Skip to content

feat: add Strands TUI harness with bounded foreground cancellation - #8207

Draft
milesatao-svg wants to merge 53 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6517-strands
Draft

milesatao-svg wants to merge 53 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6517-strands

Conversation

@milesatao-svg

@milesatao-svg milesatao-svg commented Nov 12, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Current status (head 2e55727e57, main 28bc83fd95): main merged with all conflicts resolved, CI i18n failure fixed, a Models-panel regression for discovery harnesses fixed, an unrelated spawn --agent override reverted, the Strands migration renumbered above main's latest (20261114173932630), and committed evidence/screenshots plus the unregistered strandsacp driver removed from the diff per the ao-agent-harness skill. The diff no longer contains binary assets or docs/research files; links below to them are revision-pinned history. Details and the per-step skill receipt: current-head review. Still draft: current-head CI awaits maintainer workflow approval; live audit, UI audit and Windows launch checks are BLOCKED.

Code changes: +1175 -9
Tests: +1641 -8
Others: +3139 -4

Account migration from @nikhilachale to @milesatao-svg. This draft continues original PR #6517 at original head 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739. Original commits and commit authorship are preserved. Descriptions and evidence below include historical results with their original sources.

Binary assets: 5 historical PNGs, excluded from line counts. New official SVG assets include upstream license/notice. No new reports, logs or screenshots are in the product diff.

What

Add the Strands TUI harness and fix the setup/auth/models/branding gaps found during the PR7081 skill review. Current source: 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739, reconciled with main49951ca.

  • Installed harnesses with unknown auth can open an available native setup action.
  • Strands launches its real strands --setup wizard in AO's terminal.
  • Models explains native freeform IDs instead of suggesting the harness has no models.
  • Avatar uses the exact official light/dark Strands SVGs and upstream attribution.
  • Auth uses native authenticated catalog discovery for supported first-party providers; key presence alone never becomes Connected.

The PR remains draft while fresh UI/CI verification completes and actual provider lifecycle qualification remains unavailable on this VPS.

Current review/evidence · Actual before screenshots

Why

The previous branch offered a setup plan that unknown-auth users could not reach, displayed an empty catalog for a freeform harness, used a placeholder avatar and could not verify provider authorization. Native Strands exposes the setup/provider discovery APIs needed for truthful checks.

Before / After

Before After
No setup action when native auth status is unknown Available setup button opens the native wizard without falsifying auth status
“This harness reported no models.” for a text-mode contract Explains model IDs/native provider configuration and links Account
Generic S avatar Exact upstream theme assets with attribution
Credentials present only meant configured Native successful authenticated nonempty discovery may authorize; invalid credentials, transport errors and unsupported/custom routes stay distinct
AO preload disabled module hooks in project subprocesses Launch-only flag is consumed; real child ESM/CJS APIs remain native

Before captures are attached in the linked comment. Fresh after-fix captures are being taken from the current source and will be attached directly using official GitHubCLI --attach; no local computer access or evidence branch is used.

How

The auth probe loads the installed official CLI0.2.0's native configuration/discovery APIs in memory, without load()'s disk rewrites or custom modules/plugins. It emits only a validated status and suppresses raw native errors. Probe execution is bounded. Anthropic/OpenAI/Google first-party authenticated catalogs are supported; static, custom or inconclusive inventories never prove authorization.

Setup guidance explicitly states native wizard keys last only for that terminal; persistent provider credentials are required for future AO sessions. No user credentials were read/injected or provider login completed by this review.

The SDK activity/cancellation hooks, exact checkpoint validation, private instructions, domain/installer/migration/API wiring and current-main reconciliation remain. Automatic installation stays pinned to0.2.0. The native0.2.2 comparison did not qualify an upgrade.

Intentional scope: TUI only. Native ACP lacks required mode/model APIs and permission behavior and restores stale private instructions; its candidate stays unregistered. No Chat/reviewer or unsupported permission claims are made.

Testing

  • Frontend regression RED reproduced5 missing behaviors; GREEN: all4 complete relevant suites 135/135PASS.
  • Full Strands and agentauth packages PASS. Actual installed0.2.0 offline smoke verified native environment/discovery API shape, unchanged config, rejected legacy/custom config and blocked fetch before network access.
  • Provider auth classifications use fake native responses; no successful real provider login or inference is claimed.
  • Original real Node loader RED/GREEN and full Strands race proof retained; current migration/API preflight from parent remains exactly attributed.
  • Whole-project local tsgo exceeded the3.8GiB VPS memory budget and was stopped after measured swap pressure; no local typecheckPASS claim. New-head official typecheck must pass.
  • Fresh complete CI and real Electron after-fix audit are running. 30/30 official checks passed on previous e255a13 only; those are not claims about this new head.
  • Actual provider prompts, usage, roles and Kill/restore/recall remain blocked until native provider credentials are available. No fixture is presented as live provider evidence.

Checklist

  • Continue existing PR; preserve historical evidence
  • Reconcile current main and regenerate API
  • Fix loader scope with real Node RED/GREEN
  • Fix native setup, truthful auth, text-mode models and official branding
  • Run135 frontend tests and both affected backend packages
  • Post actual before screenshots directly in PR comments
  • Verify current-head after-fix Electron states and attach screenshots
  • Finish current-head CI and exact local validation/gap report
  • Obtain provider login and qualify real lifecycle/restore behavior
Preserved historical PR description — prior source snapshots, not current qualification

Code changes: +998 -13
Tests: +1222 -5
Others: +2980 -3

Latest source snapshot: 104316c03b6b34d8debec7f5d4f42a58204414b6 includes actual main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf. Unregistered safety-gated candidate; Strands ACP is not implemented or ready. Native permission/cancel/restore contracts remain unresolved; current-head CI pending. Implementation snapshot.

Current ACP status: cb740a387cb7142ea97b36a7d0950141f7e4d0a4; actual main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 integrated. Draft; native approvals, executing interrupt, fresh restore instructions and workspace ownership fail. Chat stays unregistered; current-head CI pending. Final ACP report.

Current reconciliation: 0f659657247b427f7bdd0bb304593f826e0f3f4b; actual main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 integrated. Draft; ACP qualification incomplete and current-head CI pending. Reconciliation comment. Historical status below remains preserved.

Binary assets: 5 (excluded from line counts).

Current publication, 2026-10-15: 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f. Incomplete qualification; AO UI evidence BLOCKED; not merge-ready. Main conflicts reconciled. Exact-head CI is recorded below; no local routine suites.

Published current-main reconciliation and new exact7ebd0dca diagnostic evidence:24PASS/1authBLOCKED/1catalogFAIL/2NOT_RUN. Independent ordinary file edits worked, but fresh/restored private/project/native instruction receipt effects were absent. Assisted runner success does not replace that independent failure.

Current report and scoped evidence. Historical runtime/source attribution is retained there.

The initial publication live-feeds check failed: a pinned install spec was sent as an npm package name (HTTP400). The new source separates unversioned package metadata from pinned0.2.0 installation/reinstallation and refuses automatic updates to unqualified releases. Added regression cases are remote-CI-only; all original runtime/UI non-pass gates remain.

Exact-head CI (2026-10-15T07:12:38.660620+00:00): complete at 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f — 25 SUCCESS (25 reported; 25 expected including the merged Go aggregate gate). Current checks. Mergeability MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED; draft handoff. CI does not qualify missing native/UI/provider/OS gates. The initial head293493b9 live-feeds HTTP400 failure remains preserved; the fix is tested only by this newer head’s CI. Canonical main subsequently advanced to48c4ef5e with only two non-overlapping preview-process files; GitHub reports this head mergeable. These completed checks belong to the stated publication head, not a newly rebuilt merge with that later base.

Preserved earlier description (historical status, validation and evidence snapshots)

Binary assets in the current PR diff: 5 (excluded from line counts).

Strands is now registered as a TUI-only harness using the supported public SDK shell replacement. Exact native restore, additive private instructions and foreground tool cancellation are demonstrated inside real AO Electron. Custom tools/sandboxes/subagent modules and unsupported native reconfiguration fail closed or are explicitly out of scope. No Chat or handoff support.

Detailed recovery report and real screenshots. The functional audit passed all lifecycle gates; its overall verdict remains diagnostic FAIL (24 PASS / 1 auth BLOCKED / 1 catalog FAIL / 2 catalog NOT_RUN). Current evidence HEAD: 022084e99b25e5aff7e31c46ebc1b6e869bf320f; all 23 current-head CI checks pass (workflow). AO003 used bypass-permissions/native Auto; native one-time-approval controls were separate. AO authentication probe remains configured rather than verified authorization, despite successful real provider calls.

The diff includes 5 PNG assets (3 actual AO Electron captures and 2 historical native-only captures); binary assets have no line counts.

Original native-only checkpoint and preserved failure history

Strands CLI 0.2.0 displays “Cancelled” after Escape or Ctrl+C while an approved shell tool continues running and writes its delayed artifact about 28 seconds later. This draft records that blocker and an isolated, unregistered terminal adapter candidate. Strands is not available in AO; AO lifecycle and UI conformance remain BLOCKED / NOT RUN.

The candidate preserves native profile instructions/model/plugins, separates the visible task from standing instructions, rejects missing or malformed restore history, and reports native activity through a supported SDK plugin. It does not modify domain/registry/activity dispatch, migrations, APIs, installation, pickers, Chat, or reviewers. Unsupported permission mappings and model overrides shadowed by native model modules fail explicitly.

The full conformance report records pinned upstream revision, native initial/private-instruction and exact-restore evidence, both cancellation failures, runner limitations, reproduction instructions, and two actual native-only terminal screenshots. A PR comment provides revision-pinned report and image links. The screenshots are from a separate native reproduction and do not show AO.

Validation on the Linux VPS:

  • Final candidate package unit/race tests, vet, and golangci-lint 2.13.2 passed after the malformed-history review fix; full backend build passed.
  • Full backend tests ran and failed in five other packages: e2e startup retry (spawn 409), fake agent (missing events.log), OpenCode v2 binary resolution, integration Codex reconciliation, and service/agent private-file ancestor checks. These failures are untriaged; a baseline failure is not claimed.
  • Full-repository race/lint, frontend suites, and native-OS workflows were not run locally. At head c3c834e0e7ef, all 21 GitHub checks passed, including Go build/tests/race/lint/drift, CLI E2E on Linux/macOS/Windows and in the container, and gitleaks. These repository checks do not establish native Strands cancellation or AO lifecycle/UI support. No API regeneration is needed.
  • Staged diff check passed. Exact authorized-key scan across all 11 published files found zero matches; both screenshots were visually reviewed.

Do not register Strands until a pinned upstream fix or a separately reviewed existing containment boundary proves bounded cancellation without late side effects, followed by independent AO lifecycle and actual AO UI evidence. This draft is not a merge-ready integration.

Binary PNG assets in current PR diff: 5 (binary line counts excluded from the header).

Account migration verification

  • Exact source head copied: 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739.
  • New fork branch: milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6517-strands. Base: main.
  • Evidence comments retain their original author, timestamp, source URL and result wording.
  • Fresh validation status is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.
  • Source mergeability at migration: conflicts with current main; reconciliation pending.

Ubuntu and others added 30 commits October 15, 2026 04:38
Build the real daemon in PR CI for isolated VPS runtime verification without local validation suites or dependency installations. Record source revision, Go build info, and executable hash.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Meraj-08 and others added 6 commits October 20, 2026 18:17
An orchestrator that ran `ao spawn --agent <x>` overrode the project's
configured Worker agent, so a project set to a non-Claude worker still got
claude-code workers when the orchestrator delegated. A worker an orchestrator
spawns in a project now runs that project's configured Worker agent regardless
of the --agent it named: the orchestrator coordinates, the project owner chooses
the worker agent. Guarded like inheritedSpawnPermissions (parent must be an
orchestrator in the same project) and only when a Worker agent is configured, so
standalone spawns, non-orchestrator callers, and unconfigured projects keep the
requested harness.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
# Conflicts:
#	frontend/src/docs/content/plugins/agents/index.mdx
…nds non-refresh

After merging main, the sessions-constraint repair checked strands before
memcode, so a pre-strands (v202) schema failed with "missing strands" instead
of the expected memcode assertion. Order the memcode check first (its migration
is older). Strands pins its CLI and declines unattended version refresh, so list
it among the non-refresh harnesses in the support matrix.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 1/3

Historical material from original PR #6517, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T12:38:40Z

Original comment

Revision-pinned conformance evidence for commit c3c834e0e7ef.

Full report: c3c834e0e7ef/strands-tui-conformance.md. The complete report is reproduced below, including the actual native-only screenshots pinned to this revision. Strands remains unregistered. These are not AO screenshots.

Strands CLI terminal conformance — blocked candidate

Strands is not registered in AO. The candidate adapter remains isolated in
backend/internal/adapters/agent/strands; there are no domain, registry,
activity-dispatch, migration, OpenAPI, Chat, reviewer, installer, or picker changes.
Native CLI success does not establish AO lifecycle support. AO spawn, restore,
kill, readiness, activity and UI screenshots remain BLOCKED / NOT RUN.

Release and execution environment

  • Official executable/package: strands, @strands-agents/cli@0.2.0.
  • Upstream: strands-agents/harness-sdk,
    tag harness-cli/v0.2.0, commit e519d67021b9c009e56e9309edcd94ab87e7156e.
  • Installed dependencies resolved to @strands-agents/harness@0.1.1 and
    @strands-agents/sdk@1.20.0; the VPS installation lockfile is retained.
  • Entrypoint SHA-256:
    987e32867f74496f26075d4e5a59d1f7af291162650d2db73b277be7fbd949a0.
  • Linux VPS only, Node 24.21.0, isolated profiles and workspaces. Native setup
    retained default permissions and each tested shell/write approval was
    explicitly accepted once. Real account configuration was not changed.
  • Authorized provider: Z.ai glm-5.3-flash through its existing coding endpoint.
    Strands' official modelModule configuration instantiated the shipped
    OpenAIModel with the exact authorized base URL. This was necessary because
    its litellm convenience builder unconditionally appends /v1. No provider
    source, native CLI source, or endpoint proxy was substituted. Credentials
    were passed only through the existing VPS credential wrapper and child
    environment; they are absent from source, argv, reports and profiles.

Native result

Gate Evidence
Real TUI / initial task PASS: native Ink TUI executed a task beginning -Audit request through --prompt.
Private standing instructions PASS: provider wrote both the configured domain token and the separate AO instruction token. The visible task did not contain either value.
Exact session restore PASS: the same ao-native-001 persisted snapshot loaded after SIGKILL. The provider recovered the prior INITIAL_001 token without reading files.
Fresh restore instructions PASS: a fresh random token was generated only after the first process was killed and reaped, supplied through --instructions, and written to the restored proof.
Native activity / identity PASS for tested root invocation: the injected supported SDK plugin emitted session-start, active, then stop for the pinned native session. Cancellation exposed the delayed stop described below.
Escape cancellation FAIL: after accepting the shell command once and letting it start, Escape displayed “Cancelled” but the shell ran another 28.105 s and created the delayed file.
Ctrl+C cancellation FAIL: independent fresh run, same result in 28.090 s. Both the shell and its sleep child were still alive five seconds after Ctrl+C.
Authentication/model catalog Local configured model was exercised successfully. AO authorization and catalogs are NOT RUN; arbitrary model modules remain auth-unknown and cannot truthfully accept a --model override.

The cancellation command was exactly:

sleep 30; printf done > CANCEL_SHOULD_NOT_EXIST

Each cancellation was sent approximately two seconds after accepting the native
permission prompt. The delayed file existed after both attempts. The native
AfterInvocationEvent arrived only after the shell finished. The instantaneous
“Cancelled” label was therefore not proof that execution or side effects stopped.

The shipped SDK's
makeShell
passes { timeout } to sandbox.execute without an abort signal. The CLI
workspace sandbox can terminate a process tree when it receives a signal, but
this call does not supply one. This is consistent with the observed live process
and delayed side effect. The previous CLI 0.1.4 tag
4a42ded67431c45db51624391a4afa8faba3d454 has the same call and SDK/harness
version ranges; it was source-inspected only, not separately live-qualified.

Actual native screenshots

These are live xterm captures from the separate native-005 reproduction,
not AO screenshots. The run again created the forbidden delayed file.

At 10:56:28 UTC, five seconds after Escape, Strands shows both “Cancelled” and
“Interrupting” while its shell is still running:

Native Strands cancellation still interrupting; AO not registered or tested

At 10:56:56 UTC the composer has settled. The run's delayed artifact now exists
with contents done, despite the retained “Cancelled” label:

Native Strands settled after the delayed side effect; AO not registered or tested

The image SHA-256 values are respectively
89dac2c9ff297f5f47e544ba21a72d183f21f583e29c2130fa0058aa76247cce and
4faad8828d8375c8737dfb8db94a3ce2b688fcf3325c7e54df440cb3279e8b67.

Candidate boundaries

The unregistered package tests the intended thin adapter boundaries:

  • Use a separate visible --prompt and private --instructions argument.
    --instructions replaces saved profile.instructions, so concatenate the
    configured domain string with AO's launch instructions while preserving the
    harness's built-in contract. Restore resolves the current AO instructions again.
  • Preserve the saved model and plugin configuration. Add one private native
    activity plugin under AO data. Do not write workspace rules or global config.
  • Keep native session snapshots and launch-to-workspace identity under AO data.
    Reject missing/malformed history and workspace mismatches before constructing
    --session-id, since the native CLI otherwise creates missing IDs silently.
  • Support Ask Permissions only with native default permissions and no saved
    always-allowed tools. A requested bypass can only match an explicitly already
    configured native bypass; AO never writes that setting. Accept-edits and auto
    have no qualified mapping. The live runs used Ask Permissions only.
  • Reject authored agent projects and model overrides shadowed by native model
    modules. Do not invent a model catalog or report credential presence as a
    verified login. The generic audit runner's hardcoded bypass request cannot
    establish the default-permission AO workflow.

This is a candidate, not a completed integration. Native in-TUI session switching,
custom root agent IDs/session managers, provider/platform coverage, and AO
lifecycle delivery have not been qualified. Hook/locator handling needs to be
revalidated against those cases before any production registration. ACP, Chat,
reviewers and interface handoff are explicitly out of scope.

Reproduce and evidence

The opt-in, standard-library-only
native_cancel_probe.py
starts the real pinned CLI in a PTY, approves the exact disposable shell command
once, sends the chosen native cancellation key, records the owned process tree,
and detects the delayed artifact. It never runs in the default unit suite.
Use an already prepared disposable native profile and the authorized credentials
in the execution host's environment:

python3 backend/internal/adapters/agent/strands/testdata/native_cancel_probe.py \
  --binary /absolute/path/to/strands \
  --home /absolute/path/to/disposable-profile \
  --report /absolute/path/to/new-report-directory \
  --interrupt escape
# Repeat with a fresh report directory and --interrupt ctrl-c.

VPS evidence root:
/home/azureuser/.ao/audits/harness-watch-20261010/reports/strands/.

  • native-001: leading-dash/private/domain proof and the first restore-runner
    failure. Its readiness check ran only on incoming bytes and missed a quiescent
    ready screen. That failure is preserved.
  • native-002: exact native restore and fresh post-kill instruction proof. The
    functional turn passed, while the runner's post-proof exit condition also
    waited on terminal bytes and reached its 150-second cleanup timeout. No full
    strict audit PASS is claimed.
  • native-003: first real Escape failure, native hook events, permission and
    active terminal captures, delayed artifact.
  • native-004: independent Ctrl+C failure, same owned shell and sleep PIDs
    before and five seconds after cancellation, delayed artifact.
  • native-005: separate actual Xvfb/xterm capture run. Images are live native
    terminal captures, clearly labeled AO NOT REGISTERED / NOT TESTED. They
    are neither original-run screenshots nor AO screenshots. Capture metadata and
    cleanup status are in its result.json.

Audit tokens are nonsecret fixtures. The model echoed them in its final answer;
instruction consumption is proved, confidentiality against model echo is not.
Original failures, later controls, and screenshot reproduction are separate.

Validation

The candidate's unit tests, race test and go vet passed; go build ./... passed.
Focused golangci-lint 2.13.2 validation is recorded separately in
final-validation-003.log after the review's malformed-message-history fix.
The full go test ./... run was executed on the VPS and failed in existing
packages outside this unregistered candidate. The complete log is
backend-validation-001.log; it includes e2e startup retry, fake hook-file,
OpenCode v2 binary resolution, integration Codex reconciliation and service/agent
private-file ancestor failures. These have not been labeled passing or fixed by
this candidate. Full-repository race/lint, frontend/native-OS workflows and
remote CI remain outstanding. No API generation is required because no API or
registration source was changed.

All probe-owned processes were terminated and native evidence retained. Do not
register Strands until a pinned upstream release or a separately reviewed,
existing containment boundary proves bounded cancellation without late side
effects, followed by independent AO lifecycle and real AO UI evidence.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T12:49:16Z

Original comment

Exact-head CI verification at 2026-10-10 12:48 UTC for c3c834e: 21/21 check runs completed successfully. Every inspected check and workflow was tied to this head SHA.

  • Go: backend-core shards, chat/session/sqlite race jobs, Windows workspace, cloud build/test, lint, sqlc/API drift, and aggregate build-test passed.
  • CLI E2E: native Linux/macOS/Windows and container jobs passed.
  • gitleaks and review statistics passed.

No candidate source change or test rerun was needed. The five package failures from the earlier VPS full-backend run remain recorded and untriaged; this CI result does not relabel that local run as passing.

The conformance blocker remains: native Escape and Ctrl+C did not stop the approved shell tool or its delayed write. Strands remains unregistered, with AO lifecycle/UI evidence BLOCKED / NOT RUN. Repository CI passing is not native Strands qualification.

Full conformance report with revision-pinned native-only screenshots.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T21:28:19Z

Original comment

Strands now runs inside AO as a registered TUI harness. Audit ao-003 passed every functional lifecycle gate at 98365b809f8378f642f09d711eb727654a86090d (binary SHA-256 7eb497daf80994fd2f710cdb70725f0d754aa64c2c0b9ae489a24d56b5ad3ab1): exactly-once initial delivery, private/project instructions, activity, second message, cancellation, Kill, exact native restore, initialized empty composer, history continuity and newly injected post-Kill instructions.

The complete result remains diagnostic FAIL: 24 PASS / 1 authentication BLOCKED / 1 AO catalog FAIL / 2 catalog NOT_RUN. AO's auth probe still reports configured credentials rather than verified authorization; native listing is unavailable and AO's catalog is empty. Real provider execution used native CLI 0.2.0 / harness 0.1.1 / SDK 1.20.0 and real Z.ai glm-5.3-flash through a private loopback transport relay.

AO003 used AO bypass-permissions (native Auto); the separate native cancellation controls used one-time approval.

The public SDK plugin now propagates cancellation into Strands' native sandbox. Final native Ctrl+C reaped an already-started shell in 97 ms, settled in 210 ms, and produced no delayed write over 32 seconds. Independent AO Kill003 reaped the target shell in 389 ms with no late artifact; the unrelated restored control survived with the same generation immediately and later.

Real AO Electron: Strands restored completion and initialized composer

Capture 2026-10-10T21:08:21.227532Z; UI source 878957f4583fbe7762ebef29708a0f79a61acc5d; AO session audit-strands-daefeaa2-1; native-ID SHA-256 750f2289056d635ce4330cd6fcbf0002731214db6e9dbfcb0c8c7d4e86863ee8; generation 1dcba694-ef1b-4c71-83c2-513d5c691724, unchanged before/after. PNG SHA-256 ffae74a4e45becc91b11c019c8ece1ee128a2aa7c8651ab992c8b84e1b442303.

The complete report preserves released-native 28-second late writes, the invalid top-level config flag, AO001's actual pre-spawn stale-readiness stop, Kill002's fetch failure and the blank Electron renderer-startup failure. Only the worker's own service TasksMax was raised from 256 to 512; host RAM was unchanged.

Scope is foreground TUI. Model-callable strands_config is removed; public registry checks reject background-manager configuration. Human /setup, /tools and native profile takeover require exiting and starting a new AO session. Guard-only commit 1b9caed8a950937b516c1cf5b631a6a6a0f94264 additionally rejects saved custom subagent modules; the live audit remains labeled with its tested 98365b809 revision.

Final HEAD: 022084e99b25e5aff7e31c46ebc1b6e869bf320f. Complete exact-HEAD CI: 23/23 checks passed, verified 2026-10-10T21:45:35.644176+00:00. VPS SDK/focused tests and build evidence are separate from full CI; no full local-suite pass is claimed.

The migration-ledger CI failure at1b9caed was corrected in cf448df and its focused ledger/migration tests passed. Owned final audit sessions were killed (HTTP200) and the daemon stopped (HTTP202); isolated evidence/profiles remain.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-10T21:42:03Z

Original comment

Final CI: all 23 checks pass at the current evidence head 022084e99b25e5aff7e31c46ebc1b6e869bf320f (backend workflow, desktop workflow). This includes the corrected migration ledger; no broad local suite pass is claimed.

Permission clarification: AO003 used bypass-permissions / native Auto. The native Escape/Ctrl+C controls used separate one-time approvals. AO auth probe remains configured, rather than verified authorization, despite successful real provider calls. The strict audit remains diagnostic FAIL for the documented auth/catalog gaps. Published real AO proof.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T16:53:08Z

Original comment

Harness-specific reports, JSON receipts, screenshots and provenance now live on this integration PR branch, rather than the skill PR #6509.

Evidence index with embedded screenshots and JSON links.

Historical successes, failures and scope limitations remain as recorded. Moving these files does not rerun native/AO testing or upgrade any verdict.

This is evidence relocation only. Existing tested source/native hashes and failures are preserved; the documentation commit is not a fresh runtime pass. Applicable checks run in PR CI.

Recorded harness evidence — see scope above


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:07:48Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at aa200d3d2789, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:16:43Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 0ac108f42196, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T20:58:13Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 779c3c503fc7, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-15T06:35:44Z

Original comment

Published, incomplete qualification — AO UI evidence BLOCKED; not merge-ready.

Head 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f; main 54b28374912cb2771f17b8cc32a9482e6d607bce reconciled without force-push. Published current-main reconciliation and new exact7ebd0dca diagnostic evidence:24PASS/1authBLOCKED/1catalogFAIL/2NOT_RUN. Independent ordinary file edits worked, but fresh/restored private/project/native instruction receipt effects were absent. Assisted runner success does not replace that independent failure.

Publication report · All ordered screenshot checkpoints

Every applicable latest UI checkpoint remains NOT_RUN because this stage had no genuine isolated Electron dependencies and insufficient disk preserving512MiB. API/native receipts are auxiliary, never screenshot substitutes. No image was fabricated.

Exact publication-head CI is being checked separately below; old green heads do not qualify edited/merged source. No routine VPS tests, lint, typecheck, gofmt or CI emulator ran. Linux/provider evidence does not establish other OS/provider coverage. Original failures/profiles/logs remain intact privately. No skill6509 writes, production changes, merge, release or deployment.

The initial publication live-feeds check failed: a pinned install spec was sent as an npm package name (HTTP400). The new source separates unversioned package metadata from pinned0.2.0 installation/reinstallation and refuses automatic updates to unqualified releases. Added regression cases are remote-CI-only; all original runtime/UI non-pass gates remain.

Exact-head CI (2026-10-15T07:12:38.660620+00:00): complete at 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f — 25 SUCCESS (25 reported; 25 expected including the merged Go aggregate gate). Current checks. Mergeability MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED; draft handoff. CI does not qualify missing native/UI/provider/OS gates. The initial head293493b9 live-feeds HTTP400 failure remains preserved; the fix is tested only by this newer head’s CI. Canonical main subsequently advanced to48c4ef5e with only two non-overlapping preview-process files; GitHub reports this head mergeable. These completed checks belong to the stated publication head, not a newly rebuilt merge with that later base.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:46:00Z

Original comment

ACP queue status: BLOCKED / incomplete, not merge-ready.

Disk below 256MiB safety floor; preserve all source/evidence

The supervisor retained partial source and moved to the next harness after two bounded attempts. No routine VPS suites were run. New detailed reports/evidence belong in this PR comments; no success claim is inferred from worker exit.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:05:13Z

Original comment

Reconciliation only: refresh the live PR branch and canonical main, resolve the existing merge preserving both Strands and main’s memcode/shared architecture changes, reconcile pending migration allocation, regenerate API contracts from merged source, then refresh both heads again before a normal push. No ACP feature implementation, native/UI qualification, routine local suites, or new repository evidence files in this pass. Historical evidence and failures remain untouched. Current starting PR head: 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f; fetched actual main: 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Parent cleanup is retained; no additional deletion is needed (1.6 GiB free).


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:08:25Z

Original comment

RECONCILED — ACP qualification remains incomplete; draft retained.

Pushed head: 0f659657247b427f7bdd0bb304593f826e0f3f4b (commit). Integrated actual canonical main: 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Both actual heads were fetched at start and immediately before the normal push; ancestry retains prior PR head 4638c82aca17efa7d7d4148af37d6f2578a4637f and main. No force push or history rewrite.

Conflict decisions: preserved both Strands and main’s memcode registrations, selectability tests, install/auth metadata, CLI help, API enums, product pickers, documentation and schema repair paths. Preserved all main shared Chat/nativeacp/persistent-host changes. Moved the pending PR-only Strands migration from 0201 to fresh 0213 after main’s 0212; main migrations and burned ledger are unchanged. Updated its regression test to exercise the 0212→0213 boundary and inverse. Regenerated OpenAPI and TypeScript with the actual generators (openapi-typescript 7.4.4); no query/schema source changes required sqlc regeneration.

Gate Status
Live branch/main synchronization and semantic conflict resolution PASS
Historical Strands evidence blob preservation PASS — checked exact Git blob identities
API generation / Go formatting / diff against actual main PASS
Current-head CI PENDING — 24 check runs reported at this observation; current PR checks
Routine local suites/lint/typecheck/workflow emulation NOT_RUN — CI-only per human instruction
New native/provider/ACP/AO Chat UI qualification and independent review NOT_RUN — reconciliation pass only

The initial staged diff check reported a trailing blank line in main’s queries/conversations.sql; it is inherited unchanged from main, and the final diff check against actual main passes. No unrelated cleanup was committed. Earlier native cancellation, hidden-instruction and UI failures remain preserved in the existing comments/evidence; old green CI and screenshots do not qualify this merge. No new native/source-built binary/model/session/UI fingerprints or attachments are claimed in this pass.

Cleanup: parent removed only verified unused ignored historical node_modules, disposable npm cache, and two unused superseded Codex vendor versions, checking code status/lockfiles unchanged. This worker deleted no additional source/evidence/history/credentials/cache; no native sessions, daemons, Electron profiles or production processes were started. One stalled owned conflict-script process was stopped; generation commands have completed. Historical reports/screenshots remain byte-identical. New findings are inline here; no evidence files or branches were added. PR6509 received no modifications/comments. No merge/release/deploy.

ACP implementation and real current-head qualification continue in the separate ACP pass; reconciliation itself has no external blocker.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T23:26:59Z

Original comment

Continuing existing PR #6517 from 0f659657247b427f7bdd0bb304593f826e0f3f4b; freshly fetched actual PR branch and canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 are already integrated. Assigned linked worktree is clean. No new evidence files will be committed.

Plan: (1) repair concrete current-head CI regressions after inspecting failing logs (install inventory count, pre-Strands schema repair ordering, documentation helper lint); (2) inspect the released CLI ACP permission/cancellation and instruction/load paths and current official upstream, preserving CLI identity/defaults; (3) implement only defensible candidate bindings/guards with regression coverage, leaving Chat unregistered until native approval/cancel/load/instruction gates pass; (4) refresh both heads before any push, inspect current-head CI, and publish an explicit gate table. Routine suites run in CI only; no local suites or dependency installs. Existing historical failures remain authoritative until separately reproduced and fixed.

Resource observation: 924 MiB available at start, above 512 MiB reserve but insufficient for speculative Electron dependency installs. Parent cleanup remains preserved; no additional deletion. Real AO Chat UI/direct attachment and independent review remain required readiness gates, not substitutes for source work.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T23:38:27Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — native ACP contract fails; draft retained, Chat remains unregistered. Source/CI repairs and opt-in real-native regression coverage pushed. No merge/release/deploy.

Head: cb740a387cb7142ea97b36a7d0950141f7e4d0a4. Integrated actual canonical main: 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Both actual heads were fetched at start, before each normal push, and again before this status; no new remote changes, force pushes or discarded user edits. Existing TUI registration, defaults, instructions, safety and historical evidence remain intact. No Chat/handoff/reviewer registration was added.

Source progress:

  • b9daac8f: repair the observed reconciliation CI failures: 38 install targets rather than 37, isolate the Memcode malformed-schema assertion on the current schema while removing only Memcode, and remove the documentation helper's constant setup-action parameter. No merged migration changed; no tests disabled. The original failures remain here.
  • 47e84280, c43488c0, cb740a38: add an opt-in real native, standard-library ACP approval/restore regression probe plus Go entry point. It requires explicit binary/config/new owned runtime paths, preserves failed attempts, rejects custom tools/plugins/interventions/authored agents, copies configuration into isolated HOME, and never loads credentials itself. Normal CI skips provider usage. The final Python probe was exercised on the real provider and fails, correctly, at FAIL: tool turn sent no native permission request. The Go entry point itself is NOT_RUN locally, per CI-only instruction.
  • Independent read-only source review found no defect in the three CI fixes. Its probe customization/fingerprint findings were addressed by rejecting custom native behavior and labeling the entry hash launcherSHA256. This is scoped source review, not independent native/AO/UI acceptance.

Native provenance: stock installed @strands-agents/cli@0.2.0, harness 0.1.1, SDK 1.20.0, Node 24.21.0, Linux VPS. CLI source tag harness-cli/v0.2.0, commit e519d67021b9c009e56e9309edcd94ab87e7156e. Entrypoint SHA-256 987e32867f74496f26075d4e5a59d1f7af291162650d2db73b277be7fbd949a0; loaded dist/src/tui/acp/server.js SHA-256 0a8c616df68752f792ac40b6dcc4c797aa053b5797b9542c2f68b12e276fc93f. Handshake misleadingly identifies its version as 0.0.1; that is not an executable version fingerprint. Real provider turns used the existing authorized private DeepSeek configuration, model deepseek-chat, through the public OpenAIModel/modelModule route in an isolated profile. No credential values, private config, vendor patches or fake provider were published. Native built-in prompt retained; provider wire role not observed.

Gate Result and functional receipt
Real initialize / provider execution PASS for native execution. loadSession:true; text/tools streamed. authenticate even with an unknown method returned {}, so this acknowledgement does not prove authentication. AO auth remains unqualified.
Ordinary fresh task: private additive + independent project rule PASS native-only in native-005: ordinary workspace-description task produced hidden_value:FRESH_03418872, domain_value:DOMAIN_ACP_001, project_value:PROJECT_ACP_001. Visible task named none of these values or standing instructions.
Exact native history / replay PARTIAL: same session 8397627d-90db-44a8-9d97-7e00e8ae9199 loaded after process termination/reaping; 14 replay updates observed. Replay deduplication and AO durable projection NOT_RUN.
New private instructions after confirmed process termination FAIL: only after the first process was reaped, a new process received RESTORE_249a4b77; ordinary continuation still wrote FRESH_03418872. Project/domain values persisted. This is native process restart proof, not AO Kill acceptance.
Native permission allow / reject / cancel FAIL: default mode, empty saved allow list. Real write completed with zero session/request_permission requests. The opt-in rejection probe's rejected.json existed despite no permission being granted. No claim that denial/cancellation worked.
Executing foreground native interrupt FAIL in native-006: shell PID 1336958, kernel starttime 141221467, alive at +1s and +5s after session/cancel; delayed file existed at +15s. ACP nevertheless returned stopReason:cancelled. Unrelated control PID 1336942, starttime 141221216, stayed unchanged.
Separate AO Kill / immediate continuation NOT_RUN: no qualified Chat binding. Earlier TUI receipts are historical and not relabeled.
Missing native history PASS: random absent ID returned ACP error -32002 resource-not-found; no fresh fallback observed.
Workspace mismatch across native process restart FAIL: a copied exact history loaded successfully under a different workspace in a fresh ACP process. Its process-local cwd lock is not durable workspace ownership.
Models/options Native configured model executed. session/set_config_option returned -32601; AO option/catalog admission NOT_RUN. No unsupported option is advertised.
Reasoning / plans / daemon restart / detached reconnect / duplicate-free replay NOT_RUN / unqualified; text/tool updates alone do not establish these gates.
Actual current AO Chat UI / screenshot attachment BLOCKED: no safely registrable native Chat contract, so no AO Chat app/build/session/generation screenshot or UI fingerprint was produced. No native/log screenshot substitutes. No available GitHub attachment capability was found in enabled tools; no evidence assets or hosting branch added.
Formatting / diff / credential scan PASS: changed Go files formatted, Python syntax parsed, diff against actual main clean, zero exact authorized-key matches in the new diff. No routine suites run on VPS.
Current-head CI PENDING, exact workflows below. Earlier-head green or queued work is not acceptance.
Independent full readiness review NOT_RUN; scoped source review does not fill this gate.

The first native startup failures (native-001: missing onboarding schema version; native-002: discovery setting had wrong type), first diagnostic native failures (native-003/004), and first regression launch without its authorized environment (native-regression-001) are retained separately. Corrected setup runs do not erase them. native-005/006 and native-regression-002/003 retain the actual contract failures. Runtime bytes remain private under the assigned owned scratch root; all deliverable findings are inline here. Audit markers are nonsecret; confidentiality against model echo is not claimed.

Supported-route investigation: official CLI 0.2.1, commit 12170cf02e4ee45dabf5c3e13fbb6663a1d44a28, was released October 14 and source-inspected, not live-qualified. Its regular ACP server, and current upstream main inspected during this attempt, still lack the permission bridge and still initialize full saved snapshots. The Python authored-agent bridge calls requestPermission, but substituting an authored Python agent changes the native CLI identity/defaults and is not a qualified replacement. The existing supported AO TUI plugin propagates shell cancellation, but ACP permission forwarding and durable restore safety require native-server changes. No private vendor patch/fork is represented as stock; no overlapping integration PR was created.

Exact-head CI observation:

Workflow Status
Harness release feeds QUEUED / PENDING
CLI E2E QUEUED / PENDING
gitleaks QUEUED / PENDING
Go PENDING / PENDING
Harness proof build COMPLETED / success
Frontend QUEUED / PENDING

External/native work remaining: a supported regular-CLI permission broker plus correct cancellation, fresh-on-restore instructions and durable workspace rejection, followed by real AO nativeacp/persistent-host qualification, actual Chat UI/direct attachment, full independent acceptance and completed current-head CI. These failures prevent READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE; missing UI is not being used to stop safe source work.

Cleanup: every owned native process was reaped; executing shell and unrelated owned control are gone after provenance checks. No AO daemon/Electron or production session was started/restarted, no real profile was written, and no broad process kill occurred. Parent cleanup removed only verified unused ignored historical node_modules, disposable npm cache and two superseded Codex vendor versions after status/lockfile checks. This worker deleted no further code/cache/evidence/history/credentials; free space remains about 909 MiB, above the 512 MiB reserve. Historical evidence files are untouched. New Git files are executable test source only; no report/JSON/PNG evidence committed. PR6509 received zero modifications/comments.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:50:24Z

Original comment

Continuing source/CI implementation on PR6517 only. Live head was 9ab70103fbcf832e7594202f164f838381dc4de5; actual canonical main ff6e7b3a is now merged locally. The existing installer conflict preserves Strands and main’s waiting_for_idle status. No user changes were discarded.

Next source slice: resolve the pending Strands 0213 migration collision using the repository timestamp allocator; add a nativeacp-based, unregistered Strands candidate with explicit unsupported-settings and unsafe-server admission guards; add controlled regression coverage and submit it to CI. Production registration remains closed. The official regular TypeScript ACP server exposes no permission-request bridge even at upstream 1adcaf9fbf5f7709d25e5eb061e368527b48bb4c; Python authored-agent approval forwarding is a different native agent, not a drop-in replacement. I will preserve this distinction rather than silently bypassing consent.

This worker performs source edits, formatting, Git and remote-CI inspection only. Native/provider/AO/UI qualification is NOT RUN here. No local suites/builds/installations or additional disk cleanup; historical evidence remains untouched. Detailed progress stays inline in this PR.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:54:07Z

Original comment

Independent read-only review of 032e129e827151dda7b87ce155b905461c0d96a2 by a separate review agent: no remaining actionable source defects found within the gated candidate scope. A test-cleanup finding was fixed before publication: bounded cleanup now shuts down the exact owned test host even if an assertion fails.

The reviewer checked shared ACP admission on fresh initialization and reconnect, disabled fresh fallback, reconnect-only no-spawn behavior, timestamp migration/ledger preservation, upgrade/downgrade/legacy-QM/unknown-harness/integrity coverage and explicit production registry exclusion. No tests/builds/native/provider calls were performed by the reviewer.

This is a ports-compatible, deliberately unavailable candidate, not a functional Strands ACP integration. Real Send/permission/cancel/replay/Stop lifecycle is not exercised because native admission is closed. Approval bridging, executing-tool cancellation and additive instructions on exact restore remain unresolved native boundaries. implementationComplete=false; no approval/readiness claim.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:54:10Z

Original comment

Pushed 032e129e827151dda7b87ce155b905461c0d96a2, including actual main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf (ancestry verified). Existing PR head 9ab70103 remains an ancestor. Narrow source commits: a6218fe5 and 032e129e; merge commits preserve current-main behavior and concurrent PR work.

  • Added chatdriver/strandsacp/driver.go: existing nativeacp/persistenthost binding, NewCandidate, discovery/auth-preserving Probe, strict Resume and reconnect-only Reconnect, supported launch shape, unsupported-settings rejection and pre-session admission guard. No synthetic conversation/history or permission bypass; production Chat remains unregistered.
  • Added controlled protocol tests covering initialize-before-new/load rejection, missing-host reconnect without native resolution, rejected approval/model/effort/instruction settings, plus registry exclusion. These are CI coverage, not live proof.
  • Moved the pending Strands migration from colliding 0213 to repository-allocated 20261019154939960; preserved main’s shipped 213–215 and updated migration/ledger tests. Installer merge retains both Strands and waiting_for_idle. Generated API artifacts merged from main; no local generation.

Source closure is not claimed: the regular first-party server exposes no requestPermission client to plugins. Released regular server and current inspected main call only agent.stream and agent.cancel; newSession receives no client context, and the service never calls session/request_permission. Python authored-agent ACP supplies a broker to a different authored Python backend. Switching to it would change the required native agent/defaults. A qualified first-party regular-server change is required; no private vendor patch or fabricated extension is used. The gate intentionally rejects every current server before creating/loading a session.

Current-head CI: checks, pending at publication. No local tests/builds/lint/typecheck/provider/AO/UI work ran. Independent source review: #6517 (comment). Historical native failures and screenshots remain untouched; no new evidence/report assets committed, no deletions beyond the pending migration rename, no production changes or processes launched. Disk about 537 MiB; no additional cleanup.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:56:48Z

Original comment

Strands source snapshot: NOT IMPLEMENTED / NOT READY. Safe candidate and main reconciliation are pushed at 104316c03b6b34d8debec7f5d4f42a58204414b6. Actual canonical main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf and actual supplied PR branch were fetched again immediately before this report; both are ancestors of this head. Working tree clean. Draft retained.

Implemented source progress: nativeacp/persistenthost-based chatdriver/strandsacp/driver.go and controlled driver regression tests, registry exclusion, unique timestamped Strands migration/ledger/tests, semantic installer conflict resolution, and explicit SupportsTerminalVersionRefresh() false preserving the native 0.2.0 pin. The shared transport owns protocol/host behavior. NewCandidate, Probe, strict Resume/Reconnect and launch/settings guards exist, but every native admission is deliberately refused before session/new/load. This is not an operational Chat integration or implemented Send/approval/cancel/replay lifecycle.

Gate Result
Semantic main/PR integration and diff check PASS at source head above
Independent read-only source review PASS within candidate scope; review; reviewer also inspected the final four-line version-refresh delta, no actionable defect
Controlled protocol/regression tests SUBMITTED TO CI; not run locally
Full current-head CI PENDING; see exact-head workflows below
Released native initialize/auth/new/exact-load and ID NOT RUN by this source-only worker; prior protocol observations are historical
Native approval allow/reject/cancel BLOCKED: regular CLI exposes no ACP permission broker
Executing interrupt, separate Kill/control, no delayed side effects BLOCKED / NOT RUN; earlier executing-child failure retained
Fresh instructions and NEW post-Kill instructions on same history BLOCKED; earlier restored snapshot/instruction failure retained
Wrong-workspace/missing/corrupt history, process restart, reconnect/replay NOT LIVE-QUALIFIED; candidate does not open sessions
Supported model/options Candidate rejects unqualified model/effort/approval changes; no live settings claim
Actual current-source AO Chat UI/direct attachment BLOCKED / NOT RUN; no actual screenshot captured or attachment flow exercised

Precise implementation boundary: released first-party regular server and current official source inspected at 1adcaf9f give newSession no ACP client, stream native Agent events and call agent.cancel(), but never expose/call the ACP permission-request broker. A supported tool plugin can propagate cancellation, but cannot access the server’s client permission channel through this contract. The Python authored-agent route bridges permission events from a different Python backend; substituting it changes native CLI identity/defaults. Direct stdio interception would duplicate the transport and invent an unsafe permission bridge. No private vendor patch, unqualified fork, native prompt replacement or visible instruction preamble was introduced. A qualified first-party regular-server permission/cancel/restore change is needed before this candidate can become a functional driver. This remains implementationComplete=false, qualificationComplete=false.

Actual fingerprints: AO source 104316c03b6b34d8debec7f5d4f42a58204414b6; merged main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf; official inspected source 1adcaf9fbf5f7709d25e5eb061e368527b48bb4c, released source 12170cf02e4ee45dabf5c3e13fbb6663a1d44a28. Native executable/version/hash, provider/model, AO binary, UI build/session/generation: NOT MEASURED this attempt because native/build/AO/UI execution is excluded from this worker. The installed plugin’s 0.2.0 pin is source policy, not new binary qualification.

Exact-current-head CI (previous-head green is historical):

Workflow Observed status
Frontend queued / PENDING
gitleaks queued / PENDING
CLI E2E queued / PENDING
Go queued / PENDING
Harness release feeds queued / PENDING
Harness proof build queued / PENDING

No current-head failure was reported at this observation; queued/pending checks are not passed. First failures remain retained in prior ACP report: missing native permissions, executing child survival, restored instructions and workspace ownership. No failed attempt or historical attachment was removed/replaced. The independent review’s test-host cleanup finding was fixed in 032e129e before this snapshot.

Cleanup: this source-only worker launched zero native/provider/AO/Electron processes, touched no real profile/history/production data, ran no routine suites/builds/installations/generation, and removed no cache/evidence/user code. The pending migration was renamed only; main’s already-merged migrations are unchanged. Parent cleanup before handoff removed only verified unused ignored node_modules, disposable npm cache and superseded unused Codex vendor versions after status/lockfile checks; historical evidence/credentials/Git metadata were preserved. No additional disk cleanup occurred. New deliverables are source/tests only; reports remain inline. PR6509 and other workers’ PRs/worktrees received no modifications/comments.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 2/3

Historical material from original PR #6517, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @Meraj-08 on 2026-10-20T10:16:43Z

Original comment

Screenshots

Install-
04b-strands

06-strands-installed

Health-
08-strands-health

Spawn workers-
Screenshot 2026-10-20 at 6 15 03 PM


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:17:18Z

Original comment

Fresh testing-only retest starting for strands at current PR head d4f5b479ee66516df9fa69f695f22270f8e7136f using harness skill bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db. One bounded serial attempt (25-minute maximum; eight-minute output-stall watchdog); isolated source/runtime. Previous evidence is historical and will not count as fresh proof. Full 12-area matrix and screenshot checkpoints will follow in a new comment. No implementation, pushes, production restart, or excluded PR changes.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:34:29Z

Original comment

Fresh bounded testing-only audit: FAIL / incomplete integration. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. No full integration PASS.

Tested/current head: d4f5b479ee66516df9fa69f695f22270f8e7136f. Staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all 15 staged files matched the commit bytes. Head rechecked at 2026-10-21T06:34:06.876888+00:00: unchanged. Linux VPS, Node 24.21.0, Go 1.27.1; serial execution, GOMAXPROCS=1, GOFLAGS=-p=1, GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB, Node heap 384MiB. No source/branch/PR-description changes, pushes, merges, provider installation/upgrades, login/reset or reviewer publication. Worktree remained clean/detached.

Actual native package 0.2.0, harness 0.1.1, SDK 1.20.0. Native launcher SHA-256 987e32867f74496f26075d4e5a59d1f7af291162650d2db73b277be7fbd949a0. Fresh actual-basename ao, ao version dev, SHA-256 88729ad2368dc21c9ff8e5d92c3f907070d29893519bf3156709a980b0ff6e7a (36,991,239 bytes), built from the tested clean head, served the strict audit. Configured provider/model: Z.ai coding endpoint through the existing installed OpenAIModel module, glm-5.3-flash. Effective successful model selection remains unverified; no AO session exists. Minimum known native config copied with 0700/0600 protection; matching existing credential found despite absent worker inheritance and loaded only in the same native/daemon child environment. No value in argv/config/reports; configured presence was not promoted to authorized.

Fresh attempt UTC / exit Observation / classification
strands --version 06:20:12.378–06:20:12.866; 0 PASS: 0.2.0; output SHA-256 1f930dd1f133c1f97a94fe3acb8db34372cf4c01ffdb2b3ff4ca72f9494121e9. Correct argv independently confirmed; no wrong-flag retry.
strands --help 06:20:12.866–06:20:13.303; 0 Parser availability PASS only; no general model-list/auth-status command. Output SHA-256 980e16977addeea30ec5a2339b5591a3570ec7c6126412ba625ed3a55a37f587.
Independent native provider/file witness 06:20:20.248–06:21:21.164; 1 FAIL: 429 Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted. Your limit will reset at 2026-10-21 18:43:31; no witness file. Output SHA-256 8d886ca83f9f4d58e6d8146fb5dedbe29a035da35a07af039ebcdc64819a6251. Quota response is not missing-credential proof.
AO build 001 06:21:34.849–06:22:16.581; -15 OPERATOR/CAPACITY stop at 721 MiB free; exact PID/start checked, reaped, only owned temp removed. Not a compile defect.
AO build 002, debug symbols stripped 06:22:57.851–06:23:01.979; 0 PASS; go build -ldflags='-s -w' -o <runtime>/bin/ao ./cmd/ao, serial, no source change.
strict-001, staged audit runner 06:23:18.104–06:25:05.328; outer exit 1 Strict FAIL: 5 PASS, 1 FAIL, 1 BLOCKED, 20 NOT_RUN. First failure local_session_spawn: 80,518ms timeout, no token/cwd proof. Native child returned 0 during termination but timedOut=true; not PASS. This separate attempt did not retain 429; preserve its timeout classification.
Strict AO preflight 06:25:03.995–06:25:05.011 Probe/ensure HTTP200; registration/install PASS. fresh_probe BLOCKED: installation fresh, authentication unknown/stale with auth_check_inconclusive, effective readiness unknown. Models and all TUI lifecycle steps NOT_RUN; no session created.
native-acp-001: standalone safe protocol 06:26:39.562–06:26:40.669; 0 Limited PASS: initialize protocol1/loadSession advertisement; missing-history load rejected -32002. Native ACP metadata version0.0.1 differs from CLI package0.2.0. No provider prompt/tool/approval or AO Chat qualification.
Diagnostic continuation NOT_RUN Native workspace proof failed and AO freshness blocked; diagnostic prerequisites unmet, no diagnostic flag/retry.

Independent api-001 (06:32:39.079–06:32:47.260 UTC), PASS limited to nonprovider reads and negative admission, not a diagnostic lifecycle run: disk recovered to964MiB, permitting one cache-backed serial rebuild003 (06:32:00.298–06:32:06.096, exit0) with the same AO SHA-256. /readyz PID1479248 and serving executable hash matched; model GET/refresh HTTP200 returned selectionMode:text, customModelEntry:direct, models:[], source:manual, refresh idle/not stale. Empty catalog remains non-pass for a strict catalog requirement; no model-visibility changes were invented. Installer/auth-plan GETs returned pinned npm0.2.0 and documentation-only setup; no install/login action started. Settings excluded Strands Chat. Explicit POST /api/v1/sessions with {kind:worker,harness:strands,mode:chat,approvalMode:default} returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, message strands has no chat driver, requestId vps-linux/tXn7GiN2k6-000010; session list stayed empty. Auth remained unknown/stale/inconclusive. No provider prompt, TUI spawn or failed-readiness bypass. /shutdown HTTP202, exit0/reaped, no session IDs. Rebuilt binary is retained privately; this does not erase the earlier capacity stop/reclamation.

Native witness command: strands --print --session off --builtin-tools write --builtin-plugins '' --skills off --prompt '<unique token/cwd JSON file task>', in a disposable workspace using the existing credential route. Strict reproduction after the serial build:

node <staged-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent strands \
  --repo <tested-clean-checkout> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao \
  --local-contract <runtime>/contract-001.json \
  --report <runtime>/strict-001/report \
  --startup-timeout-seconds 40 --timeout-seconds 80

Original contract SHA-256 9dbf548542f1d8aa0c288535c596a5104d311f66763478e6dd49a964f7760646. Sanitized equivalent below replaces only the installed binary path, so displayed bytes have a different hash:

{"schemaVersion":1,"agents":{"strands":{"binary":"/path/to/native/strands","versionArgs":["--version"],"integration":{"args":["--help"],"expect":"--session-id"},"session":{"args":["--print","--session","off","--builtin-tools","write","--builtin-plugins","","--skills","off","--prompt","{prompt}"],"proofFile":"LOCAL_AUDIT_PROOF.json"},"interrupt":{"input":"\^[","settleTimeoutMs":5000}}}}

The help probe proves availability, not auth. No models command was invented: interactive /model discovers Bedrock, not this custom module route. No restoredReady expression was fabricated/reused from inventory: genuine current startup/settled/draft/restored samples were not established. Escape is documented native input, but witnessed executing-tool cancellation remains NOT_RUN. Strict report SHA-256 a3f92036356d0c429e03450669f5841d2f7c8b3c8d0e6b58088e01f3a25c3a51.

Completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Registered TUI worker; shared task/settings surfaces BLOCKED POST probe HTTP 200: supported=true, installed=true. Actual Harness/New Task UI unavailable; no AO task created.
Models Direct model text or saved modelModule; Bedrock discovery is interactive BLOCKED No general native catalog. Independent API GET/refresh HTTP200: selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, models=[], manual source. Empty catalog cannot pass strict catalog gates. Both actual model UI surfaces, persisted off/on/bulk/picker effects and effective selection NOT_RUN; no fake switches. Strict original catalog gate remains NOT_RUN.
Providers Existing Z.ai custom OpenAIModel route; glm-5.3-flash configured BLOCKED Matching existing credential found despite absent inheritance, loaded only into child environment. Independent native response 429 quota exhausted; successful auth/model/file turn unverified. AO provider/account controls and effective routing NOT_RUN.
Setup Pinned native 0.2.0; npm installer source plan; AO documentation-only auth plan NOT_RUN API installers HTTP200 offers npm @strands-agents/cli@0.2.0, update unavailable; auth-plans HTTP200 launchMode=documentation. Install/upgrade/login/logout/reset prohibited and NOT_RUN. Existing install is not fresh onboarding; actual in-page setup/maintenance unqualified.
Readiness Linux binary installation and safe auth preflight BLOCKED Installation installed/fresh; authentication unknown/stale, auth_check_inconclusive; effective readiness unknown. No strict admission bypass or promotion to authorized.
Identity and logo Strands label and shared S initial fallback NOT_RUN Label source includes Strands; no Strands avatar logo mapping/asset/license, so shared lettered-tile fallback applies. Actual display not captured.
TUI and Chat TUI registered; native ACP advertised; AO Chat candidate unregistered BLOCKED Strict TUI spawn NOT_RUN. Native initialize/missing-history negative PASS without prompt; regular ACP permission broker absent. API settings excludes Strands from Chat; explicit Chat spawn HTTP409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, zero sessions. Streaming/history/approval/Stop/reconnect/recovery remain NOT_RUN; this is truthful rejection, not Chat qualification.
Reviewer No Strands AO reviewer entry; generic native print only NOT_RUN Prompt-review suitability unqualified. No actual AO reviewer target/head/run/result/cancel/rerun. External reviewer publication prohibited; missing wiring is not N/A or worker-review proof.
Permissions and instructions Source maps default/auto/accept-edits to Ask; bypass requires explicit native config NOT_RUN Minimum copied config retained default permissions and no saved grants. No escalation/account change. Provider quota and strict preflight blocked permission decisions, ordinary private/project instruction consumption and refreshed restore proof.
Lifecycle Follow-up/cancel/Kill/archive/exact restore; separate Chat recovery NOT_RUN No AO session, executing command PID/start witness, cancellation, Kill, archived entry, exact restore, Kanban continuation or unrelated live control. Native missing-history rejection alone is not lifecycle qualification.
Evidence Exact staged source/skill; distinct fresh attempts; full screenshot index BLOCKED Strict FAIL, independent native 429 and standalone ACP-safe proof retained. All 24 mandatory screenshot IDs plus Chat/reviewer substeps below. No real Electron capture or published attachment; no approved uploader.
CI and handoff Current-head CI/source/cleanup BLOCKED 25 checks completed/success; no failing/pending check jobs. Legacy status pending with zero contexts is not a pending job. GitHub mergeable=false/dirty. Local routine suites CI ONLY/NOT_RUN. Source clean, owned tests stopped; parent verification/removal and description evidence link pending.

Screenshot index was created before actions. Zero actual Electron captures or published screenshots. At setup gate, free disk 722MiB left 22MiB above the 700MiB floor; official pinned Electron44.7.0 Linux archive alone is 122,998,223 bytes (117.3MiB), before extraction/dependencies. Dependencies absent; npm ci/Electron NOT_RUN. Initial RAM total3,906MiB / available2,509MiB; disk blocked setup. A later capacity observation was below floor after strict had already finished; reclaiming only the finished owned AO binary restored 720MiB free. Binary hashes/build metadata retained. No old frontend, symlinked dependencies, terminal mirror, synthetic pixels or API images substituted. No approved GitHub attachment uploader; private queue has zero images. Every capture/attachment below is unavailable for these reasons, regardless of functional status.

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed Functional status Screenshot/attachment Proof or reason
harness-listed Open Harness row/name/logo/auth -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. API registration/install positive; actual row unobserved.
install-offer Install/Download/manual offer -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Pinned npm installer source plan only; no UI offer capture.
install-run Installation before/active/result -> not started NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Provider installs/upgrades prohibited; existing binary is not install proof.
auth-before Inspect Configured/Connected/setup -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Existing key present; AO auth unknown/stale, unverified.
auth-action AO Login/Setup handoff/return -> not started NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Login/account mutation prohibited; documentation-only AO plan.
auth-ready Verified ready row -> unknown/stale API, UI absent BLOCKED BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Native 429/no proof; strict authentication check inconclusive.
auth-maintenance Provider/account/logout/retry states -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Account mutation/reset prohibited; original profile unchanged.
harness-models Models loading/refresh/result -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Later independent model GET/refresh HTTP200: text/direct/manual, empty models; actual Models UI not opened. Original strict model gate stays NOT_RUN.
model-visibility Off/on/bulk/save/reload/picker effects -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No observed catalog or UI; no invented switches.
provider-management Provider list/config/add/change/remove -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Existing custom native route only; management UI unqualified.
task-agent New Task Agent visibility/selection -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Registered TUI API is not actual picker evidence.
task-model Model offer/choice/effective launch -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Module configured; effective successful choice unproved.
task-running Create/card/initial output/settled result -> not started BLOCKED BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO session after strict preflight; native quota witness failed.
task-followup Composer submission/response -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No ready owned AO session.
task-cancel Executing command/Stop/settled/continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No command PID/kernel-start witness; cancellation NOT_RUN.
kill-action Running/archive confirmation/terminated -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO session; daemon exit is not session Kill.
archived Exact archived session entry -> absent NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No session was created or archived.
restore-action Archived/Restore/native ready -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO history; genuine restoredReady contract unavailable, not fabricated.
kanban-return Same card/restored continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No exact restore or continuation.
chat Chat selection/composer/all applicable actions -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. AO settings excludes Strands; explicit Chat HTTP409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; actual Chat UI actions NOT_RUN, native handshake separate.
reviewer-select Reviewer picker/model/target -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No Strands reviewer registration or target/head run.
reviewer-running Review pane/active/cancel/error/retry -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No registered reviewer/run; external publication prohibited.
reviewer-result Verdict/result/rerun/new head -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No review run/result; no GitHub reviewer publication.
reconnect-cleanup UI reconnect/recovery/cleanup screen -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No UI/session; native and daemon teardown verified separately in text.
chat/new-task New Chat task/session-new -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/followup-stream Composer streaming/output/file effect once -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/load-history AO paged history/exact native load/recall -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/approve Current approval -> authorized effect once -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/reject New rejection -> no protected effect -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/cancel-active-tool Command PID/start -> Stop -> no late effect -> continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/ui-reconnect Event reconnect -> ordered catch-up/fresh turn -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned host adoption -> same identity/no duplicate -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/kill-restore-new-instructions Archive/exact restore/new private instructions -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/negative-capabilities AO missing-history/settings/input typed rejection -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/cancel Reviewer interrupt/error/retry -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/rerun Rerun/new-head result -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/publication Reviewer external GitHub publication -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.

Current source scope: TUI adapter, unregistered gated ACP candidate, capability catalog, manual auth plan, model-entry mode. Source is not runtime/UI proof. Installed native README states print/plain/ACP have no permission UI and use stock harness tool behavior; installed regular ACP server has no requestPermission bridge. Live AO Chat rejection is now proved independently; unfinished Chat/reviewer lifecycle and UI qualification remain non-pass.

CI at 2026-10-21T06:34:07.616101+00:00: 25/25 current-head check runs completed/success, no failing/pending check jobs. Local routine unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/frontend-build/runner-fixture suites NOT_RUN by CI-only policy. Native OS/container/renderer coverage below belongs to CI, not authenticated provider/live Electron proof:

build-test, renderer-smoke, mac-update-helper, test, sqlite-race (3), windows-workspace, sqlite-race (0), chat-race (1), sqlite-race (2), backend-core (1), lint, chat-race (0), sqlite-race (1), session-store-race, api-drift, backend-core (0), sqlc-drift, linux-proof-artifact, live-feeds, cloud-build-test, native (ubuntu-latest), native (macos-latest), native (windows-latest), container, scan.

Current PR mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. Recorded main 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd comparison: 13 main-only /39 PR-only commits, merge base 8fbec789517cb2b4ae979f81bde63f8a3242f643 (also current GitHub PR base). No merge/rebase/conflict fix. Legacy commit-status API returned pending with zero contexts; this does not add a pending/failing job.

Cleanup verified 2026-10-21T06:33:29.951526+00:00: PASS for owned test processes. Strict daemon PID1469987 exited0; /proc entry absent. Exact version/help/provider/build/runner PID+kernel-start identities no longer existed and children were reaped. API daemon PID1479248/startticks161011189 received shutdown HTTP202 and exited0/reaped; no API session IDs were created. Native ACP PID1477807/startticks160975238 exited0/reaped. Invoking worker/control-host ancestry excluded and never signaled. No UI or AO session created. No production service/profile/account modification. Reports/receipts/logs, minimal isolated profile and private strict SQLite state retained outside Git and unshared; source clean, no evidence commits. Parent final owned-process verification and clean-worktree removal pending.

Next actions/unresolved: provide sufficient scratch capacity; use the same authorized provider route once quota permits a successful native file witness; run a NEW strict attempt preserving these failures, requalify auth/readiness and genuine restore cues. Independently qualify actual current-head UI/model/provider controls and any supported Chat/reviewer journeys. Parent must capture/attach safe real PNGs with provenance via an approved attachment path; there are presently none to attach. Resolve conflicts only through separately authorized source work, then recheck affected CI/runtime. PR-description link to this new evidence comment: pending parent action; description not edited.

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 3/3

Historical material from original PR #6517, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:35:45Z

Original comment

Publication correction: the first evidence comment is preserved. Readback altered its displayed Escape notation, so that displayed contract example is invalid. This new full evidence comment reconstructs Escape with String.fromCharCode(27); functional results and all original failures are unchanged.

Fresh bounded testing-only audit: FAIL / incomplete integration. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. No full integration PASS.

Tested/current head: d4f5b479ee66516df9fa69f695f22270f8e7136f. Staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all 15 staged files matched the commit bytes. Head rechecked at 2026-10-21T06:34:06.876888+00:00: unchanged. Linux VPS, Node 24.21.0, Go 1.27.1; serial execution, GOMAXPROCS=1, GOFLAGS=-p=1, GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB, Node heap 384MiB. No source/branch/PR-description changes, pushes, merges, provider installation/upgrades, login/reset or reviewer publication. Worktree remained clean/detached.

Actual native package 0.2.0, harness 0.1.1, SDK 1.20.0. Native launcher SHA-256 987e32867f74496f26075d4e5a59d1f7af291162650d2db73b277be7fbd949a0. Fresh actual-basename ao, ao version dev, SHA-256 88729ad2368dc21c9ff8e5d92c3f907070d29893519bf3156709a980b0ff6e7a (36,991,239 bytes), built from the tested clean head, served the strict audit. Configured provider/model: Z.ai coding endpoint through the existing installed OpenAIModel module, glm-5.3-flash. Effective successful model selection remains unverified; no AO session exists. Minimum known native config copied with 0700/0600 protection; matching existing credential found despite absent worker inheritance and loaded only in the same native/daemon child environment. No value in argv/config/reports; configured presence was not promoted to authorized.

Fresh attempt UTC / exit Observation / classification
strands --version 06:20:12.378–06:20:12.866; 0 PASS: 0.2.0; output SHA-256 1f930dd1f133c1f97a94fe3acb8db34372cf4c01ffdb2b3ff4ca72f9494121e9. Correct argv independently confirmed; no wrong-flag retry.
strands --help 06:20:12.866–06:20:13.303; 0 Parser availability PASS only; no general model-list/auth-status command. Output SHA-256 980e16977addeea30ec5a2339b5591a3570ec7c6126412ba625ed3a55a37f587.
Independent native provider/file witness 06:20:20.248–06:21:21.164; 1 FAIL: 429 Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted. Your limit will reset at 2026-10-21 18:43:31; no witness file. Output SHA-256 8d886ca83f9f4d58e6d8146fb5dedbe29a035da35a07af039ebcdc64819a6251. Quota response is not missing-credential proof.
AO build 001 06:21:34.849–06:22:16.581; -15 OPERATOR/CAPACITY stop at 721 MiB free; exact PID/start checked, reaped, only owned temp removed. Not a compile defect.
AO build 002, debug symbols stripped 06:22:57.851–06:23:01.979; 0 PASS; go build -ldflags='-s -w' -o <runtime>/bin/ao ./cmd/ao, serial, no source change.
strict-001, staged audit runner 06:23:18.104–06:25:05.328; outer exit 1 Strict FAIL: 5 PASS, 1 FAIL, 1 BLOCKED, 20 NOT_RUN. First failure local_session_spawn: 80,518ms timeout, no token/cwd proof. Native child returned 0 during termination but timedOut=true; not PASS. This separate attempt did not retain 429; preserve its timeout classification.
Strict AO preflight 06:25:03.995–06:25:05.011 Probe/ensure HTTP200; registration/install PASS. fresh_probe BLOCKED: installation fresh, authentication unknown/stale with auth_check_inconclusive, effective readiness unknown. Models and all TUI lifecycle steps NOT_RUN; no session created.
native-acp-001: standalone safe protocol 06:26:39.562–06:26:40.669; 0 Limited PASS: initialize protocol1/loadSession advertisement; missing-history load rejected -32002. Native ACP metadata version0.0.1 differs from CLI package0.2.0. No provider prompt/tool/approval or AO Chat qualification.
Diagnostic continuation NOT_RUN Native workspace proof failed and AO freshness blocked; diagnostic prerequisites unmet, no diagnostic flag/retry.

Independent api-001 (06:32:39.079–06:32:47.260 UTC), PASS limited to nonprovider reads and negative admission, not a diagnostic lifecycle run: disk recovered to964MiB, permitting one cache-backed serial rebuild003 (06:32:00.298–06:32:06.096, exit0) with the same AO SHA-256. /readyz PID1479248 and serving executable hash matched; model GET/refresh HTTP200 returned selectionMode:text, customModelEntry:direct, models:[], source:manual, refresh idle/not stale. Empty catalog remains non-pass for a strict catalog requirement; no model-visibility changes were invented. Installer/auth-plan GETs returned pinned npm0.2.0 and documentation-only setup; no install/login action started. Settings excluded Strands Chat. Explicit POST /api/v1/sessions with {kind:worker,harness:strands,mode:chat,approvalMode:default} returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, message strands has no chat driver, requestId vps-linux/tXn7GiN2k6-000010; session list stayed empty. Auth remained unknown/stale/inconclusive. No provider prompt, TUI spawn or failed-readiness bypass. /shutdown HTTP202, exit0/reaped, no session IDs. Rebuilt binary is retained privately; this does not erase the earlier capacity stop/reclamation.

Native witness command: strands --print --session off --builtin-tools write --builtin-plugins '' --skills off --prompt '<unique token/cwd JSON file task>', in a disposable workspace using the existing credential route. Strict reproduction after the serial build:

node <staged-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent strands \
  --repo <tested-clean-checkout> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao \
  --local-contract <runtime>/contract-001.json \
  --report <runtime>/strict-001/report \
  --startup-timeout-seconds 40 --timeout-seconds 80

Original contract SHA-256 9dbf548542f1d8aa0c288535c596a5104d311f66763478e6dd49a964f7760646. Sanitized equivalent below replaces only the installed binary path, so displayed bytes have a different hash:

{"schemaVersion":1,"agents":{"strands":{"binary":"/path/to/native/strands","versionArgs":["--version"],"integration":{"args":["--help"],"expect":"--session-id"},"session":{"args":["--print","--session","off","--builtin-tools","write","--builtin-plugins","","--skills","off","--prompt","{prompt}"],"proofFile":"LOCAL_AUDIT_PROOF.json"}}}}

The displayed JSON above omits only the control-character field. Before serializing the runtime contract, add contract.agents.strands.interrupt = {input: String.fromCharCode(27), settleTimeoutMs: 5000}. This reconstructs the documented Escape input without embedding an escape sequence in this comment. The private original contract and its hash remain unchanged.

The help probe proves availability, not auth. No models command was invented: interactive /model discovers Bedrock, not this custom module route. No restoredReady expression was fabricated/reused from inventory: genuine current startup/settled/draft/restored samples were not established. Escape is documented native input, but witnessed executing-tool cancellation remains NOT_RUN. Strict report SHA-256 a3f92036356d0c429e03450669f5841d2f7c8b3c8d0e6b58088e01f3a25c3a51.

Completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Registered TUI worker; shared task/settings surfaces BLOCKED POST probe HTTP 200: supported=true, installed=true. Actual Harness/New Task UI unavailable; no AO task created.
Models Direct model text or saved modelModule; Bedrock discovery is interactive BLOCKED No general native catalog. Independent API GET/refresh HTTP200: selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, models=[], manual source. Empty catalog cannot pass strict catalog gates. Both actual model UI surfaces, persisted off/on/bulk/picker effects and effective selection NOT_RUN; no fake switches. Strict original catalog gate remains NOT_RUN.
Providers Existing Z.ai custom OpenAIModel route; glm-5.3-flash configured BLOCKED Matching existing credential found despite absent inheritance, loaded only into child environment. Independent native response 429 quota exhausted; successful auth/model/file turn unverified. AO provider/account controls and effective routing NOT_RUN.
Setup Pinned native 0.2.0; npm installer source plan; AO documentation-only auth plan NOT_RUN API installers HTTP200 offers npm @strands-agents/cli@0.2.0, update unavailable; auth-plans HTTP200 launchMode=documentation. Install/upgrade/login/logout/reset prohibited and NOT_RUN. Existing install is not fresh onboarding; actual in-page setup/maintenance unqualified.
Readiness Linux binary installation and safe auth preflight BLOCKED Installation installed/fresh; authentication unknown/stale, auth_check_inconclusive; effective readiness unknown. No strict admission bypass or promotion to authorized.
Identity and logo Strands label and shared S initial fallback NOT_RUN Label source includes Strands; no Strands avatar logo mapping/asset/license, so shared lettered-tile fallback applies. Actual display not captured.
TUI and Chat TUI registered; native ACP advertised; AO Chat candidate unregistered BLOCKED Strict TUI spawn NOT_RUN. Native initialize/missing-history negative PASS without prompt; regular ACP permission broker absent. API settings excludes Strands from Chat; explicit Chat spawn HTTP409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, zero sessions. Streaming/history/approval/Stop/reconnect/recovery remain NOT_RUN; this is truthful rejection, not Chat qualification.
Reviewer No Strands AO reviewer entry; generic native print only NOT_RUN Prompt-review suitability unqualified. No actual AO reviewer target/head/run/result/cancel/rerun. External reviewer publication prohibited; missing wiring is not N/A or worker-review proof.
Permissions and instructions Source maps default/auto/accept-edits to Ask; bypass requires explicit native config NOT_RUN Minimum copied config retained default permissions and no saved grants. No escalation/account change. Provider quota and strict preflight blocked permission decisions, ordinary private/project instruction consumption and refreshed restore proof.
Lifecycle Follow-up/cancel/Kill/archive/exact restore; separate Chat recovery NOT_RUN No AO session, executing command PID/start witness, cancellation, Kill, archived entry, exact restore, Kanban continuation or unrelated live control. Native missing-history rejection alone is not lifecycle qualification.
Evidence Exact staged source/skill; distinct fresh attempts; full screenshot index BLOCKED Strict FAIL, independent native 429 and standalone ACP-safe proof retained. All 24 mandatory screenshot IDs plus Chat/reviewer substeps below. No real Electron capture or published attachment; no approved uploader.
CI and handoff Current-head CI/source/cleanup BLOCKED 25 checks completed/success; no failing/pending check jobs. Legacy status pending with zero contexts is not a pending job. GitHub mergeable=false/dirty. Local routine suites CI ONLY/NOT_RUN. Source clean, owned tests stopped; parent verification/removal and description evidence link pending.

Screenshot index was created before actions. Zero actual Electron captures or published screenshots. At setup gate, free disk 722MiB left 22MiB above the 700MiB floor; official pinned Electron44.7.0 Linux archive alone is 122,998,223 bytes (117.3MiB), before extraction/dependencies. Dependencies absent; npm ci/Electron NOT_RUN. Initial RAM total3,906MiB / available2,509MiB; disk blocked setup. A later capacity observation was below floor after strict had already finished; reclaiming only the finished owned AO binary restored 720MiB free. Binary hashes/build metadata retained. No old frontend, symlinked dependencies, terminal mirror, synthetic pixels or API images substituted. No approved GitHub attachment uploader; private queue has zero images. Every capture/attachment below is unavailable for these reasons, regardless of functional status.

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed Functional status Screenshot/attachment Proof or reason
harness-listed Open Harness row/name/logo/auth -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. API registration/install positive; actual row unobserved.
install-offer Install/Download/manual offer -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Pinned npm installer source plan only; no UI offer capture.
install-run Installation before/active/result -> not started NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Provider installs/upgrades prohibited; existing binary is not install proof.
auth-before Inspect Configured/Connected/setup -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Existing key present; AO auth unknown/stale, unverified.
auth-action AO Login/Setup handoff/return -> not started NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Login/account mutation prohibited; documentation-only AO plan.
auth-ready Verified ready row -> unknown/stale API, UI absent BLOCKED BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Native 429/no proof; strict authentication check inconclusive.
auth-maintenance Provider/account/logout/retry states -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Account mutation/reset prohibited; original profile unchanged.
harness-models Models loading/refresh/result -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Later independent model GET/refresh HTTP200: text/direct/manual, empty models; actual Models UI not opened. Original strict model gate stays NOT_RUN.
model-visibility Off/on/bulk/save/reload/picker effects -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No observed catalog or UI; no invented switches.
provider-management Provider list/config/add/change/remove -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Existing custom native route only; management UI unqualified.
task-agent New Task Agent visibility/selection -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Registered TUI API is not actual picker evidence.
task-model Model offer/choice/effective launch -> not opened NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. Module configured; effective successful choice unproved.
task-running Create/card/initial output/settled result -> not started BLOCKED BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO session after strict preflight; native quota witness failed.
task-followup Composer submission/response -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No ready owned AO session.
task-cancel Executing command/Stop/settled/continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No command PID/kernel-start witness; cancellation NOT_RUN.
kill-action Running/archive confirmation/terminated -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO session; daemon exit is not session Kill.
archived Exact archived session entry -> absent NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No session was created or archived.
restore-action Archived/Restore/native ready -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No AO history; genuine restoredReady contract unavailable, not fabricated.
kanban-return Same card/restored continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No exact restore or continuation.
chat Chat selection/composer/all applicable actions -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. AO settings excludes Strands; explicit Chat HTTP409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; actual Chat UI actions NOT_RUN, native handshake separate.
reviewer-select Reviewer picker/model/target -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No Strands reviewer registration or target/head run.
reviewer-running Review pane/active/cancel/error/retry -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No registered reviewer/run; external publication prohibited.
reviewer-result Verdict/result/rerun/new head -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No review run/result; no GitHub reviewer publication.
reconnect-cleanup UI reconnect/recovery/cleanup screen -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No actual Electron capture/attachment: capacity blocker and no approved uploader. No UI/session; native and daemon teardown verified separately in text.
chat/new-task New Chat task/session-new -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/followup-stream Composer streaming/output/file effect once -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/load-history AO paged history/exact native load/recall -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/approve Current approval -> authorized effect once -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/reject New rejection -> no protected effect -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/cancel-active-tool Command PID/start -> Stop -> no late effect -> continuation -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/ui-reconnect Event reconnect -> ordered catch-up/fresh turn -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned host adoption -> same identity/no duplicate -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/kill-restore-new-instructions Archive/exact restore/new private instructions -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
chat/negative-capabilities AO missing-history/settings/input typed rejection -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable AO Strands Chat unregistered and explicit creation rejected HTTP409; native approval/cancellation/restore unqualified. This subjourney NOT_RUN; native initialize/missing-history control separate. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/cancel Reviewer interrupt/error/retry -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/rerun Rerun/new-head result -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.
reviewer/publication Reviewer external GitHub publication -> not exercised NOT_RUN BLOCKED, unavailable No Strands reviewer registration/run; external reviewer publication prohibited. No UI capture/attachment.

Current source scope: TUI adapter, unregistered gated ACP candidate, capability catalog, manual auth plan, model-entry mode. Source is not runtime/UI proof. Installed native README states print/plain/ACP have no permission UI and use stock harness tool behavior; installed regular ACP server has no requestPermission bridge. Live AO Chat rejection is now proved independently; unfinished Chat/reviewer lifecycle and UI qualification remain non-pass.

CI at 2026-10-21T06:34:07.616101+00:00: 25/25 current-head check runs completed/success, no failing/pending check jobs. Local routine unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/frontend-build/runner-fixture suites NOT_RUN by CI-only policy. Native OS/container/renderer coverage below belongs to CI, not authenticated provider/live Electron proof:

build-test, renderer-smoke, mac-update-helper, test, sqlite-race (3), windows-workspace, sqlite-race (0), chat-race (1), sqlite-race (2), backend-core (1), lint, chat-race (0), sqlite-race (1), session-store-race, api-drift, backend-core (0), sqlc-drift, linux-proof-artifact, live-feeds, cloud-build-test, native (ubuntu-latest), native (macos-latest), native (windows-latest), container, scan.

Current PR mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. Recorded main 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd comparison: 13 main-only /39 PR-only commits, merge base 8fbec789517cb2b4ae979f81bde63f8a3242f643 (also current GitHub PR base). No merge/rebase/conflict fix. Legacy commit-status API returned pending with zero contexts; this does not add a pending/failing job.

Cleanup verified 2026-10-21T06:33:29.951526+00:00: PASS for owned test processes. Strict daemon PID1469987 exited0; /proc entry absent. Exact version/help/provider/build/runner PID+kernel-start identities no longer existed and children were reaped. API daemon PID1479248/startticks161011189 received shutdown HTTP202 and exited0/reaped; no API session IDs were created. Native ACP PID1477807/startticks160975238 exited0/reaped. Invoking worker/control-host ancestry excluded and never signaled. No UI or AO session created. No production service/profile/account modification. Reports/receipts/logs, minimal isolated profile and private strict SQLite state retained outside Git and unshared; source clean, no evidence commits. Parent final owned-process verification and clean-worktree removal pending.

Next actions/unresolved: provide sufficient scratch capacity; use the same authorized provider route once quota permits a successful native file witness; run a NEW strict attempt preserving these failures, requalify auth/readiness and genuine restore cues. Independently qualify actual current-head UI/model/provider controls and any supported Chat/reviewer journeys. Parent must capture/attach safe real PNGs with provenance via an approved attachment path; there are presently none to attach. Resolve conflicts only through separately authorized source work, then recheck affected CI/runtime. PR-description link to this new evidence comment: pending parent action; description not edited.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-28T09:01:08Z

Original comment

New fixes pushed — current head25bbd4386

Native terminal Setup, unknown-auth setup control, first-party native auth verification, freeform model guidance and official branding are implemented. Frontend135/135PASS; both affected backend packages and actualnative offline smokePASS. Fresh UI after captures and new-head CI are running. No live provider authorization/inference is claimed. Previous30/30 results below belong to e255a13.

Work in progress: user authorised fixes for the AO-side setup/auth/models/branding gaps after this review. Previous30/30CI results below belong to e255a13; new fixes will receive fresh verification.

Current review: real Electron findings

Current head: e255a13f2b1fa4e581c27e85cd37c191587337c4. Runtime/UI captures use parent 8e5461b902eef6ee7f531c2094105d3b2c279264; subsequent delta is only the test's errors.As lint correction. Full Strands package passed again at final head (0.990s); new-head remote lint passes.

Verdict: NOT merge-ready under skill7081. UI review and all30 official GitHub checks are complete; additional VPS suites are still running. Provider lifecycle qualification remains blocked.

Real Electron44.7.0/Linux Xvfb, native Strands0.2.0, isolated data. Official daemon build and real npm ci passed. Daemon SHA256 de55efd3901e07d901b2922074ffbaf038be0bf75aea9fc0c4228cac1e8f1da7.

Check Result Observed evidence / repro
Harness row, install detection, Health PASS Settings → Harness → Strands shows npm v0.2.0, exact executable; auth unavailable
Pin protection PASS v0.2.2 available / Update manually, explicit0.2.0 requirement; no upgrade clicked
Setup action FAIL Auth-plans API: action=setup, launchMode=documentation, available=true. Account tab: Setup status unavailable, no Login/Set up/docs button
Connected BLOCKED No existing provider setup; auth API unknown/auth_check_inconclusive. Adapter also lacks real provider verification
Models API PASS selectionMode=text, allowCustom=true, customModelEntry=direct, models=[], source=manual
Models tab GAP Says This harness reported no models. Native CLI supports freeform values but has no public model-list command; no catalog invented
New Task/custom model/Chat controls BLOCKED Actual current route: No agent is ready. Set one up in Settings. No picker reachable; no readiness override
Branding INCOMPLETE Generic S avatar; required branding touchpoints0/2
Provider turns, roles, usage, Kill/restore/recall BLOCKED No authenticated task, no provider request
Cleanup PASS Test processes stopped, ports31617/9227 closed; productionPID1554786/API3001 remains HTTP200

Unchanged UI skill runner: 3PASS/4FAIL/1NEEDS_USER/1NOT_RUN. Catalog expectation conflicts with truthful freeform mode; two New Task checks expect a legacy dialog. Raw failures preserved; manual current-route findings above do not weaken assertions.

Screenshot provenance / attachment gap

Actual unchanged screenshots were visually reviewed, retained privately on VPS, and not added to product diff:

strands-account.png 983ab12a7c7824ed753583de9560f93d653a0a2b69181b6394b854916bf3d037
strands-health.png 3b94b4e547a1d7104b6abf3b46293b15c61738f929fb676b8e393c7ffa328727
strands-models.png ecdc2964a4e8ec7e1f0d5f82b522f6f3f0bd3f017a4658c390f8663c269dae39
new-task-unconfigured-gate.png 095f68fb3f54c65b7d070fa7473bbeffd57eb72140e34555d9f1db676503f148

Attachment gap resolved: three original before-fix screenshots are attached directly in this PR comment. Official GitHubCLI2.103.3 --attach was installed privately on VPS; all image URLs return HTTP200 and SHA256 matches originals. The earlier blocker came from old CLI2.45.0. No evidence branch or local computer/browser access was used for the upload. New after-fix captures are pending the newly authorised fixes.

Concrete outstanding issues: missing advertised Setup/docs action (repro in table), missing real provider-auth verification, generic branding. Native ACP additionally returns-32601 for set_mode/set_model and restores stale private instructions; keep it unregistered.

Exact-head GitHub CI: 30/30 SUCCESS

Verified 2026-10-28T09:26:10.494504+00:00 on e255a13f2b1fa4e581c27e85cd37c191587337c4. All reported checks, including the aggregate Go gate, succeeded. These repository checks do not qualify missing Strands provider/UI/lifecycle gates. Remaining VPS suites are being reported separately; no unavailable local runner is labelled locally passed.

Official check Result
api-drift PASS
backend-core (0) PASS
backend-core (1) PASS
build-test PASS
chat-race (0) PASS
chat-race (1) PASS
checks PASS
cloud-build-test PASS
container PASS
lint PASS
live-feeds PASS
mac-update-helper PASS
native (macos-latest) PASS
native (ubuntu-latest) PASS
native (windows-latest) PASS
renderer-smoke PASS
scan PASS
session-store-race PASS
sqlc-drift PASS
sqlite-race (0) PASS
sqlite-race (1) PASS
sqlite-race (2) PASS
sqlite-race (3) PASS
test PASS
typecheck PASS
vitest (1) PASS
vitest (2) PASS
vitest (3) PASS
vitest (4) PASS
windows-workspace PASS

Setup-button root cause confirmed in source

  • needsHarnessLogin:81–82 is true only for authentication=unauthorized.
  • canRelogin:148 requires authorized/configured.
  • Account actions:87–94,133 therefore render neither action for unknown; the separate docs button requires action=instructions, whereas Strands advertises action=setup.
  • Strands intentionally reports unknown/configured, never proof of unauthorized/authorized. Do not falsify that verdict to expose a button. An available documentation/setup action should be reachable independently of verified auth status.
Parent-head native protocol, regression and preflight evidence

Strands review against harness skill PR #7081 — current evidence

Source: 8e5461b902eef6ee7f531c2094105d3b2c279264, reconciled with main 49951ca73e431bc79fd6e4b4c5ce3ba9414c86c0. Existing PR continued; draft retained. GitHub now reports merge conflicts resolved. This is an interim evidence update, not merge approval. Real Electron UI audit and complete CI are running.

Reviewed native release: official npm @strands-agents/cli@0.2.0, matching this PR's pin. Separately tested 0.2.2 only as a comparison; no silent version upgrade. Node24.22.1 / Go1.27.1. Exact installed transitives:

{
  "@strands-agents/cli": "0.2.0",
  "@strands-agents/harness": "0.1.1",
  "@strands-agents/sdk": "1.22.0",
  "@agentclientprotocol/sdk": "1.3.0",
  "ink": "7.1.1",
  "react": "19.2.8"
}
Check Result Observed evidence
Skill intake PASS Existing draft #6517 continued, no duplicate PR
CLI version / help PASS Actual released strands --version = 0.2.0; native --help supports TUI, --acp-server, --session-id, --instructions, --model
TUI touchpoints PASS Skill checker: 13/13 required; installer2/2, auth-plan1/1, model-catalog1/1 wired
Doctor PASS with limits Correct frozen checkout, CLI0.2.0; no native login-status check. ACP bridge absent, TUI-only scope
Strict live audit 5 PASS, 1 FAIL, 1 SKIP CLI installed/version, AO registration/installation, freeform models PASS; authentication inconclusive FAIL; authenticated lifecycle SKIP
Native permission/activity/cancellation boundaries PASS Released SDK1.22.0: 5 tests, 5 pass, 0 fail, 0 skipped; actual shell cancellation prevents delayed write. Offline fixture model, not authenticated agent turns
Exact seeded history replay PASS with limits Real ACP process loads exact SDK-seeded ID and replays two fixture messages; no provider call or live recall claimed
Native ACP mode/model switching FAIL upstream qualification Actual session/set_mode and session/set_model both return -32601 Method not found
Native ACP restored private instructions FAIL upstream qualification Fixture proves ACP retains OLD snapshot instructions and drops NEW instructions; native TUI initialization keeps NEW and drops OLD
ACP Chat shipping gate PASS Candidate remains unregistered; no false claim of production-ready Chat
Branding / verified Connected flow GAP Skill touchpoint checker: avatar0/2; auth plan exists but no real provider verification. UI behavior being captured
Authenticated TUI lifecycle, roles, usage, Kill/restore and PINEAPPLE recall BLOCKED Existing provider authentication unavailable on this VPS; no keys read/injected, login/logout, or provider requests
Real Electron UI RUNNING Official npm run build:daemon -- --dev succeeded; isolated real Electron is up, screenshots being collected
Full CI / remote checks RUNNING Complete sequential suites started on frozen head. Docker socket/native macOS/Windows require explicit gap/remote CI reporting

Fix applied and verified: Node preload leaked into project subprocesses

Before, AO's inherited NODE_OPTIONS preload removed node:module.registerHooks in project Node children too. The real Node regression failed with:

AssertionError: project child must retain native ESM hooks
actual: 'undefined'
expected: 'function'
FAIL TestNodePreloadLeavesProjectChildrenNative/strands-parent

Now the Strands launch enables a one-use flag and the preload consumes it. The parent keeps its loader workaround; child ESM/CJS hook APIs and inherited options remain native. Exact green results:

PASS TestNodePreloadLeavesProjectChildrenNative/unscoped
PASS TestNodePreloadLeavesProjectChildrenNative/strands-parent
PASS TestRuntimeLaunchEnvScopesNodeHookWorkaround
ok  backend/internal/adapters/agent/strands 0.850s
ok  backend/internal/adapters/agent/strands 1.906s  [race]

Native CLI0.2.0 plus AO plugins/preload also reached the composer:

{
  "fixtureProfile": true,
  "providerRequests": 0,
  "exit": 130,
  "readyComposer": true,
  "pluginLoaderError": false,
  "privateInstructionsVisible": false,
  "bytes": 5218
}

This used a fixture profile with zero provider requests, so it is bootstrap proof only.

Frozen-head preflight

PASS go test -p=1 -count=1 ./internal/adapters/agent/strands ./internal/adapters/chatdriver/strandsacp ./internal/adapters/agent/registry ./internal/adapters/chatdriver/registry ./internal/service/agentauth ./internal/service/systeminstall ./internal/adapters/agent/modelcatalog [6.33s]
PASS go test -p=1 -count=1 -run Test(MigrationStrands|ReconcileStrands|MigrationLedger|Shipped|Burned) ./internal/storage/sqlite [11.54s]
PASS go test -p=1 -count=1 ./internal/httpd/apispec/... [13.92s]

The unmerged Strands migration was regenerated after current main's migration maximum; SQL content retained. Installer cardinality now checks the domain harness set and exact membership. Generated API drift check passes. Existing incoming mobile/cloud paths match main; no unrelated net change was introduced.

Actual auth API result

{
  "installation": "installed",
  "authentication": "unknown",
  "reasonCode": "auth_check_inconclusive",
  "effectiveReadiness": "unknown"
}

This is not proof the user is signed out, and configured credentials would not alone establish Connected. Freeform model entry is intentional because the released CLI has no public model-list command; no catalog was invented.

Remaining work

Complete the real UI checkpoint report and full applicable CI, report remote checks and unavailable-runner gaps, then refresh this comment. Authenticated behavior remains unverified until provider setup and a truthful auth check exist. New reports/logs/screenshots are kept outside the product diff; verified evidence is recorded here in PR comments.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-28T09:34:50Z

Original comment

Real Strands UI screenshots — before the new fixes

Actual isolated Electron44.7.0 on VPS/Linux with native CLI0.2.0. Runtime source8e5461b902eef6ee7f531c2094105d3b2c279264; e255a13 only changes a test. No mock, credentials or provider requests. These show the gaps being fixed, not a passing final implementation.

Before fixes: installed Strands0.2.0, no setup action, generic avatar

Before fixes: installed Strands0.2.0, no setup action, generic avatar

Before fixes: freeform model contract shown as an empty catalog

Before fixes: freeform model contract shown as an empty catalog

Before fixes: New Task readiness gate with no provider authentication

Before fixes: New Task readiness gate with no provider authentication

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🏆 Review leaderboard

Nov 5–12, 2026 · UTC

Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
🥇 @ronishrohan @ronishrohan 91 160 14
🥈 @neversettle17-101 @neversettle17-101 11 15 4
🥉 @illegalcall @illegalcall 11 12 4
4 @Meraj-08 @Meraj-08 10 15 0
5 @nikhilachale @nikhilachale 7 19 3
6 @Prasad-D-Ware @Prasad-D-Ware 7 12 2
7 @Annieeeee11 @Annieeeee11 6 9 0
8 @mohakchakraborty2004 @mohakchakraborty2004 6 7 2
9 @Pritom14 @Pritom14 5 8 1
10 @Rishet11 @Rishet11 5 6 3

Ranked by distinct external PRs reviewed, then review rounds, then PR comments. Self-activity and bot activity are excluded.

Show 6 more reviewers
Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
11 @somewherelostt @somewherelostt 3 11 1
12 @ApexYash11 @ApexYash11 2 6 2
13 @Vaibhaav-Tiwari @Vaibhaav-Tiwari 2 3 0
14 @codebanditssss @codebanditssss 2 2 8
15 @harshitsinghbhandari @harshitsinghbhandari 2 2 0
16 @MohamedKamran @MohamedKamran 1 2 0

@OrcInc OrcInc added comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request labels Nov 12, 2026
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Account migration verification

  • New PR author verified as milesatao-svg; submission is a draft.
  • Original PR #6517 and this PR both point to 25bbd4386ea9d4cf3aed5fc2d14054e4c4adf739.
  • Published change-count header verified against this PR's actual GitHub file diff.
  • All 24 original human comment bodies and source links reproduced across 3 historical-evidence comments.
  • All 11 original screenshot/recording URLs reproduced and checked as HTTP 200 media.
  • Current GitHub mergeability: conflicts with main; resolution pending.
  • Fresh CI validation and current-head harness certification are pending. Copied test outcomes retain their original run/commit provenance.

nikhilachale and others added 7 commits November 14, 2026 22:52
Resolve the eight conflicts against main adf9f6a by keeping main's
fields and behavior and re-adding only the Strands entries:

- dto.go, systeminstall.go, schema.ts: keep main's new fields (branch,
  baseBranch, install progress, cua-driver) and add strands to the enums.
- chatdriver registry test: Hermes now has native chat on main, so only
  Strands stays in the TUI-only list.
- agentauth plans: keep main's Claude login text and the Strands setup plan.
- migration ledger: keep main's entries and append the Strands migration.
- HarnessAccountTab: take main's showSetup condition, which already covers
  setup actions with unknown auth.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
settings.harness.models.manualTitle and settings.harness.models.manual were
English-only, which failed the locale coverage test and crashed the
interpolation alignment test on the missing zh-CN value.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The daemon returns its manual policy catalog, which is text mode with no
models for Codex, Claude Code, Cursor and other direct-entry harnesses, as a
placeholder while a first load is pending and while the harness is signed
out. The Models tab then told those users the harness accepts model IDs
instead of providing a list, and hid the sign-in prompt. Require an idle,
warning-free, empty text catalog before showing that copy.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Reverts 25d44c6 and dabac61. They make an orchestrator-spawned worker
ignore an explicit --agent in favor of the project's Worker agent, and update
the using-ao spawn guide to match. That changes spawn behavior for every
harness, has no PR of its own, and is not on main. Keep this PR to the
Strands harness; the change can be proposed and reviewed separately.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
20261028082940187 sat below 40 migrations main shipped since, so a fresh
database ran it mid-history and an upgraded one applied it out of order
through WithAllowMissing. Take a new generator-format ID above main's
20261114072016988, and run the round-trip test from main's latest schema so
it isolates the Strands step instead of reversing every later migration.

Also list strands in `ao spawn --harness` help, as every other harness is.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ut of the diff

The harness integration guide keeps audit reports, evidence and screenshots
out of the PR diff (they belong in PR comments) and rules out unregistered
drivers. Remove the docs/research Strands reports, JSON evidence and PNG
captures, the unregistered strandsacp Chat driver, and its opt-in native ACP
probe and live test. Strands stays TUI-only. The historical evidence remains
reachable at the revision-pinned links in the PR description and comments.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Current-head review and ao-agent-harness receipt — 2e55727e57

Head: 2e55727e57987ff43ee99082741a790b66ce23d2, which includes main 28bc83fd95. GitHub reports MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED.
Skill: ao-agent-harness from PR #7081 at 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840, read from an exported copy. None of the skill's files, contracts or reports are in this diff.
Host constraints: this reviewer host is Windows and does not run project builds, tests or scripts. No VPS was touched. No provider login or credentials were used.

Changes in this update

Commit Change
8069adaad3, 2e55727e57 Merged current main and resolved all 8 conflicts. Main's fields and behavior are kept (DelegateTask branch/baseBranch, install progress, cua-driver, Hermes native chat, Claude "setup token" text, main's showSetup rule). The only additions are Strands enum, plan and ledger entries.
3158aae834 CI fix: added settings.harness.models.manualTitle and settings.harness.models.manual to de, es, fr, ja, ko, pt-BR, ru and zh-CN. This fixes both the locale-coverage failure and the interpolation crash in vitest (2), which also turned the test gate red.
4e798d90ce Defect fix: the new free-form Models panel also fired on the daemon's manual placeholder catalog (text mode, no models) for Codex, Claude Code, Cursor and similar harnesses, both during a first load (refreshState: refreshing) and while signed out (warningCode: auth_required). Those users saw "accepts model IDs instead of providing a model list" instead of the sign-in prompt. The panel now requires a settled, warning-free, empty text catalog. Regression tests added.
b66ee720b1 Scope fix: reverted 25d44c6981 and dabac6135f. They made orchestrator-spawned workers ignore an explicit --agent for every harness, had no PR of their own and are not on main.
c19163a5e9 Migration fix: the Strands CHECK migration moved from 20261028082940187 (below 40 later main migrations) to 20261114173932630, above main's latest 20261114072016988. The round-trip test now starts from main's latest schema.
3d6224ec32 Scope fix (skill §3): removed the committed docs/research Strands reports, evidence JSON and PNG captures, the unregistered strandsacp Chat driver, and its opt-in ACP probe and live test. Historical evidence stays reachable through the revision-pinned links in the description.

CHECK migration vs main's later migrations: no migration after the Strands version rebuilds sessions or rewrites its harness CHECK. Later migrations only ADD/DROP COLUMN. The ('claude-code','codex','kimi') CHECK in 20261103030401452 belongs to a separate usage table. goose runs WithAllowMissing and reconcileHarnessConstraint repairs Strands as well. Static review only; CI must confirm.

Skill step receipt

Step Result Evidence / gap
0 Intake PASS (manual) Only open Strands PR; continues closed #6517. harness_intake.mjs not run (no script execution on this host).
1 Compatibility PASS (historical) The table and unsupported-surface proof come from the earlier native qualification linked in the description (CLI pinned to 0.2.0; ACP lacks mode/model/permission behavior, so Chat is unregistered). Not re-run at this head.
2 Build / touchpoints PASS (static) Checked by equivalent greps, not by running the script. Required TUI, install, auth, models and branding touchpoints are all wired: adapter, domain, agent registry, SQLite repair + migration, 2/2 DTO enums, OpenAPI, schema.ts, product label, GetAgentHooks, activity dispatch, terminal refresh (explicitly unsupported), refresh matrix, install target and plan, auth plan, model catalog, avatar, licence. Optional: spawn help was added in this update; doctor probe has no ExpectedVersionPrefix because --version prints only 0.2.0 (the adapter enforces the pin at launch); no docs/harnesses/strands.md. Chat and reviewer are out of scope (TUI-only).
3 Contract BLOCKED A local-contracts.json entry plus doctor needs a host with the pinned CLI and credentials. Per the skill it is never committed.
4 Live audit BLOCKED Needs an authorized macOS/Linux host with Strands 0.2.0 and provider credentials. Covers TUI spawn, first prompt, system prompt and AGENTS.md, hook status, follow-up, usage, Kill, exact restore, and V1 roles.
5 UI audit BLOCKED Needs the real desktop app on an authorized host. Checkpoints 1–9, including Connected state, Models free-form panel and New Task.
6 Hand-off PARTIAL AO-side static findings are fixed (above). The live and UI Fix sections can't be produced until steps 4–5 run.

Open risks for live testing

  • Windows launch: private instructions are passed as a multi-line --instructions argv value ahead of --prompt, and the Windows binary is the npm strands.cmd shim. Batch argument handling of newlines or long lines could truncate the instructions or drop the task prompt. Needs a Windows TUI launch check; the installer is currently offered on all OSes.
  • Restore errors: a missing native ID, history or locator returns an untyped adapter error. That matches Hermes but may surface as a 500 rather than a fresh launch or typed 4xx.
  • Free-form copy scope: the Models panel message now applies to every settled free-form catalog (for example Aider, Goose, Hermes), not just Strands. Product should confirm its "configure a provider and default model in its CLI" wording for those harnesses.

CI

GitHub is holding all workflow runs for this head as action_required (fork workflows need maintainer approval). No current-head check results exist yet. Earlier results belong to 25bbd438 only.

Not merge-ready: it still needs current-head CI, a fresh review, maintainer approval and the BLOCKED live/UI gates above.

@nikhilachale nikhilachale left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Changes requested.

I reviewed the Strands TUI adapter (launch/restore, checkpoint validation, activity and permission bridge, auth probe, Node preload), the registry, domain, migration and install wiring, and the Settings Models and Account changes. The pinned install and refused updates, the fail-closed native config validation, restore checkpoint checks and auth status handling look careful. Two problems need fixing before this is ready (see inline comments):

  1. safeID rejects valid AO session IDs that contain . or uppercase letters, so Strands cannot launch in projects such as next.js.
  2. The --import preload is injected through NODE_OPTIONS, so every Node process the agent starts from the project inherits it. Older Node versions (<18.18 / 16) cannot run at all with it.

Optional, non-blocking:

  • backend/internal/cli/doctor.go: the new strands entry is inserted between the Command Code comment and its command-code entry. The comment now sits above the wrong harness, so move strands below.
  • HarnessModelsPanel: the new freeformOnly branch applies to every harness with a settled, empty text-mode catalog, not just Strands. Please check that the "Configure a provider and default model in its CLI" copy fits the other manual/text harnesses that hit it.
  • AuthStatus runs a Node subprocess plus a network catalog call (up to 15s) each time it is invoked. Consider caching if readiness polls it often.

nikhilachale and others added 4 commits November 14, 2026 23:33
safeID was applied to the AO session id, but AO session ids carry the
project prefix, which keeps dots and case (a `next.js` project yields
`next.js-1`). Every Strands spawn in such a project failed and SessionInfo
returned a hard error. Validate the AO id with the alphabet `ao hooks`
accepts, bounded in length, which still rules out separators, a leading dot
and `..` in the launches/ file name. The native session id keeps the strict
check.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The --import preload stayed in NODE_OPTIONS for every Node process the agent
started, so a project using a Node without --import support could not run
node or npm at all. The preload now removes its own token from NODE_OPTIONS,
as it already consumes the launch-only workaround flag, and leaves the user's
options intact.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Keeps Command Code's comment beside its own entry.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

@nikhilachale nikhilachale left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Approved. Both findings from the previous review are fixed at d4f23b87d4:

  1. AO session IDs: the new validAOSessionID accepts dotted and mixed-case project prefixes (next.js-1, MyApp-2). It still rejects leading dots, .., a trailing ., path separators and IDs over 200 characters. The native UUID keeps the strict safeID check. The new test covers launch, SessionInfo and restore for the accepted IDs, and rejection for the unsafe ones.
  2. NODE_OPTIONS leak: the preload now removes its own --import "file:.../agents/strands/ao-node-hooks.mjs" token from process.env.NODE_OPTIONS. It keeps any other options and deletes the variable when nothing is left. The pattern matches the URL that withNodePreload produces on both Unix and Windows. Spaces are percent-encoded, so the quoted value never contains a quote. The new test checks that a child process sees exactly the remaining options.

The doctor entry has also moved below Hermes. The rest of the delta since the last review comes from main (Cloud agent switch, handoff note extraction) and does not touch the Strands adapter. The Strands migration is still the newest one.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

4 participants