Skip to content

feat: add Mastra Code TUI and gated SDK Chat candidate - #8203

Draft
milesatao-svg wants to merge 49 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6541-mastra
Draft

milesatao-svg wants to merge 49 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6541-mastra

Conversation

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Code changes: +2401 -26
Tests: +2123 -22
Others: +102 -4

Account migration from @nikhilachale to @milesatao-svg. This draft continues original PR #6541 at original head 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0. Original commits and commit authorship are preserved. Descriptions and evidence below include historical results with their original sources.

What

feat: add Mastra Code TUI and gated SDK Chat candidate

Original PR description, preserved

Mastra Code login, auth verification and model-entry fixes at 010b5cf. Latest integrated main: b13b951.

Native Log in now opens mastracode login in the same isolated profile as sessions. Provider verification follows native active-pack/build-model resolution; API-key presence alone cannot report Connected.

New Task accepts supported direct model IDs, and Models explains native freeform selection instead of implying an available catalog. Login, runtime and auth checks use the same canonical AO data/profile root, including relative AO_DATA_DIR overrides.

Current full validation is in progress; merge readiness is not claimed.

Check Current observation
Exact-head preflight PASS: Go adapter/auth/installer/registry/ports, native Default/precedence checks and 262 UI tests
Unknown-auth action PASS: real Electron exposes native Login/Set up without changing Unknown to signed-in
Unverified credentials PASS: Account uses Credentials not verified instead of Connected
Direct model entry PASS: actual New Task payload contains the entered native model ID; freeform guidance, no invented catalog
Unspecified permissions PASS: ordinary New Task persists native Default; explicit policies and other harness defaults remain unchanged
MiniMax native inference PASS: pinned native release, supplied key, bounded request; temporary profiles removed
Z.ai native inference UNVERIFIED: Mastra reports HTTP 429; CodeBuddy JSON mode produced no qualifying result
Full local / remote CI Running on the exact source head; no blanket pass claimed

Native provider proof used Mastra0.45.0 and CodeBuddy2.164.0; CodeBuddy practical UI2.173 and the corrected2.164 API/native retry are separately identified in the evidence comment. Full lifecycle, restore and cross-platform native-provider qualification remain separate from these fixes.

Current fix and evidence status.

Current scope remains foreground TUI. Successful provider authentication, complete live lifecycle qualification and merge readiness must be assessed from the current evidence comment; historical checks below do not qualify this head.

Preserved description and evidence from earlier source revisions (historical)

Adds the native Mastra Code TUI and an unregistered SDK1.11 Chat candidate using shared ACP/persistenthost, private additive instructions, guarded exact native history/replay, manual approvals and isolated native state. Unsupported settings fail closed; production Chat, handoff and reviewers remain unavailable.

Draft: current-head CI is pending; real SDK/provider/AO/UI qualification remains unproven. Neither implementationComplete nor READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE is claimed.

Current source, review, CI and qualification snapshot. Retained previous description and historical verification.

Why

The contributor is moving this harness submission to @milesatao-svg. The linked source preserves the implementation and review history.

Before / After

Before After
Submission in PR #6541 from @nikhilachale at 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0 Submission from @milesatao-svg at the same commit 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0

Original product behavior and existing UI evidence are included in the preserved description and copied evidence comments.

How

Copy the source head into milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6541-mastra and target upstream main.

Testing

Historical test results and screenshots are reproduced in the evidence comments with their original sources. Fresh validation is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.

Checklist

  • Original head SHA and commit authorship preserved.
  • Original description and evidence provenance included.
  • Fresh CI validation on this submission.
  • Resolve current main merge conflicts.

Account migration verification

  • Exact source head copied: 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0.
  • New fork branch: milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6541-mastra. Base: main.
  • Evidence comments retain their original author, timestamp, source URL and result wording.
  • Fresh validation status is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.
  • Source mergeability at migration: conflicts with current main; reconciliation pending.

Ubuntu and others added 30 commits October 11, 2026 11:36
Preserve harness-owned evidence and merge current canonical API, storage, and native Chat updates. Runtime proof remains qualified by its original source.
Build the real daemon in PR CI for isolated VPS runtime verification without local validation suites or dependency installations. Record source revision, Go build info, and executable hash.
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 1/4

Historical material from original PR #6541, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T13:57:45Z

Original comment

Actual AO Electron proof is published with immutable evidence links. UI and serving daemon are14fedd56b; pinned native mastracode0.45.0/code-sdk1.11.0, Z.ai glm-5.3-flash. Capture was inspected for secrets and the downloaded published PNG hash matches3b38aad4a58c6e4e87977c4295aa3045837147e4e347b7bca63092318357e762.

Report, lifecycle and exact cleanup receipts

Actual AO native Mastra approval dialog

Earlier failures and differing lifecycle source heads are preserved explicitly. Permission approve/reject and pending input409 protection passed; permission-cancel recovery required later Escape after native embedding initialization, so immediate dialog cancellation is not claimed. Foreground shell Escape and independent AO Kill have separate PID/kernel-start/reaping/no-late-side-effect controls. All exact owned session processes and the isolated daemon are now gone; dirty worktrees/profiles/evidence preserved. Routine tests ran only in PR CI. Draft remains until current-head CI rerun completes.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T14:21:59Z

Original comment

Mastra stage complete. Integration head14fedd56b6904974a325d09ac3ac8c1c73cb2313 has23/23 successful GitHub checks; evidence head92c6b0e49be75d650248e7218b7af376d65676ef has5/5, including current-head fixtures. PR6541 is ready for review. The initial autoreview timeout and evidence frontend late jsdom row.animate error are preserved separately; their failed jobs passed on remote rerun. No routine local suites ran.

Immutable AO screenshot, provenance, lifecycle controls, limitations and cleanup report. Published screenshot download hash verified. Three owned sessions and isolated daemon were shut down with process identity/readback controls; dirty worktrees/profiles and prior evidence remain preserved. Scope remains TUI-only; no Chat/handoff/background ownership claim or immediate permission-dialog-cancel claim.

This stage changed no runner source. Installed runner remains8887aa2e7101b9e6d3950bfca08ffddf2e1e6c1c3f1d030c8dec2676443aecea; evidence checkout's earlier runner revisions hash23dc1a2f39bd6c88fd95b47d041040a039d16c52ab71996a278f49e68f8bdcc5 is covered by the new fixture check. Native instruction/restore/permission lessons were synced to installed skill documentation.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T16:50:50Z

Original comment

Harness-specific reports, JSON receipts, screenshots and provenance now live on this integration PR branch, rather than the skill PR #6509.

Evidence index with embedded screenshots and JSON links.

Historical successes, failures and scope limitations remain as recorded. Moving these files does not rerun native/AO testing or upgrade any verdict.

This is evidence relocation only. Existing tested source/native hashes and failures are preserved; the documentation commit is not a fresh runtime pass. Applicable checks run in PR CI.

Recorded harness evidence — see scope above


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:08:25Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at eb73fd14e7f0, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:17:43Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 6db4eca087ec, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T20:59:13Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at ec7669914826, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T23:59:48Z

Original comment

Canonical main and the green shared ACP replay CI budget reconciled at 988c6618d807, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

The shared test-only fix PR6617 had21 green applicable checks; this integration head still needs its own exact-head CI. The full20543-frame replay burst and exact-once assertions remain unchanged. No routine local suites ran. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-15T06:35:35Z

Original comment

Published, incomplete qualification — AO UI evidence BLOCKED; not merge-ready.

Head 24dc3ce57c8d53f63279b68ede76284ccab79487; main 54b28374912cb2771f17b8cc32a9482e6d607bce reconciled without force-push. Published 16 visually reviewed actual Electron screenshots with27 checkpoint rows. Real initial private/project effects, follow-up, witnessed Escape cancellation/no-late effect, idle Archive, same-native-ID/history restore and Kanban return were observed at787eaa74. The first ordinary restored continuation failed its fresh private-instruction effect. Manual onboarding/model UI and original per-image after-probe provenance remain incomplete; later diagnostics do not replace that failure.

Publication report · Full ordered report/checkpoint table

Images below are actual original captures from runtime/UI787eaa74, not the newer merged head. Sidecars, hashes, native digest, generations, functional receipts and original provenance limitations are linked in the full report.

Harness: installed/configured

Harness: installed/configured

Missing binary: manual install offer; no install progress

Missing binary: manual install offer; no install progress

Installed unconfigured: setup guide return

Installed unconfigured: setup guide return

New Task harness selection

New Task harness selection

Model menu loading frame; no manual entry proof

Model menu loading frame; no manual entry proof

Project-configured model before submit

Project-configured model before submit

Original unsupported Auto failure

Original unsupported Auto failure

Separate bypass attempt: initial output/instruction effects

Separate bypass attempt: initial output/instruction effects

Actual native UI follow-up/result

Actual native UI follow-up/result

Witnessed executing command before Escape

Witnessed executing command before Escape

Empty composer after cancel; command box lags

Empty composer after cancel; command box lags

Idle Archive confirmation

Idle Archive confirmation

Exact terminated entry

Exact terminated entry

Same native history: initialized restored composer

Same native history: initialized restored composer

History continuation; fresh private witness FAIL

History continuation; fresh private witness FAIL

Same card back in Kanban

Same card back in Kanban

Exact publication-head CI is being checked separately below; old green heads do not qualify edited/merged source. No routine VPS tests, lint, typecheck, gofmt or CI emulator ran. Linux/provider evidence does not establish other OS/provider coverage. Original failures/profiles/logs remain intact privately. No skill6509 writes, production changes, merge, release or deployment.

Exact-head CI (2026-10-15T07:12:27.707215+00:00): complete at 24dc3ce57c8d53f63279b68ede76284ccab79487 — 25 SUCCESS (25 reported; 25 expected including the merged Go aggregate gate). Current checks. Mergeability MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED; draft handoff. CI does not qualify missing native/UI/provider/OS gates. Canonical main subsequently advanced to48c4ef5e with only two non-overlapping preview-process files; GitHub reports this head mergeable. These completed checks belong to the stated publication head, not a newly rebuilt merge with that later base.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:37:17Z

Original comment

Continuing existing PR6541 only. Plan: preserve and finish the supplied main merge (allocate the unmerged Mastra migration after canonical awake206); inspect current official mastracode/SDK ACP sources for deterministic session/load and additive private hostInstructions without replacing native processors; implement only a genuinely supported thin nativeacp binding if those contracts exist. Otherwise retain the Chat gate and publish the exact upstream blocker. Native, lifecycle and actual AO Chat UI proof are mandatory before readiness; historical TUI evidence and the first restored-private-instruction failure remain historical. Routine suites run only in PR CI. No new evidence files, no PR6509 writes, no merge/release/deployment.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:38:49Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — first-party ACP exact restore is unavailable. Not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Current integration head: acd074cb8e778637abe84d39996e332626464ec0; actual canonical main: 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f (both fetched again immediately before publication). Completed the supplied merge preserving PR/main ancestry and user changes. Canonical 0206_awake.sql is unchanged; the unmerged Mastra migration is now 0207_allow_mastra_code_harness.sql. No Chat registration or speculative shim was added. Existing TUI behavior is retained.

First-party investigation: npm latest reports mastracode 0.47.1 and @mastra/code-sdk 1.14.0, beyond the initial 0.45.0/1.11 baseline. SDK archive SHA256 73f56b7850c137da1f5771e105c62c3706bc4e18e2ecb81fb4b369f4d0098870. Published dist/acp/agent.js SHA256 ea96f9eb314f28f4e381b70c36faec353be4d90a8dcb6b5c074fbf5d86e5f6b1: initialize explicitly advertises loadSession:false, there is no loadSession handler, and newSession unconditionally calls native thread.create then thread.switch. Published ACP runtime SHA256 987e7d8fa79db9568320b6f7ea841e50ca264431b23a5abf212f0a363c2c4e7b: createAcpSession accepts only coAuthor options. Underlying createMastraCode supports additive hostInstructions, but the stock ACP factory does not forward it. Supplying a custom factory alone cannot add the absent load/replay handler. No identity was invented and no mandatory processors were replaced.

Current first-party source independently still advertises loadSession:false and creates a fresh thread. Official SDK package. A qualified upstream load/replay implementation and additive host-context route are needed before thin AO Chat binding qualification. No upstream fork was created in this bounded investigation.

Gate Result Evidence / limitation
Live PR/main reconciliation PASS Merge commit acd074c; migration conflict resolved without overwrites
Official ACP deterministic exact restore BLOCKED Published SDK and current upstream source lack session/load
Private additive instructions, fresh + post-Kill restore BLOCKED Core SDK supports hostInstructions; stock ACP omits it; historical first restored ordinary-task failure remains preserved
Initialize/auth/new, stable native identity, text/reasoning/tools/plans NOT_RUN Source inspection is not native protocol proof
Native approvals allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN No new native/provider run
Executing interrupt and independent Kill, PID/birth identity/no delayed effect NOT_RUN Historical TUI receipts do not qualify Chat
Exact restore/missing history/workspace rejection BLOCKED Missing native ACP load contract
Restart/detached reconnect/replay without duplication BLOCKED Missing exact native replay
Models/options and private/project-rule consumption NOT_RUN No supported Chat route qualified
Actual AO Chat UI + direct attachment BLOCKED No current Chat session/build/capture; screenshot unavailable. No fabricated UI or repository evidence assets
Independent review NOT_RUN No Chat implementation to qualify
Current-head CI PENDING current-head run; current-head run; current-head run; current-head run; current-head run; 23 checks inspected

Native executable/model/session/generation/UI-build fingerprints: NOT_RUN / unavailable for this attempt, not inferred from package source. Historical TUI evidence and failures remain in existing comments unchanged, especially the failed fresh private-instruction effect on restored continuation (retained publication). Earlier help/version/HTTP success and green source CI do not satisfy Chat acceptance.

Resources: ~317 MiB free disk at start; no dependency allocation/build attempted because the mandatory first-party protocol blocker was established directly. No routine local suites/lint/typecheck/workflow emulation. Current-head checks are linked above and are not claimed green until complete. Cleanup: this attempt launched no AO daemon, Electron, provider session or native child; no production state/profile/credentials touched. Only owned operational checkpoint updated; no new report/evidence files, screenshots, evidence branch, release/deploy/merge, or PR6509 writes.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:51:21Z

Original comment

Reconciliation pass only. Refreshed the actual nikhilachale:feat/mastra-code-tui-integration head and canonical main. Continuing the supplied in-progress merge: retain Mastra and main Memcode registrations, preserve both native restore contracts and strict styled-output fencing, allocate the pending Mastra migration after fresh main, regenerate API artifacts, then refresh both heads again before a normal push. Routine suites run only in PR CI. No ACP implementation or new evidence files in this pass.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:53:40Z

Original comment

Reconciliation complete for PR #6541; ACP qualification is reserved for the next pass and remains blocked historically, not claimed ready here.

Pushed c23ef211a69394302dbd425888600e495f5785d3 normally to nikhilachale:feat/mastra-code-tui-integration; integrated actual canonical main 6e8d6e4e04ab210ee8dcf9678e337a6ef6d60a8c. Both heads were fetched at start and immediately before push; neither advanced at the final push refresh. Existing PR ancestry and historical evidence remain intact.

Conflict decisions:

  • Retained Mastra plus main's Memcode imports, registry/domain/install/auth/CLI/UI entries and API enum values; no reviewer or Chat registration added.
  • Preserved main's interactive native restore initializer/rollback plus Mastra's separate native restore verifier. Activity observation retains Mastra's mandatory current styled viewport while honoring main's optional styled-output preference.
  • Kept all canonical migrations unchanged. Moved pending Mastra widening from 207 to 213 after main's 212; retained 207's ledger identity and marked it burned, allowing its historical ledger entry to remain without permitting reuse. Schema repair retains both harness tails.
  • Regenerated OpenAPI and TypeScript using the source generator and pinned openapi-typescript 7.4.4. Initial npm API command completed Go generation then failed because the checkout lacked the TypeScript executable; pinned npx generation subsequently completed. No sqlc source/query contract changed.
Reconciliation verification Status
Both actual remote heads integrated PASS
Conflict markers absent; git diff --check PASS
Required API generation PASS
Routine local test/lint/typecheck suites NOT_RUN — human requires PR CI only
Current-head CI PENDING — inspected 23 checks; incomplete checks remain pending
New native/ACP/UI qualification NOT_RUN — reconcile-only pass

Current-head CI (earlier-head green is historical):

Cleanup: parent already removed only unused ignored node_modules from historical Mastra frontend and ui-lab product-ui/cloud-client checkouts, disposable npm cache, and two unused superseded Codex app-server vendor versions; affected source status/lockfile hashes were unchanged. This pass deleted no additional data, launched no AO/Electron/provider processes, and touched no production profiles/data. Free space was about 2.1 GiB on entry. No new report/evidence files or screenshots committed; historical first failures and evidence are preserved. No PR6509 modification/comment, merge, release, publishing or deployment.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:54:29Z

Original comment

Final refresh found canonical main advanced after the first retained reconciliation receipt. Integrated its agent-account fixes cleanly, fetched both actual heads again, and pushed normally.

Final pushed head: 8d711b9cabd84626dbe7965cb26a193c214afa90. Integrated canonical main: 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. The previous receipt's conflict decisions, migration213/burned207 handling, successful API generation, cleanup and validation scope still apply. Main's account-service implementation and regression tests were preserved. No ACP implementation, new evidence assets, routine local suites, production changes, or PR6509 writes.

Gate Status
Live PR and latest canonical main integration PASS
Merge conflicts / diff whitespace PASS — clean merge, git diff --check clean
Current-head CI PENDING
Native/ACP/UI qualification NOT_RUN — reconcile-only pass

Exact current-head CI: current-head checks: pending workflow discovery. Earlier-head checks are historical and do not qualify this new head. Reconciliation is complete; this is not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE for ACP. No owned runtime processes were launched; nothing further required cleanup. Parent cleanup remains exactly as recorded in the retained receipt; no additional data deleted.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:53:00Z

Original comment

ACP continuation on clean head 8d711b9cabd84626dbe7965cb26a193c214afa90, with live canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669 freshly fetched and already integrated.

Plan: first repair the three observed current-head CI regressions (install inventory count, documentation-only setup helper lint, and pre-Mastra Memcode repair fixture). Preserve production behavior and canonical migrations. Then inspect the current official SDK/ACP factory and native thread APIs for a supported additive-instruction/exact-load route; qualify only a genuine native route, keeping Chat unregistered until its gates pass. Regression execution stays exclusively in PR CI. No report/evidence files will be added. Existing failed restored-instruction evidence remains unchanged.

Resource check: about 1.1 GiB free; no further cleanup or dependency installation planned. Supplied isolated checkout is clean. No production processes/profiles touched.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:55:47Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — source fixes pushed; Mastra Chat remains unregistered and PR remains draft. Not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Head 755667202f24f3c45d1c5da921938dd7b36e9783, actual canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669. Both live refs were fetched/integrated at start, before normal push, and again before this status; final refresh found no advancement. Existing branch/user changes and history preserved. Plan.

Implemented and pushed three evidenced current-head CI repairs: documentation setup helper retains identical ActionSetup behavior without an unused argument; install inventory expects 38 plans and explicitly requires both Mastra/Memcode; the malformed Memcode repair fixture starts after Mastra migration213, removes only Memcode, and still asserts fail-closed rejection. No merged migrations/API artifacts changed. Independent read-only source review found no defect in these three files; it did not qualify Chat. gofmt and git diff --check completed; routine suites were NOT_RUN locally by human instruction.

Retained first CI failures: backend-core: 38 install plans versus stale expected37; sqlite: missing-Mastra assertion preempted missing-Memcode fixture; lint: documentationPlan action always ActionSetup. These earlier failures are not erased or claimed fixed by an uncompleted CI run.

New real stock-native protocol receipt (isolated VPS run): Node24.21.0; installed mastracode0.45.0, @mastra/code-sdk1.11.0. CLI /home/azureuser/.ao/audits/candidate-integrations-20261011/native/mastra/runtime/node_modules/mastracode/dist/cli.js, SHA256 e606fc8a07cc68ab456762c8ff17cc3d5558a4a3677f35487ddf773472ea994b. Actual initialize returned protocol1, agentInfo mastracode/1.11.0, loadSession:false, MCP http:true/sse:false and auth method IDs openai-codex/kimi-for-coding/xai. This advertises auth methods, not authorization. Real session/load for audit-only missing history returned -32601, Method not found: session/load. No new session, provider inference, login or visible task was sent. Owned native PID1330285, Linux start_ticks140979861; stdin close exited0 and /proc/1330285 was absent. No AO daemon/Electron/native descendants were created by session/new.

Supported SDK bridge investigation: current published SDK1.14.0, package tarball SHA256 73f56b7850c137da1f5771e105c62c3706bc4e18e2ecb81fb4b369f4d0098870, still exposes ACP factory (NewSessionRequest) => AcpSessionRuntime, no load handler; createAcpSession options only coAuthor. Current first-party agent source still advertises loadSession:false and unconditionally creates a fresh native thread. The server hardwires that agent; a custom runtime factory cannot supply a missing ACP method. Core SDK genuinely provides hostInstructions, thread.switch and thread.listMessages; these are promising primitives for a separately qualified provider-owned ACP extension, not evidence of native ACP replay. Its runtime factory does not forward hostInstructions. No private-internal monkeypatch, synthetic identity, hidden task concatenation, mandatory-processor replacement, vendor patch or unsupported Chat registration was introduced. An upstream ACP extension or independently qualified SDK bridge is still needed; this receipt does not claim such a bridge impossible.

Gate Status Scope / evidence
Live PR + canonical main integration PASS Exact refs above; normal push, final clean status
Protocol initialize PASS (limited) Real released executable receipt above; not full conformance
Exact ACP load / missing-history / workspace guard BLOCKED Missing native session/load; workspace rejection not run
Hidden additive instructions, fresh and NEW post-Kill restore BLOCKED Core API exists, ACP path absent; no consumption proof
Auth/new/stable identity/streaming/tools/reasoning/plans/model-options NOT_RUN No qualified restorable Chat route; configured auth is not authorization
Permission allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN No provider Chat session
Executing interrupt + separate AO Kill, PID/birth/no delayed effect, continuation NOT_RUN Short protocol process cleanup above is not this gate
Restart/detached reconnect/exact-once replay BLOCKED Native ACP exact load/replay absent
Actual AO Chat UI / direct attachment / build-model-session-generation provenance BLOCKED No qualified AO Chat session; screenshot unavailable; no screenshot/attachment fabricated
Independent source review of current fixes PASS (limited) Read-only review; no concrete defects; no runtime/tests run
Independent complete Chat review NOT_RUN Qualification absent
Current-head CI PENDING 23 checks inspected: {'QUEUED:pending': 21, 'IN_PROGRESS:pending': 2}; previous-head green is historical

Exact current-head workflow links:

Native model/conversation/generation and AO binary/UI fingerprints: NOT_RUN/unavailable in this attempt, since no inference or AO build/session was launched. Historical TUI screenshots do not satisfy Chat. The first restored ordinary-task private-instruction failure and all historical evidence remain untouched.

Cleanup/resources: parent cleanup remains exactly as supplied (unused ignored historical node_modules, disposable npm cache, two unused superseded Codex vendor versions; source statuses/lockfiles unchanged). This attempt deleted no further data, installed no dependencies, and started only the exact isolated protocol process already reaped above. Native scratch profile is under the assigned runtime root; no credentials/source profiles/production AO data were mutated. About1.1GiB free at start, above512MiB reserve. No new report/evidence files, evidence branches, repository screenshots, PR6509 writes/comments, merge/release/deployment or production restarts. Current-head CI remains pending independently of the genuine native protocol blocker.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:48:37Z

Original comment

Continuing source implementation on the authorized VPS, exclusively for this PR. Live head is 755667202f24f3c45d1c5da921938dd7b36e9783; canonical main refreshed to f86a8c56ebf370d72b0d70692363d76efb12e855.

Plan: preserve both sides of the pending main merge (native identity verification plus current main lifecycle/update semantics), reallocate the PR-only colliding migration while retaining the burned ledger, then inspect the current first-party Mastra ACP/SDK boundary for a defensible candidate driver. Add meaningful fail-closed protocol/driver coverage where implementable; keep Chat unregistered until native qualification. Submit source validation to CI only. No native/provider turns, builds, package installation, or production changes in this worker. Any required generated artifacts will be a precise resource-leased handoff, never hand-edited.

Parent cleanup removed only verified unused rebuildable dependencies/caches; source, Git metadata, native installations/profiles/history and historical evidence remain untouched. This worker will delete no additional data. New findings and receipts remain inline here; no report/evidence repository files.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:53:44Z

Original comment

Source progress pushed normally at c7402e08b3237e12601a55776333b811d661ab5e, integrating actual main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf. Current main advanced during the first push refresh; that first intermediate push did not include it, so it was immediately merged and included in this final source head. No force push or user changes discarded.

Concrete changes: resolved all three supplied conflicts while retaining Mastra identity verification plus main's resumed-child liveness/update semantics; moved the PR-only colliding migration to 20261019154911099_allow_mastra_code_harness.sql; retained burned207 and canonical213–215. Fixed session_manager/native_restore.go so a receipt and retained composer cannot publish native identity after the exact child exits or its liveness becomes unknown. Added live/dead/unknown controlled coverage. Added schema repair and regression for databases whose previous Mastra build recorded213 without canonical213's four stale-binary columns/CDC trigger.

Independent read-only review examined both-parent conflict decisions and the follow-up source fixes and reported no remaining actionable defect in those changes. It explicitly confirmed there is no actual Mastra Chat driver. This is source progress, not implementationComplete and not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Precise generated-artifact handoff to main worker under its resource lease: run npm run api in this checkout after synchronization, commit both generated OpenAPI and TypeScript outputs. The source install-target enum now correctly combines Mastra with main's waiting_for_idle status; Git auto-merging generated main artifacts alone cannot establish code-first drift parity. This source worker did not run generation/build/install or hand-edit generated files.

Supported route boundary: inspected the installed first-party SDK1.11.0's public AcpSessionFactory, createAcpSession, and MastraCodeAcpAgent. Factory receives only NewSessionRequest; createNewSession unconditionally calls native thread.create then switch; no load method exists. The public core SDK genuinely exposes additive hostInstructions and native thread operations, but its ACP factory forwards only coAuthor, and cannot supply the missing ACP load handler. A complete provider-owned SDK bridge or upstream load/hostInstructions support is still required. I did not add a constructor that merely fails every session and call that an integration, replace native mandatory processors, synthesize history/IDs, or enable Chat. Supported SDK bridge implementation remains work, not claimed impossible.

Gate Status
Fresh remote PR/main integration; source diff whitespace PASS
Independent review of above source changes PASS, limited scope
Actual ports-compatible Mastra Chat driver NOT_IMPLEMENTED
Current-head CI PENDING — exact head checks
API generation NOT_RUN — resource-leased main-worker task above
Routine local suites / native-provider / daemon-Electron / UI NOT_RUN — source-only worker constraints
Stock native exact load/replay and additive ACP hostInstructions BLOCKED — retained earlier native failure remains valid
Full lifecycle, permissions, executing interrupt/Kill, fresh+restored private instructions NOT_RUN
Actual AO Chat UI/direct attachments BLOCKED — no qualified Chat source/session; screenshot unavailable

Historical first failures/evidence remain untouched. No new source/native/AO binary/UI fingerprint is claimed: no build or native launch occurred. No new report/evidence files, packages, cache deletion, profiles, production changes or owned processes requiring cleanup. Parent cleanup remains exactly as documented in the initial comment. PR stays draft and Chat stays unregistered.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:08:07Z

Original comment

Actual SDK Chat candidate pushed: cf8e2c093581a61e4adcede702c1504171935653, with canonical main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf integrated. Both actual refs refreshed and reconciled immediately before the normal push. This supersedes the earlier “no driver exists” source state; it does not supersede historical failures or claim native/AO readiness.

backend/internal/adapters/chatdriver/mastrasdk/driver.go now provides NewCandidate(...) ports.ChatDriver, delegating Start/Resume/Reconnect and conversation Send/permission/Interrupt/Stop behavior to AO's existing ACP/persistent-host implementation. It discovers the existing Mastra plugin's native JavaScript entrypoint and resolves only its already-installed public SDK1.11.0; no package download, stock-ACP impersonation or vendor patch.

The provider-owned bridge.mjs/entry.mjs implement real SDK thread.create/getById/listMessages/switch, stable native thread IDs, native-owned AO owner/workspace metadata, complete-snapshot validation before any replay, and additive hostInstructions outside mutable thread state. Missing/foreign/malformed/unsettled/unsupported history fails closed; no latest selection or fresh fallback is exposed as restore. Local SDK boot may internally bind an owned existing thread, but exact lookup and ownership/history guards must pass before the requested thread can be used or returned. Text/reasoning/completed tools replay with native identities; live reasoning handles delta/full snapshots without duplicate prefixes. Native defaults and project/user rules remain loaded. Plans, structured input, attachments, extra roots, client MCP, effort, automatic approvals, sandbox and ephemeral settings are unsupported and rejected/unadvertised.

The first-party event mapper owns actual native approval decisions and tool events; source-preserving public plugin-manager override prevents background GitHub plugin updates. Explicit local storage/vector configuration overrides native remote/database settings. Profile, plan and observability paths stay beneath owned AO scratch data. Cancellation follows first-party suspension denial/abort/stream-detach semantics; disposal fences and waits for owned operations. Acknowledgement is not executing-child termination proof.

Meaningful Go regressions cover port-level unsupported Start/Resume/Reconnect/settings, owned private launch files, source-storage refusal, reviewed handshake and production registry exclusion. Node controlled contracts cover fresh/exact restore, stable replay, owner/workspace/resource/missing/corrupt history, terminal errors, cancellation/continuation and disposal races. A dedicated Node24 CI job runs them and is required by the backend aggregate. Routine suites remain CI-only; no local test/build/install/generation/native/provider/daemon/Electron run occurred.

Independent read-only agent review identified and led to fixes for import-only SDK resolution, explicit storage precedence, suspension-denial failures, disposal races, terminal error mapping, inherited native data paths and plugin auto-updates. Its final source review found no remaining actionable defect in the inspected candidate. This is independent source review, not GitHub required approval or runtime qualification.

Current-head CI is pending. Earlier head checks remain queued without assigned runners; no earlier green is reused. The outstanding main-worker resource-leased task remains npm run api plus commit both generated artifacts after sync; this worker is prohibited from running generation. No new contract shape was added by the SDK candidate.

Status: actual driver source is now reviewable; implementationComplete=false until current-head CI/generation are resolved. qualificationComplete=false; Chat stays unregistered and draft. Fresh and NEW post-Kill instructions, real auth/model/permission decisions, executing-child interrupt/Kill/control, exact restart/reconnect replay, actual AO Chat UI and direct attachments remain unproven. No runtime/native/UI fingerprint is fabricated. Cleanup: no owned processes launched, no additional deletion, no production or unrelated PR changes, no report/evidence assets committed.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:14:48Z

Original comment

Pushed 2c0d17f192f71188fe1513a7c407fb1be47cf3d1, including latest actual main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c. Main advanced at the final fetch; its browser-close diagnostics were merged unchanged before the normal push.

Added an actual-constructor controlled ACP regression through the detached persistent host: Start → Send → terminate → exact Resume/native-ID replay → detach/reconnect → terminate, plus missing-history rejection without fallback. This fixture is explicitly controlled protocol coverage, not native/provider/AO proof. Added immediate prompt/cancel reservation, strict protocol-version admission, and canonical native-state workspace checks. Source review's owned-host cleanup finding was fixed with bounded root shutdown and explicit controller cleanup.

Generated-artifact clarification: read-only inspection now confirms both committed OpenAPI and TypeScript already preserve the combined mastra-code install target and main's waiting_for_idle status. No SDK candidate API/SQL contract was added. Therefore the earlier blanket generation request is conditional on current-head drift CI; if drift is reported, the main worker must regenerate under its resource lease. This worker did not generate or hand-edit artifacts.

Current-head workflows: Go, Frontend, CLI E2E, gitleaks, release feeds are QUEUED/PENDING, not passed. No failing result/log exists yet; earlier-head results are not substituted.

Actual SDK candidate source is reviewable and unregistered. implementationComplete=false while current-head CI remains unverified; qualificationComplete=false. The preceding source progress and independent review summary describe the implementation and remaining real native/AO/UI gates. No local routine suites/builds/installation/native turns, additional cleanup, production changes or repository evidence files. Disk is about511MiB free; no proof allocation or deletion attempted.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 2/4

Historical material from original PR #6541, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:26:46Z

Original comment

Reviewable actual SDK Chat driver delivered; current-head CI and live qualification remain unproven. Not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Current head adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f; integrated actual canonical main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c. Both live refs were refreshed/reconciled at start, before every final normal push, and again before this snapshot. Existing user/main ancestry is preserved. Main's browser diagnostics and terminal changes were retained unchanged. No force push, published rebase, reset, cleanup deletion, merge/release/deployment or production restart.

Source delivered: mastrasdk/driver.go constructs an actual ports-compatible unregistered candidate and reuses shared ACP/persistenthost for Start/Resume/Reconnect, Send, approval responses, Interrupt and owned process termination. The provider bridge uses published SDK1.11 native thread APIs for exact identity/load/replay, native-owned AO owner/workspace metadata, complete replay validation, and additive hostInstructions outside saved thread state. It is a provider-owned SDK bridge, not stock mastracode ACP. No vendor patch, latest/fresh restore fallback, synthetic native conversation/history, hidden visible-task preamble, or mandatory processor replacement.

The real AO launch path is accounted for: stdio MCP is forwarded through the supported SDK API; canonical AO native auth/settings are copied minimally into the session-owned profile without overwriting refreshed owned files or touching source/history. Existing foreground-policy validation runs before SDK boot. Storage/vector/plans/observability are explicitly owned. A supported public plugin-manager subclass freezes source-plugin updates and excludes only AO's reserved, sentinel-verified TUI instruction contribution so hostInstructions is the single AO channel; user plugin instructions/tools/processors/signals and project rules remain. Saved legacy AO TUI context is refused. TUI behavior is unchanged apart from exporting its existing validator for reuse.

Supported candidate scope: text, native reasoning deltas/snapshots, completed tool replay, manual native permissions, exact native restore and advertised native models. Unsupported automatic permissions, effort, sandbox, ephemeral mode, extra roots, non-stdio client MCP, attachments, structured input, compaction, skills/handoff/reviewers and plans are refused or unadvertised. Native terminal prompt/model/user/project defaults are not replaced. Provider wire instruction role remains unknown/unobserved.

Meaningful regressions were submitted to CI: Go constructor/settings/private-profile/registry tests; real constructor plus detached-host controlled protocol lifecycle; Node bridge fresh/exact/missing/foreign/corrupt/unsettled history, replay identities, reasoning suffixes, cancellation/continuation, terminal errors, disposal races, import-only package loading and preservation of user plugin contributions. The new Node24 contract job is required by the backend aggregate. Controlled fixtures are not native or AO proof.

Independent read-only agent review examined the actual constructor and public SDK/AO boundaries. It found actionable defects in loader resolution, storage precedence, cancellation/disposal/terminal outcomes, profile/MCP plumbing, source-plugin updates and foreground settings; all were fixed with regressions. Final source review found no remaining actionable source defect. This is source review, not GitHub required approval or runtime acceptance.

Gate Status Current evidence / limit
Actual live PR + latest-main ancestry PASS Exact SHAs above; normal push; clean working tree
Actual ports-compatible SDK driver/source PASS, source only backend/internal/adapters/chatdriver/mastrasdk/
Formatting / diff whitespace PASS gofmt + git diff --check
Independent source review PASS Read-only agent review summarized above
Current-head complete CI PENDING 9 discovered checks: {'queued:None': 9}; no previous-head green reused
Stock native initialize/load failure Historical failure retained Stock ACP lacks session/load; SDK route does not erase that failure
New bridge initialize/auth/new/native identity NOT_RUN Source-only worker; configured auth is not authorization
Fresh + NEW post-Kill private instructions and independent project rules NOT_RUN Actual consumption remains required
Permission allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN Real provider gate remains
Executing child interrupt + separate Kill/control + PID/birth/no delayed effect NOT_RUN Native cancellation acknowledgement is insufficient
Live exact/missing/corrupt/workspace restore NOT_RUN Controlled source contracts await CI; no native claim
Native/daemon restart, detached reconnect, exact-once replay NOT_RUN Controlled source contracts are not live qualification
Actual AO Chat UI and direct attachments BLOCKED No qualified native/AO session in this source-only worker; screenshot unavailable
Local routine suites/build/generation/installs NOT_RUN Explicit human source-worker scope; routine suites are CI only

Inspected installation fingerprints (read-only, not a new execution): mastracode0.45.0, code-sdk1.11.0, ACP SDK0.21.1. Native CLI dist/cli.js SHA256 e606fc8a07cc68ab456762c8ff17cc3d5558a4a3677f35487ddf773472ea994b. SDK dist/index.js: 8ff03ec80711b90c9311687406d02b5b083069f956d3e8595cdfa87dabf7e798; first-party event mapper: b67bab7b8468af19a54ca5bada265055fb5ba983fcc0ba30b33d0356e13912f9. Current AO build/binary/model/session/generation/UI fingerprints: NOT_RUN/unavailable. No source-only result is promoted to E2E.

Current-head workflows:

Exact current-head checks. All inspected runs remain queued; no failing job log exists yet. Paired generated OpenAPI/TypeScript already retain Mastra plus main's new status enum; drift CI is authoritative. Any required regeneration remains a main-worker resource-leased task, never hand-edited here.

Historical first native failures and prior reports remain untouched: retained stock/native report, actual SDK source progress, ports regressions. No screenshots or attachments were fabricated, committed or hosted on an evidence branch.

Cleanup: parent cleanup remains exactly as previously recorded; this worker deleted no additional data, started no native/provider/AO/Electron processes, copied no real credentials at execution time, and changed no production profiles/services. Source implements private profile copying, but it was not executed on this VPS. No new report/evidence assets were added to Git. PR6509 and other workers' PRs/worktrees were untouched.

Operational verdict: working / waiting-ci. implementationComplete=false solely until current-head CI and any ensuing genuine source failures are resolved; qualificationComplete=false. The actual candidate is pushed and independently source-reviewed, but remains unregistered/draft. No irreducible native blocker is claimed: the supported SDK route is implemented and now needs real qualification by the execution owner.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:27:22Z

Original comment

The prior PR description is preserved verbatim below before making the body concise. Its historical tests/status belong to their stated older heads and are not current SDK/AO qualification claims. The current source/gates snapshot is here.

Retained previous description

Code changes: +1232 -17
Tests: +844 -28
Others: +245 -3

Adds the native Mastra Code TUI with additive AO instructions and exact local-history restore. Chat, reviewers, and interface handoff remain outside this integration.

Review fixes:

  • Fresh restart isolates native history while preserving earlier databases and exact restore after failed launches.
  • Restore retains the native model, checks locks across platforms, and refreshes private instructions after native metadata hydration.
  • Dialog checks ignore transcript markers; tracked configuration is refused before writes; unsupported task prefixes have actionable errors.
  • Native profile configuration determines auth status; canonical paths prevent duplicate instructions; terminated/deleted sessions release serialized-input state.

Removed the proof-build workflow, all 67 PR-only research/evidence files, and unrelated FX/OpenCode schema repairs. Main conflicts and all seven review threads are resolved.

Historical verification (prior head): all 24 CI checks pass at 1cb9705a990a3eb87eca2a8a20ed01241a2954b8, including full frontend tests/typechecks, Go race suites, lint, API/sqlc drift, Windows Mastra history/locks, renderer smoke, and CLI E2E across all three OSes plus Docker. Current checks. GitHub reports MERGEABLE.

Local adapter/lifecycle regressions, generated-plugin hydration, full session-manager suite, backend build/vet, macOS CLI E2E, affected storage/activity suites, product UI (160 tests), and Cloud client (29 tests) passed.

Local validation limits and retries

Full local race validation hit disk limits; pinned local lint timed out, and the long project typecheck was stopped. Those full jobs passed in CI. The initial session-manager deadline test failed under load; its full suite rerun passed.

The frontend suite passed 8,273 tests with three timing failures in unchanged tests: GlobalSettingsForm — “keeps the current language and reports a persistence failure”; board-empty-states — “respects a dismissed automatic login after the notice remounts”; IndependentSideChatDelivery — “retains the page boundary as new turns arrive (older history loaded: true)”. Rerunning all three files with one worker passed all 126 tests. An earlier native SQLite ABI mismatch was corrected by rebuilding for Node 24.

Draft: a successful current-head native lifecycle run, including the first restored continuation with changed private instructions, is still required. Historical failed native proof is not claimed as a pass.

Current ACP batch: BLOCKED, stock native ACP lacks exact load/replay and additive host-context forwarding. Chat remains unregistered. Current source fixes and CI status: latest qualification report.

Latest reconciliation: #6541 (comment) (ACP qualification remains gated).

Current source continuation (not complete ACP): #6541 (comment)


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:31:52Z

Original comment

Continuing the existing SDK candidate at adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f; both actual live PR branch and canonical main were freshly fetched, and main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c is already integrated. Working tree is clean.

Plan: inspect exact-head CI and repair genuine failures; review the actual constructor/bridge/history/settings boundaries with an independent read-only reviewer; preserve gated/unregistered status until real native/AO/UI qualification. No duplicate integration or helper-only implementation is being introduced. Go workflow remains queued with no jobs/logs yet. Routine suites remain CI-only.

Disk is about 490 MiB free; no builds, installs, generation, native/provider turns or additional deletions are authorized for this source worker. Existing code/history/evidence and production remain untouched.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:35:37Z

Original comment

Independent read-only source review of adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f: no actionable source defect identified.

The reviewer verified an actual NewCandidate(...) ports.ChatDriver with Start/Resume/Reconnect guards and inherited shared ACP/persistenthost conversation/permission/stop behavior, rather than helpers alone. Controlled lifecycle coverage exercises Start→Send→Terminate→Resume→Close→Reconnect plus missing-native-ID rejection; bridge regressions cover native owner/workspace/resource/history validation, no fresh fallback or partial replay, cancellation continuation, MCP, reasoning identity, settings rejection and disposal races. Production registry exclusion remains explicit.

A supplemental static comparison with preserved first-party @mastra/code-sdk1.11.0 and its installed core declarations found no concrete API mismatch: additive hostInstructions, storage/vector/MCP/plugin options, native thread create/get/list/switch/metadata, mapper state/allow_once/reject_once semantics and cleanup methods exist. Native thread.create() binds the new native identity; abort returns void as assumed.

This independent review made no edits and ran no imports, suites, builds, native/provider calls or UI. It is not current-head CI, runtime qualification or required GitHub approval. Actual new-driver auth, private-instruction consumption before/after Kill, executing-child interruption, real permission decisions, restore/replay and AO Chat UI still need separate proof. CI remains queued. No source changes were manufactured merely to trigger another run.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:36:42Z

Original comment

Mastra source continuation: working / waiting-ci; not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. Snapshot 2026-10-19 16:36:41 UTC.

Actual existing PR head: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f. Actual canonical main: d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c, verified ancestor after fetching both again immediately before this publication. No conflict, remote advance, dirty change or new commit was needed in this continuation. Existing user source and ancestry remain intact.

The actual SDK1.11 candidate remains in backend/internal/adapters/chatdriver/mastrasdk/{driver.go,bridge.mjs,entry.mjs,loader.mjs}, with constructor/ports lifecycle, shared ACP/persistenthost, guarded exact native history, additive private host context, native permission mapper, settings validation, isolated profile/storage and meaningful controlled regressions. Production Chat registration remains excluded and this PR remains draft. This is a first-party SDK embedding route, not stock mastracode ACP.

Current-head independent read-only source review found no actionable source defect, including a supplemental comparison against preserved SDK1.11/core source. No source edit was manufactured while CI is queued.

Gate Status Limit
Actual live PR + main sync, clean diff PASS Exact SHAs above; no force push/reset/discard
Actual driver and meaningful regression source PASS, source only Existing constructor, bridge and lifecycle tests preserved
Independent source review PASS Linked review; not GitHub required approval
Current-head full CI PENDING All five workflows queued; Go has no jobs/logs yet; no historical green reused
SDK/native auth, model and new native conversation NOT_RUN This attempt is source/CI-only; configured auth is not authorization
Fresh + NEW post-Kill private instructions/project rules NOT_RUN Real model consumption required
Native permissions allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN Static first-party mapping is not live proof
Executing child interrupt + separate Kill/control NOT_RUN PID/birth/no delayed effect still required
Native exact/missing/corrupt/workspace restore; restart/reconnect/replay NOT_RUN Controlled source coverage is not live qualification
Actual AO Chat UI/direct screenshot attachment BLOCKED No new AO/UI run in this source-worker scope; screenshot unavailable
Routine local suites, builds, generation and installs NOT_RUN Explicit human restriction; CI-only suites

Exact-head CI inspected now:

No failure log exists yet to diagnose. Specific source closure remaining: inspect those complete current-head results and fix any genuine failures; request the main worker's resource lease only if drift requires API/sqlc generation. implementationComplete=false until that CI gate is actually green; qualificationComplete=false. The queued CI gate does not establish an irreducible native blocker or authorize advancing unfinished code as complete.

Read-only fingerprints, not a fresh execution: preserved native mastracode0.45.0 dist/cli.js SHA256 e606fc8a07cc68ab456762c8ff17cc3d5558a4a3677f35487ddf773472ea994b; SDK1.11.0 dist/index.js 8ff03ec80711b90c9311687406d02b5b083069f956d3e8595cdfa87dabf7e798; first-party mapper b67bab7b8468af19a54ca5bada265055fb5ba983fcc0ba30b33d0356e13912f9. Candidate source is pinned by head above. Current AO binary/build/UI/model/session/generation fingerprints remain NOT_RUN/unavailable. Authenticated provider wire role remains unknown.

Historical first failures remain retained in the previous detailed snapshot and its linked native reports; nothing here upgrades them. No new report/evidence files or screenshots were committed or fabricated.

Cleanup: no native/provider/AO/Electron processes started, so no owned runtime processes need termination. Parent cleanup remains as recorded: only verified unused historical ignored node_modules, disposable npm cache and two superseded Codex vendor versions were removed, with code status/lockfile checks unchanged. This continuation deleted nothing, changed no credentials/profiles/history/production, and touched no other worker's PR or PR6509. About490 MiB free precludes builds under the512 MiB reserve. No new allocation was attempted.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:41:24Z

Original comment

Deadline snapshot — source candidate pushed; implementation closure waiting on CI; ACP qualification incomplete. 2026-10-19 16:41:23 UTC.

Freshly fetched actual PR head adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f and canonical main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c again immediately before this publication. Both are ancestors of the clean local head; no remote advance, conflict, additional commit or push was necessary. Existing source/user changes and ancestry are preserved.

Actual reviewable driver: backend/internal/adapters/chatdriver/mastrasdk/driver.go (NewCandidate, Start/Resume/Reconnect and launch/settings admission), bridge.mjs (native SDK lifecycle/history/model/permission mapping), entry.mjs (isolated first-party SDK runtime), loader.mjs (version-pinned public exports). Controlled ports/bridge/history/registry regressions are already committed. This is the SDK1.11 embedding candidate, not stock mastracode ACP; production Chat registration remains excluded and PR remains draft. Additional inspection found no concrete source defect to change; no speculative commit or CI bypass was introduced.

Gate Current result
Live branch + latest-main ancestry / clean diff PASS, exact SHAs above
Actual ports-compatible driver + meaningful regression source PASS, source only
Independent read-only source review PASS; no actionable source findings; not required GitHub approval
Complete current-head CI PENDING; workflows below; Go has zero jobs/logs so far
Real new-driver native/provider/AO lifecycle NOT_RUN in this source-only continuation
Fresh + NEW post-Kill hidden instructions; independent project rules NOT_RUN; model consumption required
Permissions allow/reject/cancel; executing-child interrupt and separate Kill/control NOT_RUN; native PID/birth/no-late-effect controls required
Exact/missing/corrupt/wrong-workspace history; restart/reconnect/exact-once replay NOT_RUN live; controlled coverage is not runtime proof
Actual current-source AO Chat UI/direct attachment BLOCKED; no new UI capture/attachment

implementationComplete=false until complete current-head CI is green; qualificationComplete=false; not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. Specific remaining source task: inspect these complete CI results, retrieve any failing logs and fix genuine defects; generation only under the main worker's resource lease if required. GitHub queueing is an external verification wait, not an evidenced irreducible native implementation blocker. No further safe implementation change has been identified while waiting.

Native/source/binary fingerprints, historical first failures and complete qualification limits remain retained in the previous detailed source snapshot. No new native/model/session/generation/AO executable/UI fingerprint exists for this continuation; provider wire role remains unknown. Historical TUI/native proof does not qualify this new Chat driver.

Cleanup/resource delta: nothing deleted, no builds/installs/generation/local suites/native/provider/daemon/Electron processes launched, no production/profile/history mutations, no report/evidence files or assets created in Git. About482 MiB disk free is below the512 MiB build reserve; no allocation attempted. Parent's earlier narrowly verified cache cleanup remains as recorded. No other worker's PR or PR6509 was modified/commented. Work remains working / waiting-ci, rather than advancing this incomplete gate as complete.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:47:07Z

Original comment

Independent read-only review of adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f: no actionable source defects found in mastrasdk/{driver.go,bridge.mjs,entry.mjs,loader.mjs} and controlled driver/bridge regressions.

Reviewer confirmed an actual ports.ChatDriver and ChatDriverReconnector, unsupported lifecycle/policy/effort rejection, native thread owner/workspace/resource/history admission before replay, immediate cancellation turn reservation, abort despite suspension-denial failure, disposal fences, private additive launch instructions, and explicit production registry exclusion. No edits or tests/builds/native/provider/UI execution were performed by the reviewer. Native SDK external semantics, real permission decisions, executing-child termination and exact-once AO replay remain separate qualification requirements.

Continuation after the fixed delivery deadline: the live head and canonical main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c were fetched again and already integrated; clean source required no new commit. Actual source candidate exists, but implementationComplete=false while full current-head CI is unfinished; qualificationComplete=false and not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Current-head progress: macOS CLI E2E, macOS update helper, and gitleaks now PASS. Windows CLI and frontend tests are running. Go, including the Mastra SDK contract job, now has queued jobs. Remaining checks are queued; no failing result/log has been observed. Continuing to inspect results and repair genuine failures without manufacturing a commit or weakening gates.

Retained deadline snapshot, fingerprints, first failures, live qualification and UI gaps remain applicable. No new native/AO/UI proof or screenshot attachment exists. No deletion, runtime process, local suite/build/generation/install, profile/history/production mutation, or Git evidence asset was introduced in this continuation. No other worker's PR or PR6509 was touched.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:50:07Z

Original comment

Mastra remains working / waiting-ci, not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. 2026-10-19 16:50:06 UTC. The fixed delivery deadline has passed; this is the truthful continuing-work snapshot.

Refreshed actual PR branch and actual canonical main again immediately before publication. Current head: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f. Integrated latest main: d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c, verified ancestor. Clean worktree and git diff --check; no concurrent advance/conflict, additional source commit or push was necessary. Existing user source/ancestry remain intact.

Actual implementation remains reviewable in backend/internal/adapters/chatdriver/mastrasdk/{driver.go,bridge.mjs,entry.mjs,loader.mjs}: NewCandidate is a real ports-compatible driver using shared ACP/persistenthost, with Start/Resume/Reconnect admission and inherited Send/permissions/Stop behavior. SDK bridge owns native thread creation/exact history admission/replay, additive private host context, native manual approvals and supported model selection. Controlled ports lifecycle, history, cancellation, configuration, loader and registry tests are committed and wired into CI. This is the first-party SDK1.11 embedding candidate, not stock mastracode ACP. Production Chat registration remains excluded; draft status remains.

Fresh independent read-only review found no actionable source defects, after explicitly checking actual driver rather than helpers alone. No speculative code/CI-bypass commit was introduced while results are pending.

Gate Result
Actual live-head/latest-main sync and source diff PASS
Actual driver + meaningful regression source PASS, source only
Independent read-only source review PASS, linked above; not required GitHub approval
Complete current-head CI PENDING: 5 PASS, 1 running, 18 queued; no failure observed
Real SDK initialize/auth/model/new native ID NOT_RUN by this source-only worker
Fresh + NEW post-Kill private instructions/project rules NOT_RUN live
Native permission allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN live
Executing child interrupt + separate Kill/control NOT_RUN live; PID/birth/no-delayed-effect proof required
Exact/missing/corrupt/wrong-workspace restore, restart/reconnect/replay NOT_RUN live; controlled coverage does not prove it
Actual AO Chat UI and durable direct screenshot attachment BLOCKED; no fresh UI capture/attachment

Current-head checks, inspected now (historical green is not substituted):

Workflow / check Status Exact result
CLI E2E / native (ubuntu-latest) QUEUED job
Go / mastra-sdk-contract QUEUED job
Harness release feeds / live-feeds QUEUED job
Frontend / mac-update-helper SUCCESS job
gitleaks / scan SUCCESS job
CLI E2E / native (macos-latest) SUCCESS job
CLI E2E / native (windows-latest) SUCCESS job
Go / backend-core (0) QUEUED job
Frontend / test IN_PROGRESS job
CLI E2E / container SUCCESS job
Go / backend-core (1) QUEUED job
Frontend / renderer-smoke QUEUED job
Go / chat-race (0) QUEUED job
Go / chat-race (1) QUEUED job
Go / session-store-race QUEUED job
Go / sqlite-race (0) QUEUED job
Go / sqlite-race (1) QUEUED job
Go / sqlite-race (2) QUEUED job
Go / sqlite-race (3) QUEUED job
Go / windows-workspace QUEUED job
Go / cloud-build-test QUEUED job
Go / lint QUEUED job
Go / sqlc-drift QUEUED job
Go / api-drift QUEUED job

implementationComplete=false until complete current-head CI passes. qualificationComplete=false. Specific implementation closure remaining: inspect the above unfinished results; retrieve failing logs and fix actual defects if any arise. API/sqlc generation, if required by a real drift failure, needs the main worker's resource lease. No evidenced irreducible native implementation blocker was found; the checkpoint stays working, so CI queueing cannot silently advance unfinished Mastra work.

Retained full native fingerprints, first failures and qualification limits remain unchanged. Native0.45.0/SDK1.11 static source fingerprints are historical; no new native execution, AO executable/build/model/session/generation/UI fingerprint or screenshot exists in this continuation. Provider wire role remains unknown.

Cleanup: no local routine suite, build, package/toolchain allocation, generation, provider/native/daemon/Electron process, extra deletion or production/profile/history mutation. No runtime process was launched to clean. Parent's earlier verified ignored-cache cleanup remains the only cleanup. About481 MiB free at start was below the512 MiB build reserve. Existing evidence and first failures remain untouched; no new report/evidence assets were written to Git. No other worker's PR or PR6509 was modified/commented.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:50:23Z

Original comment

ACP implementation remains incomplete after bounded continuation attempts. Partial source is preserved; no full-ready or implementation-complete claim. Remaining: ['Inspect complete exact-head CI run 39285287680 and other pending checks; retrieve any failing logs and fix genuine source defects. API/sqlc generation only by main-worker resource lease if required.']. Reports remain inline; no source/evidence deletion or production change.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:51:55Z

Original comment

ACP implementation remains incomplete after bounded continuation attempts. Partial source is preserved; no full-ready or implementation-complete claim. Remaining: ['Inspect complete exact-head CI run 39285287680 and other pending checks; retrieve any failing logs and fix genuine source defects. API/sqlc generation only by main-worker resource lease if required.']. Reports remain inline; no source/evidence deletion or production change.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:53:28Z

Original comment

ACP implementation remains incomplete after bounded continuation attempts. Partial source is preserved; no full-ready or implementation-complete claim. Remaining: ['Inspect complete exact-head CI run 39285287680 and other pending checks; retrieve any failing logs and fix genuine source defects. API/sqlc generation only by main-worker resource lease if required.']. Reports remain inline; no source/evidence deletion or production change.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:55:00Z

Original comment

ACP implementation remains incomplete after bounded continuation attempts. Partial source is preserved; no full-ready or implementation-complete claim. Remaining: ['Inspect complete exact-head CI run 39285287680 and other pending checks; retrieve any failing logs and fix genuine source defects. API/sqlc generation only by main-worker resource lease if required.']. Reports remain inline; no source/evidence deletion or production change.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:37:16Z

Original comment

Fresh testing-only retest starting for mastra-code at current PR head adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f using harness skill bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db. One bounded serial attempt (25-minute maximum; eight-minute output-stall watchdog); isolated source/runtime. Previous evidence is historical and will not count as fresh proof. Full 12-area matrix and screenshot checkpoints will follow in a new comment. No implementation, pushes, production restart, or excluded PR changes.

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 3/4

Historical material from original PR #6541, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:47:41Z

Original comment

Testing-only current-status evidence for PR #6541 — BLOCKED / incomplete. Strict audit: BLOCKED, exit 1. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. No implementation/source/branch changes, pushes, merges, reviewer publication or routine local validation suites.

Tested source/current-head recheck: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f; skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db (all 15 staged files byte-match pinned Git objects). Final readback at 2026-10-21T05:47:23.541288+00:00: head adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f, base d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c, mergeable False, mergeable_state dirty. Recorded comparison main 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd was not merged. Linux amd64, Node v24.21.0, Go 1.27.1. UI source is the same tested head; UI did not launch.

Actual AO executable basename ao, version dev, SHA256 917287de2a6e7a9f4fba8661a6f0a951a9bfb60bf7255d5a3ecd68481d935706. Embedded VCS revision equals tested source and vcs.modified=false; serial go build -o runtime/bin/ao ./cmd/ao exit 0, 2026-10-21T05:39:49.993020+00:00–2026-10-21T05:40:34.233258+00:00, with GOMAXPROCS=1, GOFLAGS=-p=1, GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB. This was a live-proof binary build, not a validation suite.

Actual native CLI SHA256 e606fc8a07cc68ab456762c8ff17cc3d5558a4a3677f35487ddf773472ea994b, installed mastracode@0.45.0, SDK @mastra/code-sdk@1.11.0. Fresh package-version read exit 0; actual native mastracode --acp + ACP initialize exit 0 (2026-10-21T05:45:06.084810+00:00–2026-10-21T05:45:08.397295+00:00) returned agent mastracode, wire version 1.11.0, protocol 1, loadSession=false; output SHA256 cc335eda236b6ac1e7acb4abe9dee766a5d848ec63b283aa190ce94cf3670be7. This supported capability/version probe made no authenticate/session/new/prompt call. It is separate from the parent's 2026-10-21T05:37:21.079902+00:00 --version heuristic (exit 1, required prompt; output SHA256 204f9fe6dd526742985f7899e100c61abd9af6eae1135587c1bbf1dbdf3214e3), preserved as OPERATOR/PROBE failure, not provider/auth failure. No CLI version flag or model-list command was invented.

Fresh native --help exit 0, 2026-10-21T05:41:04.983114+00:00–2026-10-21T05:41:07.897376+00:00, stdout SHA256 58fbce6d5d79062b2e2f26b29d7263944ab78a05caa66919c616415e2c5b69d5. Existing native custom-provider settings were copied minimally with mode 0700/0600; original bytes unchanged. Selected provider Zai, requested model zai/glm-5.3-flash. No inherited key was assumed missing: the known authorized native profile contained the matching stored key; no credential environment reference was required. No key/account identifier/private profile path is published.

Fresh bounded native workspace command:

MASTRA_APP_DATA_DIR=<isolated-profile> mastracode --prompt '<create unique JSON token/cwd witness>' --model zai/glm-5.3-flash --permission-mode auto --max-turns 6 --timeout 60 --output json

2026-10-21T05:41:07.929650+00:00–2026-10-21T05:41:14.349564+00:00, exit 1, output bytes 1286, stdout SHA256 73537f2dc4aa636a13fe91df73a96fbaeb14fe6418c7327053c12f703f7f3d13. Provider error: Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted. Your limit will reset at 2026-10-21 18:43:31. NATIVE_WITNESS.json absent. No successful provider/auth/file witness; configured authorization remains BLOCKED. This native headless permission scope does not qualify AO permissions. No provider retries or account changes.

Strict attempt strict-001: runner 2026-10-21T05:42:51.259Z–2026-10-21T05:43:08.759Z, classification strict, summary BLOCKED. Invocation:

node <pinned-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent mastra-code --repo <tested-source> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao --local-contract <runtime>/local-contract.json --report <runtime>/strict-001/report --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 45 --keep-daemon

Exact saved contract SHA256 6525e27f446892004c21192e0cce23cd8424c37e1e73a9111731771ecd2aa891; sanitized equivalent bytes:

{"schemaVersion":1,"agents":{"mastra-code":{"binary":"<installed-native>/mastracode","integration":{"args":["--help"],"expect":"Usage: mastracode --prompt"},"aoModelsPath":"agents/{agent}/models","interrupt":{"input":"\^[","settleTimeoutMs":5000}}}}

The published binary path is redacted, so equivalent bytes have a different hash. --help proves only the parser. Version/session/model commands omitted with derivation receipts; separately tested native workspace failed quota, so it was not retried. Escape derived from native implementation; restoredReady omitted because fresh startup/settled/draft/restored samples were unavailable. Strict gates: local_binary/local_integration/registered/installed/fresh_probe PASS; authentication BLOCKED (configured, unverified); local_version/local_session_spawn/local_models_list and every dependent AO lifecycle/catalog gate NOT_RUN. No diagnostic attempt: its successful-native-proof prerequisites were not met. No synthetic readiness, fabricated catalog, HTTP restore shortcut or turn through blocked readiness.

Independent actual-daemon API proof (after strict finalization, before owned shutdown): /readyz 200 matched PID 1460427, kernel-start 160712408, selected executable/hash. Settings omitted Mastra from Chat. Model GET and refresh POST both 200: selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, allowCustom=true, models=[], source manual. This qualifies model-mode API observations only; empty catalogs do not qualify strict catalog conformance. Chat creation returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED (requestId vps-linux/88QiQrZ2Re-000011); reviewer selection returned 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS (requestId vps-linux/88QiQrZ2Re-000012). Session list remained empty. No review trigger/external publication was performed. Stock ACP lacks exact load; the candidate SDK driver is unregistered, not qualified Chat.

Actual Electron preparation: a real pinned npm ci --no-audit --no-fund ran in this new checkout 2026-10-21T05:41:40.625272+00:00–2026-10-21T05:42:10.698174+00:00, exit -9. Capacity started 1533 MiB free; 800 MiB stop trigger sampled 782 MiB, but in-flight writes overshot to 676 MiB at shutdown, briefly below the required floor. Only this run's new incomplete node_modules/npm/Electron caches were removed; capacity restored to 1533 MiB. No old dependencies were symlinked/reused, no launcher with old paths ran, no global/native installs. Electron never launched; zero actual AO PNG captures. No approved attachment uploader; private attachment-queue.json is empty. Every required action/result remains explicit below; no image URLs or substitute images.

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI TUI registered through adapter/domain/API/generated client/product identity; actual desktop required BLOCKED Live inventory/probe registration PASS; /readyz matched selected executable/PID. Electron dependencies could not be provisioned within disk floor; UI never launched.
Models Native provider/model text mode; Agent Harness and New Task surfaces independently required BLOCKED GET and POST refresh returned 200, selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, allowCustom=true, models=[]. No CLI catalog/version command defined. Requested zai/glm-5.3-flash reached provider quota failure; effective successful selection, picker effects, persistence and bulk controls unverified. No fabricated catalog/toggles.
Providers Existing native custom-provider configuration; explicit provider metadata and effective routing BLOCKED Existing Zai custom provider/key copied minimally into isolated profile. No environment credential reference was required by that profile. Fresh provider command returned Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted; configured does not establish verified authorization. AO add/change/remove/account controls not exercised.
Setup AO installer/auth plans are manual/documentation only NOT_RUN Installer API: available=false, automatic=false, method=manual; auth plan: action=setup, launchMode=documentation. No installer/login/account switch/logout/reset initiated; provider installation/upgrades/login were outside authorization. Native login exists, but AO documentation plan is not an in-app login implementation.
Readiness Linux native binary, fresh installation/configuration observations and usable provider BLOCKED Binary and safe --help/ACP initialize PASS; strict registered/installed/fresh_probe PASS; AO authentication configured/unverified BLOCKED. Provider quota blocks a usable turn; no readiness override or diagnostic continuation.
Identity and logo Mastra Code label and licensed upstream SVG BLOCKED Product identity/avatar mapping and Apache-2.0 logo attribution exist in current source. Actual avatar/UI rendering unverified because Electron setup was capacity-blocked.
TUI and Chat TUI supported; stock ACP and unregistered SDK candidate assessed independently BLOCKED TUI lifecycle NOT_RUN behind strict auth prerequisite. Stock ACP initialize: loadSession=false. Mastra absent from settings.chatHarnesses; explicit Chat spawn returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED with no fallback/session. SDK candidate remains unregistered; no Chat conformance claimed.
Reviewer Excluded by current integration docs; native prompt review is distinct from AO reviewer support NOT_RUN No Mastra reviewer registry/vocabulary entry. Safe reviewer selection returned 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS before session lookup. No reviewer run/result/cancel/rerun; no GitHub reviewer execution/publication authorized. This is not a reviewer PASS.
Permissions and instructions Native default and explicit bypass TUI policies; additive managed plugin instructions NOT_RUN Source maps default/bypass and rejects auto/accept-edits, but no registered AO provider turn passed readiness. Approval/rejection, argv edge cases, independent standing instructions and refreshed instruction consumption remain unverified.
Lifecycle Executing cancellation, Kill/archive, exact restore, reconnect and continuation NOT_RUN Strict dependent gates all NOT_RUN. No AO worker/session or executing-command witness existed; no PID/kernel-start cancellation or delayed-side-effect claim. Native probe/daemon teardown PASS is separate from task lifecycle.
Evidence Current source/native/AO/skill fingerprints, distinct attempts, full index and durable images BLOCKED Fresh receipts retained outside Git, strict BLOCKED preserved, no diagnostic attempt. Zero actual UI PNGs; attachment queue empty. No approved uploader; AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. All 24 mandatory checkpoints plus Chat/reviewer subjourneys retained.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub checks and mergeability; routine suites CI only FAIL 25 current-head checks: 21 success, 4 failure (backend-core (0), session-store-race, lint, build-test); no pending. PR mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. No local unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/build-fixture/runner-fixture suites run. Description link to this new comment pending parent.

All screenshot checkpoints and supported/excluded subjourneys (no session/generation exists; no action/result capture was produced):

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed state Functional status Screenshot/attachment status Proof or reason
harness-listed Open Agent Harness → not opened BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Registration API passed; actual Electron unavailable
install-offer Inspect installation offer → API manual-only observed BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Manual installer metadata observed; no real AO page capture
install-run Start AO installation → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED MANUAL_ONLY; provider installation/upgrades not authorized
auth-before Inspect existing-account state → API configured/unverified BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Fresh strict auth observation; no AO UI
auth-action Start Login/Setup/Configure → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Documentation-only AO plan; no login/reset authorization
auth-ready Verify connected state and first successful turn → quota error BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Configured-only and exhausted provider quota; no successful witness
auth-maintenance Account/provider change/logout/retry → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Account changes/resets prohibited; no safe fresh maintenance branch
harness-models List/refresh Harness models → API text mode/empty list BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Refresh API 200; actual Agent Harness surface not opened
model-visibility Off/on/bulk and reload/picker effects → not exercised NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Text-mode provider exposes no discovered catalog; no fake switches; UI unavailable
provider-management Provider list/configuration actions → isolated stored configuration only BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Existing Zai metadata/key presence only; no account-management UI/routing success
task-agent Open New Task/select harness → not opened BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED UI unavailable; API registration is separate
task-model Select task model → no UI selection BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Free-text mode API observed; successful effective native selection unverified
task-running Create task/card and completed initial output → not created NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Strict auth prerequisite blocked; native standalone witness failed quota
task-followup Composer follow-up/response → not sent NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No initialized AO task
task-cancel Stop executing command/settle → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No live executing PID/kernel-start witness
kill-action Archive control/confirmation/terminated → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No worker session
archived Find exact archived card → unavailable NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No worker session
restore-action Restore exact native history/ready → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No killed task/history or fresh restored-ready samples
kanban-return Same restored card/continuation → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Restore prerequisites unrun
chat New Task Chat/shared composer journeys → rejected by API NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; stock ACP loadSession=false; candidate unregistered
reviewer-select Select Mastra reviewer/target → rejected by API NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS; no registered reviewer
reviewer-running Reviewer run/cancel/retry → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No registered reviewer; external publication not authorized
reviewer-result Review result/rerun on target head → not produced NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No run/result; review publication prohibited
reconnect-cleanup UI reload/reconnect/recovery → unrun; owned shutdown → clean NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No UI/controller identity to reconnect; exact daemon/native cleanup receipts PASS
chat/new-task Registered Chat task creation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/followup-stream Shared composer, partial stream, tool/text output and file witness → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/load-history Native load/history/pagination/no duplicates → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/approve Offered approval and protected effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/reject Separate offered rejection/no effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/cancel-active-tool Stop with command PID/kernel-start and absent delayed effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/ui-reconnect Event/UI reconnect plus continuation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned daemon/host recovery and continuation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/kill-restore-instructions Kill/exact load/new ordinary instruction control → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/negative-restore-capabilities Native missing-history/workspace/capability validation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
reviewer/target-head Reviewer picker/PR6541 head identification → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized
reviewer/cancel Actual run cancellation and worker isolation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized
reviewer/rerun Actual result and rerun/new-head result → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized

Current-head CI (read via authorized GitHub helper; no routine suites executed on VPS):

Failing CI detail: backend-core (0) failed TestEveryRefreshHarnessResumesExactConversation/mastra-code: version_refresh_test.go:27: missing explicit refresh capability; session-store-race failed TestTerminalRefreshSupportMatrix: mastra-code refresh capability = false, want true; lint reports 1 gocritic stringXbytes and 7 staticcheck ST1005 issues in candidate mastrasdk/driver.go; build-test is the failed aggregate. Build/vet/format steps inside backend-core CI passed; this does not clear the failed test job. Windows/macOS native CI success is not Mastra provider lifecycle/OS qualification. No pending checks in the current-head readback.

Cleanup: PASS. Native help/package/workspace/ACP PIDs were individually reaped. Exact owned daemon PID 1460427 / kernel-start 160712408 received SIGTERM at 2026-10-21T05:45:33.783843+00:00, stopped by 2026-10-21T05:45:34.021325+00:00, no SIGKILL, listener closed. The keep-daemon capture window ended then; strict runner subsequently exited 1. Final exact PID and process-group scan found 0 surviving owned PIDs and 0 group members. Source including untracked files remains clean, original native profile unchanged, reports survive. Temporary profiles/databases/receipts/logs remain private under this PR's sibling runtime outside Git; no production daemon touched. Failed UI setup dependencies/caches alone were reclaimed. Parent must perform its independent ownership check and remove only its new clean detached worktree.

Unresolved/next action: retain the first quota failure; rerun native proof after authorized provider capacity is available, then a fresh strict attempt with independently proven contracts. Product owners must resolve CI failures/conflicts outside this testing-only worker. Provide enough UI setup capacity to preserve the 700 MiB floor; qualify every remaining UI/lifecycle/model/provider/instruction journey and publish safe actual screenshots via an approved uploader. Chat/reviewer production qualification remains separate and unrun. PR-description link to this new evidence comment is pending parent (description was not edited). No integration completion or merge-readiness claim.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:48:23Z

Original comment

Current-status evidence readback correction: the first new comment is preserved. The publication path normalized the escaped Escape notation in its JSON excerpt. This new comment uses an unambiguous generator; runtime results, matrices and failures are unchanged.

Testing-only current-status evidence for PR #6541 — BLOCKED / incomplete. Strict audit: BLOCKED, exit 1. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. No implementation/source/branch changes, pushes, merges, reviewer publication or routine local validation suites.

Tested source/current-head recheck: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f; skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db (all 15 staged files byte-match pinned Git objects). Final readback at 2026-10-21T05:47:23.541288+00:00: head adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f, base d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c, mergeable False, mergeable_state dirty. Recorded comparison main 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd was not merged. Linux amd64, Node v24.21.0, Go 1.27.1. UI source is the same tested head; UI did not launch.

Actual AO executable basename ao, version dev, SHA256 917287de2a6e7a9f4fba8661a6f0a951a9bfb60bf7255d5a3ecd68481d935706. Embedded VCS revision equals tested source and vcs.modified=false; serial go build -o runtime/bin/ao ./cmd/ao exit 0, 2026-10-21T05:39:49.993020+00:00–2026-10-21T05:40:34.233258+00:00, with GOMAXPROCS=1, GOFLAGS=-p=1, GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB. This was a live-proof binary build, not a validation suite.

Actual native CLI SHA256 e606fc8a07cc68ab456762c8ff17cc3d5558a4a3677f35487ddf773472ea994b, installed mastracode@0.45.0, SDK @mastra/code-sdk@1.11.0. Fresh package-version read exit 0; actual native mastracode --acp + ACP initialize exit 0 (2026-10-21T05:45:06.084810+00:00–2026-10-21T05:45:08.397295+00:00) returned agent mastracode, wire version 1.11.0, protocol 1, loadSession=false; output SHA256 cc335eda236b6ac1e7acb4abe9dee766a5d848ec63b283aa190ce94cf3670be7. This supported capability/version probe made no authenticate/session/new/prompt call. It is separate from the parent's 2026-10-21T05:37:21.079902+00:00 --version heuristic (exit 1, required prompt; output SHA256 204f9fe6dd526742985f7899e100c61abd9af6eae1135587c1bbf1dbdf3214e3), preserved as OPERATOR/PROBE failure, not provider/auth failure. No CLI version flag or model-list command was invented.

Fresh native --help exit 0, 2026-10-21T05:41:04.983114+00:00–2026-10-21T05:41:07.897376+00:00, stdout SHA256 58fbce6d5d79062b2e2f26b29d7263944ab78a05caa66919c616415e2c5b69d5. Existing native custom-provider settings were copied minimally with mode 0700/0600; original bytes unchanged. Selected provider Zai, requested model zai/glm-5.3-flash. No inherited key was assumed missing: the known authorized native profile contained the matching stored key; no credential environment reference was required. No key/account identifier/private profile path is published.

Fresh bounded native workspace command:

MASTRA_APP_DATA_DIR=<isolated-profile> mastracode --prompt '<create unique JSON token/cwd witness>' --model zai/glm-5.3-flash --permission-mode auto --max-turns 6 --timeout 60 --output json

2026-10-21T05:41:07.929650+00:00–2026-10-21T05:41:14.349564+00:00, exit 1, output bytes 1286, stdout SHA256 73537f2dc4aa636a13fe91df73a96fbaeb14fe6418c7327053c12f703f7f3d13. Provider error: Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted. Your limit will reset at 2026-10-21 18:43:31. NATIVE_WITNESS.json absent. No successful provider/auth/file witness; configured authorization remains BLOCKED. This native headless permission scope does not qualify AO permissions. No provider retries or account changes.

Strict attempt strict-001: runner 2026-10-21T05:42:51.259Z–2026-10-21T05:43:08.759Z, classification strict, summary BLOCKED. Invocation:

node <pinned-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent mastra-code --repo <tested-source> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao --local-contract <runtime>/local-contract.json --report <runtime>/strict-001/report --timeout-seconds 35 --startup-timeout-seconds 45 --keep-daemon

Exact saved contract SHA256 6525e27f446892004c21192e0cce23cd8424c37e1e73a9111731771ecd2aa891; sanitized reproduction generator (substitute only the installed binary path):

const contract = {schemaVersion:1,agents:{"mastra-code":{
  binary:"<installed-native>/mastracode",
  integration:{args:["--help"],expect:"Usage: mastracode --prompt"},
  aoModelsPath:"agents/{agent}/models",
  interrupt:{input:String.fromCharCode(27),settleTimeoutMs:5000}
}}};
process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify(contract,null,2)+String.fromCharCode(10));

The published binary path is redacted and generator formatting differs, so reproduced bytes have a different hash. Escape is exactly codepoint U+001B, not the text ESC. No restored-ready expression is supplied. --help proves only the parser. Version/session/model commands omitted with derivation receipts; separately tested native workspace failed quota, so it was not retried. Escape derived from native implementation; restoredReady omitted because fresh startup/settled/draft/restored samples were unavailable. Strict gates: local_binary/local_integration/registered/installed/fresh_probe PASS; authentication BLOCKED (configured, unverified); local_version/local_session_spawn/local_models_list and every dependent AO lifecycle/catalog gate NOT_RUN. No diagnostic attempt: its successful-native-proof prerequisites were not met. No synthetic readiness, fabricated catalog, HTTP restore shortcut or turn through blocked readiness.

Independent actual-daemon API proof (after strict finalization, before owned shutdown): /readyz 200 matched PID 1460427, kernel-start 160712408, selected executable/hash. Settings omitted Mastra from Chat. Model GET and refresh POST both 200: selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, allowCustom=true, models=[], source manual. This qualifies model-mode API observations only; empty catalogs do not qualify strict catalog conformance. Chat creation returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED (requestId vps-linux/88QiQrZ2Re-000011); reviewer selection returned 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS (requestId vps-linux/88QiQrZ2Re-000012). Session list remained empty. No review trigger/external publication was performed. Stock ACP lacks exact load; the candidate SDK driver is unregistered, not qualified Chat.

Actual Electron preparation: a real pinned npm ci --no-audit --no-fund ran in this new checkout 2026-10-21T05:41:40.625272+00:00–2026-10-21T05:42:10.698174+00:00, exit -9. Capacity started 1533 MiB free; 800 MiB stop trigger sampled 782 MiB, but in-flight writes overshot to 676 MiB at shutdown, briefly below the required floor. Only this run's new incomplete node_modules/npm/Electron caches were removed; capacity restored to 1533 MiB. No old dependencies were symlinked/reused, no launcher with old paths ran, no global/native installs. Electron never launched; zero actual AO PNG captures. No approved attachment uploader; private attachment-queue.json is empty. Every required action/result remains explicit below; no image URLs or substitute images.

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI TUI registered through adapter/domain/API/generated client/product identity; actual desktop required BLOCKED Live inventory/probe registration PASS; /readyz matched selected executable/PID. Electron dependencies could not be provisioned within disk floor; UI never launched.
Models Native provider/model text mode; Agent Harness and New Task surfaces independently required BLOCKED GET and POST refresh returned 200, selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, allowCustom=true, models=[]. No CLI catalog/version command defined. Requested zai/glm-5.3-flash reached provider quota failure; effective successful selection, picker effects, persistence and bulk controls unverified. No fabricated catalog/toggles.
Providers Existing native custom-provider configuration; explicit provider metadata and effective routing BLOCKED Existing Zai custom provider/key copied minimally into isolated profile. No environment credential reference was required by that profile. Fresh provider command returned Weekly/Monthly Limit Exhausted; configured does not establish verified authorization. AO add/change/remove/account controls not exercised.
Setup AO installer/auth plans are manual/documentation only NOT_RUN Installer API: available=false, automatic=false, method=manual; auth plan: action=setup, launchMode=documentation. No installer/login/account switch/logout/reset initiated; provider installation/upgrades/login were outside authorization. Native login exists, but AO documentation plan is not an in-app login implementation.
Readiness Linux native binary, fresh installation/configuration observations and usable provider BLOCKED Binary and safe --help/ACP initialize PASS; strict registered/installed/fresh_probe PASS; AO authentication configured/unverified BLOCKED. Provider quota blocks a usable turn; no readiness override or diagnostic continuation.
Identity and logo Mastra Code label and licensed upstream SVG BLOCKED Product identity/avatar mapping and Apache-2.0 logo attribution exist in current source. Actual avatar/UI rendering unverified because Electron setup was capacity-blocked.
TUI and Chat TUI supported; stock ACP and unregistered SDK candidate assessed independently BLOCKED TUI lifecycle NOT_RUN behind strict auth prerequisite. Stock ACP initialize: loadSession=false. Mastra absent from settings.chatHarnesses; explicit Chat spawn returned 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED with no fallback/session. SDK candidate remains unregistered; no Chat conformance claimed.
Reviewer Excluded by current integration docs; native prompt review is distinct from AO reviewer support NOT_RUN No Mastra reviewer registry/vocabulary entry. Safe reviewer selection returned 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS before session lookup. No reviewer run/result/cancel/rerun; no GitHub reviewer execution/publication authorized. This is not a reviewer PASS.
Permissions and instructions Native default and explicit bypass TUI policies; additive managed plugin instructions NOT_RUN Source maps default/bypass and rejects auto/accept-edits, but no registered AO provider turn passed readiness. Approval/rejection, argv edge cases, independent standing instructions and refreshed instruction consumption remain unverified.
Lifecycle Executing cancellation, Kill/archive, exact restore, reconnect and continuation NOT_RUN Strict dependent gates all NOT_RUN. No AO worker/session or executing-command witness existed; no PID/kernel-start cancellation or delayed-side-effect claim. Native probe/daemon teardown PASS is separate from task lifecycle.
Evidence Current source/native/AO/skill fingerprints, distinct attempts, full index and durable images BLOCKED Fresh receipts retained outside Git, strict BLOCKED preserved, no diagnostic attempt. Zero actual UI PNGs; attachment queue empty. No approved uploader; AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. All 24 mandatory checkpoints plus Chat/reviewer subjourneys retained.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub checks and mergeability; routine suites CI only FAIL 25 current-head checks: 21 success, 4 failure (backend-core (0), session-store-race, lint, build-test); no pending. PR mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. No local unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/build-fixture/runner-fixture suites run. Description link to this new comment pending parent.

All screenshot checkpoints and supported/excluded subjourneys (no session/generation exists; no action/result capture was produced):

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed state Functional status Screenshot/attachment status Proof or reason
harness-listed Open Agent Harness → not opened BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Registration API passed; actual Electron unavailable
install-offer Inspect installation offer → API manual-only observed BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Manual installer metadata observed; no real AO page capture
install-run Start AO installation → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED MANUAL_ONLY; provider installation/upgrades not authorized
auth-before Inspect existing-account state → API configured/unverified BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Fresh strict auth observation; no AO UI
auth-action Start Login/Setup/Configure → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Documentation-only AO plan; no login/reset authorization
auth-ready Verify connected state and first successful turn → quota error BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Configured-only and exhausted provider quota; no successful witness
auth-maintenance Account/provider change/logout/retry → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Account changes/resets prohibited; no safe fresh maintenance branch
harness-models List/refresh Harness models → API text mode/empty list BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Refresh API 200; actual Agent Harness surface not opened
model-visibility Off/on/bulk and reload/picker effects → not exercised NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Text-mode provider exposes no discovered catalog; no fake switches; UI unavailable
provider-management Provider list/configuration actions → isolated stored configuration only BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Existing Zai metadata/key presence only; no account-management UI/routing success
task-agent Open New Task/select harness → not opened BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED UI unavailable; API registration is separate
task-model Select task model → no UI selection BLOCKED Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Free-text mode API observed; successful effective native selection unverified
task-running Create task/card and completed initial output → not created NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Strict auth prerequisite blocked; native standalone witness failed quota
task-followup Composer follow-up/response → not sent NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No initialized AO task
task-cancel Stop executing command/settle → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No live executing PID/kernel-start witness
kill-action Archive control/confirmation/terminated → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No worker session
archived Find exact archived card → unavailable NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No worker session
restore-action Restore exact native history/ready → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No killed task/history or fresh restored-ready samples
kanban-return Same restored card/continuation → not attempted NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Restore prerequisites unrun
chat New Task Chat/shared composer journeys → rejected by API NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; stock ACP loadSession=false; candidate unregistered
reviewer-select Select Mastra reviewer/target → rejected by API NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED 400 UNKNOWN_REVIEWER_HARNESS; no registered reviewer
reviewer-running Reviewer run/cancel/retry → not started NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No registered reviewer; external publication not authorized
reviewer-result Review result/rerun on target head → not produced NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No run/result; review publication prohibited
reconnect-cleanup UI reload/reconnect/recovery → unrun; owned shutdown → clean NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED No UI/controller identity to reconnect; exact daemon/native cleanup receipts PASS
chat/new-task Registered Chat task creation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/followup-stream Shared composer, partial stream, tool/text output and file witness → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/load-history Native load/history/pagination/no duplicates → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/approve Offered approval and protected effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/reject Separate offered rejection/no effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/cancel-active-tool Stop with command PID/kernel-start and absent delayed effect → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/ui-reconnect Event/UI reconnect plus continuation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned daemon/host recovery and continuation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/kill-restore-instructions Kill/exact load/new ordinary instruction control → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
chat/negative-restore-capabilities Native missing-history/workspace/capability validation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Chat unregistered; stock ACP loadSession=false; explicit request rejected
reviewer/target-head Reviewer picker/PR6541 head identification → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized
reviewer/cancel Actual run cancellation and worker isolation → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized
reviewer/rerun Actual result and rerun/new-head result → not executed NOT_RUN Unavailable; attachment BLOCKED Reviewer unregistered; explicit selection rejected; no reviewer publication authorized

Current-head CI (read via authorized GitHub helper; no routine suites executed on VPS):

Failing CI detail: backend-core (0) failed TestEveryRefreshHarnessResumesExactConversation/mastra-code: version_refresh_test.go:27: missing explicit refresh capability; session-store-race failed TestTerminalRefreshSupportMatrix: mastra-code refresh capability = false, want true; lint reports 1 gocritic stringXbytes and 7 staticcheck ST1005 issues in candidate mastrasdk/driver.go; build-test is the failed aggregate. Build/vet/format steps inside backend-core CI passed; this does not clear the failed test job. Windows/macOS native CI success is not Mastra provider lifecycle/OS qualification. No pending checks in the current-head readback.

Cleanup: PASS. Native help/package/workspace/ACP PIDs were individually reaped. Exact owned daemon PID 1460427 / kernel-start 160712408 received SIGTERM at 2026-10-21T05:45:33.783843+00:00, stopped by 2026-10-21T05:45:34.021325+00:00, no SIGKILL, listener closed. The keep-daemon capture window ended then; strict runner subsequently exited 1. Final exact PID and process-group scan found 0 surviving owned PIDs and 0 group members. Source including untracked files remains clean, original native profile unchanged, reports survive. Temporary profiles/databases/receipts/logs remain private under this PR's sibling runtime outside Git; no production daemon touched. Failed UI setup dependencies/caches alone were reclaimed. Parent must perform its independent ownership check and remove only its new clean detached worktree.

Unresolved/next action: retain the first quota failure; rerun native proof after authorized provider capacity is available, then a fresh strict attempt with independently proven contracts. Product owners must resolve CI failures/conflicts outside this testing-only worker. Provide enough UI setup capacity to preserve the 700 MiB floor; qualify every remaining UI/lifecycle/model/provider/instruction journey and publish safe actual screenshots via an approved uploader. Chat/reviewer production qualification remains separate and unrun. PR-description link to this new evidence comment is pending parent (description was not edited). No integration completion or merge-readiness claim.

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 4/4

Historical material from original PR #6541, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T16:33:08Z

Original comment

Fresh independent review against the current ao-agent-harness skill from #7081, not earlier review criteria.

Reviewed PR head: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f.
Skill head: 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840.
Disposition: FAIL / not qualified under the current skill. This is review evidence, not an approval or a request to register the unfinished Chat candidate.

Findings

  1. P2 — Kill before native identity → Restore returns HTTP 500. On the exact-head isolated Linux desktop: POST /sessions {harness:"mastra-code",mode:"tui",approvalMode:"default",prompt:"Say hello."} →201; immediate Kill→200; Restore→500 INTERNAL_ERROR in 72 ms. The log says mastra-code restore requires a complete native thread UUID; refusing fresh fallback. The plain error from history.go35–36 and107–108 is escaping the API boundary. The guide requires a typed4xx or fresh fallback for missing identity/history. Keep the refusal to silently resume unrelated history; return the documented client error. Evidence: negative-restore.json, request vps-linux/g9mXos8Gxk-000082. The throwaway session remains terminated.

  2. P1 — Auth can never become verified/Connected. AuthStatus only returns unknown or configured, even with a stored provider key. Strict audit reports ao_authenticated: FAIL — Authentication check was inconclusive; all provider-backed TUI/role qualification is consequently skipped. This is an AO verification gap, not proof the user lacks a login. Native help exposes no auth-status command; no command, credentials, or successful auth was fabricated. The fresh Account view also showed Unknown with no Login/Set up/Configure action, despite the documentation-only setup plan. See screenshots05,06 and manual11.

  3. P2 — Missing terminal refresh capability breaks required CI. The registered adapter does not implement SupportsTerminalVersionRefresh. The current touchpoint scan is TUI 11/13. Exact-head backend-core(0) fails TestEveryRefreshHarnessResumesExactConversation/mastra-code: missing explicit refresh capability; session-store-race fails TestTerminalRefreshSupportMatrix: mastra-code refresh capability=false,want true. These are actual test failures, not runner outages.

  4. P2 — New Task cannot enter the advertised native model ID. The live models API correctly returns selectionMode:"text", models:[], customModelEntry:"direct", allowCustom:true, which passes the strict backend audit. In the actual desktop, select Mastra Code→Model: no options and no model text input. TaskComposer948–949 hardcodes allowCustom=false and converts direct entry to none. This shared existing picker behavior prevents this new free-form harness from meeting the skill's New Task model checkpoint. Screenshots09,10,12 and manual-model.txt. Do not fix this by inventing a catalog.

  5. P2 — Installer is documentation only. The only plan is manual on all OSes, although the native CLI is published through npm. The current guide requires executable official installer coverage and a working Install button. UI “install PASS” means only already installed; it did not exercise installation. Also add the real binary override to harnessProbeSpecs: ao doctor currently defaults to the ID mastra-code, while the executable is mastracode.

Current-skill handoff gap

The guide explicitly says “no unregistered drivers.” This diff retains the unregistered mastrasdk candidate. Chat/reviewer/handoff absence is an honest TUI-only scope omission, not a claim that production Chat is broken. Keep unqualified Chat unregistered; remove/split the candidate to satisfy the guide. Its exact-head lint job also fails eight issues: one gocritic stringXbytes and seven ST1005 errors. build-test is the aggregate failing gate. Other exact-head checks, including mastra-sdk-contract, API/sqlc drift and native OS jobs, passed; contract tests do not substitute for live qualification. Routine unit/lint/race validation was read from CI, not rerun on the VPS.

Live and UI evidence

All source/build/native/UI work ran on the VPS in a private exact-head worktree. Native package mastracode 0.45.0 was installed privately. A stock install resolved SDK 1.15.0 from its ^1.11.0 range; before live probes I explicitly pinned the private setup to SDK 1.11.0. This is not a stock current dependency-resolution pass. Native --help exited0; --version exited1 and showed required-prompt usage. That version failure is an upstream/contract limitation, not an AO implementation finding, and no wrapper replaced it with a fake successful version command.

Strict skill audit: 4 PASS, 2 FAIL, 1 SKIP — CLI installed/AO registered/installed/free-form models PASS; CLI version upstream FAIL; AO auth FAIL; provider live SKIP. No native login-status/model-list command is exposed, so those were not invented. First-prompt delivery, worktree, private instructions, AGENTS.md, hooks, native identity, follow-up, usage, Kill of an in-flight child, exact successful restore, history and roles remain BLOCKED/unproven. The separate missing-ID restore diagnostic above is a real product failure, not a successful lifecycle audit.

Raw UI audit captured nine checkpoint screenshots: listing, installed detection, health and New Task agent PASS; Models tab, login and New Task models FAIL; auth NEEDS_USER; update NOT_RUN. Manual adjudication: absence of a model catalog is valid free-form behavior, so the raw Models-tab catalog expectation is not a backend failure. The empty New Task input and missing setup action were separately confirmed. Auth “NEEDS_USER” does not override the unconditional AO-side verification gap. Running/provider checkpoint is BLOCKED, not PASS.

Evidence retained privately at:
/home/azureuser/.ao/dev/pr6541-review-20261023T180000Z/
(live-audit/report.md, per-check JSON, ui-audit/ui-report.md, raw/manual PNGs, negative-restore.json, CLI help/version, compatibility, intake/touchpoints and CI logs).
No evidence was added to the product diff. The pristine skill was preserved; the audit runtime copy changed only its temporary-root prefix to ~/.ao/ma-audit- to respect AO state isolation/short sockets, with original/patched SHA256 in audit-runtime-hashes.txt; checks were unchanged.

Screenshot evidence is now PUBLISHED: all 12 captured PNGs and raw results on the separate evidence branch, pinned to 4e5d5812a17796a6b04546fa0dd273d34cbbe2f4. This resolves the earlier NOT_DONE attachment gap; the test verdicts and qualification limits remain unchanged. No login/logout, key entry or credential copying was performed; production AO and real user data were untouched.

Cleanup verified: the owned throwaway session is terminated, isolated desktop/daemon stopped, ports 3003/9223 closed, product worktree clean and removed with normal git worktree remove, and private native/build/state artifacts removed. Only small reports/logs/screenshots remain. Production PID 1554786 is unchanged.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T16:55:18Z

Original comment

Review evidence: screenshots and raw results (#7081)

Publishing the retained 2026-10-23 VPS review evidence using the same separate evidence-branch approach as #7093. This is not a new test run and changes no verdict.

Reviewed product head: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f. Current PR head at publication: adb222647b06e3f4b0ffa1adcb777106fb0ccf6f.
Skill #7081 head: 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840. Evidence commit: 4e5d5812a17796a6b04546fa0dd273d34cbbe2f4.
Native setup: mastracode 0.45.0, private SDK 1.11.0.

All 12 PNGs are embedded below, with immutable URLs. Each published PNG was fetched back and its SHA-256 matched the captured file.
Evidence is on the fork's evidence/harness-reviews-6541-6546-20261023 branch, outside this product PR diff.

Evidence Result / scope Files
Strict live audit 4 PASS / 2 FAIL (native --version and auth inconclusive) / 1 SKIP (live) report.md · report.json
AO auth response Unknown/inconclusive; not proof of invalid credentials raw response
Backend model API PASS: freeform/direct entry raw response
Desktop audit Raw checkpoints and screenshots; interpretation below report.md · report.json
Negative restore Create 201 -> immediate kill 200 -> restore 500, before native history ID existed HTTP receipts · daemon cause
Capture context and limitations Exact setup, blocked checks and cleanup README

Interpretation: Already installed is not an Install-button pass. The Models-tab runner assumes a catalog, while the backend correctly supports freeform models; the separately verified UI issue is missing usable direct entry in New Task. Update was NOT_RUN. Authenticated prompt, role, usage and successful history/restore qualification remain BLOCKED/SKIP. The negative 500 probe is not successful restore or process-kill recovery proof.

Mastra's manual Account check separately confirmed missing Login/Set up/Configure controls. Native --version remains an upstream/contract failure. Stock npm resolved SDK 1.15.0; the isolated test explicitly pinned SDK 1.11.0. This is not a stock-install qualification.

PNG bytes are unchanged. Text files have ANSI styling removed and private test-root prefixes normalized. Selected text and screenshot OCR were scanned for credential patterns with no matches; no private env/config files were published. SHA-256 manifest.

Captured UI checkpoints

01-harness-listed-PASS.png — Harness listing

Mastra Code: Harness listing

02-install-PASS.png — Existing installation (Install action not exercised)

Mastra Code: Existing installation (Install action not exercised)

03-health-PASS.png — Health: authentication Unknown

Mastra Code: Health: authentication Unknown

04-models-FAIL.png — Models tab: raw catalog-centric runner observation

Mastra Code: Models tab: raw catalog-centric runner observation

05-login-FAIL.png — Account/login: raw runner capture

Mastra Code: Account/login: raw runner capture

06-auth-check-NEEDS_USER.png — Auth check: no verified Connected verdict

Mastra Code: Auth check: no verified Connected verdict

07-update-NOT_RUN.png — Update NOT_RUN

Mastra Code: Update NOT_RUN

08-new-task-agent-tui-PASS.png — New Task: harness selection

Mastra Code: New Task: harness selection

09-new-task-models-tui-FAIL.png — New Task: empty model entry

Mastra Code: New Task: empty model entry

10-manual-new-task-model.png — Manual New Task model check

Mastra Code: Manual New Task model check

11-manual-account-configure.png — Manual Account/setup check

Mastra Code: Manual Account/setup check

12-manual-model-open.png — Manual model-menu check

Mastra Code: Manual model-menu check


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T17:19:59Z

Original comment

Follow-up: the native login route exists; Z.ai/MiniMax provider support

Checked the exact published packages used for the review: mastracode 0.45.0, @mastra/code-sdk 1.11.0 and its pinned @mastra/core 1.75.0. This is package/source and documentation verification, not an authenticated provider run.

Native login: mastracode 0.45.0 actually implements mastracode login in dist/cli.js and dist/login-command-C0Ro4glG.js, even though its root --help did not list it. The interactive menu offers Add an API key, then asks for a provider ID. The --provider flag is OAuth-provider-only in that handler; do not recommend mastracode login --provider zai or --provider minimax.

The native TUI also implements /connect, /api-keys, /model and /custom-providers. Official commands and native terminal login method.

Native provider Env variable Example catalog ID (not account-verified)
Z.ai API ZHIPU_API_KEY zai/glm-5.2
Z.ai Coding Plan registry entry ZHIPU_API_KEY zai-coding-plan/glm-5.2
MiniMax API MINIMAX_API_KEY minimax/MiniMax-M3
MiniMax Token Plan registry entry MINIMAX_API_KEY minimax-coding-plan/MiniMax-M3

These four provider records and models are present in core 1.75.0's published dist/provider-registry.json. Official environment names. A registry entry does not prove a particular subscription, key or model is accepted; plan, endpoint, region and model entitlement still need a real provider check.

AO wiring gaps at adb2226:

  • agentauth/plans.go:19 offers a documentation-only setup plan instead of opening the native login/configuration flow.
  • The adapter launches with MASTRA_APP_DATA_DIR=<AO_DATA_DIR>/mastra-code/profile. Login must use that same profile; logging in through an ordinary terminal's default profile does not configure AO's isolated profile.
  • Native API-key login stores apikey:<provider> records in that profile's auth.json; the SDK loads stored keys into provider env vars at startup. AO's AuthStatus only inspects settings.json.customProviders[].apiKey and never verifies native stored API keys, native OAuth or provider env credentials. Therefore successful native login can still leave AO showing Unknown.
  • Both this PR and CodeBuddy return a valid freeform model contract, but TaskComposer.tsx:948-949 sets allowCustom=false and converts direct entry to none. No usable models/direct entry then appears. Native Mastra's provider catalog exists; AO has not exposed it here.

Required follow-up: launch mastracode login as a native terminal auth action with the exact runtime profile, verify authorization through the native/provider boundary, and honor direct model entry or expose real native catalog metadata. Do not invent a models-list command or mark credentials authorized from presence alone.

No credential file was inspected, no key was entered, and no login/logout or real provider call was performed. This follow-up does not change the existing BLOCKED authenticated-lifecycle verdict.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T19:24:20Z

Original comment

Mastra Code: login, auth and model fixes pushed at 010b5cf; includes main b13b951.

Evidence is attached below. Full local and GitHub validation is still running; this is not a merge-ready verdict. Reviewed against harness skill7081.

Check Observed result
Exact-head focused validation PASS: adapter/auth/registry/installer/ports, native Default/precedence checks; 262 UI tests. Receipt
Fresh Unknown-auth account PASS: native Login/Set up is available; Unknown does not become signed-in.
Configured credentials Covered by focused tests: Credentials not verified; a real accepted native request is required for Connected.
Models PASS: Models explains native freeform configuration; New Task sends the entered model ID. No synthetic catalog. Outgoing request
Ordinary New Task PASS: UI omits approvalMode, backend persists native Default and reaches the real native setup/login gate. Owned-row verification
MiniMax PASS: native mastracode 0.45.0 / SDK 1.11.0 / core 1.75.0, MiniMax-M3 accepted after fixing structured SDK result handling (2.42s).
Z.ai UNVERIFIED: native selected-provider request returned HTTP429; credentials remain configured/unverified.
Full CI PENDING: complete local suites and current-head remote checks are running. Earlier failed attempts are not relabeled passed.
Cleanup Owned test sessions terminated and isolated app/daemon/PTYs stopped; production readyz stayed200. No production AO data or account was changed.

Native first attempts · Mastra corrected native result · Probe-byte equivalence.

Real Electron/UI capture revision: 0772781. The current head changes only a test query option and, for Mastra, a method comment after that proof; runtime behavior is unchanged. Source provenance.

The ordinary unmodified UI request launched native mastracode0.45.0 and reached its setup TUI.

Account action:
Mastra Code Account action

Native model guidance:
Mastra Code Models guidance

Native login chooser, without selecting an account or entering a key:
Mastra Code native login

Direct model selection:
Mastra Code custom model

UI report · Runtime proof · All artifacts and reproduction inputs · SHA256 manifest.

Limitations: no successful provider turn inside an AO UI session, full lifecycle/restore/permission-enforcement qualification, or cross-platform native-provider proof is claimed. CodeBuddy's explicit Open setup /login reopening was not executed while its chooser was already active; that action has source/unit coverage. The earlier CodeBuddy outgoing-request timing incident and native-version drift are retained in the evidence. Existing Chat candidates remain gated/unregistered. Native checks used bounded temporary environments; keys, raw provider replies and credential files are not attached. The complete70-file public evidence bundle was read back with HTTP200 and matching SHA256 hashes.

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🏆 Review leaderboard

Nov 5–12, 2026 · UTC

Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
🥇 @ronishrohan @ronishrohan 91 160 14
🥈 @neversettle17-101 @neversettle17-101 11 15 4
🥉 @illegalcall @illegalcall 11 12 4
4 @Meraj-08 @Meraj-08 10 15 0
5 @nikhilachale @nikhilachale 7 19 3
6 @Prasad-D-Ware @Prasad-D-Ware 7 12 2
7 @Annieeeee11 @Annieeeee11 6 9 0
8 @mohakchakraborty2004 @mohakchakraborty2004 6 7 2
9 @Pritom14 @Pritom14 5 8 1
10 @Rishet11 @Rishet11 5 6 3

Ranked by distinct external PRs reviewed, then review rounds, then PR comments. Self-activity and bot activity are excluded.

Show 6 more reviewers
Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
11 @somewherelostt @somewherelostt 3 11 1
12 @ApexYash11 @ApexYash11 2 6 2
13 @Vaibhaav-Tiwari @Vaibhaav-Tiwari 2 3 0
14 @codebanditssss @codebanditssss 2 2 8
15 @harshitsinghbhandari @harshitsinghbhandari 2 2 0
16 @MohamedKamran @MohamedKamran 1 2 0

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Account migration verification

  • New PR author verified as milesatao-svg; submission is a draft.
  • Original PR #6541 and this PR both point to 010b5cf8c2171b93c7f6843268ae4a987e8fbce0.
  • Published change-count header verified against this PR's actual GitHub file diff.
  • All 38 original human comment bodies and source links reproduced across 4 historical-evidence comments.
  • All 34 original screenshot/recording URLs reproduced and checked as HTTP 200 media.
  • Current GitHub mergeability: conflicts with main; resolution pending.
  • Fresh CI validation and current-head harness certification are pending. Copied test outcomes retain their original run/commit provenance.

@OrcInc OrcInc added comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request labels Nov 12, 2026
@OrcInc OrcInc added this to the Agents & orchestration milestone Nov 12, 2026
nikhilachale and others added 2 commits November 14, 2026 23:11
Resolve conflicts against main adf9f6a while keeping main's daemon,
API and UI behavior:

- CI: keep main's reusable go.yml and storage-race job; keep the Mastra
  SDK contract job (gated by ci-ok through the go lane) and the Windows
  mastracode step.
- Auth: combine main's provider-key hold-back for sign-in terminals with
  the Mastra isolated profile; keep main's DataDir and the auth-scoped
  context. The Mastra probe now applies the readiness auth environment and
  reports provider checks as provider_validation (model_selection_unresolved
  for an unselected build model), so main's Settings logic shows unverified
  Mastra credentials as "Credentials not verified".
- Settings: take main's account-row and unknown-auth login logic and tests;
  add provider_rate_limited and provider_quota_exhausted to the unverified
  provider codes (only Mastra emits them).
- New Task: keep main's local catalog-only gate; allow a typed model ID only
  for Mastra Code with a direct-entry catalog, shared with the Models panel
  hint through acceptsLocalModelID.
- Session input: run the Mastra terminal-message check before main's
  composer-draft fence so the fence still spans the write; keep serialized
  input alongside main's inputLeaseSince.
- Native restore proof uses main's launchPath, nativeRestoreMetadata and
  RelaunchError classification.
- SQLite: keep both schema repairs; no later migration rebuilds sessions.
- Add the missing directEntry string to every locale, Mastra to the agent
  tone map, ao doctor and the shell-agent classifier.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…edger

Move the sessions harness migration to 20261114174310512 so it sorts after
main's newest migration, as the harness integration guide requires. Builds
that applied the old number re-run it harmlessly: the update only widens a
constraint that lacks mastra-code, and the startup repair covers any gap.

Treat 0207, used only by an earlier Mastra candidate, like the Hermes 0203
reservation: burned with a comment rather than a ledger entry, so the ledger
check again flags every deleted shipped migration.

List the Mastra Code guide in the docs index.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Reconciliation and harness-skill receipt — head 3b47ef62d158c074edae651ca1ed6759405d8721

Base: main at adf9f6a303a60be99543c74fa3bd1b7cf3675253. Merged (no rebase, no force-push) on top of the previous head 010b5cf8. Skill: ao-agent-harness from PR #7081 at 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840, read from an exported copy. None of its files, contracts or reports are in this diff.

Not merge-ready. CI on this head has not run yet (fork workflows are waiting for maintainer approval). No live, UI or provider qualification was done on this head.

What changed in this update

  • Resolved 18 conflicts and kept main's daemon, API and UI behavior: reusable go.yml (the Mastra SDK contract job is gated through ci-ok), held-back provider keys for sign-in terminals, main's Settings account and unknown-auth logic, main's local New Task model gate, the composer-draft fence and inputLeaseSince, and the import-aware relaunch path.
  • Locale fix: settings.harness.models.directEntry was missing from every non-English catalog. That was the instance.test.ts coverage and interpolation failure. It is now in all 8 locales, each with {{agent}}.
  • Native-restore proof now uses launchPath, nativeRestoreMetadata(rec) and RelaunchError. Before, an imported or relocated launch could fail the Mastra cwd witness, and its failure skipped main's relaunch classification.
  • Mastra auth uses the shared diagnostic vocabulary: provider_validation, plus model_selection_unresolved when no build model is selected. Its probe also applies the readiness auth environment. With main's diagnostics-driven Settings, unconfirmed Mastra credentials still show "Credentials not verified". provider_rate_limited and provider_quota_exhausted were added to the unverified codes; only Mastra emits them.
  • New Task: main keeps typed model IDs off for local tasks. A typed ID is now allowed only for Mastra Code with a direct catalog (acceptsLocalModelID). The Models panel hint uses the same rule. The earlier change that applied to every direct harness was dropped. Maintainer decision requested on this scope.
  • Touchpoints main added since the PR base: agent-tone.ts (an exhaustive Record<AgentId> that would fail typecheck), the ao doctor probe (mastracode, PATH-only) and the shell-agent classifier.
  • Migration renumbered to 20261114174310512, above main's newest (20261114072016988). No later main migration rebuilds sessions. 0207 is now burned with a comment, like Hermes 0203, and the ledger's deleted-migration check is strict again.

Skill receipt

Step Result Evidence / gap
0 Intake SKIP Continuing this open PR. harness_intake.mjs was not run on this host.
1 Compatibility PASS (historical) The pinned mastracode@0.45.0 / SDK 1.11.0 table is in docs/harnesses/mastra-code.md. Not re-verified against a live CLI on this head.
2 Touchpoints PASS (TUI, install, auth, models, branding, docs) by inspection Every required TUI/install/auth/models/branding touchpoint was checked by grep. docs-index is added. Chat (chat-registry, chat-switch-target) and reviewer are intentionally unwired. harness_touchpoints.mjs itself was not executed.
2 "No unregistered drivers" FAIL (policy) chatdriver/mastrasdk is an unregistered SDK Chat candidate, kept deliberately with its gating intact. Maintainers should decide whether to keep it here or split it out.
2 Migration above main's latest PASS Renumbered as above.
3 Contract / doctor BLOCKED Needs run_local.sh doctor on a mac/Linux host with the CLI installed.
4 Live audit (TUI spawn, hooks, restore, roles) BLOCKED Needs run_local.sh audit mastra-code on mac/Linux with a provider login. Not run on this Windows host.
4 Chat SKIP Chat is not registered.
5 UI audit (install, login, Connected/unverified, New Task model ID, spawn) BLOCKED Needs the desktop app plus ui_audit.mjs on mac/Linux.
6 Hand-off Open GitHub CI, Native/independent review, maintainer approval and the live audits above.

Validation

  • Local: no builds or tests were run (Windows-host restriction). Checks were static only: conflict-marker scan, CRLF scan, symbol existence for every cross-package reference in mastracode/mastrasdk, and interface conformance against changed ports.
  • CI: pending approval for the fork workflow runs on 3b47ef62.

Live-test needs before merge

  1. audit mastra-code with a working provider: spawn, first prompt, hooks working→idle, exact restore with a native witness, Kill, follow-up.
  2. UI: Settings shows "Credentials not verified" for a configured but unconfirmed provider and Connected after a provider round trip, Log in opens mastracode login in the isolated profile, and New Task accepts a typed Mastra model ID.
  3. Paste vs. keystroke under serialized input. During a Mastra paste, typed keys are refused with the exclusive-operation error rather than queued behind main's fence.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants