Skip to content

feat: integrate CodeBuddy Code foreground TUI sessions - #8202

Draft
milesatao-svg wants to merge 41 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6546-codebuddy
Draft

milesatao-svg wants to merge 41 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6546-codebuddy

Conversation

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Code changes: +1233 -24
Tests: +1693 -25
Others: +1058 -3

Account migration from @nikhilachale to @milesatao-svg. This draft continues original PR #6546 at original head 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441. Original commits and commit authorship are preserved. Descriptions and evidence below include historical results with their original sources.

What

feat: integrate CodeBuddy Code foreground TUI sessions

Original PR description, preserved

CodeBuddy Code login, auth verification and model-entry fixes at 81ac436. Latest integrated main: b13b951.

Native Set up now opens CodeBuddy and the Open setup action sends /login. Provider verification uses a bounded, tool-free native request with hooks, function mods, MCP, persistence and updater/background work disabled for that check.

New Task accepts supported direct model IDs, and Models explains native freeform selection instead of implying an available catalog. Login, runtime and auth checks use the same canonical AO data/profile root, including relative AO_DATA_DIR overrides.

Current full validation is in progress; merge readiness is not claimed.

Check Current observation
Exact-head preflight PASS: Go adapter/auth/installer/registry/ports, native Default/precedence checks and 262 UI tests
Unknown-auth action PASS: real Electron exposes native Login/Set up without changing Unknown to signed-in
Unverified credentials PASS: Account uses Credentials not verified instead of Connected
Direct model entry PASS: actual New Task payload contains the entered native model ID; freeform guidance, no invented catalog
Unspecified permissions PASS: ordinary New Task persists native Default; explicit policies and other harness defaults remain unchanged
MiniMax native inference PASS: pinned native release, supplied key, bounded request; temporary profiles removed
Z.ai native inference UNVERIFIED: Mastra reports HTTP 429; CodeBuddy JSON mode produced no qualifying result
Full local / remote CI Running on the exact source head; no blanket pass claimed

Native provider proof used Mastra0.45.0 and CodeBuddy2.164.0; CodeBuddy practical UI2.173 and the corrected2.164 API/native retry are separately identified in the evidence comment. Full lifecycle, restore and cross-platform native-provider qualification remain separate from these fixes.

Current fix and evidence status.

The five pre-existing historical binary assets remain outside line counts.

Current scope remains foreground TUI. Successful provider authentication, complete live lifecycle qualification and merge readiness must be assessed from the current evidence comment; historical checks below do not qualify this head.

Preserved description and evidence from earlier source revisions (historical)

Current continuation: c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e includes canonical main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c. Reviewed driver source fixes pushed; current-head CI pending, qualification incomplete and Chat shipping gated. Exact completion/remaining-work snapshot.

Binary assets in this source snapshot: 5 (excluded from line counts).

Foreground TUI with native Default/manual permissions; Chat/ACP, Auto, Accept Edits, Bypass, background work, reviewer and handoff excluded.

Current status

Current source snapshot: cd56c657748d75054d5a50e7b1aff8bed4475ca3 (includes PR-host main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669, including Memcode 0202 and per-folder accounts 0210-0212). CodeBuddy now uses migration 0215; the 0207 draft collision is guarded and tested. An unregistered ACP candidate is included; Chat/ACP remains outside supported and registered scope pending native qualification. A focused fix removes a redundant ActionSetup parameter flagged by Linux lint. All 25/25 exact-head checks pass across Go, Frontend, CLI E2E, harness proof, harness release feeds, and gitleaks; AO review approved this head with no findings. GitHub reports MERGEABLE. Focused SQLite and migration tests, registry/activity, installer/auth and API tests, Go build/vet, Product UI typecheck and 160 tests, and docs build pass locally. Native CodeBuddy login/TUI at this source remains NOT_RUN; independent GitHub approval remains required.

The earlier reporting-only reconciliation used isolated source worktrees and did not rerun CodeBuddy. This continuation built and tested the current source locally, but did not perform a new native CodeBuddy login or TUI run. Historical native evidence remains scoped to its recorded source and release.

Historical runtime build: Historical AO/UI source 5827f13d75b639eac6ed76f6d572b6752c060da5, released @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code@2.164.0, Node24.21.0/Ubuntu; launcher SHA256 426186a82e36466d5be485f335ced1b0d664539c53b72a5f10ba3a267e60dab6. Earlier lifecycle sources/failures remain separately recorded. Report · evidence index, original receipts, image/provenance hashes. Receipt SHAs/bytes are unchanged. Linux/VPS proof is not Windows/macOS native proof. Runner SHA256 8887aa2e7101b9e6d3950bfca08ffddf2e1e6c1c3f1d030c8dec2676443aecea remains historical where reported; manual/standalone proof is not a strict runner PASS.

Changes since runtime proof: The harness guide records direct model IDs, supported permissions/input/history bounds and an intentional initials avatar fallback because no asset reuse terms were verified. Native/UI journeys at the current source are NOT_RUN. Current-main reconciliation preserves the integration and upstream migration ledger; current source/CI state is recorded above.

The matrix separates current verification from recorded historical passes; NOT_RUN does not erase those passes. Excluded interfaces/manual model input are deliberate supported-scope decisions.

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Foreground TUI with native Default/manual permissions; Chat/ACP, Auto, Accept Edits, Bypass, background work, reviewer and handoff excluded. NOT_RUN Adapter/registry/API/generated/product paths are present; current Settings/task journeys not reverified.
Models Truthful native/freeform model IDs; no invented catalog. Pre-launch/defaults and effective selection need current-source review. NOT_RUN Historical native selection separate from current picker/default verification.
Setup Pinned official npm native install and harness guide with auth/model/permission/history prerequisites. NOT_RUN Harness guide; current Settings/native setup journey NOT_RUN.
Readiness Binary/profile/config, native Default mode and bounded instructions/history; current-source validation pending. NOT_RUN Historical native proof does not qualify all advertised OS/current config cases.
Identity and logo Product label and intentional initials fallback; asset reuse terms were not verified. NOT_RUN Fallback disposition; actual current avatar UI NOT_RUN.
TUI and Chat TUI supported; Chat/ACP/handoff excluded deliberately. Historical actual AO screenshots retained. NOT_RUN Historical actual AO images; excluded interfaces are deliberate.
Permissions and instructions Bounded additive private instructions and native Default/manual; other modes rejected deliberately. NOT_RUN Historical scoped PASS/limits; current live path NOT_RUN.
Lifecycle Historical executing Escape, independent Kill/control, exact native restore and fresh instructions; draft/permission409 guards. NOT_RUN Historical scoped PASS/limits; current live path NOT_RUN.
Evidence Pinned historical source/native/runner/UI receipts, attempts, images and provenance; missing originals disclosed. NOT_RUN Historical evidence retained; current native/UI proof NOT_RUN. Reproduction-input limitations below remain explicit.
CI and handoff Exact source checks/merge snapshot; incomplete live qualification and historical cleanup. PASS (25/25 CI); NOT_RUN (native/UI) All exact-head checks pass and AO review approved; independent GitHub review required. Current native/UI qualification NOT_RUN.

Current validation and merge order

Focused CodeBuddy adapter, migration, registry and guard tests pass locally, along with Go build/vet, API and sqlc drift checks, Product UI typecheck and 160 tests, Cloud client typecheck and 29 tests, docs build, E2E typecheck, and guarded browser integration. Broad Windows runs encounter unrelated Unix/macOS fixture, symlink, and filesystem assumptions; exact-head Linux CI is the full-suite gate. Native CodeBuddy login/TUI at this source is NOT_RUN.

Migration merge gate: PR-host main includes Memcode 0202 and per-folder accounts 0210-0212; its migration maximum is 0212. CodeBuddy #6546 uses 0215, while the shared burned-version ledger reserves draft 0207 so preview databases cannot silently skip the CodeBuddy migration. The migration regression covers a database that used Open Interpreter's old draft 0207, then applies CodeBuddy 0215. Open claims include Pool #6551 at 0208, Neovate #6494 at 0209, usage-limit recovery #6717 at 0213-0214, and Open Interpreter #6496 at 0216. Other open PRs #6541, #6892, and #6364 still claim 0207; their owners must coordinate numbering and the shared harness CHECK/repair paths before merging. The latest 435-open-PR survey found #6546 as the only observed 0215 claimant. Open claims are coordination inputs, not reserved versions.

Recheck PR-host main and active migration claims immediately before any merge. If 0215 lands elsewhere first, or another PR changes the shared harness CHECK/repair paths, reconcile on current main, choose a genuinely free version above its migration maximum, rerun affected tests and exact-head CI, and obtain fresh review. Do not merge #6546 until independent GitHub approval is recorded.

Historical implementation and evidence

Supersedes closed/unmerged contract-only5503 (native2.151.0). Implements current rendered input admission, native profile overrides, bounded additive instructions, exact native-ID history restore and migration0215/historical schema reconciliation. Missing/corrupt/foreign/ambiguous history fails closed; history over32MiB and instructions over64KiB are refused. Credential inventory stays configured; freeform models do not imply a catalog. Suggested prompts remain conservatively nonempty pending native resolution. CI/static output is not an initialized TUI; historical final lab used CI=false. This limited qualification is not a strict catalog/auth runner pass. Historical source 5827f13 had 23/23 green checks; evidence 36f0605 had 5/5/150 fixtures. Earlier native/login/provider/startup/static-renderer/capture, permission-cancel and freed=true assertion failures remain reachable in the report.

historical receipt 1 · historical receipt 2

Reproduction and retained-original limitations

The pinned reports/JSON retain action/result, file/token effects, process identity, cancellation, native-history continuity and capture assertions. A complete sanitized executable reproduction bundle is not established for every manual helper: exact helper bytes/hash and invocation, applicable local-contract bytes/hash with probe argv and interrupt/readiness/draft-cleanup settings, and complete native/AO fingerprints are unavailable where not recorded in the linked receipts; recoverability of those original inputs is unknown. No missing command, contract, hash or result is invented. Later reproductions must use a new attempt and cannot replace original failed/missing evidence.

Recorded owned-process/session/daemon/Electron cleanup is historical. Source worktrees, native profiles/history, dirty scratch workspaces, binaries and raw logs were reported retained privately; a complete current inventory/location/hash and recoverability of every original class are unavailable in the public record. Current recoverability is unknown; this reporting fix reconstructs no missing input and silently substitutes none. Share sanitized artifacts only; exclude credential stores, raw DBs and provider-profile directories. Preserve the retained failures and original screenshots.

Actual AO CodeBuddy exact restore

Actual native permission card in AO

Latest reconciliation: #6546 (comment)

ACP continuation at b499e9beb17668bbe1253649f9a0ea2e32b5ee91: unregistered 2.164.0 nativeacp candidate with bounded additive instructions and strict settings admission. Chat remains unavailable pending authenticated native lifecycle and AO UI qualification; current-head CI pending. Routine validation for this continuation runs only in PR CI. Prior source/validation statements above remain historical.

Latest ACP candidate status (BLOCKED, Chat unregistered): #6546 (comment)

Why

The contributor is moving this harness submission to @milesatao-svg. The linked source preserves the implementation and review history.

Before / After

Before After
Submission in PR #6546 from @nikhilachale at 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441 Submission from @milesatao-svg at the same commit 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441

Original product behavior and existing UI evidence are included in the preserved description and copied evidence comments.

How

Copy the source head into milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6546-codebuddy and target upstream main.

Testing

Historical test results and screenshots are reproduced in the evidence comments with their original sources. Fresh validation is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.

Checklist

  • Original head SHA and commit authorship preserved.
  • Original description and evidence provenance included.
  • Fresh CI validation on this submission.
  • Resolve current main merge conflicts.

Account migration verification

  • Exact source head copied: 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441.
  • New fork branch: milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6546-codebuddy. Base: main.
  • Evidence comments retain their original author, timestamp, source URL and result wording.
  • Fresh validation status is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.
  • Source mergeability at migration: conflicts with current main; reconciliation pending.

Ubuntu and others added 30 commits October 11, 2026 14:55
Preserve harness-owned evidence and merge current canonical API, storage, and native Chat updates. Runtime proof remains qualified by its original source.
Build the real daemon in PR CI for isolated VPS runtime verification without local validation suites or dependency installations. Record source revision, Go build info, and executable hash.
# Conflicts:
#	backend/internal/adapters/agent/registry/registry_test.go
#	backend/internal/cli/spawn.go
#	backend/internal/domain/harness.go
#	backend/internal/httpd/apispec/openapi.yaml
#	backend/internal/httpd/controllers/dto.go
#	backend/internal/observe/activity/observer.go
#	backend/internal/service/agentauth/plans_test.go
#	backend/internal/service/systeminstall/systeminstall.go
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/db.go
#	frontend/src/api/schema.ts
#	frontend/src/docs/content/plugins/agents/index.mdx
#	packages/product-ui/src/agents.ts
# Conflicts:
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrate_burned_versions_test.go
# Conflicts:
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/db.go
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrate_burned_versions_test.go
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrate_codebuddy_test.go
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrations/0207_allow_codebuddy_harness.sql
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrations/0214_allow_codebuddy_harness.sql
#	backend/internal/storage/sqlite/migrations/0215_allow_codebuddy_harness.sql
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 1/2

Historical material from original PR #6546, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T15:33:05Z

Original comment

CodeBuddy TUI qualification evidence is published immutably at 36f060529655dff4c61bfac56e65f05393d95b2e in PR6509. Report and exact lifecycle/cleanup receipts. Both images were inspected for secrets and downloaded from GitHub to verify their PNG SHA256 against the captured originals.

Actual AO exact-ID restore and fresh private instructions

Actual native permission card in AO

Final daemon/UI/source5827f13d75b639eac6ed76f6d572b6752c060da5:23 green exact-head checks. Earlier native/login/provider/startup/CI/static-renderer/capture failures remain separate. TUI/default permissions only; configured auth/freeform models remain honest. Owned cleanup confirmed; no merge/release/deploy.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T15:47:28Z

Original comment

Final handoff: source 5827f13d75b639eac6ed76f6d572b6752c060da5 has23/23 green checks; evidence 36f060529655dff4c61bfac56e65f05393d95b2e has5/5 green checks, including150/150 fresh audit fixtures. PR6546 is ready for review. Native/AO permissions, current-viewport input, cancellation, independent Kill, exact history restore/fresh private instructions and inspected Electron screenshots are recorded in the immutable report linked above. All owned processes are gone and all delayed-side-effect files remain absent after restore/cleanup. TUI/default permissions only; configured auth/freeform models remain explicit. No merge, release or deployment.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T16:50:35Z

Original comment

Harness-specific reports, JSON receipts, screenshots and provenance now live on this integration PR branch, rather than the skill PR #6509.

Evidence index with embedded screenshots and JSON links.

Historical successes, failures and scope limitations remain as recorded. Moving these files does not rerun native/AO testing or upgrade any verdict.

This is evidence relocation only. Existing tested source/native hashes and failures are preserved; the documentation commit is not a fresh runtime pass. Applicable checks run in PR CI.

Recorded harness evidence — see scope above


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:08:32Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at d3fb82e0c85c, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:17:54Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 9bee877fd482, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T19:49:35Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at e28ada310b1c, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T20:59:25Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at af0e0cfeab77, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:20:35Z

Original comment

Continuing existing PR #6546 on the authorized VPS. Refreshed actual live head fa1d060365d644e1479fdfee5434ecb9c16e2fe5 and canonical main 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f; main is already an ancestor, worktree clean. Existing TUI fixes and historical evidence remain untouched. Duplicate search found this PR and closed #5503; no separate CodeBuddy ACP integration PR.

Plan: (1) qualify installed official 2.164.0 stdio ACP in isolated runtime/profile, including exact load and additive instructions; (2) only after native prerequisites pass, add a thin provider binding around shared nativeacp/persistenthost with meaningful regression coverage, conservative settings, no handoff/reviewer changes; (3) qualify real provider lifecycle and actual AO Chat UI, with direct authorized GitHub screenshot attachments; (4) refresh both remotes before each push/status, inspect exact-head CI and independent review. Routine suites run in PR CI only. No new evidence/report files in Git and no changes/comments to #6509.

Initial resource preflight: ~508 MiB free disk, ~2.5 GiB available memory. Prefer existing pinned binaries/CI artifacts; avoid a dependency installation that exceeds capacity. Native/UI/approval/interrupt/restore gates are NOT_RUN at this point; help/version output is discovery only. Private runtime bytes stay under the supplied runtime root. Unsupported or unqualified Chat remains unregistered.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T17:24:05Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — native ACP account-session authorization unavailable. Not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Refreshed BOTH actual PR branch and canonical main immediately before this report: head fa1d060365d644e1479fdfee5434ecb9c16e2fe5, main 6f299014062c392b82b820b23dc08affcaaff04f. Head unchanged, main already an ancestor, worktree clean. No source edits, commits or push; existing contributor TUI work and historical evidence preserved. No modifications/comments to #6509. Existing supported scope remains foreground TUI/default native permissions; Chat stays unregistered. Historical TUI passes do not qualify current Chat.

Actual native probe and retained first failures

VPS official installed @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code@2.164.0, executable /home/azureuser/.ao/audits/candidate-integrations-20261011/tools/codebuddy/node_modules/@tencent-ai/codebuddy-code/bin/codebuddy.

  • Launcher SHA256 426186a82e36466d5be485f335ced1b0d664539c53b72a5f10ba3a267e60dab6.
  • Executed payload dist/codebuddy.js SHA256 2d8e7c1aab61d62f983c85d9fc473c85a2d22afb0e13683920586ba69e82b4a3.
  • Package metadata SHA256 68e0ff61dfa12f526d40e6cc1de24ad7d7f06e93aa3f235753b61b0ddc5a11b8.
  • Real stdio argv: codebuddy --acp --permission-mode default; one historical-profile retry also selected --model glm-5.3-flash. Initial bounded probe additionally supplied additive --append-system-prompt; instruction consumption was never reached.
  • initialize returned protocolVersion 1, loadSession true, image/embeddedContext true; advertised auth methods iOA, external (Google/Github), internal (WeChat), selfhosted. This is handshake discovery, not conformance.
  • First empty isolated profile: session/new and explicit session/load of cb-missing-20261018-not-real both returned {"code":-32000,"message":"Authentication required","data":{"category":"auth"}}.
  • Second bounded attempt minimally copied string-valued native local-storage entries from retained authorized native-005 profile into isolated private0600 files. Same new/load errors.
  • Third attempt minimally copied current native credential-store string entries; same session/new error. Source profiles were read only. All owned native process groups were stopped and waited; exit0 is cleanup, not a passing Chat turn.
  • Installed official source initializeSession awaits auth initialization, then throws authRequired when currentSessionSubject is empty, before session request admission. No account session became available from either existing store. The authorized private DeepSeek configuration exists; its custom provider API key is not a CodeBuddy account session and was not misrepresented as one. No new account, interactive OAuth, token exposure or alternate-provider impersonation attempted.

Acceptance status

Gate Verdict Observed result / dependency
Official executable/version and real initialize PASS (scoped) Fingerprints and native response above; not full protocol qualification
Authenticated new and stable conversation identity BLOCKED Native auth-required before session admission
Exact load / workspace mismatch / missing history BLOCKED Auth rejection precedes history validation; no fresh fallback claimed
Text/reasoning/tools/plans and model/options NOT_RUN No admitted conversation; model flag accepted is not effective-model proof
Native permission allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN No admitted conversation
Executing child interrupt with PID/birth identity; separate AO Kill/control; immediate continuation NOT_RUN No admitted conversation
Fresh private instructions + independent project rules NOT_RUN No provider turn; no claim about wire role
New post-Kill private instruction with same restored history NOT_RUN No native identity/Kill/restore established
Process/daemon restart, detached reconnect, replay without duplication NOT_RUN Native prerequisite blocked
Actual AO Chat UI screenshot and direct attachment BLOCKED Chat not registered/qualified; no authenticated authorized GitHub browser/upload flow available in this execution context. Screenshot unavailable. Historical TUI images remain historical; no replacement PNG/log mirror or committed evidence assets
Independent implementation review NOT_RUN No new implementation to review; acceptance gate remains false
Current-head CI PENDING 9/24 successful, 15 unfinished at report time; no previous-head green substituted

Exact-head CI links

Check Current state Link
api-drift queued job
sqlite-race (2) queued job
cloud-build-test queued job
lint queued job
session-store-race queued job
backend-core (0) queued job
chat-race (0) queued job
sqlite-race (3) queued job
windows-workspace in_progress job
sqlc-drift queued job
sqlite-race (1) queued job
sqlite-race (0) queued job
chat-race (1) queued job
backend-core (1) in_progress job
mac-update-helper success job
renderer-smoke success job
scan success job
native (windows-latest) success job
native (macos-latest) success job
native (ubuntu-latest) success job
linux-proof-artifact success job
test in_progress job
container success job
live-feeds success job

Disposition and cleanup

No build, routine suite, lint, vet, typecheck, fixtures or workflow emulation run on VPS. No AO daemon, Electron instance or AO session launched. Bounded native children stopped; private isolated runtime/profile bytes retained under the supplied owned scratch runtime, no deliverable evidence files added to Git. Production and unrelated controls untouched. Native CLI/source hashes are above; AO binary/UI build/model/session/generation fingerprints are unavailable, because AO Chat qualification never started. No screenshots captured or uploaded. First native failure and both unsuccessful recovery attempts are retained inline above.

Required external prerequisite: an already authorized, valid CodeBuddy native account session usable by ACP, or an officially supported release/path that admits the authorized custom-provider configuration without that account prerequisite. Then rerun the full native/AO/UI lifecycle gates. A legitimate direct GitHub screenshot attachment mechanism is also required for final handoff. No merge, release or deployment performed. The queue moving on does not resolve this blocker.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:43:35Z

Original comment

Reconciliation pass only on the authorized VPS. Refreshed live PR head 97b8515eee55969908d93be81bf43bd191b57149 and canonical main 6e8d6e4e04ab210ee8dcf9678e337a6ef6d60a8c. Preserve the existing merge and all contributor/history changes. Resolve the append-only migration ledger by retaining main 210–212, moving pending CodeBuddy migration above main to 214 (213 is an observed concurrent open claim), and retaining preview 207 as burned. Update executable migration references; historical evidence stays untouched. No ACP implementation/builds or routine local suites in this pass. Refresh both heads again before push; report exact-head CI as pending where unfinished.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T21:44:17Z

Original comment

RECONCILED — reconciliation pass only; ACP readiness not claimed.

Pushed c5b7dcafff14e9df1db6f37d0d59e9efa7147b55 normally to nikhilachale/agent-orchestrator:feat/codebuddy-code-tui-integration, integrating actual canonical main 6e8d6e4e04ab210ee8dcf9678e337a6ef6d60a8c. Both actual remotes refreshed at start, immediately before push, and again before this report; no additional advancement. Existing PR head 97b8515eee55969908d93be81bf43bd191b57149 and main are preserved in merge ancestry. Worktree clean.

Conflict decisions: combined the migration ledger instead of selecting either side. Main's merged 210–212 migrations are unchanged. Moved pending CodeBuddy migration 207 to 214 above current main (213 has an observed open competing claim), updated executable test/comment references, and retained 207 as burned for preview databases. Existing repair coverage still seeds preview 207. Historical evidence, first failures, contributor TUI work, native defaults, and Chat registration remain unchanged. No ACP implementation in this pass; prior account-session/UI blockers remain historical unresolved qualification gaps, not reconciliation blockers. Recheck migration allocation before eventual merge.

Validation Status
Merge ancestry, conflict markers, diff whitespace, clean worktree PASS (static inspection)
Routine suites/build/native/UI qualification NOT_RUN in this pass; routine suites restricted to PR CI
Current-head CI PENDING; snapshot below, no previous-head green substituted
Current-head check Status Link
renderer-smoke queued check
mac-update-helper queued check
sqlite-race (0) queued check
backend-core (1) queued check
sqlite-race (1) queued check
lint queued check
sqlite-race (2) queued check
sqlite-race (3) queued check
test queued check
windows-workspace in_progress check
sqlc-drift queued check
api-drift queued check
backend-core (0) queued check
chat-race (0) queued check
scan queued check
session-store-race queued check
chat-race (1) in_progress check
native (ubuntu-latest) queued check
native (macos-latest) in_progress check
native (windows-latest) queued check
cloud-build-test queued check
linux-proof-artifact in_progress check
live-feeds in_progress check
container in_progress check

Cleanup: parent already removed only verified unused ignored historical node_modules, disposable npm cache, and two superseded vendor versions, checking affected Git status and lockfile hashes unchanged. This pass deleted no additional data; approximately 2.8 GiB free at preflight. No source/history/credentials/screenshots/evidence removed, no audit processes launched, no production state touched. No new report/evidence files committed, no action on PR6509, no merge/release/deployment. Full current-head CI and ACP acceptance will be revisited in the ACP pass.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:34:03Z

Original comment

Continuing ACP implementation on refreshed live head a766da0d9dc89a31e8163b038fa09e425829c6f1, integrated canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669; both already current, checkout clean. Read current architecture and fallback harness/process skills. Existing TUI and historical evidence remain intact.

Implementation plan: add chatdriver/codebuddyacp as an explicitly unregistered candidate using shared nativeacp/persistenthost, exact installed 2.164.0 admission, additive native private instructions (bounded UTF-8), default native approval policy, and existing foreground/no-update native controls. Reject unqualified model/effort/permission settings. Add regression coverage for launch boundary, version admission, unsupported settings and shipped-registry exclusion. No new migration/API change is needed. Do not register or claim native restore conformance before real authentication/history proof. Routine tests run only in PR CI; source review independently checks the candidate.

Retain first native authentication-required failures from the prior final comment; no login retry/key substitution. Current disk ~1.1 GiB; no further cleanup, dependency installs or expensive build planned. Missing authenticated new/load blocks real Chat lifecycle, private instruction consumption and correlated AO UI proof, but does not stop this source work. Screenshot direct attachment remains unqualified. No modifications/comments to #6509; no merge/release/deploy.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-18T22:37:43Z

Original comment

BLOCKED — gated candidate implemented; not READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE.

Final refresh of both actual branches: pushed/live head b499e9beb17668bbe1253649f9a0ea2e32b5ee91, integrated canonical main 55b02b848dd3f05f4d010fc5d603d5e9e6217669; both unchanged and main is an ancestor. Clean worktree. Normal push to nikhilachale/agent-orchestrator:feat/codebuddy-code-tui-integration; no history rewrite. Existing contributor work, migration 0215, TUI behavior and historical evidence retained. No new migration/API/generated output needed.

Source progress and review

Added chatdriver/codebuddyacp.NewCandidate using shared nativeacp/persistenthost. It launches the exact user-installed executable with --acp --permission-mode default, bounded additive --append-system-prompt, and the same native foreground/no-cron/no-update controls as TUI. Native default prompts and independent project/user rules are not replaced. Empty model selection preserves native defaults; all explicit model/effort selections and nondefault/unknown permission values are rejected until qualified. No hidden instructions concatenated into visible tasks. Version probe admits exact 2.164.0 only; this is a compatibility check, not authenticated binary attestation.

Chat remains unregistered in the shipped driver registry. Meaningful authored CI regressions cover additive/default prompt arguments, instruction UTF-8/NUL/64KiB bounds, settings rejection, exact version admission and shipped-registry exclusion. No runtime/fixture suites, lint, vet, typecheck or workflow emulation ran locally. gofmt and git diff --check completed. No builds performed.

Independent read-only reviewer examined the candidate and shared seams: no remaining actionable findings after strict raw permission admission replaced normalization (which would accept unknown values as default). Review was source-only; no compile/native/UI qualification. This is independent candidate review, not final full integration approval.

Native fingerprints and retained first failures

Actual installed executable /home/azureuser/.ao/audits/candidate-integrations-20261011/tools/codebuddy/node_modules/@tencent-ai/codebuddy-code/bin/codebuddy returned 2.164.0 in this continuation. SHA256 rechecked:

  • Launcher 426186a82e36466d5be485f335ced1b0d664539c53b72a5f10ba3a267e60dab6.
  • Executed dist/codebuddy.js payload 2d8e7c1aab61d62f983c85d9fc473c85a2d22afb0e13683920586ba69e82b4a3.
  • Package metadata 68e0ff61dfa12f526d40e6cc1de24ad7d7f06e93aa3f235753b61b0ddc5a11b8.

Shipped source contains the additive argument and native foreground environment controls. This does not prove provider consumption. Retained original native ACP/auth failures remain authoritative as originally recorded. Native initialize advertised v1/loadSession; real session/new and explicit load returned authentication-required before admission across the prior bounded isolated-profile attempts. No blind authentication retry, key substitution or private vendor patch in this continuation. Account configuration is not authorization. No stable authenticated native session/model/AO generation exists for this candidate; provider wire role remains unknown.

Acceptance

Gate Verdict Scope / blocker
Source candidate and registry gate PASS (source inspection) Implemented, formatted, pushed; test execution pending CI
Exact released version/fingerprint PASS (scoped) Version and hashes above; not protocol conformance
Real authenticated initialize/new and protocol BLOCKED Retained native account-session auth-required before session admission
Exact load, missing history/workspace rejection BLOCKED Auth prevents reaching native history validation; no fresh fallback proof
Stable identity/text/reasoning/tools/plans/options NOT_RUN No authenticated conversation; optional capabilities unadvertised
Permission allow/reject/cancel NOT_RUN Requires admitted real native session
Executing child interrupt PID/birth identity; separate AO Kill/control; continuation NOT_RUN Native prerequisite blocked
Fresh private instructions and independent project rules NOT_RUN Launch channel implemented; actual consumption unproved
NEW instructions after confirmed Kill on SAME history NOT_RUN No Kill/identity/restore proof
Detached reconnect, process/daemon restart and replay without duplication NOT_RUN Shared implementation reused; harness qualification absent
Actual AO Chat UI and durable direct screenshot attachment BLOCKED Chat deliberately unregistered and native account unavailable; no actual Chat capture/attachment. UI/build/session/generation fingerprints unavailable. Historical TUI images do not qualify Chat
Independent review PASS (candidate source only) Read-only reviewer; full live integration review remains pending
Current-head required CI PENDING Exact-head workflows below; no earlier-head green substituted

Exact-head CI inspected at 2026-10-18T22:37:42.528646+00:00

Workflow Status
gitleaks queued
Harness release feeds queued
CLI E2E queued
Go pending
Harness proof build success
Frontend in_progress

No completed failure logs exist for these unfinished workflows at inspection. CI is not claimed green; Go is pending admission/queue, other workflows queued/in progress. Required current-head results still need follow-up before readiness.

Cleanup and remaining action

No owned daemon, Electron app, audit session or provider turn was started in this continuation; bounded version command exited. No production restart/profile/tunnel/token change. No additional disk deletion; ~1.1GiB free. Parent cleanup removed only verified unused ignored historical dependencies/rebuildable cache/superseded vendor copies and checked source status/lockfile hashes unchanged; source/history/credentials/evidence were preserved. New detailed receipts exist only inline here; no report/JSON/PNG evidence committed. #6509 received zero modifications/comments. No merge/release/deploy.

Remaining external prerequisite: a valid CodeBuddy native account session using the authorized account, then real ACP lifecycle/standing-instruction/restore/UI qualification and direct screenshot publication. Candidate source and tests can be reviewed now without that login. Current-head CI must finish and genuine failures must be resolved before any ready claim. Keep Chat unregistered.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T15:53:09Z

Original comment

Continuing existing PR6546 after fresh fetch of actual nikhilachale:feat/codebuddy-code-tui-integration head cd56c657748d75054d5a50e7b1aff8bed4475ca3 and canonical main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf. The concurrent contributor auth-plan change is fast-forwarded and preserved. Main merge has two concrete conflicts: installer Job target/status and migration ledger 215. Resolve semantically, retain main merged migrations and burned preview ledger; allocate pending CodeBuddy migration by current timestamp generator and update executable migration references. Historical evidence stays untouched.

Then improve the existing actual NewCandidate driver/lifecycle regression coverage without duplicate transport/registration: use current shared ACP/persistenthost seams, fail closed on unqualified settings/restore identity, preserve native default prompt/permissions, and independently review source. Routine suites execute only in PR CI. Existing native2.164.0 auth-required failures are retained; no blind login retries/provider-key substitutions. ~540MiB disk: no dependency install/build allocation/additional deletion. Native account/UI/direct-attachment qualification remain separate and do not stop safe source/CI progress. No production or PR6509 actions.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:06:35Z

Original comment

Pushed 992668a6d40db5ea2d36f8cc73354fd4707fad3b normally after fresh actual PR/main integration. Contains canonical main ff6e7b3a424e8e0765f0fc521572e52d2aefdfaf and concurrent contributor auth-plan change cd56c657; no work overwritten.

Actual driver changes: strict exact-ID Resume/Reconnect; only proven host absence permits replacement/disk-history preflight, so a live first turn adopts its existing host; replacement never falls back fresh. Native history/workspace validation reuses the agent plugin. Exact2.164.0 is checked on actual launches as well as Probe. The observed ACP1/load handshake is required (stock omits AgentInfo; no identity invented). Direct config setters now obey the candidate's unqualified-settings refusal. Explicit image/context/steer gates survive native advertisement. Existing shared conversations keep history/ACK/hibernation/termination/live-reconnect ports.

Native profile safety: candidate launch/replacement now requires an explicitly preprovisioned session-owned profile at AO DataDir/agents/codebuddy/chat/sessionID with the exact private ownership marker. No implicit real native-home mutation, automatic credential replacement or source-profile copying. This lab prerequisite is not shipped profile setup support; candidate remains unregistered.

Tests authored through actual NewCandidate and the real detached host against an explicitly synthetic stdio executable: Start/Send/successful terminal receipt+ACK, config refusal, exact replacement/replay/private-context separation, no fresh fallback, first-turn live adoption, missing host/history preflight, auth/version/profile refusal. Additional controlled permission/interrupt coverage is being completed. These are source/transport regressions, not real CodeBuddy lifecycle proof. Routine suites remain CI-only.

Migration reconciliation 6fb893be: retained merged main213/214/215, preserved installer CodeBuddy target plus waiting_for_idle, moved pending CodeBuddy SQL unchanged to generator-allocated 20261019155340715_allow_codebuddy_harness.sql, retained burned207. Added pre-goose repair only for identifiable CodeBuddy previews whose collided214/215 canonical effects are entirely absent; partial canonical schema refuses transactionally. Regressions preserve existing preview sessions, check main tables/triggers/version-refresh, repeat migration idempotency and partial-schema rollback. No merged migration modified.

Independent read-only review identified and rechecked the source defects; no remaining actionable source finding in the pushed change. No compilation/suites/provider calls performed by reviewer. Current-head CI is pending and will be inspected; prior green cd56c657 is historical. First native auth-required failure remains retained; no blind login retry/key substitution. Actual AO Chat/native/UI/attachment gates remain blocked. ~517MiB free: no build/dependency allocation or deletion. No production/native/daemon/Electron process launched; historical evidence untouched; no new repository report/evidence files or PR6509 actions.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:12:31Z

Original comment

Current pushed head e674ea3d158bf0d8b66ea20e00f540f64173170f includes actual main 94a769ddd86f233e041faca054d9d59310f05836, refreshed again before each normal push. Main browser-close fixes and contributor auth changes are preserved.

Independent read-only reviewer confirms actual ports-compatible codebuddyacp.NewCandidate and lifecycle wiring, rather than helpers alone. Reviewed strict replacement/no-fresh-fallback history checks, attach-first live adoption, exact launch-version admission, direct config restrictions, explicit prompt-capability exclusions, and owned-profile prerequisite. Optional conversation history/ACK/hibernate/terminate/reconnect interfaces remain intact. Preview migration214/215 collision repair preserves main canonical migrations and identifiable CodeBuddy sessions; partial canonical schema refuses transactionally.

Controlled process tests now invoke the actual candidate through the real persistent host, using an explicitly synthetic provider. Added allow/reject/unoffered-decision refusal, pending-approval cancellation, streaming interruption, successful terminal receipts/ACK and executed immediate continuation. Review found two fixture issues: continuation raced post-turn Ready, and cancelled permission RPC remained outstanding. Both corrected: wait for post-terminal Ready, emit pinned SDK $/cancel_request with original requestId, require matching ApprovalResolved, and refuse the stale request before continuation. Reviewer rechecked final correction and found no remaining actionable source defect. No compilation/tests/provider calls executed locally or by reviewer. These are authored regressions, not native CodeBuddy permission/child proof.

Current-head Go, Frontend, CLI, proof artifact, feeds, scan: queued. Prior25/25 at cd56c65 is historical, not this head. ImplementationComplete=false until full current-head CI is green; qualificationComplete=false.

Candidate remains unregistered. Native2.164.0 account-session auth-required first failure is retained; no blind retry/key substitution. Native/AO/UI/private-instruction/child/Kill proof remains incomplete; private provider wire role unknown. Explicit session-owned native profile provisioning is a candidate prerequisite, not shipped automatic credential/profile setup. Actual UI screenshot/direct attachment unavailable. No native/AO/Electron process launched, no local suites or dependency/build allocation/deletion. Historical evidence/production/PR6509 untouched.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-19T16:19:55Z

Original comment

WORKING / waiting for current-head CI. Not implementationComplete, qualificationComplete or READY_FROM_OUR_SIDE. Snapshot 2026-10-19T16:19:42.085156+00:00, before the human deadline2026-10-19T16:43:36Z. Current source progress is pushed and preserved; no all-nine completion claim.

Fresh actual PR branch and canonical main were fetched/reconciled immediately before this snapshot and every normal push. Head c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e contains actual main d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c; worktree clean. Normal pushes preserve contributor ancestry and concurrent edits; no force push/reset/rebase. Main's newest Xterm correction merged cleanly. GitHub mergeable=True; draft=False (existing state preserved).

Existing CodeBuddy Code TUI plus actual unregistered NewCandidate Chat driver. New source enforces attach-first live adoption, strict replacement history/identity and no fresh fallback, launch-time exact version, direct config restrictions, explicit prompt capability gates, and a preprovisioned AO-session-owned native profile. It preserves native default prompt/default permission mode and source profiles. No shipped Chat/profile setup claim.

6fb893be preserves main213/214/215, moves pending CodeBuddy SQL unchanged to generator-allocated20261019155340715, and repairs identifiable preview214/215 collisions without changing merged migrations or deleting sessions. 992668a6 adds actual driver guards and process regressions; 9cab3455/e674ea3d finish controlled permission/cancel/interrupt/continuation coverage. Tests use an explicitly synthetic stdio executable through the actual detached host, require successful terminal receipt/ACK, approval resolution and Ready. Independent review identified and rechecked both fixture defects. No suite was run locally.

Gate Result Exact scope / remaining work
Actual ports-compatible driver and meaningful regressions PASS source review Actual constructors/lifecycle/config/history code, not helpers alone; independent review. Reviewed driver source unchanged by later main-only merge.
Formatting, diff whitespace, merge ancestry and clean worktree PASS static Performed on this VPS; not a runtime/build result.
Complete current-head CI BLOCKED, queued/pending 10 check runs currently reported; none failed/completed successfully at this observation. Full workflow/job states below, including Go. Prior-head green is historical.
Real native authenticated new/load BLOCKED Valid native CodeBuddy account session unavailable; configured credentials are not authorization.
Real private instructions, model/options, permissions and child cancellation NOT_RUN Native session admission prerequisite remains blocked.
Real AO Kill/control, exact restore, restart/reconnect/replay NOT_RUN Synthetic transport regressions do not establish these native/AO gates.
Actual current-source AO Chat UI BLOCKED Only 499MiB free, below512MiB proof reserve. No current desktop/dependencies/artifact allocation or native/AO runtime launch; no UI screenshot captured.
Legitimate durable direct screenshot attachment BLOCKED No established authorized attachment flow; no fabricated screenshot, terminal mirror, committed image or evidence branch.
Independent source review PASS within stated scope No remaining actionable source defect found after fixes; not GitHub approval or live conformance.
Routine local suites/lint/vet/typecheck/fixtures/workflow emulation NOT_RUN Human CI-only instruction honored.

Source driver SHA256 46c30901d538a8a2346d6516afc3af62cff0dbc57cd3fa93e478c5200ebb5469 at source head above. Historical official2.164.0 launcher SHA256 426186a82e36466d5be485f335ced1b0d664539c53b72a5f10ba3a267e60dab6; payload SHA256 2d8e7c1aab61d62f983c85d9fc473c85a2d22afb0e13683920586ba69e82b4a3. No native version/provider/account probe was rerun in this continuation. Current-source AO binary/UI hashes, native model/session/generation and screenshot provenance: unavailable, because no runtime/build/UI was launched. Provider wire role remains unknown for any unobserved authenticated request. Retained native evidence/first failures. Real native2.164.0 initialize advertises load but session/new and session/load returned auth-required with the bounded empty/historical/current isolated credential-store attempts. Those first failures remain unchanged. No blind login retry, account creation or provider-key substitution was attempted.

Current-head workflows:

Workflow Actual state
CLI E2E QUEUED
Frontend QUEUED
gitleaks QUEUED
Harness proof build QUEUED
Go QUEUED
Harness release feeds QUEUED

Reported current-head jobs:

Check Actual state Link
linux-proof-artifact QUEUED job
test QUEUED job
mac-update-helper QUEUED job
live-feeds QUEUED job
native (windows-latest) QUEUED job
scan QUEUED job
native (ubuntu-latest) QUEUED job
renderer-smoke QUEUED job
container QUEUED job
native (macos-latest) QUEUED job

Every available current-head result was inspected; no failing log is available for queued jobs. Superseded ancestor-run cancellation was requested only on the two owned PR branches to release concurrency; current-head checks were never cancelled, skipped or disabled. Some old-run cancel calls returned409/not-in-progress; that was not relabeled a successful recovery. GitHub REST and GraphQL both report the current queue; hosted CI execution remains external. Next action is inspect all current-head outcomes, retrieve actual failing logs and repair genuine failures through refreshed normal pushes. Operational checkpoint stays working, implementationComplete=false; no irreducible source-blocker or final green-CI claim.

Cleanup: no owned native/AO/daemon/Electron/audit sessions were launched, so none required termination. Production, credentials/native profiles, histories, existing evidence, unrelated controls and other workers' PRs were untouched. Parent cleanup was limited to verified unused ignored dependencies, disposable npm cache and superseded vendor copies, with source/status/lockfile checks unchanged. This worker performed no additional disk cleanup, dependency/build allocation, merge/release/deployment, or PR6509 modification/comment. All new narratives remain inline here; no new repository report/JSON/PNG evidence assets.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:27:21Z

Original comment

Fresh testing-only retest starting for codebuddy at current PR head c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e using harness skill bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db. One bounded serial attempt (25-minute maximum; eight-minute output-stall watchdog); isolated source/runtime. Previous evidence is historical and will not count as fresh proof. Full 12-area matrix and screenshot checkpoints will follow in a new comment. No implementation, pushes, production restart, or excluded PR changes.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 2/2

Historical material from original PR #6546, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:36:21Z

Original comment

CodeBuddy testing-only current-status evidence — BLOCKED / incomplete integration (2026-10-21T05:36:20.346696+00:00)

  • Runtime-tested source and fresh current PR head: c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e (unchanged).
  • Exact staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all 15 staged files match that commit. Strict runner only; no product/source edits, pushes, merges, installs or reviewer publication.
  • Recorded comparison main: 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd; read-only divergence 24 main-only / 26 PR-only commits. Current GitHub base d1f210d9e7e57f7dff5a52bcfc7887d58ab7da6c; mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. No main merge attempted.
  • Linux amd64; Node v24.21.0; Go go1.27.1. Backend binary is a real file named ao, reports dev, embeds tested SHA and vcs.modified=false.

Binary SHA-256:

Binary Version SHA-256
native 2.164.0 426186a82e36466d5be485f335ced1b0d664539c53b72a5f10ba3a267e60dab6
native-headless 2.164.0 f9affe2aed036a3a3ee8486b82e77b176a2a4b21f7bed721074c1c1e4a312e65
native-tui 2.164.0 2d8e7c1aab61d62f983c85d9fc473c85a2d22afb0e13683920586ba69e82b4a3
ao dev 82d250d2fef4e2bd5a1275bacc3fe81f091cc7085ddb0efdfe2c69f45fd4fc41

Fresh command/attempt receipt:

  • Native codebuddy --version: 2026-10-21T05:28:43.010908+00:00–2026-10-21T05:28:43.042824+00:00, exit 0, 2.164.0; output SHA-256 8b9b02ec11edcb605bbfeef648977963d402ec375abc92806d425566b7af6a66. Native entrypoint independently confirms this argv. Parent version evidence was not used as provider proof.
  • Native codebuddy --help: 2026-10-21T05:28:43.043116+00:00–2026-10-21T05:28:45.806499+00:00, exit 0; output SHA-256 283bf08f881ba116818c3ebf2da597f7f1884baad3b27eb24ed24f87be9775be. Advertises TUI, -p, --model, --resume, --append-system-prompt and --acp. It exposes no standalone model catalog/auth-status subcommand; doctor describes updater health. This is capability discovery, not verified auth.
  • Only live-backend build: GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB go build -o <runtime>/bin/ao ./cmd/ao; 2026-10-21T05:29:24.471718+00:00–2026-10-21T05:30:08.483019+00:00, exit 0. Free disk after build 1716 MiB; 700 MiB floor preserved. Routine unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/frontend/runner fixtures were CI ONLY and not run here.
  • strict-001: 2026-10-21T05:31:44.271Z–2026-10-21T05:31:53.901Z, exit 1, finalized state finished, summary BLOCKED. First blocking gate authentication: "CodeBuddy Code has credentials configured, but AO could not verify them." Binary/version/help, registration/installation/fresh probe passed; native workspace turn/model catalog and all TUI lifecycle gates NOT_RUN. Runner daemon PID 1456053, readiness HTTP 200; stopped=true, exit 0. No diagnostic attempt: direct native workspace proof prerequisite absent.
  • Separate API inspection: 2026-10-21T05:32:48.218100+00:00–2026-10-21T05:32:55.335396+00:00, owned daemon PID 1456841, kernel-start 160652103; /readyz PID matched and executable matched the hashed AO build. Models GET and refresh POST: HTTP 200, selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, allowCustom=true, source=manual, models=[]; refreshed timestamp changed. Empty catalog was not converted to a strict PASS.
  • Explicit Chat request: HTTP 409, SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, spawn: chat mode unsupported for harness: codebuddy has no chat driver; request ID vps-linux/m4M2LVUEd3-000011; subsequent GET /sessions returned sessions: []. Settings omit codebuddy from chatHarnesses. No TUI fallback.
  • Native configured provider/model metadata: Zai, glm-5.3-flash, api.z.ai coding endpoint; effective native model/provider and authorization NOT_RUN. One minimum known models config was copied into the isolated profile; only its credential was passed in memory to establish configured-state probing. No original profile/history/plugin store was copied wholesale; original minimum config still matches. No account reset or login.
  • Native live safety blocker (source-derived, not a provider/auth failure): installed full startup initializes home-relative .codebuddy diagnostics/memwatch and retention cleanup using os.homedir() despite CODEBUDDY_CONFIG_DIR. Complete native storage isolation was not qualified under this task’s original-profile protection boundary. Native provider/file witness was therefore NOT_RUN. Version/help produced no matching original-home memwatch log. No native executing-command cancellation or exact restore was attempted.
  • No fabricated native model listing, interrupt input or restoredReady pattern. Native startup/settled/draft/restored samples absent. The AO adapter only accepts Default; runner bypass is incompatible if lifecycle becomes eligible. No weakened diagnostic run or forced provider turn.

Reproduction (generic paths; selected contract is intentionally incomplete):

cd <source>/backend
GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB go build -o <runtime>/bin/ao ./cmd/ao
TMPDIR=<runtime>/tmp NODE_OPTIONS=--max-old-space-size=384 node <staged-skill>/scripts/audit_ao.mjs \
  --agent codebuddy --repo <source> --ao <runtime>/bin/ao \
  --local-contract <runtime>/contract.json --report <runtime>/strict-001/report \
  --timeout-seconds 25 --startup-timeout-seconds 45

Use the same authorized credential route privately; do not print credentials or run login. Credential presence alone remains configured. TMPDIR, native config, AO data/run files and all outputs resolve under the private PR runtime. No Electron was launched. Contract public equivalent (native path redacted only):

{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "agents": {
    "codebuddy": {
      "binary": "<native>/codebuddy",
      "versionArgs": [
        "--version"
      ],
      "integration": {
        "args": [
          "--help"
        ],
        "expect": "CodeBuddy Code"
      },
      "aoModelsPath": "agents/{agent}/models"
    }
  }
}

Exact private contract bytes SHA-256 f97b31db2d22d79620a417f9828437a004b3ac8d4b105e7770911238ff20c419; strict JSON SHA-256 65ff341cb434d581c584a71aa8eab43f1107f1c294101975ed717c74e6faa42e. The exact local binary path is intentionally replaced above. integration=--help proves command availability only. session/models/interrupt/restoredReady are omitted with reasons, not invented. Native references: environment configuration, model configuration; pinned executable/source and current AO docs are the version-specific evidence.

Completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Registered foreground TUI worker/orchestrator; shared task/settings UI BLOCKED Current daemon inventory/probe identifies codebuddy and installed=true. API enum/registry traced. Actual Electron unavailable: current checkout has no frontend/node_modules; installs and borrowed dependencies forbidden.
Models Native --model ID; AO text/direct entry, manual source BLOCKED GET models and POST refresh both HTTP 200, selectionMode=text, customModelEntry=direct, models=[]. No standalone native catalog command established. Both UI surfaces, visibility/bulk/picker changes and effective native model NOT_RUN; no fake catalog/toggles.
Providers Existing native third-party configuration; native-owned account/routing BLOCKED Minimum known model config copied privately with 0700/0600 protection; configured Zai / glm-5.3-flash / api.z.ai metadata only. No provider authorization or effective routing verified. AO setup is documentation-only; add/change/remove/account UI and native changes NOT_RUN.
Setup Pinned native installer; documentation-only AO setup NOT_RUN Installer API advertises npm @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code@2.164.0; update unavailable until qualified. Auth plan action=setup, launchMode=documentation. Installation/upgrades/login/logout/account reset prohibited; no setup flow executed.
Readiness Linux amd64 binary, fresh local configuration observation BLOCKED Fresh version 2.164.0, installed=true and configured auth. Strict first blocking gate: authentication; AO cannot verify credentials. No supported safe auth-status command established; configured does not mean authorized. Other OS runtime coverage NOT_RUN.
Identity and logo CodeBuddy Code label with documented initials fallback BLOCKED Native help and AO probe use CodeBuddy Code. docs/harnesses/codebuddy.md records fallback because suitable official asset redistribution terms are unverified. Actual avatar/logo UI capture unavailable.
TUI and Chat AO TUI adapter; native ACP advertised, AO Chat excluded/unregistered BLOCKED Strict TUI lifecycle not admitted after unverified auth. Explicit Chat request HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED, no fallback/session created. ACP help flag is not conformance. Chat streaming/history/approvals/cancel/recovery remain NOT_RUN; not classified as upstream-unsupported N/A.
Reviewer No CodeBuddy AO reviewer registration or qualified native review contract NOT_RUN Separate reviewer vocabulary/registry exclude codebuddy. No actual reviewer picker/run/result/cancel/rerun. Native --agents is not reviewer qualification. External review/publication forbidden; no reviewer execution or GitHub review was performed.
Permissions and instructions AO native Default only; additive --append-system-prompt in source NOT_RUN Current adapter rejects accept-edits/auto/bypass. Strict runner requests bypass-permissions only if lifecycle admitted; it never reached spawn. No permissions bypass was forced. Hidden/project instruction delivery and independent consumption untested.
Lifecycle Foreground cancel, Kill/archive, exact native restore are claimed by adapter NOT_RUN No provider session or executing-command PID/kernel-start witness. Therefore cancellation/reaping/delayed-side-effect absence, native ID/history continuity, initialized restored composer, refreshed instructions, Kanban return and reconnect are unproven. Daemon teardown is separate and passed.
Evidence Pinned strict attempt, independent safe API receipts, full UI checkpoint index BLOCKED Strict attempt exit 1 / BLOCKED preserved; no diagnostic attempt (native workspace proof absent). Actual screenshots absent. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED; no approved uploader. Empty private attachment queue retained; no invented URLs or archived screenshots.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub checks; testing-only handoff FAIL 25 latest check runs: 19 success, 6 failure, none pending. mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. No local routine suites or fixes. Cleanup PASS, source clean, parent PR-description evidence-link update pending.

Every screenshot checkpoint was indexed before actions. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. Current frontend dependencies are absent; npm ci/install and symlinking/using an old frontend are prohibited. Existing UI launchers hardcode another checkout and were read only, never launched. No real safe PNG was captured; private attachment queue has zero entries and BLOCKED uploader status. No local path counts as published image evidence. Action/result states below remain separate from the attachment status.

Checkpoint/substep Action → observed result Functional status Screenshot/attachment status and reason
harness-listed Discover harness → API registered/installed; actual Agent Harness page not opened BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
install-offer Open install offer → API pinned npm method observed; page/action not seen BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
install-run Start install → not started; provider installation/upgrades prohibited NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
auth-before Inspect credentials → fresh API configured only; actual page unavailable BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
auth-action Open login/setup → documentation plan only; login/account flows prohibited NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
auth-ready Refresh authorization → configured, not verified; no provider turn BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
auth-maintenance Change account/logout/retry → not executed; accepted original profile preserved NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
harness-models List/refresh Models → API text/direct and empty catalog; actual panel unavailable BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
model-visibility Toggle off/on/bulk and reload pickers → no established catalog, UI absent; no fabricated entries NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
provider-management Inspect/change provider → config metadata only; no UI/configuration/routing proof BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
task-agent New task select CodeBuddy → task dialog unavailable BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
task-model Choose native model → text/direct API mode; actual picker/effective model unobserved BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
task-running Submit task → no admitted provider session; running/output/settled result absent NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
task-followup Send follow-up → no ready native or Chat conversation NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
task-cancel Stop executing command → no real command PID/kernel-start witness NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
kill-action Archive/Kill → no worker session created NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
archived Find archived entry → no worker session created NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
restore-action Restore exact entry → no native ID/history or fresh readiness samples NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
kanban-return Return restored card and continue → no restored session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
chat Create and exercise Chat → explicit API rejection, no registered driver; positive subjourneys below unrun NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
reviewer-select Select CodeBuddy reviewer → absent reviewer registration; actual picker unavailable NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
reviewer-running Execute/cancel reviewer → no qualified registered reviewer; no run NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
reviewer-result Read result/rerun → no run/result; external publication unauthorized NOT_RUN BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
reconnect-cleanup Reconnect/recover UI → no UI/session; owned daemon shutdown passed independently BLOCKED BLOCKED: No actual current-checkout Electron: frontend dependencies absent and installation forbidden. No capture or published attachment; approved uploader unavailable.
chat/new-task Native session/new and first task once → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/followup-stream Shared composer, partial stream and file/output witness → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/load-history Exact native session/load, ordered replay and continuation → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/approve Offered approval and gated side effect → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/reject Separate rejection with no denied side effect → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/cancel-active-tool Stop turn with real PID/kernel-start and late-file absence → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/ui-reconnect Reload/subscription reconnect without duplicate turn → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned detached host adoption and continuation → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/kill-restore-instructions Archive/restore same conversation and new private instructions → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/negative-restore-capability Missing-history/workspace controls; explicit Chat capability rejection separately passed → not exercised: no CodeBuddy Chat driver/session NOT_RUN BLOCKED: Actual AO UI unavailable; no published attachment. Native ACP advertised but unqualified; API-only rejection is not this journey.
chat/explicit-rejection Explicit mode=chat → HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; sessions=[] PASS BLOCKED: Functional daemon negative control passed; no actual UI or published attachment.
reviewer/publication External GitHub reviewer publication → not attempted NOT_RUN NOT_RUN: Explicit permission boundary; no reviewer registered or executed; no screenshot.

Current-head CI (GitHub helper readback; all returned head SHAs match tested SHA):

Job State / conclusion Receipt
build-test completed / failure job
backend-core (1) completed / failure job
sqlite-race (1) completed / success job
chat-race (0) completed / success job
sqlite-race (2) completed / success job
sqlite-race (0) completed / success job
backend-core (0) completed / failure job
sqlc-drift completed / success job
lint completed / failure job
session-store-race completed / failure job
chat-race (1) completed / success job
windows-workspace completed / success job
sqlite-race (3) completed / success job
api-drift completed / success job
cloud-build-test completed / failure job
linux-proof-artifact completed / success job
test completed / success job
mac-update-helper completed / success job
live-feeds completed / success job
native (windows-latest) completed / success job
scan completed / success job
native (ubuntu-latest) completed / success job
renderer-smoke completed / success job
container completed / success job
native (macos-latest) completed / success job

Cleanup and unresolved handoff:

  • Cleanup PASS at 2026-10-21T05:34:04.395819+00:00: strict daemon exited 0; independent API daemon exited 0 and was reaped; no runtime-owned AO/native/UI processes remain. Worker/control ancestors were excluded by ancestry/start identity and left intact. No broad kill, global stop, production restart, worktree removal or data cleanup occurred.
  • Source remains clean including untracked paths; no branch/source modifications or committed evidence. Private retained classes: plan, exact non-secret contract, receipts/reports/logs, hashed binaries, isolated daemon data and protected minimum native configuration. No screenshots, raw profiles or databases are published. Parent retains final process verification and clean detached worktree removal.
  • Remaining gaps: verified provider authorization and safe fully isolated native workspace/file turn; native model discovery/effective route; Default-permission TUI spawn and guarded follow-up; real command cancellation/Kill and exact restore/new instructions; both actual model surfaces/picker preference effects; provider/account/setup operations; ACP Chat conformance and missing AO driver; independent reviewer qualification/registry/UI/run; every real Electron checkpoint and durable attachment; six failing CI jobs and merge conflict.
  • Next action: arrange a qualified native storage isolation boundary without changing accepted original profiles; preserve this strict BLOCKED attempt, then perform only separately authorized fresh native and AO Default-mode proof. Supply current-checkout Electron dependencies via the parent’s authorized preparation and an approved attachment route. Supported Chat/reviewer wiring gaps require separately authorized product work; this worker cannot implement them. Parent must link this new evidence comment from the PR description (pending; description untouched). Full integration PASS remains unavailable.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T16:31:00Z

Original comment

Re-review against harness skill #7081 — changes required

Reviewed exact PR head c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e on the VPS using SKILL.md at 04c8c95b and its integration guide. Product source was not modified. This is a review, not an approval or a claim of completed native qualification.

Findings

  1. [P1] Implement the terminal version-refresh contract and its fixtures. CodeBuddy Plugin never implements ports.AgentTerminalVersionRefresher. The skill scan reports TUI 11/13 required touchpoints; refresh and its matrix are missing. Exact-head CI confirms both TestEveryRefreshHarnessResumesExactConversation/codebuddy: missing explicit refresh capability (backend-core 0) and TestTerminalRefreshSupportMatrix: codebuddy refresh capability = false, want true (session-store-race). Add the explicit capability and exact-history fixtures; do not weaken the history guard just to satisfy the matrix.

  2. [P1] Add real authentication verification. AuthStatus can return only configured when one of two environment variables exists, or unknown. There is no branch that verifies a native login or returns authorized. That means this implementation cannot establish Connected after a successful native login, independently of whether a user has credentials. The new skill explicitly requires “verified, not just configured”. Fresh strict audit: CLI installed/version, AO registered/installed and freeform model API PASS; ao_authenticated FAIL: Authentication check was inconclusive; authenticated lifecycle/role checks SKIP. Implement and prove a supported native/provider verification route; neither environment presence nor another harness's login is sufficient. I did not read credentials or log in/out.

  3. [P2] Return a typed client error for missing native restore history. GetRestoreCommand propagates ordinary errors from the history guard. These survive restoreArgv and fall through to HTTP 500. Reproduced on this head in the isolated desktop: create a Default-permission CodeBuddy TUI session → immediately Kill → Restore. Spawn 201, Kill 200, Restore 500 INTERNAL_ERROR in 31ms (request vps-linux/t97Af3tP3v-000241). Daemon cause: restore standalone-1: restore command: codebuddy: exact native session ID required for restore. The new guide requires an explicit fallback or typed 4xx for this expected condition, never 500. Preserve the fail-closed history checks while giving the service a typed error.

  4. [P2] Make the advertised freeform model override usable in New Task. The adapter exposes native model input, and the real API returns selectionMode:text, customModelEntry:direct, allowCustom:true, models:[]. However TaskComposer hardcodes allowCustom=false and converts direct entry to none. The real New Task CodeBuddy picker had no model choices or visible text input; the UI audit also failed this checkpoint. Respect the API's direct-entry capability or provide real native configured options. This does not require inventing a model catalog: the freeform backend response itself is valid.

  5. [P2] Keep the unregistered Chat candidate out of this TUI PR. codebuddyacp/driver.go expressly remains unregistered, while its candidate/tests and shared ACP extensions are in this diff. The new guide says “no unregistered drivers”. Move the candidate/shared-only changes to a follow-up; do not register unqualified Chat merely to clear this finding. Its exact-head lint fails goimports at driver.go:13, and its synthetic interrupt test times out at lifecycle_test.go:512. Those failures do not establish a native ACP cancel result.

  6. [P2] Remove historical audit artifacts from the shipping diff. This head adds 18 docs/research/ evidence/report files, including 5 PNGs (evidence index). Skill feat(skill): add ao-agent-harness skill to integrate and audit any harness #7081 requires reports, receipts and screenshots in PR comments, not commits. Preserve the existing historical receipts/links, but move them out of the proposed product diff.

Fresh verification and limits

Check Result
Released CLI installed privately PASS — @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code@2.164.0, native --version = 2.164.0
CLI/compatibility inspection Native --help captured; exact resume, additive system prompt, permission modes and --acp declared. No documented auth-status or model-list command was invented
Exact-head daemon build + real frontend npm ci PASS; GOWORK=off, GOFLAGS=-mod=readonly
Skill live audit 5 PASS, 1 FAIL (ao_authenticated), 1 SKIP (live)
Registered hooks/activity mapping Present; not a substitute for fresh authenticated behavior proof
UI Harness list/detail, installed state, Health and New Task agent selection observed; model entry failed as described
Install button / native login / Connected Not qualified. Private npm installation is not a PASS for the AO Install button
Authenticated first prompt, >8KiB paste, instructions, usage, follow-up, process Kill, exact positive restore/history, roles BLOCKED/SKIP after strict auth gate; the negative restore test above does not qualify these
Chat Deliberately unregistered; no Chat support claimed
Branding Documented initials fallback observed; no official logo/license qualification. Scanner's missing asset/map is recorded, not presented as proof of a broken avatar
Platforms Actual VPS/Linux only; no fresh macOS/Windows native qualification

Current exact-head CI is 19/25 success, 6 failures, not the older green snapshot in the description. Besides the linked failures, cloud-build-test fails TestCleanupHookRunsCommandsOnce (log); attribution of that cloud failure to CodeBuddy is not established. build-test is also failed. Routine unit/race/lint suites were inspected in CI, not falsely reported as locally passed.

Current-main gate: observed main 3b52fd9a0eeb3d9d41caa0465d4a235247c020ae already has migrations through 20261022172135175, while this PR adds 20261019155340715_allow_codebuddy_harness.sql. Reconcile with current main and choose/verify the next migration under the new guide before merge; compatibility with a database already upgraded to that main was not established here.

Evidence was generated outside Git under the private VPS review root. The pristine #7081 skill was retained; a separate runtime copy changed only its hardcoded temporary state prefix from /tmp/ao-audit-* to short ~/.ao/cb-audit-* for repository isolation rules, with original/runtime hashes recorded and audit assertions unchanged. The stock UI runner's generic Models-tab and Login-label results need the above scope distinction: empty truthful freeform catalog is allowed, a documentation setup plan exists, and I am not claiming the native login control was exercised.

Screenshot evidence is now PUBLISHED: all 10 captured PNGs and raw results on the separate evidence branch, pinned to 4e5d5812a17796a6b04546fa0dd273d34cbbe2f4. This resolves the earlier NOT_DONE attachment gap; the test verdicts and qualification limits remain unchanged. The private diagnostic session and isolated app/daemon were stopped; production AO was untouched.

Disposition: not ready for approval under #7081. Fix the AO issues, remove/split the excluded diff content, rerun exact-head CI and the authenticated native/UI gates, then obtain a fresh review.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T16:55:12Z

Original comment

Review evidence: screenshots and raw results (#7081)

Publishing the retained 2026-10-23 VPS review evidence using the same separate evidence-branch approach as #7093. This is not a new test run and changes no verdict.

Reviewed product head: c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e. Current PR head at publication: c9e14d9661257a429530aa0213e27bc0c9ab6e7e.
Skill #7081 head: 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840. Evidence commit: 4e5d5812a17796a6b04546fa0dd273d34cbbe2f4.
Native setup: @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code 2.164.0.

All 10 PNGs are embedded below, with immutable URLs. Each published PNG was fetched back and its SHA-256 matched the captured file.
Evidence is on the fork's evidence/harness-reviews-6541-6546-20261023 branch, outside this product PR diff.

Evidence Result / scope Files
Strict live audit 5 PASS / 1 FAIL (auth inconclusive) / 1 SKIP (live) report.md · report.json
AO auth response Unknown/inconclusive; not proof of invalid credentials raw response
Backend model API PASS: freeform/direct entry raw response
Desktop audit Raw checkpoints and screenshots; interpretation below report.md · report.json
Negative restore Create 201 -> immediate kill 200 -> restore 500, before native history ID existed HTTP receipts · daemon cause
Capture context and limitations Exact setup, blocked checks and cleanup README

Interpretation: Already installed is not an Install-button pass. The Models-tab runner assumes a catalog, while the backend correctly supports freeform models; the separately verified UI issue is missing usable direct entry in New Task. Update was NOT_RUN. Authenticated prompt, role, usage and successful history/restore qualification remain BLOCKED/SKIP. The negative 500 probe is not successful restore or process-kill recovery proof.

The CodeBuddy Login runner FAIL is retained as a selector observation. The final manual Account control check timed out, so the review does not assert a separately proven missing-setup-button defect.

PNG bytes are unchanged. Text files have ANSI styling removed and private test-root prefixes normalized. Selected text and screenshot OCR were scanned for credential patterns with no matches; no private env/config files were published. SHA-256 manifest.

Captured UI checkpoints

01-harness-listed-PASS.png — Harness listing

CodeBuddy Code: Harness listing

02-install-PASS.png — Existing installation (Install action not exercised)

CodeBuddy Code: Existing installation (Install action not exercised)

03-health-PASS.png — Health: authentication Unknown

CodeBuddy Code: Health: authentication Unknown

04-models-FAIL.png — Models tab: raw catalog-centric runner observation

CodeBuddy Code: Models tab: raw catalog-centric runner observation

05-login-FAIL.png — Account/login: raw runner capture

CodeBuddy Code: Account/login: raw runner capture

06-auth-check-NEEDS_USER.png — Auth check: no verified Connected verdict

CodeBuddy Code: Auth check: no verified Connected verdict

07-update-NOT_RUN.png — Update NOT_RUN

CodeBuddy Code: Update NOT_RUN

08-new-task-agent-tui-PASS.png — New Task: harness selection

CodeBuddy Code: New Task: harness selection

09-new-task-models-tui-FAIL.png — New Task: empty model entry

CodeBuddy Code: New Task: empty model entry

manual-model-menu.png — Manual model-menu confirmation

CodeBuddy Code: Manual model-menu confirmation


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T17:20:02Z

Original comment

Follow-up: native login and Z.ai/MiniMax configuration options

Checked the published @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code 2.164.0 package, retained native --help and official CLI docs. This is package/source and documentation verification, not an authenticated provider run.

Native login: launch codebuddy for the native first-run login screen; /login reopens login inside the TUI. Do not invent a codebuddy auth login command. Official first-run login and slash commands.

Third-party keys: CodeBuddy documents CODEBUDDY_API_KEY + CODEBUDDY_BASE_URL + CODEBUDDY_MODEL for a provider-compatible endpoint. It does not automatically treat a standalone ZAI_API_KEY or MINIMAX_API_KEY as CodeBuddy configuration. Its native models.json also supports explicit custom models with a full compatible API URL and environment-variable key references. Environment configuration, custom-model configuration.

Z.ai and MiniMax therefore have a documented protocol/configuration route; a valid matching provider key, plan, model and endpoint still need a live check. MiniMax documents its Anthropic-compatible endpoint at https://api.minimax.io/anthropic, with currently supported model details in its API reference. For Z.ai, distinguish the ordinary API from Coding Plan endpoints and account access; a compatible protocol alone is not an account-authorization PASS. Z.ai tools/plan scope.

AO wiring gaps at c9e14d9:

  • agentauth/plans.go:61 is documentation-only, so it does not open native terminal login/configuration.
  • codebuddy.go:189-200 only returns configured for CODEBUDDY_API_KEY/CODEBUDDY_AUTH_TOKEN presence, otherwise Unknown. No native-login or provider authorization verdict is established.
  • GetConfigSpec returns freeform native model entry. The shared TaskComposer.tsx:948-949 disables custom/direct entry, producing the unusable empty picker captured in the review. The correct fix is usable native direct entry and/or a truthful native/configured catalog, not fabricated model rows.
  • CodeBuddy's native /model and custom models.json exist, but this does not make them visible in AO automatically.

Required follow-up: offer native login/configuration in AO, keep it in the session's intended native profile/environment, verify the selected provider, and repair the model picker. The prior automated Login selector failure remains distinct from a manually reproduced button finding; this comment establishes the documentation-only source wiring and the native options.

No credential file was inspected, no key was entered, and no login/logout or real provider call was performed. Support is documented; the user's exact Z.ai/MiniMax keys are not live-verified by this check.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-23T19:24:21Z

Original comment

CodeBuddy Code: login, auth and model fixes pushed at 81ac436; includes main b13b951.

Evidence is attached below. Full local and GitHub validation is still running; this is not a merge-ready verdict. Reviewed against harness skill7081.

Check Observed result
Exact-head focused validation PASS: adapter/auth/registry/installer/ports, native Default/precedence checks; 262 UI tests. Receipt
Fresh Unknown-auth account PASS: native Login/Set up is available; Unknown does not become signed-in.
Configured credentials Covered by focused tests: Credentials not verified; a real accepted native request is required for Connected.
Models PASS: Models explains native freeform configuration; New Task sends the entered model ID. No synthetic catalog. Outgoing request
Ordinary New Task PASS: UI omits approvalMode, backend persists native Default and reaches the real native setup/login gate. Owned-row verification
MiniMax PASS: native CodeBuddy 2.164.0, MiniMax-M3 completed a structured native inference result (15.06s).
Z.ai INCONCLUSIVE: JSON mode returned no qualifying result. Exit0 is not accepted as authentication; no specific provider rejection is inferred.
Full CI PENDING: complete local suites and current-head remote checks are running. Earlier failed attempts are not relabeled passed.
Cleanup Owned test sessions terminated and isolated app/daemon/PTYs stopped; production readyz stayed200. No production AO data or account was changed.

Native first attempts · Mastra corrected native result · Probe-byte equivalence.

Real Electron/UI capture revision: 8a7252b. The current head changes only a test query option and, for Mastra, a method comment after that proof; runtime behavior is unchanged. Source provenance.

The first practical UI request ran native2.173 because the private Node toolchain PATH shadowed the pinned2.164 prefix. Those screenshots remain labeled2.173. After correcting only private PATH precedence, an API retry on the same daemon launched native2.164 and its terminal mux showed the login chooser. The retry is API/native proof, not a second UI-form proof.

Account action (CodeBuddy final settings capture uses native2.173; native2.164 login capture follows):
CodeBuddy Code Account action

Native model guidance:
CodeBuddy Code Models guidance

Native login chooser, without selecting an account or entering a key:
CodeBuddy Code native login

Direct model selection:
CodeBuddy Code custom model

UI report · Runtime proof · All artifacts and reproduction inputs · SHA256 manifest.

Limitations: no successful provider turn inside an AO UI session, full lifecycle/restore/permission-enforcement qualification, or cross-platform native-provider proof is claimed. CodeBuddy's explicit Open setup /login reopening was not executed while its chooser was already active; that action has source/unit coverage. The earlier CodeBuddy outgoing-request timing incident and native-version drift are retained in the evidence. Existing Chat candidates remain gated/unregistered. Native checks used bounded temporary environments; keys, raw provider replies and credential files are not attached. The complete70-file public evidence bundle was read back with HTTP200 and matching SHA256 hashes.

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🏆 Review leaderboard

Nov 5–12, 2026 · UTC

Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
🥇 @ronishrohan @ronishrohan 91 160 14
🥈 @neversettle17-101 @neversettle17-101 11 15 4
🥉 @illegalcall @illegalcall 11 12 4
4 @Meraj-08 @Meraj-08 10 15 0
5 @nikhilachale @nikhilachale 7 19 3
6 @Prasad-D-Ware @Prasad-D-Ware 7 14 2
7 @Annieeeee11 @Annieeeee11 6 9 0
8 @mohakchakraborty2004 @mohakchakraborty2004 6 7 2
9 @Pritom14 @Pritom14 5 8 1
10 @Rishet11 @Rishet11 5 6 3

Ranked by distinct external PRs reviewed, then review rounds, then PR comments. Self-activity and bot activity are excluded.

Show 6 more reviewers
Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
11 @somewherelostt @somewherelostt 3 11 1
12 @ApexYash11 @ApexYash11 2 6 2
13 @Vaibhaav-Tiwari @Vaibhaav-Tiwari 2 3 0
14 @codebanditssss @codebanditssss 2 2 8
15 @harshitsinghbhandari @harshitsinghbhandari 2 2 0
16 @MohamedKamran @MohamedKamran 1 2 0

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Account migration verification

  • New PR author verified as milesatao-svg; submission is a draft.
  • Original PR #6546 and this PR both point to 81ac43669ba88052c880b4f66e856a8e6174f441.
  • Published change-count header verified against this PR's actual GitHub file diff.
  • All 23 original human comment bodies and source links reproduced across 2 historical-evidence comments.
  • All 17 original screenshot/recording URLs reproduced and checked as HTTP 200 media.
  • Current GitHub mergeability: conflicts with main; resolution pending.
  • Fresh CI validation and current-head harness certification are pending. Copied test outcomes retain their original run/commit provenance.

@OrcInc OrcInc added comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request labels Nov 12, 2026
@OrcInc OrcInc added this to the Agents & orchestration milestone Nov 12, 2026
nikhilachale and others added 2 commits November 14, 2026 23:10
Resolve conflicts with main while keeping main's daemon, API and UI
behaviour:

- ACP: keep main's model-switch check and steering negotiation; apply
  the provider config validator first and gate steer/images/embedded
  context on explicit capability overrides.
- Session guard: run the terminal-readiness check before main's
  composer-draft check, which still runs last under its input fence.
- Session manager: take main's restore and launch signatures; keep the
  serialized-input opt-in. Drop the duplicate RestoreConfig.Env field.
- Settings: keep main's auth summary and unknown-auth actions; report
  CodeBuddy credentials its native inference check did not accept as
  not verified.
- New Task: move direct model entry into main's TaskModelPicker, scoped
  to New Task so automation pickers keep main's behaviour.
- Add settings.harness.models.directEntry to every locale with the
  {{agent}} placeholder (fixes the zh-CN catalog failure).
- Renumber the CodeBuddy CHECK migration above main's latest
  (20261114173149181) and burn the preview number 20261023181512240.
- Keep live-run evidence out of the diff; link docs/harnesses/codebuddy.md
  from docs/README.md.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Harness skill receipt — PR #7081 ao-agent-harness @ 04c8c95b against head a0866c8eaa

Head a0866c8eaa304053176426d76919e86e228f4992 merges main 28bc83fd95 into the previous head 81ac43669b (fast-forward, no force-push). GitHub reports MERGEABLE. Merge readiness is not claimed.

The skill's scripts were not run. This audit host is Windows, where running them is not allowed, and no VPS was used. The touchpoint results below come from reading the code against harness_touchpoints.mjs's rules. No contracts, reports or screenshots are in the diff.

What changed in this update

  • Merged main and resolved 17 conflicts, keeping main's daemon, API and UI behaviour. Removed a duplicate ports.RestoreConfig.Env field the merge would otherwise have introduced (compile break).
  • Added settings.harness.models.directEntry with {{agent}} to all 8 non-English locales. This fixes the earlier i18n/instance.test.ts catalog failure, including zh-CN.
  • Renumbered the CodeBuddy sessions CHECK migration to 20261114173149181, above main's latest (20261114072016988). Recorded 20261023181512240 as a burned preview number. Rechecked main's later migrations: they only add or drop sessions columns, so the CHECK text widening survives.
  • Removed the committed live-run evidence from docs/research/. Earlier receipts remain at their linked commits.
  • Kept main's "configured" and unknown-auth Harness states. CodeBuddy native_inference diagnostics other than provider_accepted now show Credentials not verified.
  • New Task accepts typed model IDs when the catalog's entry mode allows it. Automation pickers keep main's behaviour.

Per-step receipt

Step Result Evidence / gap
0 Intake PASS Open PR #8202 continues #6546; continuing it.
1 Compatibility BLOCKED docs/harnesses/codebuddy.md records 2.164.0 behaviour from historical Linux runs. Not re-observed at this head. Needs a live mac/Linux host.
2 Touchpoints, TUI PASS 13/13 required Adapter, domain, registry, SQLite repair + migration, DTO/OpenAPI/schema enums, product label, hooks, activity dispatch, terminal refresh, refresh matrix. Optional: spawn help ok; doctor-probe absent (see below).
2 Touchpoints, install / auth / models PASS 2/2, 1/1, 1/1 npm plan pinned to @tencent-ai/codebuddy-code@2.164.0; native login plan; direct-entry model catalog.
2 Touchpoints, branding FAIL 0/2 required No assets/agents/codebuddy.* and no AgentAvatar.tsx entry. Needs an official logo with its licence/source; not fabricated.
2 Touchpoints, docs PASS (optional) docs/harnesses/codebuddy.md, docs/README.md index (added), agents index.
2 Chat surface SKIP / open Scope is TUI-only, but the PR ships an unregistered chatdriver/codebuddyacp package plus shared ACP changes. The skill says "no unregistered drivers" and asks for Codex/Claude tests on shared ACP edits. Decision requested.
2 doctor-probe (optional) OPEN Binary name matches the ID, so the default PATH probe applies. A pinned --version spec was not added because no recorded proof of the flag exists.
3 Contract BLOCKED No contract was written or committed. Needs an authorized mac/Linux audit host.
4 Live audit BLOCKED Not run (Windows host; no VPS). Native login, TUI lifecycle, restore, hooks and usage remain unqualified at this head.
5 UI audit BLOCKED Not run. Checkpoints 1–9 need screenshots from the real desktop app on mac/Linux.
6 Fix / hand-off OPEN The rows above remain.

CI

The workflows on a0866c8eaa (CI, gitleaks, Harness release feeds, Public boundary) are action_required. A maintainer must approve fork-PR workflow runs before any check reports. No local test runs were made on this host.

Still required before merge: maintainer-approved CI passing on this head, a fresh review, independent maintainer approval, and live TUI + UI audit evidence from a mac/Linux host.

@nikhilachale nikhilachale left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

AO review: changes requested

Reviewed head a0866c8eaa against main (merge base 28bc83fd95). The CodeBuddy adapter, auth probe, history guard, migration and installer pieces follow existing harness patterns. Three problems need fixing before this is ready. Each one has its own inline comment:

  1. Serialized input drops the user's keystrokes (session_input.go). Terminal keystroke leases are held while queued, so the new rule refuses the second key whenever two frames overlap.
  2. Every not-ready surface is reported as a pending permission decision (sessionguard/guard.go). A mid-turn session and an unsent draft both come back as SESSION_AWAITING_DECISION, and the composer-busy classification is lost.
  3. Launch-time version probing now applies to every registered native-ACP harness (nativeacp/driver.go), even though it only serves the unregistered CodeBuddy candidate.

Optional, not blocking:

  • TaskComposer now passes allowDirectEntry for every local task. That turns on freeform model IDs in New Task for all direct-entry harnesses (Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode, ...), not just CodeBuddy, and it flips an existing test expectation. If that is intended, call it out in the PR description. Otherwise, scope it to CodeBuddy.
  • settings.harness.models.directEntry ("Configure its provider in {{agent}} first") now shows for any direct-entry harness with an empty catalog, and its wording is CodeBuddy-specific.
  • Manager.serializedInput entries are never deleted when a session ends.
  • repairRenumberedCodeBuddyMigrationHistory runs on every startup for every database that has codebuddy in its schema. If a future migration drops or renames version_refresh, either harness-release table, or either trigger, every install will fail with "partial schema; refusing preview repair". Consider marking the repair as done, or limiting it to identifiable preview ledgers.

I did not run any tests or programs. This is a static review of the diff.

Comment thread backend/internal/sessionguard/guard.go Resolved
nikhilachale and others added 2 commits November 14, 2026 23:35
A terminal holds one input lease per queued data frame, so refusing every
second lease on a guarded harness dropped the user's own fast typing, key
repeats and chunked pastes. Raw leases now stack as before for every
harness. A guarded paste is admitted only while its delivery's lease is the
session's sole writer, and new input is refused only until that paste's
lease is released. A delivery under an exclusive operation holds no lease and
leaves input open afterwards.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…changed

- Guard: a CodeBuddy draft or queued keystrokes now suppress as
  composer-busy (retryable, ErrComposerBusy), an active turn as busy
  (new retryable ErrSessionBusy / SESSION_BUSY, retried by report
  delivery), and only a native decision as awaiting decision. Send and
  after-start delivery no longer treat either busy outcome as delivered.
- Rename the paste-guard port method to ValidateTerminalPaste. main's
  daemon admission duck-types ValidateTerminalMessage(message, screen),
  so the shared name routed Hermes through the paste guard and CodeBuddy
  through daemon admission, each with swapped arguments.
- nativeacp: Launch no longer runs VersionProbe; registered bindings
  probe at admission only, as on main. The CodeBuddy candidate rechecks
  its exact binary in its own Configure.
- Scope typed New Task models and the Models hint to CodeBuddy so other
  direct-entry harnesses keep main's catalog picker.
- Stop the preview ledger repair once CodeBuddy's migration is recorded,
  so a later change to 214/215 objects cannot block startup.
- Fix the input-checker test for main's DeliverWithComposerCheck.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Optional notes from the review of a0866c8eaa, addressed in 1dc1b6fad2:

  • New Task direct entry: scoped to CodeBuddy (acceptsTypedNewTaskModel). Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode and the other direct-entry harnesses keep main's catalog-only local picker, and the flipped TaskComposer expectation is back to main's. Cloud tasks are unchanged.
  • settings.harness.models.directEntry: now shown only for harnesses whose New Task accepts a typed ID (CodeBuddy today). Other empty catalogs keep "This harness reported no models."
  • Manager.serializedInput never cleared: removed. Its replacement guardedPaste entry is deleted when the session's last input lease is released.
  • Preview ledger repair on every startup: it now stops once CodeBuddy's migration (20261114173149181, or the burned preview number 20261023181512240) is recorded. A later migration that changes the 214/215 objects therefore can't be read as a preview ledger. Covered by TestCodeBuddyPreviewRepairStopsOnceItsMigrationIsRecorded.

No tests were run locally (Windows host). The fork-PR workflows still need maintainer approval to run on this head.

@nikhilachale nikhilachale left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

AO review: approved

Re-reviewed head 1dc1b6fad2 (fix commits 42a9bae5d2 and 1dc1b6fad2 on top of the previously reviewed a0866c8eaa). Every finding from the previous review is resolved:

  1. Keystroke leases stack again. AcquireSessionInput now refuses only while a guarded paste is in progress (guardedPaste). beginGuardedPaste admits a paste only when the caller holds the sole lease, and the flag clears on the last release. While keystrokes are still queued, a paste is refused as a retryable composer-busy instead of dropping keys. The new test covers overlapping raw leases before and after a paste, and a paste with no lease under an exclusive operation.
  2. Refusals are now distinguished. The plugin joins ErrTerminalComposerDraft or ErrTerminalTurnActive onto ErrTerminalMessageNotReady. The guard maps them to SuppressedComposerBusy, SuppressedBusy and SuppressedAwaitingUser. send and deliverStartedInput map those to ErrComposerBusy, the new ErrSessionBusy (SESSION_BUSY) and ErrAwaitingDecision. Report delivery treats both busy cases as ErrOrchestratorBusy. Each case has a test.
  3. Shared native-ACP launch is unchanged. The launch-time version recheck moved into codebuddyacp's own Configure. A test now asserts that shared Launch runs no extra version command.

The optional items were also handled. Typed model entry in New Task and the Settings direct-entry message are limited to CodeBuddy via acceptsTypedNewTaskModel. guardedPaste entries are removed on release. The preview migration-ledger repair now stops for good once either CodeBuddy migration number is recorded, and a test covers a later canonical schema change. Renaming the paste guard to ValidateTerminalPaste also avoids a collision with the existing daemon ValidateTerminalMessage admission contract, and a registry test enforces that.

No changes requested. I did not run any tests or programs. This is a static review of the diff.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants