, outputs and file mutation once → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/load-history Paged history and exact native load/continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/approve Current permission request, no effect before approval, one authorized operation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/reject New permission request, native rejection, no denied side effect → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/cancel-active-tool PID/kernel-start witness, Stop, bounded child stop and no late write → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/ui-reconnect Same controller identity, no duplicated turns and fresh continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned daemon replacement, host adoption and exact continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/kill-restore-instructions Archive/restore, same native/workspace/history and new private instructions → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/negative-capabilities Missing history/workspace mismatch and unsupported input/settings → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer/cancel Actual AO reviewer cancel and worker isolation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer/rerun Actual rerun/new-head correlated result → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1

Current-head CI (GitHub only; no local unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/build-fixture/runner-fixture suites executed): 26 check runs, all completed/success, no failing or pending check runs. Legacy combined-status endpoint returns pending, total_count=0 (no legacy contexts, not a pending job). Current-head released-TUI CI uses a local model fixture and does not prove authenticated provider/UI/platform lifecycle conformance.

Check Status Evidence
build-test completed/success job
sqlite-race (1) completed/success job
lint completed/success job
sqlite-race (0) completed/success job
chat-race (0) completed/success job
backend-core (0) completed/success job
sqlite-race (2) completed/success job
chat-race (1) completed/success job
backend-core (1) completed/success job
sqlc-drift completed/success job
session-store-race completed/success job
windows-workspace completed/success job
api-drift completed/success job
sqlite-race (3) completed/success job
cloud-build-test completed/success job
linux-proof-artifact completed/success job
container completed/success job
native (windows-latest) completed/success job
native (ubuntu-latest) completed/success job
mac-update-helper completed/success job
scan completed/success job
released-tui completed/success job
test completed/success job
live-feeds completed/success job
native (macos-latest) completed/success job
renderer-smoke completed/success job

GitHub merge state: mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty; fresh base SHA 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Recorded comparison main SHA 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd; local divergence at that recorded main is 38 main-only / 18 PR-only commits. No merge/conflict repair was authorized or attempted.

Safe reproduction (paths intentionally generic; no installation/login):

export GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB
export NODE_OPTIONS=--max-old-space-size=384
export HOME="$RUNTIME/native-home" USERPROFILE="$RUNTIME/native-home"
export TMPDIR="$RUNTIME/tmp" NEOVATE_SELF_UPDATE=none
node "$STAGED_SKILL/scripts/audit_ao.mjs" --agent neovate \
  --repo "$TESTED_SOURCE" --ao "$RUNTIME/bin/ao" \
  --local-contract "$RUNTIME/native-contract-001.json" \
  --report "$RUNTIME/attempts/NEW-ATTEMPT/report" \
  --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 60

Runtime contract SHA256: 5472cda43f2016e2a886e667299803f912e8a283db2681fa94dc7c5b864ffe48. Independently derived native argv: version [--version]; integration [--help] expecting Quiet mode, non interactive; session [--quiet,--approval-mode,yolo,--model,aozai/glm-5.3-flash,--,{prompt}], proof file LOCAL_AUDIT_PROOF.json; AO models path agents/{agent}/models; interrupt byte Escape (\^[). models and restoredReady absent with reasons above. Correct global selected-model probe: neovate config get -g model. Disposable file-witness prompts/tokens and local absolute executable/profile paths omitted; original private receipts retain hashes.

Cleanup and retained data: strict daemon PID 1463726 and independent API daemon PID 1464353 each exited 0; all native/ACP/npm launches reaped. Exact owned PID/kernel-start/process-group inventory found zero remaining processes at 2026-10-21T05:57:45.551997+00:00. No provider AO session was created; no Kill/restore/cancellation lifecycle claim follows from daemon cleanup. Worktree clean. Private runtime retains strict JSON/Markdown/issues/logs, API/native/ACP receipts, protected isolated profile, binary, workspace and empty attachment queue outside every Git checkout. No new evidence commit, pushes, merges, old-comment edits, provider installs, account resets, production changes or external reviewer publication. Parent final owned-process verification/worktree removal remains separate.

Unresolved next actions: establish a successful independent native provider/file witness without changing accepted account state; resolve AO configured-only readiness in an authorized product-work scope; derive real native composer/restore/interrupt evidence before lifecycle work; qualify required Chat/reviewer scope independently rather than inferring it from TUI; provision sufficient isolated UI disk capacity, capture every action/result and have the parent attach reviewed PNGs using an approved route; resolve PR conflicts outside this testing-only worker. Current PR contains historical committed evidence, which was not reused or modified here. PR-description link to this new evidence comment is pending for parent; description was not edited. No full integration completion claim.

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 3/3

Historical material from original PR #6494, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:02:00Z

Original comment

Final evidence copy for exact readback. First fresh evidence comment remains unchanged. Its readback changed only textual Escape notation; this copy uses hexadecimal notation. These are the same test attempts, not a rerun.

Bounded fresh harness retest — Neovate / PR #6494 — 2026-10-21T06:00:54.560773+00:00

Verdict: FAIL. Strict TUI audit: FAIL. AO UI capture and attachment evidence: BLOCKED. Full integration PASS is unavailable.

Tested source: fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f. Staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all 15 staged files byte-match that commit. Current GitHub head readback: fe0363e92d8e071f86de55f69da129ebd5443e4f (unchanged). Detached worktree clean; no main merge or source/branch modifications. Linux x64, Node v24.21.0, Go 1.27.1. UI source intended: same tested SHA; no actual Electron window ran.

Native @neovate/code 0.28.5 SHA256: 676775b5762ea6464da5560693daca3a2dad807ab6ca661bbeb795ec186b9323. Fresh serial AO build (GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB go build -o "$RUNTIME/bin/ao" ./cmd/ao) exited 0; actual basename ao, version dev, SHA256 5757620cd83aa820fb593da43ef9b258669127dbc1949d67b9ffcd8ad791073d; Go build info records tested revision and vcs.modified=false. Binary file mtime 2026-10-21T05:53:34.007308+00:00 (build start timestamp was not separately captured).

Model/provider: aozai/glm-5.3-flash / aozai. Only minimum matching existing native provider configuration was copied into an isolated 0700 profile with 0600 config. No original profile/account writes. Fresh configured state is not verified authorization. No credential values or private profile paths are published.

Attempts and first failures (UTC):

Attempt Time Command / result
native-version 2026-10-21T05:51:23.809548+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:24.758829+00:00 <installed-neovate> --version; exit 0; PASS. exit and output hash only; no auth claim
native-help 2026-10-21T05:51:24.759287+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:25.701872+00:00 <installed-neovate> --help; exit 0; PASS. exit and output hash only; no auth claim
native-model 2026-10-21T05:51:25.702422+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:51:26.636092+00:00 <installed-neovate> config get model; exit 0; PASS. Valid project-scoped query exited 0; returned undefined, so no global selected-model claim. Corrected -g attempt is separate.
native-provider 2026-10-21T05:51:26.636654+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:52:41.722791+00:00 <installed-neovate> --quiet --approval-mode yolo --model aozai/glm-5.3-flash -- <unique disposable token/cwd file-witness task>; exit -15; FAIL. No matching provider-authenticated file witness; bounded 75s timeout, empty stdout/stderr, reaped; not an explicit native auth rejection
native-model 2026-10-21T05:56:51.318815+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:52.271983+00:00 <installed-neovate> config get -g model; exit 0; PASS. Fresh global setting aozai/glm-5.3-flash; output SHA256 e05e19e65930d21c36c3cb9adb93a62c2c53cc696d2927e342409f458236f875
chat 2026-10-21T05:56:51.318802+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:53.315661+00:00 <installed-neovate> acp --cwd <runtime-workspace> --model aozai/glm-5.3-flash; exit 0; PASS. Local native initialize/session-new and currentModelId only; no provider turn or registered AO Chat qualification. Stdout SHA256 eba3aa7aa492faaf5e8514d20ff46c99560eded676d3b8707a41bee1aec85c91
strict-audit 2026-10-21T05:53:52.751Z → 2026-10-21T05:54:34.047Z node <pinned-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent neovate --repo <tested-source> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao --local-contract <runtime>/native-contract-001.json --report <runtime>/attempts/strict-001/report --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 60; exit 1; FAIL. Finished strict report; direct native proof FAIL, AO auth BLOCKED configured; dependent TUI lifecycle NOT_RUN; daemon exit 0
chat 2026-10-21T05:56:21.384445+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:56:24.497379+00:00 python3 <runtime>/api-probe.py; exit 0; PASS. Safe registered daemon inventory/model/refresh/preference persistence and excluded Chat/reviewer rejection only; no AO Chat lifecycle; owned daemon exit 0
ui 2026-10-21T05:54:41.270383+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:55:03.761767+00:00 npm ci --no-audit --no-fund; exit -9; BLOCKED. Disk guard stopped setup before 700 MiB floor; free MiB before/minimum/after [1349, 826, 808]; only incomplete owned dependency/cache trees removed afterward

Independent native witness: 75-second timeout, no output and no matching file; stdout/stderr SHA256 each e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855. PID 1462710, kernel-start 160763945, stopped/reaped. This is a failed bounded proof attempt, not proof of expired/missing credentials. Strict local session then independently timed out at its 35-second bound. Both attempts remain separate. Strict native proof timestamps: 05:53:58.457Z → 05:54:33.976Z, duration 35,519 ms, timedOut=true, command exitCode=null after timeout handling, proofObserved=false.

Native ACP returned an empty agentCapabilities object and one available/current model aozai/glm-5.3-flash; native ID digest e143da32a5efc950239c64227751374dc78f2338df07a90e59ec1662756eff9e. This is local initialization only: no streamed/authenticated ACP turn, session/load, approvals, executing-tool cancellation or recovery was qualified. AO has no Neovate Chat driver, so its shared composer journeys remain NOT_RUN/NOT_IMPLEMENTED. Reviewer suitability is independently unqualified; no AO reviewer was run or published.

Strict result (strict-001):

Gate Verification Observed result
local_binary PASS local executable resolved
local_version PASS local version command succeeded
local_integration PASS local integration probe succeeded
local_session_spawn FAIL direct local CLI session did not produce valid token and workspace evidence
local_models_list NOT_RUN local model-list command is not defined
registered PASS agent is registered
installed PASS AO resolved the installed executable
fresh_probe PASS installation and authentication observations are fresh
authentication BLOCKED Neovate Code has credentials configured, but AO could not verify them.
ao_models_api NOT_RUN AO readiness prerequisite did not pass
tui_spawn NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
correct_working_directory NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
initial_prompt_exactly_once NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
hidden_ao_instructions NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
project_agents_md NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
proof_file_creation NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
second_message NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
activity_status NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
cancellation NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
native_session_id NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
termination NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
native_restore NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
same_ao_session_workspace NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
post_restore_terminal_ready NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
post_restore_message NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
history_file_continuity NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
system_prompt_restore NOT_RUN preflight prerequisite did not pass
model_catalog_consistency NOT_RUN both local and AO model catalogs are required for comparison

No diagnostic runner attempt: native direct file proof failed, so diagnostic prerequisites were not met. Missing native model-list CLI stays NOT_RUN; no command was invented. restoredReady was deliberately omitted because no fresh settled/restored composer samples established a safe pattern. Native ACP model discovery is separate later evidence and does not rewrite strict gates.

Safe independent daemon API receipt (05:56 UTC): /readyz PID 1464353/executable/hash matched the owned launch; fresh probe/ensure returned installed/configured and effectiveReadiness=unknown. Models GET and refresh each HTTP 200 with one explicit provider-labelled entry, source=config, selectionMode=catalog, customModelEntry=configured, allowCustom=false. Native ACP and AO configured model IDs match. PATCH disabledModels off/read/on/read persisted in this runtime only; actual picker changes and last-enabled/bulk UI behavior were not exercised. Explicit Chat creation returned HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED (request vps-linux/34TIVK9YwM-000011) and session lists stayed unchanged. Reviewer configuration returned HTTP 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS (request vps-linux/34TIVK9YwM-000013); this is rejection proof, not an actual reviewer session.

AO read-only offers: installer uses @neovate/code@0.28.5; auth plan offers native terminal setup. Install/update/reinstall, login, account changes, logout/reset were NOT_RUN by authorization. No provider/account operation or production restart was performed. Read-only installer metadata also advertises an update target ending @neovate/code@0.28.5@latest; execution and package-spec validity remain NOT_RUN, not a tested successful update.

Completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI TUI worker/orchestrator; shared settings/task surfaces BLOCKED Fresh daemon inventory/probe confirms registered and installed. Actual selected-head Electron setup stopped by disk guard; no UI capture.
Models Native configured models; AO source=config/catalog; no native model-list CLI BLOCKED AO GET/refresh HTTP 200 and fresh native ACP session/new agree on aozai/glm-5.3-flash. Isolated preference disable/read/enable/read passed. Both UI surfaces, actual picker changes, bulk/last-enabled behavior and authenticated effective launch NOT_RUN. One configured model; no invented switches/catalog.
Providers Existing aozai native provider configuration BLOCKED Matching saved credential copied minimally into protected isolated profile; native provider witness timed out. Configured is not verified auth/account/effective routing. Model entry carries provider=aozai. AO add/change/remove/account flows and configured-account grouping NOT_RUN.
Setup AO npm installer offer and native terminal setup plan NOT_RUN Read-only APIs offer pinned @neovate/code@0.28.5 install and terminal setup. Install/update/reinstall/login/logout/account changes prohibited by testing authorization; no fresh onboarding claim.
Readiness Fresh Linux binary/config/auth observations BLOCKED Installation fresh/installed, authentication fresh/configured, reasonCode=auth_configured_unverified, effectiveReadiness=unknown. Independent native file proof failed by timeout, not an explicit credential rejection. Native macOS/Windows runtime not exercised.
Identity and logo Neovate Code label and intentional initials fallback BLOCKED API label and product-ui identity present; current avatar map has no Neovate asset. Repo documents fallback. Installed upstream README links logos, but separate asset licensing and actual AO avatar were not verified.
TUI and Chat AO TUI registered; native ACP local initialization; AO Chat absent FAIL Strict TUI audit FAIL at direct local file proof; dependent AO TUI turns NOT_RUN. Native initialize/session-new PASS only. Explicit Chat HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED with no session created. Supported native ACP is not qualified AO Chat; missing production driver remains unfinished scope, not N/A.
Reviewer No AO Neovate reviewer registration NOT_RUN Safe selection rejected HTTP 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS. Prompt-driven native review suitability remains unqualified. No actual AO review target/head/run/result/cancel/rerun; external reviewer publication forbidden.
Permissions and instructions Adapter maps default→default, accept-edits/auto→autoEdit, bypass→yolo NOT_RUN Mappings/source inspected only. No accepted provider witness or admitted AO lifecycle session, so approval/rejection, instruction consumption and long/multiline guarded input were not qualified. No readiness bypass.
Lifecycle TUI follow-up/cancel/Kill/archive/exact restore/reconnect NOT_RUN Strict preflight blocked dependent turns. No executing command PID/kernel-start witness, native ready composer, native identity continuity or delayed-side-effect proof. Missing freshly derived restoredReady contract retained honestly; clean daemon teardown is separate.
Evidence Fresh source/binary/contract receipts and complete checkpoint index BLOCKED One strict attempt preserved; standalone native/API/ACP/UI setup attempts separate. Zero actual AO UI PNGs; all required attachment evidence BLOCKED. No approved uploader. Historical committed evidence was not reused or changed; no new evidence committed.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub CI, conflict state and owned cleanup BLOCKED 26 check runs completed success on tested head; no pending/failing check runs. Legacy status endpoint says pending with zero contexts. PR mergeable=false/dirty; source clean. Local routine suites CI ONLY/NOT_RUN. PR-description evidence link remains pending for parent; runtime/UI/auth gaps unresolved.

Screenshot checkpoint index (all required rows, plus explicit Chat/reviewer subjourneys):

U1 = actual current-head Electron setup BLOCKED by capacity. Fresh npm ci --no-audit --no-fund started with 1349 MiB free, disk guard at 850 MiB stopped it (sampled minimum 826 MiB; 808 MiB after stop, above 700 MiB floor), exit -9 after bounded TERM/KILL grace, process reaped. Xvfb/scrot were available, but dependencies/runtime setup did not complete and Electron never launched. Only new incomplete dependency/cache trees were removed; space recovered to 1348 MiB. No safe actual AO screenshots exist for this attempt.

A1 = no approved working GitHub attachment uploader. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. Private attachment queue exists with zero PNG entries; no fake image URLs or substitute images. No checkpoint counts as published screenshot proof. No capture timestamp/session/generation is asserted for a nonexistent image.

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed state Functional status Screenshot / attachment
harness-listed Open Harness listing → no Electron window; API registration/label/installed confirmed. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
install-offer Inspect Install offer → API offer read, before/action/result UI unavailable. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
install-run Start Install → not attempted; provider installation/upgrades unauthorized. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-before Inspect existing credential state → fresh configured/unverified; no visible AO row. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-action Start login/setup → not attempted; login/account provisioning prohibited. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-ready Fresh verification → AO configured/unverified; native file proof timed out; no ready UI. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
auth-maintenance Account change/logout/retry → account mutations prohibited; existing route preserved. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
harness-models List/refresh models → API list/refresh and native ACP model match passed; real Harness loading/result absent. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
model-visibility Off/on/bulk/reload/picker effects → API disable/enable readback passed; actual UI/pickers/bulk/last-enabled NOT_RUN. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
provider-management Inspect/add/change/remove provider → configured provider metadata only; no verified routing/account/UI actions. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-agent New Task Agent selection → no Electron dialog; registered ID available through API only. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-model New Task Model selection → no dialog; one configured native/AO model observed separately. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-running Submit → no admitted AO TUI task; strict preflight blocked; native provider file witness failed. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-followup Composer follow-up → no fresh AO provider session/initial completion. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
task-cancel Stop active tool → no executing PID/kernel-start witness; no cancellation claim. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
kill-action Archive control/confirmation → no provider AO session; daemon shutdown is not this journey. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
archived View exact archived session → no created AO provider session. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
restore-action Restore exact session/ready composer → no saved native AO identity or fresh ready contract. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
kanban-return Restore/continue/same Kanban card → prerequisites absent. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat Select Chat/stream/history/approval/reject/Stop/reconnect → AO driver NOT_IMPLEMENTED; truthful API rejection only. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-select Select actual AO Neovate reviewer/target/head → no registration; truthful capability rejection only. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-running Start/cancel/error/retry reviewer → no registered reviewer; publication-capable execution prohibited. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer-result Result/verdict/rerun/new head → no AO review run; external publication unauthorized. NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reconnect-cleanup UI reconnect/recovery/final screen → no UI/provider session; exact owned process teardown passed independently. BLOCKED Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/new-task Persisted Chat session/new and initial file proof → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/followup-stream Shared composer, partial stream, outputs and file mutation once → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/load-history Paged history and exact native load/continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/approve Current permission request, no effect before approval, one authorized operation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/reject New permission request, native rejection, no denied side effect → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/cancel-active-tool PID/kernel-start witness, Stop, bounded child stop and no late write → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/ui-reconnect Same controller identity, no duplicated turns and fresh continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned daemon replacement, host adoption and exact continuation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/kill-restore-instructions Archive/restore, same native/workspace/history and new private instructions → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
chat/negative-capabilities Missing history/workspace mismatch and unsupported input/settings → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer/cancel Actual AO reviewer cancel and worker isolation → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1
reviewer/rerun Actual rerun/new-head correlated result → NOT_RUN NOT_RUN Unavailable — U1 / A1

Current-head CI (GitHub only; no local unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/build-fixture/runner-fixture suites executed): 26 check runs, all completed/success, no failing or pending check runs. Legacy combined-status endpoint returns pending, total_count=0 (no legacy contexts, not a pending job). Current-head released-TUI CI uses a local model fixture and does not prove authenticated provider/UI/platform lifecycle conformance.

Check Status Evidence
build-test completed/success job
sqlite-race (1) completed/success job
lint completed/success job
sqlite-race (0) completed/success job
chat-race (0) completed/success job
backend-core (0) completed/success job
sqlite-race (2) completed/success job
chat-race (1) completed/success job
backend-core (1) completed/success job
sqlc-drift completed/success job
session-store-race completed/success job
windows-workspace completed/success job
api-drift completed/success job
sqlite-race (3) completed/success job
cloud-build-test completed/success job
linux-proof-artifact completed/success job
container completed/success job
native (windows-latest) completed/success job
native (ubuntu-latest) completed/success job
mac-update-helper completed/success job
scan completed/success job
released-tui completed/success job
test completed/success job
live-feeds completed/success job
native (macos-latest) completed/success job
renderer-smoke completed/success job

GitHub merge state: mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty; fresh base SHA 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Recorded comparison main SHA 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd; local divergence at that recorded main is 38 main-only / 18 PR-only commits. No merge/conflict repair was authorized or attempted.

Safe reproduction (paths intentionally generic; no installation/login):

export GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB
export NODE_OPTIONS=--max-old-space-size=384
export HOME="$RUNTIME/native-home" USERPROFILE="$RUNTIME/native-home"
export TMPDIR="$RUNTIME/tmp" NEOVATE_SELF_UPDATE=none
node "$STAGED_SKILL/scripts/audit_ao.mjs" --agent neovate \
  --repo "$TESTED_SOURCE" --ao "$RUNTIME/bin/ao" \
  --local-contract "$RUNTIME/native-contract-001.json" \
  --report "$RUNTIME/attempts/NEW-ATTEMPT/report" \
  --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 60

Runtime contract SHA256: 5472cda43f2016e2a886e667299803f912e8a283db2681fa94dc7c5b864ffe48. Independently derived native argv: version [--version]; integration [--help] expecting Quiet mode, non interactive; session [--quiet,--approval-mode,yolo,--model,aozai/glm-5.3-flash,--,{prompt}], proof file LOCAL_AUDIT_PROOF.json; AO models path agents/{agent}/models; interrupt byte Escape (hex 0x1b). models and restoredReady absent with reasons above. Correct global selected-model probe: neovate config get -g model. Disposable file-witness prompts/tokens and local absolute executable/profile paths omitted; original private receipts retain hashes.

Cleanup and retained data: strict daemon PID 1463726 and independent API daemon PID 1464353 each exited 0; all native/ACP/npm launches reaped. Exact owned PID/kernel-start/process-group inventory found zero remaining processes at 2026-10-21T05:57:45.551997+00:00. No provider AO session was created; no Kill/restore/cancellation lifecycle claim follows from daemon cleanup. Worktree clean. Private runtime retains strict JSON/Markdown/issues/logs, API/native/ACP receipts, protected isolated profile, binary, workspace and empty attachment queue outside every Git checkout. No new evidence commit, pushes, merges, old-comment edits, provider installs, account resets, production changes or external reviewer publication. Parent final owned-process verification/worktree removal remains separate.

Unresolved next actions: establish a successful independent native provider/file witness without changing accepted account state; resolve AO configured-only readiness in an authorized product-work scope; derive real native composer/restore/interrupt evidence before lifecycle work; qualify required Chat/reviewer scope independently rather than inferring it from TUI; provision sufficient isolated UI disk capacity, capture every action/result and have the parent attach reviewed PNGs using an approved route; resolve PR conflicts outside this testing-only worker. Current PR contains historical committed evidence, which was not reused or modified here. PR-description link to this new evidence comment is pending for parent; description was not edited. No full integration completion claim.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-22T00:20:09Z

Original comment

Screenshot 2026-10-22 at 05 43 35

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🏆 Review leaderboard

Nov 5–12, 2026 · UTC

Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
🥇 @ronishrohan @ronishrohan 91 162 15
🥈 @neversettle17-101 @neversettle17-101 11 15 4
🥉 @illegalcall @illegalcall 11 13 5
4 @Meraj-08 @Meraj-08 10 15 0
5 @nikhilachale @nikhilachale 7 19 3
6 @Prasad-D-Ware @Prasad-D-Ware 7 12 2
7 @Annieeeee11 @Annieeeee11 6 9 0
8 @mohakchakraborty2004 @mohakchakraborty2004 6 7 2
9 @Pritom14 @Pritom14 5 8 1
10 @Rishet11 @Rishet11 5 6 3

Ranked by distinct external PRs reviewed, then review rounds, then PR comments. Self-activity and bot activity are excluded.

Show 6 more reviewers
Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
11 @somewherelostt @somewherelostt 3 11 1
12 @ApexYash11 @ApexYash11 2 6 2
13 @Vaibhaav-Tiwari @Vaibhaav-Tiwari 2 3 0
14 @codebanditssss @codebanditssss 2 2 8
15 @harshitsinghbhandari @harshitsinghbhandari 2 2 0
16 @MohamedKamran @MohamedKamran 1 2 0

@OrcInc OrcInc added comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request labels Nov 12, 2026
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Account migration verification

  • New PR author verified as milesatao-svg; submission is a draft.
  • Original PR #6494 and this PR both point to 116129b6c81f111e65b82b1c24a86e07dc07c2f2.
  • Published change-count header verified against this PR's actual GitHub file diff.
  • All 21 original human comment bodies and source links reproduced across 3 historical-evidence comments.
  • All 4 original screenshot/recording URLs reproduced and checked as HTTP 200 media.
  • Current GitHub mergeability: conflicts with main; resolution pending.
  • Fresh CI validation and current-head harness certification are pending. Copied test outcomes retain their original run/commit provenance.

nikhilachale and others added 6 commits November 14, 2026 23:08
Resolve 23 conflicts against main adf9f6a:
- harness lists: keep Neovate alongside main's Hermes everywhere
- session manager: keep main's launchPath/nativeRestoreMetadata and its
  existing Env plumbing; drop the PR's now-duplicate RestoreConfig.Env and
  LaunchConfig Env keys; keep the PR's env on preflight and native restore
- schema repair: keep both 0195 (Neovate fork) and 0199 repairs; normalize
  Neovate out before exact historical repairs and re-append it last, as main
  does for Hermes
- settings UI: keep main's unverified/renewal auth states; Neovate's saved
  credential still reads "Connected" via the existing loggedIn key, so the
  PR's duplicate settings.harness.connected strings are dropped
- schema.ts: main's generated file plus Neovate in the three harness enums
- add Neovate to main's new exhaustive doctor, shell-agent and tone maps

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Neovate 0.28.5 reads 28 provider key variables, but AuthStatus checked
only eight, so a MiniMax (MINIMAX_API_KEY) or other env-only provider
read as unconfigured. Check the full pinned registry list, and offer
Neovate's main provider keys (including MiniMax and Z.ai) in AO's
provider-key setup, which main's exhaustive setup-method test requires.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main now allocates UTC-timestamped migration IDs. Retire the unmerged
0209 candidate the same way main retired Hermes' 0203: reserve 209 in
the ledger and burnedVersion, and add 20261114173957269, ordered after
main's latest 20261114072016988.

The new migration follows the Hermes template: Up is idempotent, so
pre-merge installs that already applied 0209 pass through it, and a
schema guard fails loudly on an unrecognized constraint. Down refuses
while Neovate rows exist and removes Neovate wherever it sits, instead
of assuming it immediately precedes 'fake'.

Verify Neovate last in the schema repair, matching its append order, so
the Memcode negative fixture still reports Memcode.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Neovate's catalog includes every built-in provider's models, which stay
selectable until native /login stores a key, so treat it as a
multi-provider harness and do not hide its catalog behind setup.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Current-head reconciliation and ao-agent-harness receipt

Head: 5e17150f187e83a403d95d8b0f29b3c63f9a6805 (fast-forward from 116129b6). Base merged: main 28bc83fd95. GitHub reports the PR as mergeable (no conflicts).
Skill reference: .agents/skills/ao-agent-harness at 04c8c95b23d7 (PR #7081). I read it with git show. None of its files, contracts, reports or screenshots are in this diff.

Changes in this pass

  • Merged main and resolved all 23 conflicts. Neovate now sits beside main's Hermes in every harness list. I removed fields the merge had duplicated (RestoreConfig.Env, and Env in three LaunchConfig literals) and kept main's launchPath and nativeRestoreMetadata restore flow.
  • Main added maps and tests that must cover every harness, and they lacked Neovate. I added it to ao doctor (PATH-only probe), shell-agent classification, the agent tone map and the provider-key setup methods.
  • Lint: fixed the prealloc finding at modelcatalog/neovate.go:66 (neovateAllModels), the only finding in the last lint run.
  • Auth: AuthStatus checked 8 key variables, but the pinned 0.28.5 registry reads 28. Keys such as MINIMAX_API_KEY, MOONSHOT_API_KEY and GROQ_API_KEY did not count as configured. It now checks the full list, and a new test covers MiniMax and Z.ai.
  • Migration: replaced 0209_allow_neovate_harness.sql with 20261114173957269_allow_neovate_harness.sql, ordered after main's latest 20261114072016988. 0209 is now reserved as burned, the same way main retired Hermes' 0203. Up is idempotent, so installs that already applied 0209 just pass through it, and a guard rejects a constraint it doesn't recognize. Down refuses while Neovate rows exist and removes 'neovate' wherever it sits. Before, it assumed Neovate came directly before 'fake'.
  • I checked main's later migrations. None after Hermes rebuilds sessions or changes its harness CHECK. 20261114072016988 only recreates session_account_pins.
  • Schema repair now handles Neovate the same way as Hermes: it removes Neovate before the exact historical repairs, adds it back last and checks for it last.
  • Settings: kept main's new unverified and renewal auth states. A saved Neovate key still shows "Connected" through the existing loggedIn key. Neovate is listed in MULTI_PROVIDER_HARNESSES, so its built-in catalog shows before a key is saved.

Provider compatibility (pinned @neovate/code 0.28.5 registry)

Provider Native env AO auth detection AO key setup Catalog Live auth
MiniMax (minimax, minimax-cn) MINIMAX_API_KEY PASS (fixed this pass) PASS (env_MINIMAX_API_KEY) PASS (static) NOT VERIFIED
Z.ai (zai-coding-plan, zhipuai, zhipuai-coding-plan) ZHIPU_API_KEY PASS PASS (env_ZHIPU_API_KEY) PASS (static) NOT VERIFIED

Neovate 0.28.5 does not read ZAI_API_KEY (Hermes does). For Z.ai, Neovate needs ZHIPU_API_KEY.

Skill steps

Step Result Evidence or gap
0 Intake PASS Continuing the existing PR. No second PR opened.
1 Compatibility BLOCKED Not rechecked live. Earlier evidence is in the description. Chat (ACP load/resume) is still unsupported upstream.
2 Touchpoints PASS required, with optional items open Checked by grep against the harness_touchpoints.mjs rules (script not run). TUI, install, auth, models and branding are wired. Optional and still missing: avatar-license, harness-doc, docs-index, docs-agents-index (docs were dropped in 66081ca7c0). Chat and reviewer are SKIP because neither is registered.
3 Contract BLOCKED No local-contracts.json entry. The skill isn't on main and must not be copied in. run_local.sh doctor not run.
4 Live audit BLOCKED Not run. This Windows host is off-limits for runs, and no Linux or macOS audit host is authorized.
5 UI audit BLOCKED Not run, for the same reason.
6 Hand-off Partial The AO-side fixes above are in. Still needed: the live audit and the UI audit.

Validation

  • Local: none. Go and Node suites were not run on this Windows workstation. Everything was checked by reading code only.
  • CI: the fork's runs for this head (CI, gitleaks, Public boundary, Harness release feeds) are action_required and need a maintainer to approve them.

Still a draft. This is not ready to merge: it still needs CI, a fresh review, maintainer approval and the live and UI audits.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants