Skip to content

feat: integrate Pool native ACP Chat with scoped lifecycle proof - #8201

Draft
milesatao-svg wants to merge 29 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6551-pool
Draft

milesatao-svg wants to merge 29 commits into
OrchestratorInc:mainfrom
milesatao-svg:codex/copy-pr-6551-pool

Conversation

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Code changes: +517 -21
Tests: +810 -4
Others: +823 -5

Account migration from @nikhilachale to @milesatao-svg. This draft continues original PR #6551 at original head a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157. Original commits and commit authorship are preserved. Descriptions and evidence below include historical results with their original sources.

What

feat: integrate Pool native ACP Chat with scoped lifecycle proof

Original PR description, preserved

Binary assets in this source snapshot: 3 (excluded from line counts).

Latest repair and clean runtime-tested source: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157. Final status, completion matrix and current-head CI · Detailed current native/AO evidence and retained failures. Exact-head CI: 25/25 successful. Actual Electron UI and screenshot publication remain blocked. Earlier source/CI/runtime snapshots below are retained as historical evidence and are superseded by this repair's linked status.

Unix Chat only; TUI, Auto, reviewers, handoff and unqualified optional ACP features refused.

Current status

Current source snapshot: 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7 (base db77f945db58ce1d9970e99e7e9b68396f38c78b). Open for review; GitHub mergeability MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED. Exact-head CI: pending (3 successful, 20 queued/running, 0 unsuccessful among 23 reported checks). CI run 1 · CI run 2 · CI run 3 · CI run 4. Green source CI does not establish current native/UI runtime proof or full integration readiness.

This fix created only clean isolated source worktrees and temporary review reports; it created no AO/native sessions, provider profiles or owned runtime processes. No local build, gofmt, test, fixture, provider or UI run was performed.

Historical runtime build: Historical AO/UI reconnect/capture source fb60bd4097ebd4109bbe7ee68e908f722e6ee03f; earlier full lifecycle a7eadca3d2f4ccbd7dd376933fc8a57793430209. Released Pool1.0.16 executable SHA256 db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2; final AO executable SHA256 b30f2dfa7b1f1c796c5772cb96d7d5c32b4bfb53c39f2c4ff7ca669f2cca8ded. Attempt003 and the final reconnect are distinct. Report · evidence index, original receipts, image/provenance hashes. Receipt SHAs/bytes are unchanged. Linux/VPS proof is not Windows/macOS native proof. Runner SHA256 8887aa2e7101b9e6d3950bfca08ffddf2e1e6c1c3f1d030c8dec2676443aecea remains historical where reported; manual/standalone proof is not a strict runner PASS.

Changes since runtime proof: Source now discovers configured models through a short native ACP session, retaining provider-native model IDs/current default and a configuration-sensitive cache fingerprint. Settings has an actual manual setup plan and user guide, and unsupported OS is rejected before Chat startup. Explicit malformed provider configuration is rejected before native artifacts, but after AO allocation; this is not a pre-allocation malformed-config guarantee. TUI/Auto capability refusals remain separate. Setup documentation records the intentional initials avatar fallback; Poolside trademark guidance does not establish a verified logo grant for this avatar use. None of these changed paths has new native/UI runtime proof. The first source-CI attempt at cd4df74 reported goimports, preallocation and error-string lint issues; the follow-up corrects those source details. Original failed lint job is retained; no AO screenshot exists because this was a source-lint job.

The matrix separates current verification from recorded historical passes; NOT_RUN does not erase those passes. Excluded interfaces/manual model input are deliberate supported-scope decisions.

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Unix Chat only; TUI, Auto, reviewers, handoff and unqualified optional ACP features refused. NOT_RUN Adapter/registry/API/generated/product paths are present; current Settings/task journeys not reverified.
Models Configured native ACP discovery; provider-native IDs/current default; configuration fingerprint in cache. NOT_RUN Source wiring complete; new picker/default/discovery/native effective-selection paths have no current live/UI proof.
Setup Actual Settings manual plan links Pool setup/login guide and prerequisites. NOT_RUN Source path registered; current Settings journey NOT_RUN.
Readiness macOS/Linux preflight; explicit malformed config refused before native artifacts, after allocation. NOT_RUN Guard source implemented; current provider/config/OS runtime paths NOT_RUN.
Identity and logo Product label and intentional initials fallback recorded in setup guide; no verified licensed logo. NOT_RUN Branding disposition documented; actual current avatar UI NOT_RUN.
TUI and Chat Chat registered; TUI/handoff excluded deliberately. Historical actual AO Chat screenshots retained. NOT_RUN Historical actual AO images; excluded interfaces are deliberate.
Permissions and instructions Manual/accept-edits/allow-all native mappings; lazy bounded SessionStart context is observational and native hooks fail open. NOT_RUN Historical scoped PASS/limits; current live path NOT_RUN.
Lifecycle Historical reject/pending/executing cancel, Kill/control isolation, exact restore/fresh instructions and reconnect. NOT_RUN Historical scoped PASS/limits; current live path NOT_RUN.
Evidence Pinned historical source/native/runner/UI receipts, attempts, images and provenance; missing originals disclosed. NOT_RUN Historical evidence retained; current native/UI proof NOT_RUN. Reproduction-input limitations below remain explicit.
CI and handoff Exact source checks/merge snapshot; incomplete live qualification and historical cleanup. NOT_RUN Exact-head CI pending (3 successful, 20 queued/running, 0 unsuccessful among 23 reported checks); mergeability MERGEABLE. Source CI scope only; current native/UI qualification NOT_RUN.

Historical implementation and evidence

Adds nativeacp agent/Chat registration, project/task defaults, pre-allocation TUI/Auto rejection, product labels, DTO/generated contracts and migration0208 with historical/burned-schema reconciliation. Native ACP identity pool-acp1.0.16 is checked. Optional images/embedded context/resource links/elicitation/nested agents/terminal output remain scoped off. Private bounded unnamed SessionStart hooks preserve native/user defaults and tools; a matcher is required. Hooks can initialize lazily and fail open, so AO checks a session/workspace witness after prompt completion; this is an observational check, not a pre-tool security boundary. Detached adoption retains original context. The Kill API exposes no freed count. Historical fb60bd4 source CI was 23/23 green; evidence d4ccc7f was 5/5/150 fixtures. Z.ai404, missing matcher, eager restored-context check, post-reject model refusal, observer assertion failures and resource-stop build remain distinct.

historical receipt 1 · historical receipt 2

Reproduction and retained-original limitations

The pinned reports/JSON retain action/result, file/token effects, process identity, cancellation, native-history continuity and capture assertions. A complete sanitized executable reproduction bundle is not established for every manual helper: exact helper bytes/hash and invocation, applicable local-contract bytes/hash with probe argv and interrupt/readiness/draft-cleanup settings, and complete native/AO fingerprints are unavailable where not recorded in the linked receipts; recoverability of those original inputs is unknown. No missing command, contract, hash or result is invented. Later reproductions must use a new attempt and cannot replace original failed/missing evidence.

Recorded owned-process/session/daemon/Electron cleanup is historical. Source worktrees, native profiles/history, dirty scratch workspaces, binaries and raw logs were reported retained privately; a complete current inventory/location/hash and recoverability of every original class are unavailable in the public record. Current recoverability is unknown; this reporting fix reconstructs no missing input and silently substitutes none. Share sanitized artifacts only; exclude credential stores, raw DBs and provider-profile directories. Preserve the retained failures and original screenshots.

Actual AO Pool active after reconnect

Actual AO Pool settled with fresh restored instructions

Why

The contributor is moving this harness submission to @milesatao-svg. The linked source preserves the implementation and review history.

Before / After

Before After
Submission in PR #6551 from @nikhilachale at a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157 Submission from @milesatao-svg at the same commit a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157

Original product behavior and existing UI evidence are included in the preserved description and copied evidence comments.

How

Copy the source head into milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6551-pool and target upstream main.

Testing

Historical test results and screenshots are reproduced in the evidence comments with their original sources. Fresh validation is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.

Checklist

  • Original head SHA and commit authorship preserved.
  • Original description and evidence provenance included.
  • Fresh CI validation on this submission.
  • Resolve current main merge conflicts.

Account migration verification

  • Exact source head copied: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157.
  • New fork branch: milesatao-svg/agent-orchestrator:codex/copy-pr-6551-pool. Base: main.
  • Evidence comments retain their original author, timestamp, source URL and result wording.
  • Fresh validation status is tracked by this PR's GitHub checks.
  • Source mergeability at migration: conflicts with current main; reconciliation pending.

Ubuntu and others added 22 commits October 11, 2026 16:20
Preserve harness-owned evidence and merge current canonical API, storage, and native Chat updates. Runtime proof remains qualified by its original source.
Build the real daemon in PR CI for isolated VPS runtime verification without local validation suites or dependency installations. Record source revision, Go build info, and executable hash.
@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 1/2

Historical material from original PR #6551, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T16:25:31Z

Original comment

Pool qualification is BLOCKED; this draft is unregistered. Official native Pool1.0.16 initialized ACP and created sessions, but the available authorized Z.ai coding endpoint failed native model turns with404 at /v4/v1/chat/completions. Explicit /v1 did not repair it. A separate direct provider control at /v4/chat/completions returned200; that is not Pool/AO conformance. Unknown native history hard-failed instead of creating fresh history.

Immutable native hold report and curated qualification record are published in PR #6509. Both were downloaded and SHA-256 verified after publication. Native executable hash is db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2; no proprietary binary, credential, database, profile or full raw log is committed.

Actual AO Chat/API/nativeacp, permissions/cancellation/replay and Electron screenshot gates are NOT_RUN: no successful native provider turn enabled safe production registration, and no AO session was launched. Screenshot unavailable for that reason; no synthetic image substitutes. Three exact owned native PIDs are absent after bounded cleanup; production AO and the preparation checkout remain untouched.

Source head 9edca42a13e5f808ed0ce42926b241168ec5b09e, evidence head 0c7b7656c9e63de44f0ad8c9c47581e8f0c8f821. Current-head GitHub Actions are running; no local routine suites were executed. Leave draft pending a released native provider-path fix or an already authorized working compatible endpoint, then full native and actual AO qualification.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T16:38:21Z

Original comment

Final Pool stage result: BLOCKED on a native provider prerequisite; PR #6551 remains draft and unregistered.

  • Source 5b3e03be4a004f24c6ece1325755d1bcb9596245: 20/20 exact-head GitHub Actions checks green. The prior lint failure was fixed from remote logs, with no local routine suites.
  • Evidence 0c7b7656c9e63de44f0ad8c9c47581e8f0c8f821: 5/5 exact-head checks green, including fresh 150/150 fixtures. Runner SHA remains 8887aa2e7101b9e6d3950bfca08ffddf2e1e6c1c3f1d030c8dec2676443aecea.
  • Immutable native qualification report and curated JSON were downloaded and hash-verified.

Native Pool1.0.16 initializes/new-sessions successfully and hard-rejects unknown history, but its first model turn emits /v4/v1/chat/completions and receives404 with the available authorized Z.ai coding route. Explicit /v1 also fails. Direct /v4/chat/completions control returns200; this does not prove Pool/AO conformance. A released native path fix or an already authorized working compatible endpoint is required before full qualification.

No production registration, migration/API/UI, reviewer or handoff was added. Native tool/private-instruction/permission/cancel/replay and actual AO Chat/API/host/Kill/Electron screenshot gates are NOT_RUN; screenshot unavailable because no safely admitted AO session exists. No substitute pixels or integration claim. All three owned native PIDs are absent; production PID625660 remains present, native profiles/history/preparation and old evidence are preserved. Only the hashed, regenerable release archive was removed after verifying no open references; the executable remains available. No merge, release or deployment.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-11T21:20:15Z

Original comment

Pool recovery is now implemented in the existing branch. Immutable report and process/provenance receipts. Backend/UI head fb60bd4097ebd4109bbe7ee68e908f722e6ee03f; source CI is green23/23, evidence CI green5/5 including150/150 fixtures. Stock native tools, manual permissions, private instruction freshness after Kill, exact history and detached reconnect passed actual AO proof.

Actual AO active

Actual AO settled

PNG SHA256: active 7a7302b08b63ee8f0029bafe52ae6074d4c94c37f0ba390386d2f415de6f37b3; settled b9175c4c808de0b96eab6f4d9378c5ca8e82ebd5a79827dfcc7afe6a4b4b1a57. Visually inspected actual Electron captures. Earlier failures retained, owned runtime cleanup complete. Scope remains Unix Chat only; no TUI/Auto/handoff/reviewer or unproved optional capabilities.

Final exact-head CI: source backend/race gate, source frontend, evidence frontend, 150/150 fixtures. Stage complete; no merge or release.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T16:55:26Z

Original comment

Harness-specific reports, JSON receipts, screenshots and provenance now live on this integration PR branch, rather than the skill PR #6509.

Evidence index with embedded screenshots and JSON links.

Historical successes, failures and scope limitations remain as recorded. Moving these files does not rerun native/AO testing or upgrade any verdict.

This is evidence relocation only. Existing tested source/native hashes and failures are preserved; the documentation commit is not a fresh runtime pass. Applicable checks run in PR CI.

Recorded harness evidence — see scope above


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:08:39Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at ec67be6459d6, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T18:18:07Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at c98324f1533e, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-12T20:59:37Z

Original comment

Canonical main conflicts reconciled at 2048d4a668e3, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

Validation is PR CI only; current-head checks are pending until GitHub reports them. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-13T00:00:02Z

Original comment

Canonical main and the green shared ACP replay CI budget reconciled at 20776be48ccb, preserving previous source/evidence ancestry and every existing harness report/screenshot byte. Reconciliation receipt.

The shared test-only fix PR6617 had21 green applicable checks; this integration head still needs its own exact-head CI. The full20543-frame replay burst and exact-once assertions remain unchanged. No routine local suites ran. This merge does not constitute a new native/AO run or promote historical fresh/restore/provider-role proof. Harness evidence stays on this integration PR; PR6509 remains reusable guidance and linked summaries.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:00:54Z

Original comment

Fresh testing-only retest starting for pool at current PR head 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7 using harness skill bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db. One bounded serial attempt (25-minute maximum; eight-minute output-stall watchdog); isolated source/runtime. Previous evidence is historical and will not count as fresh proof. Full 12-area matrix and screenshot checkpoints will follow in a new comment. No implementation, pushes, production restart, or excluded PR changes.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:11:31Z

Original comment

Current bounded testing receipt — PR #6551 — BLOCKED / integration incomplete

Tested source/current head: 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7. Exact staged skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db; all staged files matched that Git object. Current-head readback at 2026-10-21T05:08:13.682072+00:00; no main merge. Recorded comparison mainSHA: 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd (121 main-only / 20 PR-only commits); current GitHub base is db77f945db58ce1d9970e99e7e9b68396f38c78b, with mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. Clean detached source, no source/branch modifications, commits, pushes, description edits or review publications.

This is fresh Linux x86_64 proof. Historical committed notes/screenshots are references only. Actual current frontend never ran: its node_modules is absent, and installation/symlinking was prohibited. AO UI evidence: BLOCKED. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED. No working approved GitHub attachment uploader; no PNG was produced or published, and no screenshot checkpoint counts as attached.

Actual provenance:

Artifact Version / identity SHA-256
Native Pool fresh pool --version: 1.0.16; ACP pool-acp 1.0.16 db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2
Actual serving AO ao version: dev; Go build info vcs.revision=56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7, vcs.modified=false a253335836e191ebf7e5f2cf46d3a4659184f78678d79fd93a435435a98ac233
Staged audit runner skill commit above; Node v24.21.0 04e3843c4ad2d3ff9fed8c48b6e264c1e68d6d23f70fc5adf4860c0105871c09
Preserved strict report state finished, summary BLOCKED 3ba31b3c2dc9e889f808a51c6428a200cd87b797dae34038444ac3cea32537d6

Go: 1.27.1; Node: v24.21.0. Minimal live-only backend build ran serially with GOMAXPROCS=1, GOFLAGS=-p=1, GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB, Node heap 384MiB, existing caches; start 05:02:55.169677Z, finish 05:03:40.016383Z, exit 0. Available disk 2229 MiB before build and 2063 MiB at final inventory; no broad cleanup. No local unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/frontend/fixture suites ran (CI ONLY).

Distinct actual attempts and first failures:

Attempt Actual execution / outcome
Fresh safe native argv probes pool --help, pool --version, pool acp --help: exit 0 at 05:02:20.910616–05:02:21.301614Z. Native help supports --version; no wrong-flag failure in this worker. Later pool exec --help exit 0, 05:06:55.955751–05:06:55.990975Z, confirms supported noninteractive mode; no exec task was run.
native-acp-001 pool acp; 05:03:51.533967–05:04:07.613092Z. Minimum existing authorized key reused only in memory with isolated HOME/XDG; no saved profile modified. initialize protocol 1, loadSession=true, authMethods=[] in standalone route; provider metadata provider: api.deepseek.com. Native catalog offers deepseek-flash (current/default) and deepseek-v4-pro. session/set_mode(always-allow) succeeded. The fresh provider turn ran 05:03:52.156949–05:04:02.605355Z, ended end_turn, observed 331 session/update messages and created/validated NATIVE_PROOF.json token + exact cwd in the disposable workspace. Native authorization/routing worked for this turn; this does not change AO's configured-only auth state or qualify AO Chat.
strict-001 Exactly one default-strict staged runner, no diagnostic flag. Report started 05:04:21.643Z, finalized 05:04:23.027Z BLOCKED. Native binary/version/version-only integration and registration/installation/freshness PASS. First non-pass local_session_spawn: NOT_RUN because no command contract defined; local_models_list NOT_RUN because catalog was observed through ACP, not an invented CLI list. Actual blocker: fresh AO auth configured/unverified, effectiveReadiness unknown. AO models and all TUI lifecycle/cancel/restore gates remained NOT_RUN; model comparison NOT_RUN. Version-only integration is only safe binary evidence, not auth/provider conformance. No TUI, interrupt or restoredReady contract fabricated for this Chat-only AO adapter.
strict runner process receipt --keep-daemon finalized its report but retained its child's stdio and did not exit. At 05:05:12.579699Z only the finished runner PID 1449273/kernel-start 160481440 received SIGTERM, command exit -15 at 05:05:12.614047Z. Original report/failure retained. The owned daemon stayed available for read-only Doctor/API checks and was later shut down explicitly. This is an operator/runner-retention limitation, not provider auth failure.
independent API reads /readyz HTTP 200 matched daemon PID 1449284/kernel-start 160481450, actual executable hash above, runtime-scoped data/runfile. settings.chatHarnesses includes pool. GET agents/pool/models HTTP 200: selectionMode=catalog, source=acp, two exact native model IDs, fresh nonempty catalog. This is separate proof; strict report's ao_models_api stays NOT_RUN. GET installers HTTP 200 manual-only/unavailable; GET auth-plans HTTP 200 has no Pool entry; GET sessions stayed empty.
diagnostic Chat proposal BLOCKED / NOT_EXECUTED. Automatic approval review rejected the combined model-refresh/registered Chat-spawn action because AO auth remained configured-only. The script was rejected before execution; no explicit refresh or Chat session was started. Explicit additional approval was requested and has not been received. No workaround or diagnostic PASS claimed; no executed second runner attempt.
tui-negative-001 05:07:21.034689–05:07:21.057987Z. Explicit Pool mode=tui POST returned HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED: “Pool requires Chat mode”; requestId vps-linux/Wpl44wsGAh-000014. GET sessions before/after both empty; no allocation or provider turn. Native Pool also offers an interactive ACP client; this N/A concerns the documented AO Chat-only integration scope, not an assertion that upstream has no TUI.

Native proof file SHA-256: d9d7504586ca71153545dee4b70e9459a4d87341972101d0d1acc5b1429a1150. Native conversation-ID digest: 0f6830100734a3cab2f75998169ca7ac4ab18284c9257eefeffb5d2c69963bae. No raw identity/profile/credential stream is published. No effective AO model/routing, active-tool cancellation, restored readiness, exact history continuity or standing-instruction consumption claim follows from the native file turn.

Complete completion matrix:

Area Supported scope Verification Proof or reason
Registration and UI Unix native ACP Chat; shared TaskComposer/Chat surfaces BLOCKED Registered API/probe/settings and generated enums include pool. Actual current Electron unavailable: frontend/node_modules absent; installation/symlinking prohibited. No UI launch or UI verification.
Models Native ACP catalog, configured model entries; default deepseek-flash NOT_RUN Native and independent AO GET catalog agree on deepseek-flash and deepseek-v4-pro (HTTP 200, source acp, selectionMode catalog). Native currentValue deepseek-flash; first native turn succeeds. Agent Harness Models listing/refresh, both UI pickers and persisted off/on/bulk effects NOT_RUN; dedicated Harness model visibility controls not found in this checkout (NOT_IMPLEMENTED). Proposed explicit refresh was rejected before execution. No fabricated catalog or model switches.
Providers Native standalone DeepSeek route via existing credential; native login/logout exposed BLOCKED initialize reports provider: api.deepseek.com and native file turn passes. AO catalog rows have no explicit provider/account metadata. AO add/change/remove/account configuration and effective AO routing NOT_RUN; no Pool auth plan. Native route success does not verify AO account management.
Setup User-installed Pool 1.0.16; AO manual guide NOT_RUN GET installers: available=false, automatic=false, method=manual; reinstall unavailable. GET auth-plans has no Pool entry, although native help advertises login/logout. Fresh installation, login, logout, account changes and retry branches forbidden/unexecuted; no install or login command invoked. In-page login/setup remains NOT_IMPLEMENTED.
Readiness Linux/macOS admitted by source; Linux x86_64 tested BLOCKED Fresh probe installed=true, authStatus=configured. Ensure: fresh auth_configured_unverified, effectiveReadiness=unknown. Native provider route succeeded independently; AO inventory remains configured-only. No Windows/macOS runtime qualification.
Identity and logo Poolside Pool label and intentional accessible initials fallback BLOCKED Current product-ui label and Pool guide explicitly document no verified licensed logo asset. AgentAvatar has no Pool asset mapping. Branding disposition recorded; real row/avatar visual verification unavailable.
TUI and Chat AO TUI N/A for documented Chat-only scope; native itself also offers an interactive ACP client BLOCKED Actual explicit TUI request returned HTTP 409 SESSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED; sessions stayed empty. No invented TUI/restoredReady contract. Chat is registered; native ACP proof passes, but registered AO Chat attempt BLOCKED by automatic approval review and never executed. Native ACP is not AO Chat conformance.
Reviewer Not registered in AO reviewer vocabulary/registry; native suitability unqualified NOT_RUN No Pool reviewer adapter/picker/run. Native help has no dedicated review subcommand; generic review suitability not established, so no upstream-unsupported claim. Select/run/result/cancel/rerun and exact target/head correlation NOT_RUN. GitHub reviewer publication explicitly unauthorized.
Permissions and instructions Source maps manual/accept-edits/allow-all; Auto refused NOT_RUN Native ACP offered default, accept-edits, always-allow; always-allow setter succeeded for the disposable file turn. No approve/reject enforcement, AO instruction consumption, additive-role, ordinary-task or restored instruction proof. Source standing-hook implementation is not live consumption evidence.
Lifecycle Supported Chat lifecycle needs independent registered AO proof NOT_RUN No AO Chat session created. Follow-up, active-tool cancel/PID witness, Kill/archive, exact restore, fresh instructions, Kanban return, event reconnect and daemon-host recovery unexecuted. Native settled-process cleanup is not active-turn cancellation. Strict TUI dependent gates remain NOT_RUN.
Evidence Current exact binaries; strict/native/API receipts; full checkpoint index BLOCKED One strict attempt retained BLOCKED; one native ACP turn PASS; proposed diagnostic rejected before execution. All 24 mandatory screenshot rows plus 10 Chat subjourneys retained below. No PNGs, fake URLs or published attachments. AO UI attachment evidence: BLOCKED.
CI and handoff Current-head GitHub CI only; no local routine suites BLOCKED 24/24 current-head check-runs completed success; no failing/pending check-runs. Legacy combined status pending with zero contexts is not a pending job. GitHub mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty. Recorded mainSHA divergence: 121 main-only / 20 PR-only commits. No merge or fix attempted. Owned cleanup PASS; clean detached source retained for parent removal; PR description link pending parent update.

Complete screenshot/action/result checkpoint index (all captures and attachments unavailable; API/source observations never substitute for images):

Checkpoint/substep Action and expected → observed Functional status Screenshot/attachment
harness-listed Discover row/name/logo/state → API registration confirmed, real page not opened; no session. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
install-offer Manual/unavailable offer → API plan observed available=false, automatic=false; UI before-state unavailable. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
install-run Install before/active/result → no installation authorized or started; all three states unavailable. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
auth-before Existing credential before-state → native route verified independently; AO probe configured-only; UI unavailable. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
auth-action AO setup handoff/return → no Pool auth plan; no login or credential-changing flow authorized. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
auth-ready Fresh verified ready-state → AO authentication remains configured/unverified; no AO provider task. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
auth-maintenance Account/provider change/logout/retry before/action/result → unauthorized credential changes, no Pool auth plan. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
harness-models Harness listing/loading/refresh/result → NOT_IMPLEMENTED dedicated panel; AO GET catalog passed separately; explicit refresh unexecuted. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
model-visibility Off/on/bulk/save/reload/picker effects → NOT_IMPLEMENTED controls/preferences in this checkout; no synthetic switches. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
provider-management Provider selection/add/change/remove/configuration before/action/result → no Pool account/setup UI wiring established; native route only. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
task-agent New Task visible/selected harness → UI unavailable; source selection wiring alone is not action evidence. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
task-model New Task offered/chosen model → native/AO catalogs agree; UI selection and effective AO model not executed. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
task-running Submit/card/running/output/settled → registered Chat spawn rejected by automatic approval before execution; native proof is separate. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
task-followup Shared composer submit/response → no AO Chat session or real UI. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
task-cancel Active command/Stop/settled → no AO executing PID/kernel-start witness; no cancellation sent. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
kill-action Archive before/confirm/terminated → no AO task session; daemon shutdown is separate. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
archived Archived exact entry → no AO task session or archived card. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
restore-action Restore action/native-ready state → no task; no native load/identity continuity claim. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
kanban-return Same restored card/continued result → no task or continuation. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat New Chat/shared composer/stream/output/history/decisions/Stop/recovery → registered diagnostic rejected, no AO Chat execution. BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
reviewer-select Reviewer picker/harness/model/target trigger → Pool not registered; native suitability unqualified; publication unauthorized. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
reviewer-running Reviewer running/interrupt/error/retry → no reviewer run, worker or pane. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
reviewer-result Target/head result/verdict/rerun → no reviewer run; no GitHub review/comment published by reviewer. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
reconnect-cleanup UI reconnect/recovery/final cleanup capture → no UI/session. Exact owned daemon shutdown independently verified HTTP 202 and PID absent. NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/new-task New task persisted Chat/native initialization → unexecuted BLOCKED BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/followup-stream Shared composer ordinary follow-up, partial output, final output → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/load-history Reopen/paged history/native exact session load → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/approve Protected effect withheld, offered approval, effect once → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/reject Separate pending request/reject/no effect/usable continuation → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/cancel-active-tool PID/kernel-start witness, Stop, stopped/reaped/no delayed effect → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/ui-reconnect UI event reconnect, same controller/history, no duplicate turn → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/daemon-host-recovery Owned daemon replacement/adoption and continuation → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/kill-restore-instructions Archive/Kill/exact restore/new private instruction effects/control session → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.
chat/negative-restore-capability Missing history/workspace mismatch/unsupported settings typed refusals → unexecuted NOT_RUN BLOCKED — current frontend dependencies absent; no real capture or approved uploader/attachment.

Current-head CI readback (all listed checks have exact head 5667039): 24 check-runs completed success, zero failing/pending/unavailable returned check-runs. Legacy combined status returned pending with total_count=0 and no contexts; no legacy pending job exists to name. This does not prove live provider/UI conformance.

Job Current result
build-test completed / success
sqlite-race (0) completed / success
sqlite-race (2) completed / success
sqlite-race (3) completed / success
sqlite-race (1) completed / success
cloud-build-test completed / success
chat-race (0) completed / success
api-drift completed / success
backend-core (1) completed / success
chat-race (1) completed / success
lint completed / success
session-store-race completed / success
backend-core (0) completed / success
sqlc-drift completed / success
windows-workspace completed / success
native (macos-latest) completed / success
native (windows-latest) completed / success
native (ubuntu-latest) completed / success
container completed / success
linux-proof-artifact completed / success
test completed / success
mac-update-helper completed / success
renderer-smoke completed / success
scan completed / success

Reproduction/current-status receipt: source and skill are pinned above. Safe generic reproduction uses existing authorized native credentials in the environment (never in argv/reports) and a new isolated RUNTIME directory:

GOMAXPROCS=1 GOFLAGS=-p=1 GOMEMLIMIT=384MiB go build -o RUNTIME/bin/ao ./cmd/ao
pool --version
pool acp --help
# Native proof used ACP initialize, session/new, session/set_mode(always-allow),
# session/prompt with a single disposable workspace/file witness; then exact cleanup.
TMPDIR=RUNTIME/tmp node SKILL/scripts/audit_ao.mjs --agent pool \
  --repo SOURCE --ao RUNTIME/bin/ao --local-contract RUNTIME/contract.json \
  --report RUNTIME/NEW_ATTEMPT/report --timeout-seconds 25 \
  --startup-timeout-seconds 35 --keep-daemon

Actual first-strict contract (binary path generalized here; no credentials):

{"schemaVersion":1,"agents":{"pool":{"binary":"INSTALLED_POOL","versionArgs":["--version"],"integration":{"args":["acp","--version"],"expect":"1.0.16"}}}}

Exact private contract byte hash: e3a2312c54a97445ff7b674679111cbf81af7efa2dffcaf2114333e2267489a0; runner normalized agent-entry hash: b23eff0937ca48495e8bb0e03365eb3fe5ee2b0711c976e37084dd6e98db3614. Missing session/models/interrupt/restoredReady fields are preserved, never inferred as passes. Native provider proof helper SHA-256 13a9eb0586998d6bd944518d0a042465eb835f95da3899cd751987ddcf8dc152; successful stdout/turn transcript retained only as bounded curated receipts/hashes, not published raw. The strict runner is TUI-oriented; its blocked catalog/preflight path does not qualify supported Chat.

Source corroboration: current Pool guide; Chat binding/permission gates; TUI rejection before allocation; actual Harness settings controls; auth-plan registry; separate reviewer vocabulary. These links describe implementation, not runtime proof.

Cleanup PASS: native PID 1449208/kernel-start 160478441 was settled, then stopped with bounded TERM/KILL (exit -9); PID absent at 05:04:07.613078Z. No active command was witnessed, so this is not cancellation proof. Owned AO PID 1449284/kernel-start 160481450 had zero task sessions; verified executable/readyz identity before POST /shutdown, HTTP 202 at 2026-10-21T05:09:35.865517+00:00; exact PID absent by 2026-10-21T05:09:36.149194+00:00, remainingOwnedPids=[]. No UI process was launched. Source clean, no untracked evidence. Parent still performs final process verification and removes only its clean detached source worktree.

Retained privately outside every Git checkout, under this PR's sibling runtime only: plan/matrix/checkpoint index, exact contract, current build/native binaries or reference link, isolated native/AO state/history, safe receipts, bounded logs, first strict report/issues, and empty attachment-queue.json. Profiles/state/DBs/raw logs are not public attachments. No credential-file copy or entire store copy was made; no original native profile changed. No evidence commits, fake screenshots/URLs, production daemon action, installations/upgrades, login reset or reviewer publication.

Unresolved/next actions: keep integration incomplete; obtain explicit approval before any configured-only diagnostic AO Chat action; qualify registered Chat through actual shared UI including streaming/history/approve/reject/cancel/recovery/exact restore/instructions; safely provide current-head Electron dependencies and approved image attachment path; qualify both model surfaces/persisted visibility and provider/account controls; assess missing AO login and reviewer wiring separately; resolve PR conflicts in an authorized implementation worker. PR-description evidence link is pending parent update; this worker does not edit it. Green CI, native success and worker exit do not establish completion.

Final pre-publication head readback: 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7 at 2026-10-21T05:11:20.034605+00:00; mergeable=false, mergeable_state=dirty.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:37:12Z

Original comment

Explicitly approved isolated AO Chat diagnostic — BLOCKED

User approval was given on 2026-10-21: “Run isolated AO Chat diagnostic”, using the same already-tested DeepSeek credential. Prior automatic-review block is preserved: #6551 (comment). One registered Chat session and at most one provider turn; no model refresh, account/config changes, installs, source changes or production restart.

Source: 5667039; head at publication: 5667039
AO executable SHA256: a253335836e191ebf7e5f2cf46d3a4659184f78678d79fd93a435435a98ac233
Native Pool SHA256: db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2
UTC: 2026-10-21T05:33:13.995001+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:37:11.533548+00:00

Diagnostic provider/file result: BLOCKED; actual sessions: 0; requested turns: 1; persisted Chat mode: False; file token/cwd witness: False; proof SHA256: unavailable; native identity digest: unavailable.

Reason/limits: registered Chat spawn rejected; preserved API envelope; no retry

Actual API request HTTP Request ID Duration
GET /readyz 200 not supplied 1 ms
POST /api/v1/agents/pool/probe 200 not supplied 1 ms
GET /api/v1/agents/pool/models 200 not supplied 721 ms
POST /api/v1/projects 201 not supplied 14 ms
POST /api/v1/sessions 400 not supplied 33 ms

Strict auth remains configured/unverified and strict TUI audit remains BLOCKED. This diagnostic does not qualify real UI screenshots/attachments, full Chat journeys, cancellation, exact restore, reviewer, models/provider controls or onboarding. No existing evidence was edited. Fresh isolated readyz PID/executable/data ownership: PASS. Cleanup: PASS; remaining owned process count 0; compute lease held 2.385 seconds.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:49:09Z

Original comment

Explicitly approved isolated AO Chat diagnostic — FAIL

User approval was given on 2026-10-21: “Run isolated AO Chat diagnostic”, using the same already-tested DeepSeek credential. Prior automatic-review block is preserved: #6551 (comment). One registered Chat session and at most one provider turn; no model refresh, account/config changes, installs, source changes or production restart.

Source: 5667039; head at publication: 5667039
AO executable SHA256: a253335836e191ebf7e5f2cf46d3a4659184f78678d79fd93a435435a98ac233
Native Pool SHA256: db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2
UTC: 2026-10-21T05:39:19.395339+00:00 → 2026-10-21T05:49:08.184228+00:00

Diagnostic provider/file result: FAIL; actual sessions: 1; requested turns: 1; persisted Chat mode: False; file token/cwd witness: False; proof SHA256: unavailable; native identity digest: unavailable.

Reason/limits: 'workspacePath'

Actual API request HTTP Request ID Duration
GET /readyz 200 not supplied 464 ms
POST /api/v1/agents/pool/probe 200 not supplied 1 ms
GET /api/v1/agents/pool/models 200 not supplied 449 ms
POST /api/v1/projects 201 not supplied 21 ms
POST /api/v1/sessions 201 not supplied 935 ms
POST /api/v1/sessions/pool-approved-diag-1/kill 200 not supplied 2044 ms

Strict auth remains configured/unverified and strict TUI audit remains BLOCKED. This diagnostic does not qualify real UI screenshots/attachments, full Chat journeys, cancellation, exact restore, reviewer, models/provider controls or onboarding. No existing evidence was edited. Fresh isolated readyz PID/executable/data ownership: PASS. Cleanup: PASS; remaining owned process count 0; compute lease held 5.807 seconds.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T05:51:32Z

Original comment

Pool approved Chat diagnostic — corrective read-only evidence receipt

The user explicitly approved “Run isolated AO Chat diagnostic” on 2026-10-21 using the same previously tested DeepSeek credential. This corrects the operator observer failure, not the provider/authentication result. Preserve both prior attempts: original automatic-review block, scratch default-branch setup failure, and observer-error attempt. None was edited.

Tested/current PR head: 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7 (matches pinned 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7). AO SHA256: a253335836e191ebf7e5f2cf46d3a4659184f78678d79fd93a435435a98ac233; native Pool SHA256: db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2. Skill: bfb28b79f90df0a56892e8d8b1d3139dea1148db.

Observation Result Actual evidence
Fresh daemon ownership PASS /readyz PID/executable/data ownership matched the new isolated daemon and exact binary.
Scratch project correction PASS Prior DEFAULT_BRANCH_UNRESOLVED was a fixture error. Only the new scratch repository received a local origin and cached origin/HEAD → origin/main before acquiring compute.
Registered AO Chat creation PASS POST /api/v1/sessions HTTP201; durable session_mode=chat, harness pool, one registered session. HTTP201 establishes creation only.
Native/provider transport PASS for this narrow observation One real turn started at 2026-10-21 05:49:05.852611497 +0000 UTC; 11 persisted message.delta events, one usage event, and a provider assistant message were received. No authentication/provider rejection was observed.
Tool transport PASS for this narrow observation One ACP pwd command activity completed at 05:49:07.084978724 UTC. This is not a file-write witness.
Structured identity Persisted Provider conversation SHA256 559ab0bb31df8b95e717ed8c989df332a8a5ef8352dbe4c8831c8e9de68b3adf; provider turn SHA256 96592ea0359a96e18ddb9b28e510cfd3f391070561d689884c955a4dcd7b8d48; controller generation d2703132-2ef4-4cbe-99c9-c244ebca6d4b. Legacy agent_session_id is empty and is not claimed as established.
Complete ordinary turn/file witness INCOMPLETE No retained, validated token/cwd file witness was captured. Turn completion was interrupted by our observer/cleanup, so provider file conformance is not established.
Observer correctness FAIL (operator) The observer incorrectly read public session.workspacePath, which this response does not expose. The path is durable in isolated SQLite. Its KeyError immediately initiated cleanup.
Auth/strict qualification BLOCKED unchanged Fresh targeted Pool probe returned authStatus=configured, not verified authorization. The strict TUI audit remains BLOCKED.
Actual UI/screenshots NOT_RUN This diagnostic does not qualify AO UI captures/attachments or full Chat/reviewer/cancel/restore/onboarding/model/provider-management journeys.

The provider assistant text was: “I'll check the working directory and write the file.” Final durable turn state is failed, with bounded error ACP session/prompt: {"code":-32800,"message":"Request cancelled","data":{"error":"context canceled"}}. The kill request began at 05:49:05.856398 UTC, during that initial turn; the error is consistent with the operator-initiated cleanup, not a failed credential. There was one registered Chat session and one initial provider turn, with no subsequent prompt, retry, restore, model refresh, login/account/config change, install, source change, or production restart.

Lease acquired 2026-10-21T05:49:02.376525+00:00, released 2026-10-21T05:49:08.183981+00:00; held 5.807 seconds including cleanup. Cleanup PASS, session durably terminated; read-only recheck at 2026-10-21T05:51:31.680037+00:00 finds 0 live processes in the exact owned runtime scope. Successful responses supplied no request-ID header; the preserved earlier setup400 carried vps-linux/J8NgurMHns-000005. Provider/tool request IDs were not exposed in the retained activity. No IDs are fabricated.

Outcome: registered Chat/provider streaming/tool transport observed; complete provider/file test interrupted by operator observation error. No full diagnostic/integration PASS and no auth-state upgrade. This receipt used only retained isolated SQLite/files and GitHub metadata; no additional live work was run.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:34:03Z

Original comment

Authorized implementation repair (repair) starts at PR head 5667039, latest main 0c11049, readonly harness skill a67b5d2. Pool/Docker existing branch fixes only; surgical code and regression tests are allowed. Actual worker gpt-6.1-sol/high/fast, 90-minute maximum. Routine suites run in CI only; bounded live/build/UI work uses the shared lease and full proof waits for the existing retest queue to finish. Old evidence/comments and production remain preserved.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:39:45Z

Original comment

Implementation repair started on the existing Pool PR. Freshly fetched PR head is 56670397922d374a83c4344ba8999e47457828d7; current main 0c11049ce0bc1613428e67cc28bfc6fb09c68acd is being merged with both sides preserved.

Reassessment found shared model visibility controls already on main. The scoped repairs are native Pool Account setup/logout wiring, keeping setup reachable when auth is unknown, and avoiding invented provider groups from model namespace text. Auth remains configured/unknown without a safe verification result; inventory/model discovery will not send a test prompt.

The earlier disposable default-branch fixture error and subsequent workspace observer error are preserved as test-plumbing failures. Historical native file proof and registered Chat streaming/pwd remain distinct; they do not establish current-head qualification or verified AO authentication.

Routine build/test/race/lint/typecheck/fixture suites are CI-only under this repair policy. Any bounded runtime work uses the shared non-waiting lease. Long native/AO lifecycle and actual Electron proof are deferred to the final-proof phase if compute/capacity does not permit them. Actual UI capture and published screenshot attachments remain BLOCKED; screenshot unavailable because no current UI run or approved uploader exists in this repair phase. TUI, Reviewer and handoff remain outside this Chat-only scope.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T06:46:01Z

Original comment

Implementation repair (repair) incomplete at 2026-10-21T06:46:00.347268+00:00. free capacity fell below 700MiB. Owned cleanup: PASS. Worktree retained at its private operational location, including uncommitted work. No merge/deploy/force-push occurred. Current source/CI/proof claims are only those explicitly recorded by the worker; missing proof and durable UI attachments remain gaps.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T07:27:35Z

Original comment

Authorized implementation repair (final-proof) starts at PR head 5667039, latest main 474962e, readonly harness skill 2bca6e7. Pool/Docker existing branch fixes only; surgical code and regression tests are allowed. Actual worker gpt-6.1-sol/high/fast, 90-minute maximum. Routine suites run in CI only; bounded live/build/UI work uses the shared lease and full proof waits for the existing retest queue to finish. Old evidence/comments and production remain preserved.

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Copied source evidence 2/2

Historical material from original PR #6551, copied for this account migration. Source PR head when copied: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157. Each original comment below retains its own author, timestamp and source link. Its test results and screenshots describe the original run and commit. Fresh checks for this submission are shown on this PR.

Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T07:40:55Z

Original comment

Pool final-proof repair is pushed at 9f4e10a8a549eb1880905a1248ade2bc420ea7d4, merging latest fetched main 474962e31bea34b96588e8d91ea7a46d82557f8c.

Implemented and recovered from the preserved unfinished repair: native Account setup/logout plans, reachable setup while auth is unknown, provider grouping only from native metadata, explicit Chat-only terminal refresh refusal, and regression source for those boundaries. Main already supplies shared model visibility controls; no duplicate model subsystem was added. The unmerged Pool migration now uses the repository timestamp generator above main, with updated inverse/legacy-schema regression source. API artifacts were regenerated from Go sources.

Required API generation and one minimal serial AO build passed under the shared lease. The first build attempt failed because the isolated sparse checkout omitted a Go workspace module; that original failure is retained, then corrected before retry. No provider call was made during generation/build. Routine unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/fixture suites are CI-only for this task; fresh current-head checks are now being inspected.

Authentication remains configured/unknown: no safe native authorization-status verifier is wired, and neither inventory nor model discovery sends a test prompt. Supported Chat execution will be qualified separately with an explicit disposable task. Native, registered AO Chat, and actual Electron proof are independent pending rows. TUI, Reviewer and handoff remain intentionally excluded. Initials branding remains the documented fallback without a verified reusable logo license.

The read-only hygiene scan passes formatting, whitespace, migration numbering and main freshness. It still flags the original PR's historical evidence files/host paths and pre-existing proof workflow; these originals are preserved unchanged, and no new report, log or screenshot is committed. Scanner misses caused by current registry/docs layouts are not treated as runtime failures or passes.

Actual current-source Electron UI proof is still pending a capacity forecast. Published screenshot attachments remain BLOCKED because no approved working uploader is available. This is an incomplete integration qualification, not a full PASS.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T07:48:41Z

Original comment

Fresh Pool native + registered AO Chat functional proof: 19 recorded checks PASS, with auth/UI qualification gaps retained.

Tested clean source 9f4e10a8a549eb1880905a1248ade2bc420ea7d4 on Linux; executable build info reports that revision with vcs.modified=false. AO SHA-256 d6c39ccc916fc834fbbd684218420045e8527a1c5e45817383713757dd469362; native Pool 1.0.16 SHA-256 db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2. Provider: existing authorized DeepSeek standalone route; native/AO selected model deepseek-flash. Attempt UTC 2026-10-21T07:44:22.810274+00:00 → 2026-10-21T07:46:39.044163+00:00. This is explicit functional diagnostic coverage; AO inventory authentication remains configured/unverified.

Independent surface Actual behavior and outcome
Native ACP Fresh file with unique token and actual cwd, incremental output, native offered reject/approve decisions with matching side effects, active foreground-command cancellation with PID/kernel-birth witness and no late file after its scheduled write window, exact native session/load plus mutation preserving earlier fields: PASS.
Registered AO Chat Real worker in its AO worktree, unique file/token/cwd, assistant streaming observed before completion, selected/effective native model, independent private and project instruction file effects: PASS.
AO approvals New actual native permission request for each reject/approve case, offered decision delivered once, no side effect before approval, denied file absent/approved file present: PASS.
AO active cancellation Actual foreground PID/kernel-birth witness while turn running, interrupt through Chat API, witnessed child stopped, no late file beyond the scheduled window, then successful same-conversation continuation: PASS.
AO Kill and exact restore Termination and owned-child cleanup confirmed; a new private rule was configured/read back only after Kill. Same native identity/worktree restored; ordinary continuation preserved earlier file fields and consumed the new private rule: PASS.
Metadata and scope Serving readyz PID/executable matched owned launch; native Account setup plan available; model catalog returned native choices without a prompt; explicit TUI and Auto requests refused with typed 4xx: PASS.

There were 11 explicit provider turns total across native and AO proof. Scratch Git setup used an owned main commit, a local origin and cached origin/main/origin/HEAD, without network. Workspace observation used the current desktop-workspace DTO, fixing the earlier observer assumption. Those historical first failures remain preserved.

Functional proof receipt SHA-256 267f48d7fc7e4fb84ef8dc611f3894796141bb1f907e7b558f0e19dce2e1bf69; exact private proof-helper bytes SHA-256 f28d0b0e77e6edf89209e2ae669f875ddf4233e2570a462be9923aee828cf682. Sanitized invocation shape: proof-lease.py --runtime <fresh-private-attempt> --full --seconds 1500 -- python3 live-proof.py. Full helper/command receipts, native histories, workspaces and binaries are retained privately; credential-reader locations and private instructions are excluded from public excerpts. This bounded inline receipt is not an uploaded reproduction bundle.

Owned cleanup: PASS, zero survivors verified by PID plus kernel birth; shared compute held 136.845 seconds. No production state, original profiles, older evidence or historical comments were changed. The original sparse-module build failure is retained separately from the corrected successful build/live attempt.

Limits remain explicit: safe AO authorization verification is unavailable; no login/logout action was performed, no unrelated live control-session isolation, daemon replacement, negative-history restore or actual current-source Electron journey is established by this attempt. Reviewer/handoff remain excluded and need their honest scope disposition separately. Model visibility UI/onboarding/provider-maintenance UI are not covered by API/native results. Actual UI capacity is being measured. Screenshot publication remains BLOCKED without an approved uploader. This does not establish full integration PASS.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T08:06:42Z

Original comment

Current-head Pool functional evidence — a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157.

The first pushed repair's SQLite CI failed because Pool's new schema check masked main's existing malformed-constraint diagnostic. a10f3551 restores that check order without changing Memcode source/tests. Original failed job is preserved. New-head full CI is running; prior-head greens are not substituted for it.

Fresh current-head proof completed: 19 core native/AO rows PASS, plus 6 scope/isolation rows PASS (separate attempts, not 25 unique capabilities). Both attempts verified zero owned survivors.

  • Native Pool: real one-file token/cwd task and stream; actual reject/approve decisions and side effects; witnessed active-command cancellation with no delayed file; exact session/load and preserving continuation.
  • Registered AO Chat: real worktree task, assistant streaming before completion, native effective deepseek-flash, independent project/private instruction effects, reject/approve, witnessed cancellation and usable continuation, Kill, same native identity/workspace restore, and ordinary continuation consuming a new private rule introduced only after Kill.
  • Remaining scope: typed Reviewer selection rejection and TUI-handoff refusal; durable model visibility off/on readback; killing one Chat session preserved the exact live control processes, and the control then completed its own real token/cwd file task.

A distinct current-head attempt stopped when the observer assumed one permission request per task: after the requested write was approved, Pool asked to read back its result. The native ledger retains both distinct requests. That attempt remains FAIL/incomplete. The corrected private observer explicitly rejects additional requests and keeps the protected-file, process and settled-turn gates unchanged. The later fresh attempt passed; its secondary-rejection branch was not needed in that reproduction. No product permission gate was weakened.

Clean tested source/build: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157, vcs.modified=false; AO executable SHA-256 7ac23e055e86263293f7b5d70d0bd700ef8af58faa6d09fe10313ad3d6fc19f2. Native Pool 1.0.16 SHA-256 db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2. Current successful attempts requested 12 explicit provider turns. Native/catalog inventory itself sent no test prompt. Core UTC 2026-10-21T08:02:36.526197+00:00 → 2026-10-21T08:04:43.572187+00:00; scope UTC 2026-10-21T08:05:05.094353+00:00 → 2026-10-21T08:05:23.151514+00:00.

Core receipt SHA-256 1e7dfe480447e592aab9f5991f0bb53cc2aa981703fb590e4cb04eab464d65d2; scope receipt 232ff41173ccd6667f31ad86f3657742461c585fbcb002bfc4e33d42516b4ac5. Helpers 046a7d284127ae9e0288a28f27c2e26b052a1e5d1b7784874bd28aa13741a36a and 4d875ca3d23d0f0eff38f5215be4005f6b63dd0cc856af38aafaed9312e030bc are retained privately with actual commands, isolated histories/workspaces and original failed attempts. Sanitized invocation shapes: proof-lease.py --runtime <fresh-private-attempt> --full --seconds 1500 -- python3 live-proof-final.py, then a separate 180-second lease for scope-proof-final.py. Credential-reader locations/private instructions are excluded from public excerpts; these hashes are not an uploaded reproduction bundle.

Actual Electron/UI proof: BLOCKED capacity. The measured current lockfile forecast needs 2.43 GB including the 700 MiB free reserve. Even removing every remaining permitted regenerable Go-cache entry would provide only 1.71 GB. No npm ci or Electron launch was attempted; no new PNG exists. All 24 UI checkpoint rows remain in the private checkpoint/attachment queue. Published screenshot attachments are independently BLOCKED because no approved uploader is available.

AO auth remains configured/unverified; no native safe status probe, login/logout operation, default/manual-mode run, provider-account maintenance UI, model-picker UI, actual UI reconnect/daemon replacement or negative-history restore is established by these functional tests. TUI, Auto, Reviewer and handoff remain intentionally excluded and truthfully refused. Existing initials branding remains the documented license fallback. This is supported functional proof with explicit qualification gaps, not full integration PASS.


Original comment by @nikhilachale on 2026-10-21T08:26:09Z

Original comment

Pool final-proof status — implementation pushed, functional proof scoped; full integration qualification remains incomplete.

Current PR head and clean tested source: a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157. Latest merged main: 474962e31bea34b96588e8d91ea7a46d82557f8c. Normal fast-forward pushes only: 9f4e10a8 then a10f3551; no merge, deployment, publish or force push. Exact-head CI: 25/25 successful; 0 queued/running; 0 unsuccessful. run 1 · run 2 · run 3 · run 4 · run 5 · run 6

The surgical repair adds native Account setup/logout plans, keeps setup reachable for unknown auth, retains provider metadata without inventing groups from model IDs, explicitly refuses terminal refresh, reconciles latest main/API artifacts and the unmerged migration, and preserves existing schema-error precedence. Main's model visibility subsystem was reused. Excluded integrations and the readonly harness skill were not edited.

Current-head native/AO proof is 19 core rows PASS + 6 scope/isolation rows PASS, with zero owned survivors. Detailed current-head evidence and original failure distinctions. Runtime AO SHA-256 7ac23e055e86263293f7b5d70d0bd700ef8af58faa6d09fe10313ad3d6fc19f2; Pool 1.0.16 SHA-256 db70340b41c8bd76dbe2b5926a6e46cda804789b9774b3d4cfba3591f0de02f2. Successful current-head attempts used 12 explicit provider turns; catalog/probe operations did not silently prompt.

Completion area Verified disposition
Registration/UI Backend registration, actual Chat worker and Account plan PASS; current Electron UI BLOCKED.
Models Native catalog/effective selection and off/on preference readback PASS; real Models/New Task picker interaction NOT_RUN.
Providers Existing DeepSeek standalone execution PASS; native provider metadata preserved, model namespace is not inferred as provider. Provider-account add/change/remove UI NOT_RUN/manual route.
Setup Native login/logout plan source and regressions implemented; offered API plan PASS. Actual login/logout NOT_RUN under the no-new-login/no-account-change constraint.
Readiness/auth Owned readyz/probe and native execution PASS. AO inventory auth configured/unverified; safe native status verification unsupported. No inventory prompt sent.
Identity/branding Poolside Pool label and documented initials fallback retained; no verified reusable official logo license/asset, actual avatar UI NOT_RUN.
TUI/Chat Supported native/AO Chat functional cases PASS. TUI and Auto typed refusals PASS; these interfaces remain excluded.
Reviewer/handoff Explicitly excluded; actual Reviewer selection and TUI-handoff rejection PASS. No reviewer run or interface handoff claimed.
Permissions/instructions Bypass execution and accept-edits approve/reject PASS; independent private/project rules and fresh post-Kill rule consumption PASS. Default/manual mode not separately driven.
Lifecycle Witnessed native/AO cancel/no-late-effect, continuation, Kill/exact restore and live control-session isolation PASS. UI reconnect, daemon replacement, independent history-only recall/replay-duplicate checks and missing-history negatives NOT_RUN.
Evidence Current binary/source/receipt hashes and all failures retained privately; fresh actual PNG count 0; 24 UI checkpoints unavailable; attachments BLOCKED.
CI/handoff 25/25 successful; 0 queued/running; 0 unsuccessful; routine suites CI-only. run 1 · run 2 · run 3 · run 4 · run 5 · run 6

Actual UI/attachments remain BLOCKED. The measured current lockfile forecast requires 2.43 GB including the 700 MiB reserve; only 1.71 GB would be available even after all remaining permitted Go-cache removal. No npm ci, Electron launch or capture was attempted. There is also no approved working attachment uploader. These are separate blockers; no fake image, URL or evidence commit substitutes for them.

Required UI checkpoint Functional scope Actual UI image/attachment
harness-listed API registration/plan PASS; UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
install-offer manual guide plan observed; UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
install-run NOT_RUN — manual-only/no native install performed Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
auth-before configured/unverified API state observed Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
auth-action NOT_RUN — no new login permitted Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
auth-ready strict verified-auth BLOCKED; explicit provider turns PASS Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
auth-maintenance NOT_RUN — no logout/account/profile changes performed Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
harness-models native/AO catalog PASS; panel UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
model-visibility off/on API readback PASS; actual picker effects NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
provider-management existing route task PASS; maintenance UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
task-agent actual API Chat selection PASS; New Task UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
task-model native effective model PASS; picker UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
task-running native/AO actual file/cwd/stream PASS Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
task-followup actual same-conversation continuation PASS Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
task-cancel actual witnessed active cancellation PASS Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
kill-action actual API Kill/owned teardown PASS; UI action NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
archived terminated record observed; archived UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
restore-action actual exact native/AO restore PASS; UI action NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
kanban-return restored API session/continuation PASS; board UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
chat core actual Chat protocol/function PASS; UI NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
reviewer-select N/A excluded scope; typed selection refusal PASS Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
reviewer-running N/A excluded scope; no reviewer run Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
reviewer-result N/A excluded scope; no reviewer result Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture
reconnect-cleanup owned cleanup PASS; UI reconnect/daemon replacement NOT_RUN Unavailable — measured Electron capacity block; no actual capture

Original failures remain separate: sparse Go workspace-module omission before generation/build; the first pushed head's SQLite regression, corrected by a10f3551; the first capacity parser's null metadata error; and a current-head observer-stopped attempt after a distinct verification-read approval. The later helper explicitly rejects secondary requests without changing original permission/file/process gates; its successful reproduction did not need that secondary branch. The earlier failed attempt is not relabeled PASS. The initial capacity-forecast helper was corrected in place; its original bytes were not separately frozen, so no original-helper hash is claimed. Its failure and lease receipts remain retained.

The hygiene scanner still flags the original PR's 12 evidence files, old host-path receipts and proof workflow. They are retained unchanged because no verified attachment relocation is available. No new evidence, reports, binaries, PNGs or workflow changes were committed. Current command/receipt/helper hash indexes, source/native binaries, isolated histories/workspaces, checkpoint queue and prior dirty repair checkout are retained privately. Public excerpts exclude credential-reader locations, private instructions and profiles; no uploaded executable reproduction bundle is claimed.

Final owned cleanup: PASS; every leased child ended and per-attempt PID/kernel-birth checks reported zero survivors. Native installs/profiles/history, original evidence/comments and both source worktrees remain retained. Routine unit/race/lint/vet/typecheck/build-fixture/runner-fixture suites ran only in CI. Current source compile/API generation and actual live proof ran only under the shared lease. Linux functional proof does not qualify native macOS/Windows behavior.

No full integration PASS: strict auth verification, actual UI journeys and published screenshot attachments remain unqualified. The next UI proof needs sufficient permitted capacity and an approved uploader; it does not need a new account or credential reset.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🏆 Review leaderboard

Nov 5–12, 2026 · UTC

Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
🥇 @ronishrohan @ronishrohan 91 163 14
🥈 @neversettle17-101 @neversettle17-101 11 15 4
🥉 @illegalcall @illegalcall 11 12 4
4 @Meraj-08 @Meraj-08 10 15 0
5 @nikhilachale @nikhilachale 7 19 3
6 @Prasad-D-Ware @Prasad-D-Ware 7 12 2
7 @Annieeeee11 @Annieeeee11 6 9 0
8 @mohakchakraborty2004 @mohakchakraborty2004 6 7 2
9 @Pritom14 @Pritom14 5 8 1
10 @Rishet11 @Rishet11 5 6 3

Ranked by distinct external PRs reviewed, then review rounds, then PR comments. Self-activity and bot activity are excluded.

Show 6 more reviewers
Rank Reviewer PRs reviewed Review rounds PR comments
11 @somewherelostt @somewherelostt 3 11 1
12 @ApexYash11 @ApexYash11 2 6 2
13 @Vaibhaav-Tiwari @Vaibhaav-Tiwari 2 3 0
14 @codebanditssss @codebanditssss 2 2 8
15 @harshitsinghbhandari @harshitsinghbhandari 2 2 0
16 @MohamedKamran @MohamedKamran 1 2 0

@milesatao-svg

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Account migration verification

  • New PR author verified as milesatao-svg; submission is a draft.
  • Original PR #6551 and this PR both point to a10f3551a0fc15f673a8026c65e461da2324f157.
  • Published change-count header verified against this PR's actual GitHub file diff.
  • All 21 original human comment bodies and source links reproduced across 2 historical-evidence comments.
  • All 2 original screenshot/recording URLs reproduced and checked as HTTP 200 media.
  • Current GitHub mergeability: conflicts with main; resolution pending.
  • Fresh CI validation and current-head harness certification are pending. Copied test outcomes retain their original run/commit provenance.

@OrcInc OrcInc added comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request labels Nov 12, 2026
@OrcInc OrcInc added this to the Agents & orchestration milestone Nov 12, 2026
nikhilachale and others added 6 commits November 14, 2026 23:07
Resolve conflicts with main's Hermes harness, ACP transport, registry,
SQLite and API changes, keeping main behavior and adding Pool alongside:

- acp: keep InstallCheck/RetryStartupExit with ValidateSessionReady and
  adapt bindSessionValidation to main's (response, model) failure hook
- acp tests: pass main's steering argument to conversationCapabilities
- nativeacp: keep main's SessionMeta/QuickStop/steering fields, add
  ValidateSessionReady and Preflight without duplicating ValidateInitialize
- harness, registries, DTO enums, OpenAPI and schema.ts: list hermes then pool
- agentauth: keep both plans and give Pool its documented POOLSIDE_API_KEY
  provider-key method, required by main's account-setup coverage test
- sqlite: reconcile and verify both Hermes and Pool; ledger Pool's migration
  in version order; baseline the Pool round-trip test on the migration
  immediately before it so it exercises only Pool's Up/Down
- TaskComposer: route Pool through main's submitMode/launchFallback as a
  Chat-only agent
- settings: keep main's showSetup account action, which covers Pool setup
- workflows: keep main's manual-only harness artifact build

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Pool's turn-settings validator returned a plain error, so main's
SupportsPermissionMode treated every mode as supported and the Chat
permission picker offered Auto, which launch then refused. Wrap
ErrChatPermissionModeUnsupported and assert the driver's checker agrees
with the native mode mapping.

Drop the duplicate CHAT_PERMISSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED case the merge left
in the conversation error switch; main already maps it earlier.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The qualification receipts, reconciliation JSON, evidence reports and UI
screenshots are run artifacts. They remain available at the contributor's
pinned fork commit linked from the PR description; repository docs keep
only the Pool setup guide.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Main has shipped migrations through 20261114072016988, so Pool's
20261021073338393 would apply out of order on every existing database.
Take a fresh ID above main's latest, append it to the ledger, and baseline
the Pool round-trip test on the migration immediately before it. Also
cover the latest schema in the repair-anchor test and assert that ACP
bindings without an explicit capability opt-out keep protocol-declared
capabilities.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nikhilachale

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Main reconciliation and ao-agent-harness receipt (current head)

Head: 4d24e176a02b62289c7fc8b9cbe01f8f20fd0393 · Base: main @ 28bc83fd954c · GitHub: MERGEABLE, merge state BLOCKED.
Skill reference: PR #7081 at 04c8c95b23d717ccd2bc314e4577a0596b92e840, read only. No skill files, contracts, reports or screenshots are committed here.

What changed on this branch

The 23 conflicts were resolved by merging main. History was not rewritten (fast-forward from a10f3551a0). Main's behavior is kept and Pool is added alongside Hermes.

Defects found and fixed:

  • ACP transport (compile break after merge): bindSessionValidation used the old one-argument promptResponseFailure. It now uses main's (response, model) signature. The PR's capability test now passes main's new steeringFor argument.
  • nativeacp: the merge would have set ValidateInitialize twice. Main's SessionMeta, QuickStop and steering fields are kept.
  • Account setup: main's TestEverySupportedHarnessHasAccountSetupMethod needs a provider-key method. Added env_POOLSIDE_API_KEY, which Poolside documents as the credential pool checks before credentials.json.
  • Permission picker: Pool's validator did not wrap ErrChatPermissionModeUnsupported, so main's SupportsPermissionMode would have offered Auto in the Chat picker. Fixed, with a test.
  • Conversation errors: removed a duplicate, unreachable CHAT_PERMISSION_MODE_UNSUPPORTED case; main already maps it.
  • Migration: renumbered allow_pool_harness from 20261021073338393 to 20261114174351283, above main's latest (skill §3). The ledger entry is appended. The round-trip test now baselines on the migration just before Pool's, so it covers only Pool's Up/Down. I rechecked the later migrations: only sessions carries the full harness CHECK (usage_bindings is intentionally narrower), and nothing later rebuilds it. Startup reconcile verifies both Hermes and Pool.
  • TaskComposer: Pool goes through main's refactored submitMode and launchFallback as a Chat-only agent.
  • Settings: kept main's showSetup account action. It shows Pool's Set up when auth is unknown and Open setup when configured.
  • Workflow: kept main's manual-only harness-proof-build.yml. The PR copy would have re-enabled it on every backend PR.
  • Scope (skill §3): removed the committed proof JSON, evidence reports and screenshots. They remain at the contributor's pinned fork commit linked in the description.
  • Shared ACP code: added a test that bindings with no explicit capability opt-out keep protocol-declared capabilities.
  • CLI: added pool to the ao spawn --harness help.

Per-step receipt

Step Result Evidence or gap
0 Intake PASS (manual) Open PR #8201 continues #6551. harness_intake.mjs was not run on this Windows host.
1 Compatibility PARTIAL Chat via pool acp with session/load. System prompt goes through a private SessionStart settings overlay with a post-prompt witness. Permissions map to default, accept-edits and always-allow; Auto is refused. Models come from ACP discovery. Gap: no verifying login probe, so auth is configured or unknown. Only exact pool-acp 1.0.16 is admitted.
2 Touchpoints PARTIAL (manual review) Wired: domain, agent and chat registries, SQLite constraint, migration and reconcile, DTO/OpenAPI/schema enums, product-ui label, terminal-refresh opt-out, refresh matrix, install target and manual plan, auth plan, model catalog, docs index, spawn help. Not wired, by stated design (maintainer decision): chat-switch-target (handoff unsupported), avatar-asset/avatar-map (no licensed logo), reviewer surfaces, automatic installer (EULA acceptance stays with the user). Optional doctor-probe is absent because pool --version is unverified. harness_touchpoints.mjs was not run here.
3 Contract BLOCKED Needs a local-contracts.json entry on the audit host.
4 Live audit BLOCKED Not run. Pool Chat needs macOS/Linux, and this host is Windows. Needs an authorized macOS/Linux host with Pool 1.0.16 and an existing login.
5 UI audit BLOCKED Same host requirement. Earlier screenshots predate this merge and are historical only.
6 Hand off OPEN CI, live and UI gates below.

Gates still open

  • CI: every workflow on this head is action_required. A maintainer must approve the fork runs. Nothing has executed yet.
  • Local validation: none on this host (no go test, lint, vitest or tsc). openapi.yaml and schema.ts were edited by hand to the generator's output and need the drift checks to confirm.
  • Live tests needed on this head:
    • Fresh start: the witness matches the session/new id.
    • Exact resume via session/load: the witness matches the stored id.
    • Resume-missing falls back to a fresh session.
    • Persistent-host reattach keeps the original context, with no witness check.
    • Chat permission picker shows only Manual, Accept edits and Allow all.
    • Auto and TUI requests are refused before allocation.
    • The renumbered migration applies on an existing current-main database.
    • Model discovery works, and Settings shows Set up / Open setup.
  • Review: a fresh review and maintainer approval are needed. This is not merge-ready.

@nikhilachale nikhilachale left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Review: changes requested (1 required change)

Reviewed head 4d24e176a0 against main (merge base 28bc83fd95). The Pool Chat integration is well contained. It is Chat-only at spawn (rejects TUI before allocation), Auto is refused through the driver permission checker, terminal launch/restore are hard-refused, discovery reuses the native ACP catalog with a config/credential fingerprint, and the reconcile path repairs a skipped migration. The shared ACP changes are safe for the other adapters: the new explicit-opt-out loop in conversationCapabilities only changes behavior for Pool, since piacp opts out of Approvals, which the protocol never sets. ValidateSessionReady is not bound on reconnect, and Launch/configure (which deletes the witness) only runs on a real launch, so a live host keeps its witness.

Required (inline):

  • The Pool down migration can leave rows that break the restored CHECK, and it silently does nothing once a later harness sits before fake. Mirror the guarded Hermes migration.

Optional suggestions (not required):

  • service/chat/service.go PreflightChat: the hardcoded Pool/Auto branch repeats chatAdmissionError (pool validateTurnSettings already returns ErrChatPermissionModeUnsupported for Auto through SupportsPermissionMode). Dropping it would keep harness-specific policy in the driver.
  • poolacp.validateSessionReady compares filepath.Clean paths. If Pool ever reports a symlink-resolved cwd (for example macOS /private/var or a symlinked home), every completed turn would fail. Comparing filepath.EvalSymlinks results on both sides would be more robust.
  • cli/doctor.go has no pool entry in its binary/version table, so ao doctor will not report Pool.
  • adapters/agent/pool.ResolveBinary lists pool.exe even though the integration refuses Windows. This is harmless, but it is inconsistent with the Unix-only scope.

The Pool down step narrowed the sessions CHECK even while pool rows
existed, and matched only when Pool sat directly before 'fake', so the
next harness migration would turn it into a silent no-op. Mirror the
Hermes migration: refuse rollback while pool rows exist or the constraint
shape is unknown, remove the Pool entry wherever it sits, and assert it is
gone after RESET. The up step now widens any constraint ending in 'fake'
and asserts Pool is present.

Because Up now also widens historical variants, startup repair sets Pool
aside before its exact historical replacements, as it does for Hermes,
then appends it again.

Tests cover refusal while a pool row exists, rollback after a later
harness lands before 'fake', and the Up guard on an unknown constraint.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

comp/daemon Go daemon, process lifecycle, and backend control plane. enhancement New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants